2. Fiji
3. Tocantins
4. Cook Islands
5. China
6. Gabon
7. Amazon
8. All Stars
9. Pearl Islands
10. Panama
11. Vanuatu
12. Guatemala
13. Marquesas
14. Palau
15. Thailand
16. Africa
17. Outback
18. Borneo
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
VBeauregarde |
|||
|
1. Micronesia
2. Fiji 3. Tocantins 4. Cook Islands 5. China 6. Gabon 7. Amazon 8. All Stars 9. Pearl Islands 10. Panama 11. Vanuatu 12. Guatemala 13. Marquesas 14. Palau 15. Thailand 16. Africa 17. Outback 18. Borneo |
|||
JLK Name |
|||
|
The First 8
1.Pearl Islands- This was way better than the Amazon, the Outcasts twist blew me away. It has Rupert and Jon and Lillian being the annoying one with the scout-girl outfit. 2.Outback- This one seems very natural, I like the last episode they were really appreciating their time in the outback but the first episode was boring, the boots are predictable (Alicia, Rodger, Elisabeth, Nick). Episode 6 was the best episode ever I like how emotional it is! 3.Borneo- I don't think there will be a season like Borneo because its the first one. I like Greg's exit. This season also introduces the "alliance". 4.Amazon- I like the first 4 episodes! It was so interesting to watch! But I hate how Rob controls the game, if Jenna didn't win that two immunities in the end, Rob would have won. I love Christy and I like how they switch alliances so fast making it not predictable! 5.Marquesas- Very average season miles better than S3,S5,S8 but the final suck! I didn't thought Vecepia would win because she's so invisible like Zoe!. 6.All-Stars- Post-merge were the worst ever its painful to watch Robm/amber dominating the game. It was so dissapointing. 7.Africa- Boring I can only remember Lex being angry for receiving 1 vote and the Switch 8.Thailand- The final 7 sucks! The Fake-merge and Ghandia accusing Ted were awesome but overall boring! Post ASS 1. Micronesia- I think there's no episode in this season that I can qualify as boring or just ok! Even though I hate its Half-All Star instead of Full-All Star season, this was an excellent season. The fans are so dumb and not just smart. But I think if James, Jonathan were not evacuated and Kathy didnt quit the season would probably be better. 2. Palau- Ulong losing every week and Stephannie being the last one was awesome to watch! Koror also has personality all their flaws came out after the merge - great cast 3. Cook Islands- this season has so many twists its great to watch, I love watching Jonathan not sharing the food with Parvati and company and there's Candace bitching about it though the last episode sucked! Final 5 in the last ep! and a final 3! 4. China- It has some moments like Peih-Gee going mad at James, Peihgee/Jaime throwing the challenge, Jaime using the hii, Frosti caught Amanda/Todd getting the hii, Denise who completely lied at the reunion totally tops Dre from Fiji! Jean-Robert/Dave being an ass, so vast improvement from Fiji. 5. Guatemala- Has some moments from Stephannie, Judd, Jaime, the Car curse but half of the cast were pretty boring like Brandon, Bobbyjon, Lydia, Cindy, Danni, Rafe and the rest of the pre-merge boots! 6. Vanuatu- Nice cast but some of them are really boring. Ami, Twila, Scout and Eliza were interesting but in some episodes they had some few scenes and the first episode killed the season. 7. Exile Island- Forgettable, the only moment I can think of EI was Cirie in the Tie-breaker, Shane being nuts and Courtney being crazy. I think Fiji has more moments, when it came back to 16 players this season screwed up 3/4 of the cast are boring like Bruce, Nick, Austin, Sally, Aras, Danielle, Misty, Melinda, Ruth Marie! 8. Fiji- Forgettable, so many things happened in this season like Lisi and Rocky being total nuts but they didnt make the merge. Yau, Dre were pretty decent. I like the challenges but I think the cast are the reason why its so forgettable maybe its their aura! POST FVF 1. Tocantins- It was really close to a classic Survivor format but it had HII and Exile Island. But I like Exile Island it doesnt have that cheesy props except for the Urns. The Timbira 6 was just messy I think its stupid of them having the Jalapao 3 reaching the final four. I love Coach - best survivor ever and he is not trying to be the star of the show all the things he said comes out naturally and his antics were never predictable I can't still believe he would have a poem, the title Dragon slayer, the nicknames for everbody, the cane, etc. all of those were awesome. I felt that episode of him when he was voted out that was just priceless even if its all about him. Tocantins has a big start I like the opening sequence, the first impression I like that one and Sandy/Sierra were really mad bcos the tribe picked them out. After that Sandy was looking for that hii instead of making a shelter for her tribe and she doesn't know what a pace is LOL. Episode 5/6 were boring but after that IC in Episode 7 and it gets so good! I also like Dragon vs the Dragon Slayer, Sierra versus Debbie/Coach/Tyson, the Exile alliance, Debbie voting off Coach and Coach was almost speechless when he founds about it, JT losing his tooth, JT and Stephen arguing in the final TC I think its the first time I see the F2 arguing! which is pretty unique! I hate JT winning its a bit typical - Stephen again another good contestant not to win no jury votes was just not acceptable. If only Sandy made at the merge over Taj or Erinn and JT being blindsided or Stephen won over JT Tocantins would have been in my Top 5. 2. Gabon- I like Bob's fake immunity idols, Marcus being screwed in the 2nd switch-up, Sugar fighting with Corinne, Randy being disliked by the tribe and using the fake hidden immunity idol making him one of the biggest fools ever, Sugar crying all the time, Ken's overmanipulation and Crystal's ability in the challenges were the key moments of the season. Ranking of All Seasons Best seasons 1. Micronesia 2. Pearl Islands 3. The Australian Outback 4. Borneo 5. Palau 6. Cook Islands 7. Tocantins Average and So-so Seasons 8- The Amazon 9- China 10- Marquesas 11- Gabon 12- Guatemala 13- Vanuatu 14- Panama Worst Seasons 15- Fiji 16- All-Stars 17- Africa 18- Thailand
Last Edited By: JLK Name
05/18/09 10:10 AM.
Edited 3 times.
|
|||
tomash |
|||
|
1. Pearl Islands (Great season, excellent cast)
2. Micronesia (If the fans had gotten more screen time it would have been my favourite, epic post-merge and the first half was solid as well) 3. Vanuatu (Last couple of episodes were amazing... the females were great, the the fat five not so much - except for Rory and Chris) 4. Marquesas (Just an overall solid season) 5. Guatemala (Underrated) 6. Borneo (Still good) 7. Tocantins (It could have been a lot better, especially on the editing side - the cast was great though) 8. Amazon (It's a good season, but most of the people got on my nerves) 9. Exile Island (Good start, then boring, then fun again, then a horrible ending) 10. Gabon (Clusterfuck season.. I liked it a lot up to the Crystal boot, but watching it after that I just couldn't stand any of the top 5 - really killed the season for me) 11. Palau (Not THAT bad, problem was most of the interesting people were on Ulong, and they all got voted off) 12. All Stars ( Had great potential, but got gradually worse as all the 'best' all stars got voted off one by one) 13. China (Overrated as hell, I liked Courtney/PG/Todd, apart from that it was kinda boring) 14. Australian Outback (After the Jerri-boot it became horribly boring) 15. Fiji (Great challenges + the post merge was OKish, rest of the season though...) 16. Thailand (Had it's moments, but it was generally pretty blah, and I hated most of the cast) 17. Africa (Dull as hell) 18. Cook Islands (Horrible cast, horrible editing, horrible season) |
|||
CSCin3D |
|||
|
Anybody who ranks Tocantins above 14= retarded
|
|||
tomash |
|||
|
Tocantins wasn't that bad, plenty of seasons are worse. Seeing Timbira implode was hilarious. It could have been a lot better though, and I blame the editors/EI/HII. |
|||
molemantn |
|||
|
Tocantins could have been great, but the editors just totally screwed it over. It had all the makings of a great season, but something didn't come together
in the editing room. Probably ignoring everyone else in favor of Coach/Exile alliance in the beginning. I feel like the Taj/Steven/JT alliance could have been
highlighted more, making the end more dramatic.
|
|||
JLK Name |
|||
CSCin3D wrote: And yet you're avatar is the 2nd booted person from a forgettable season. HUH! |
|||
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
CSCin3D wrote: Thailandsurvivor wrote: |
|||
astroline |
|||
|
TOP:
1. Palau 2. China 3. Cook Islands 4. Micronesia MIDDLE: 5. Vanuatu 6. Exile Island 7. Marquesas 8. Gabon 9. Borneo 10. Tocantins 11. Africa 12. Pearl Islands BOTTOM: 13. Australia 14. Thailand 15. Fiji HAVEN'T SEEN -- Amazon, All Stars, Guatemala |
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
astroline wrote:Those are like 2 of the greatest seasons (to me) 1. Marquesas 2. Guatemala 3. Amazon 4. Vanuatu 5. Borneo 6. Africa 7. Thailand 8. Pearl Islands 9. Gabon 10. Australia 11. China 12. Fiji 13. Exile Island 14. Tocantins 15. Micronesia 16. All-Stars 17. Palau 18. Cook Islands |
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
JLK Name wrote:A 2nd boot isn't always forgettable, most times they are more memorable than half the cast. i.e, Melinda, Candace. |
|||
pushingjate |
|||
|
Wow, why are people putting Australia so low? No season has come close to the greatness of Australia (and S1). These were the days when Survivor was #1 in the
ratings. They actually focused on the elements, and you had a lot of great characters come out from Australia. The only thing exile/immunity idols have done
are turn this show into the shit that plays on VH1 now.
|
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
pushingjate wrote:I didn't see Australia on its original run. I do agree that it was great, but the ending was unbearable. I don't like the GOOD PEOPLE DESERVE TO WIN crap that was shoved down our throats... |
|||
JLK Name |
|||
YemaGrl1988 wrote:and Dolly |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
YemaGrl1988 wrote:I'll give you Candace, but Melinda? Really? She's the most forgettable cast member from Exile. Or if not her, then she's bottom 3 with Nick and Ruth Marie. |
|||
1TxT1 |
|||
|
1. Micronesia
2. Cook Islands 3. Pearl Islands 4. All-Stars 5. Exile Island 6. Fiji 7. Amazon 8. Tocantins 9. China 10. Gabon 11. Palau 12. Marquesas 13. Vanuatu 14. Guatemala 15. Thailand 16. Africa 17. Borneo 18. Outback |
|||
ZeWish |
|||
|
1. Pearl Islands
2. Australian Outback 3. China 4. Exile Island 5. Micronesia 6. Borneo 7. Tocantins 8. Palau 9. Guatemala 10. Amazon 11. Marquesas 12. Gabon 13. Marquesas 14. Vanuatu 15. Thailand 16. All-Stars 17. Fiji 18. Africa |
|||
Deadpool |
|||
|
1. ASS
2. Tocantins 3. Micronesia 4. Gabon 5. Fiji 6. China 7. Cook Islands 8. Pearl Islands 9. Palau 10. Vanuatu 11. Amazon 12. Exile Island 13. Guatemala 14. Marquesas 15. Thailand 16. Africa 17. Outback 18. Borneo |
|||
PJMichaelangelo |
|||
Raydawggie wrote:The twist didn't cost Marcus the game. MARCUS cost Marcus the game. All he had to do was reassure Susie and he couldn't be bothered to do so. |
|||
craig |
|||
|
Post ASS
1. Micronesia 2. Vanuatu, Cook Islands 4. Guatemala, China, Gabon 7. Palau, EI, Tocantins 10. Fiji |
|||