So who was that one person that singlehandedly killed a season for you, whether it be by stopping a power shift or just plain sucking the life out of the show?
0 Kudo
- Survivor Sucks
- Lions, Tigers, Survivors - Oh My!
- Survivor Spoilers
- MESS Hall Tribal Council
- MESS Hall Archive
- Survivor Speculation
- Survivor 20+
- The Amazing Race
- Big Brother
- Big Brother - PAST SEASONS
- The Apprentice
- American Idol
- American Idol PAST SEASONS
- The Mole
- Lost
- Other Shows That Suck
- Off Topic
- Clubs That Suck. No, Really.
- The Dump
- Monster Island
- Purgatory
- FAQ
- In Memory, 9/11/01
Who Ruined Each Season?
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 CSCin3D |
Who Ruined Each Season? |
Lead | |
|
Posts: 13526 (06/09/07 10:22 AM) Registered user |
|
||
 SenseiKreese |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 2886 (06/09/07 10:29 AM) Registered user |
Season 1: Dr. Sean Season 2: Nobody (maybe Kimmi) Season 3: Kim J. Season 4: Sarah Season 5: Jan Season 6: Jenna Season 7: Lill Season 8: Boston Rob Season 9: Nobody Season 10: Caryn Season 11: Rafe or Lydia Seasons 12-: Don't care |
||
|
Angelus |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 304 (06/09/07 10:52 AM) Registered user |
Season 4: Vee
Season 8: Rob M Season 10: Everybody Season 13: Yul Season 14: Earl |
||
|
RobVanStratus |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 9482 (06/09/07 11:04 AM) Registered User |
Borneo - Pagong for voting off Joel instead of Gretchen. Take out Gretchen and Pagong may have actually listed to Joel about the alliance they would have made an exciting game.
Sean K./Kelly for not changing the game up at the F8. Had Sean not revealed his vote for Jenna, the vote would have likely tied 3-3-1-1. Australia - Amber. Dumb bitch didn't switch sides to join Elisabeth/Rodger at the F6 for a F3 shot, which was a place better than if Ogakor had stuck together. Africa - Brandon for not switching at the F9 and Kim J for not wanting to go with a female alliance at the F3. Marquesas - No one. Thank goodness for the F9 power struggle. Some people made mistakes on their own that ruined their own game, but it didn't ruin the season. Thailand - Mark Burnett. Fake merge got rid of the potential for a real betrayal with Shii-Ann leaving Sook Jai. Penny would have gone first, followed by Ken and Erin. Shii-Ann/Jake would have then had a better shot of turning Ted/Helen, who would have turned and then used Jan's vote to regain control. Brian would have lost and that would have been sad to me, but it would have been a more exciting game. Amazon - Alex/Dave/Heidi/Jenna. The four of them were a disgusting little group of brats and full of themselves. Jenna deserved to win, but their piss poor behavior throughout the season made it hard to watch sometimes. Pearl Islands - Jon/Rupert. Stupid assholes made it about them, causing other great players to be ignored. And Andrew for being a @#%$ to Lil and whining. Allstars - Romber. Nuff said. Vanuatu - Lopevi not voting off Chris first. Palau - The quitters, Ashlee/Jeff/Janu/Ian. And Mark Burnett again for having 2 people not get to play the game. Guatemala - Gary/Danni. That stupid storyline of Danni knowing who Gary was ruined the season. And Rafe ruined it as well when he and Danni had to be self righteous and say Cindy should have given up her car. Exile Island - Terry/Nick/Austin/Dan for having that dumbass boys club that ruined La Mina and made Ruth Marie/Misty go out early when it shoulda been any of those 4 fucks. Cook Islands - Parvati/Adam. Stupid cunts made the season unbearable, especially Parvati. She acted like she was an amazing player but she just sucked, both in the game and off cameras. Fiji - Dreamz for being an asshole and costing Yau-Man his win, Mark Burnett for dicking over Michelle. |
||
|
WylDawg |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 21007 (06/09/07 11:18 AM) Registered user |
As much as I DESPISE Romber, how could they have possibly ruined ASS?
All they did was form an alliance and ride it to the end, which any rational player would try to do. Everyone else who were alligned with them and didn't even try to split them up ARE the ones who ruined the season. But mostly that other guy, what was his name?........ Oh, TWATWAFFLE!!! Also, why is Amber always the only one to blame for Colby/Tina/Keith dominating? Aren't Filarski and the old guy just as guilty? Instead of using Amber to split them up, they prefered accepting they're respective 5th and 4th place while kissing Tina and Colby's ass along the way. |
||
|
tullfan2 |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 3993 (06/09/07 11:23 AM) Registered User |
S1 - Greg (for refusing to play)
S2 - Varner (for stepping off the perch) S3 - Brandon (for being too cute and thwarting the power shift) S4 - Gabriel (for refusing to play) S5 - Jan S6 - Dave (for not exploiting the info that Jenna spilled) S7 - Andrew (for alienating Lil) S8 - Mark Burnett (for casting Rob M. instead of Sean Rector who deserved it more) S9 - Eliza (for being a pawn) S10 - Caryn S11 - Stephenie S12 - Terry S13 - Nate (for insisting that Raro vote for Yul) S14 - Lisi (for being annoyingly insane) For many seasons, it's hard to choose just one person |
||
|
sweEt Mauritius |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 836 (06/09/07 12:29 PM) Registered user |
S1 - Sean, he was just so annoying, self-righteous, and just terrible in all social/gameplay aspects
S2 - Colby, again very annoying, full of stupid sayings, whereas Kelly's challenge streak was fun and not too big his was just annoying esp. near the end S5 - Mark Burnett or whoever decided a fake merge was a good idea, because Thailand could have been great had Shii Ann been able to vote with Chuay Gahn to get rid of Penny S6 - Matthew, for being so oblivious to everyone else's thoughts on him, for thinking he was smart, etc. S7 - ANDREW, for being so melodramatic about everything, for getting mad at Lil for playing the game and actually saying at the reunion that she shouldn't be allowed to play like everyone else because she was in a boy scout uniform. One of my least favorite people ever. S8 - Lex, for getting rid of Jerri instead of Amber. Still don't know why they were afraid of what Rob would do. THey would have had the freaking majority. ugh. S9 - Sarge, for flipping out on Twila about a situation he wasn't a part of, his obviously fake "fakeout" at the final TC, his telling Twila she cast her son to hell (wtf?), and for trying to act cool S10 - Ian, for acting like such a wimp in most situations esp. final episode, for his Katie love, and for smelling bad :) S11 - Rafe, for being so bitter about Danni's final decision which he gave his permission for and for being so selfish about Cindy's car decision, when he would have voted her out anyway S12 - Terry, for being himself S13 - Becky/Ozzy/Sundra (they're so interchangeable it's like they're one person), for allowing Yul to win so easily, for being boring, for not doing much of anything (except for Ozzy who boringly won challenges) S14 - Dreamz, for messing up everyone's plans making it difficult for any kind of overthrow of Earl and Yau to occur, for being annoying, for being stupid, for lying to everyone at the reunion saying he was playing Yau the whole time about the car, for trying to make himself look smart, for not being voted out instead of Lisi. |
||
|
fanofcoils |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 3177 (06/09/07 12:31 PM) I need a life |
Who was worse, Andrew or Lex?
Would Andrew have been mad at Rob M backstabbing him? Would Lex hate Lil? |
||
|
fanofcoils |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 3177 (06/09/07 12:32 PM) I need a life |
Wanda and Jonathan did get to play the game. They got a chance to form impressions, alliances, etc. And they were the worst to do so.
|
||
|
sweEt Mauritius |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 836 (06/09/07 12:37 PM) Registered user |
Quote: Easily Andrew. I don't even really dislike Lex as a person, I just thought he made a really bad mistake in the game and got too bitter about it, but at least he did have a reason for being bitter. Andrew, on the other hand, was just plain annoying. He was just so overdramatic about everything (crying when Morgan won immunity? come on), he defends Osten so much in the PI commentaries its disgusting, and then disses Lil because she made a move that was the best for herself. Your tribe treated her like crap and you want her to stay with you guys now that she's come back and there's a merge, but she goes with the tribe that shows her respect and kindness. But she was in a boy scout uniform so even though everyone else has a right to play the game, she doesn't. Get over it. God, I just realized how much I really do hate him. 
|
||
|
YemaGrl1988 |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 8333 (06/09/07 1:17 PM) Registered user |
1) Sean. Stupid. Annoying. Fuckhead.
2) Colby. Boring and predictable in immunities. 3) Brandon for not switching at F9. 5) Mark Burnett for that Late Merge shit. 7) Jon, too annoying and not entertaining (in my view) 8) Everyone! 10) Steph. For voting off your strongest member first and thus making your season so predictable. 11) Rafe. 12) Terry 13) Yul, Ozzy, Becky, Adam, Jonathan, Candice, Nate and Casting People. 14) Earl and Yau Man. Boring stupid people. |
||
|
Quiddity |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 6726 (06/09/07 1:38 PM) Registered User |
I would hardly say any season has ever been "ruined" with perhaps the exception of All Stars. Who was the most responsible for any bad aspects of the season though? ...
Borneo - Sean, by being so vocal about his idiotic alphabet strategy and not comprehending that Tagi would use him to have complete control over the game. Australia - Kimmi, for revealing that Jeff had a prior vote, which led to the less likable (IMHO) Ogakor seizing control despite the fact that Kucha dominated pre-merge. Africa - Kim P. While she was the hottest girl that season, even more IMHO than fan favorites Jessie and Kelly, she was willing to completely destroy Samburu simply because she was mad at Brandon. Could have had complete control over the game if not for that. Marquesas - Hmm. To be honest I can't really think of anyone here. I'm pretty happy with how things turned out. Thailand - Whoever had the genius idea on Sook Jai of throwing pre-merge challenges, which resulted in old, boring Chuay Gahn dominating the post-merge. Amazon - Dave, for making the smart move of seperating Heidi and Jenna, but then making the moronic move of voting out Jeanne instead, then targetting Christy at the merge instead of one of them. A big reason why Amazon had one of the stupidest casts ever. Pearl Islands - Lill, for being so negative all the time, portraying the Boy Scouts in a bad light (I'm an Eagle Scout), and making one of the most predictable F2 finishes ever. All Stars - Twatwaffle. Responsible for getting rid of many stars early in the season then when he could have broken up Romber and saved the season, he votes out the worst possible person. His ridiculously hypocritical attitude and expectation that outside relationships would trump gameplay came close to completely destroying this season. Vanuatu - Leann. My fave woman from the season, one of my favorites ever, but being so public about booting Scout from their F4 turned what would have been the hottest F4 ever into Thailand redux at the F3. And ever since the women's alliance collapses women have really had no shot at winning the game outside of Danni. Palau - Ian, for being one of the big time players of the season only to quit at the most important time. Guatemala - Stephenie. While the season was great, if they hadn't spent such an absurd amount of time on her than women like Danni, Cindy and Lydia would have gotten more time and the season could have been even greater. Exile Island - Terry. Completely dominated physically, that with the HII at F4 got him all the way to F3. But the guy was an ass, a strategic retard, and the producers had a hard on for him so we got way too much of him. Cook Islands - The producers. The HII, the F3, the horrible casting, the horrible editing, the bottle twist, how much more can I say? Yul was a tremendous social and strategic player but I can't properly rate him because the twists this season were so unfair. Fiji - Dreamz, for backstabbing my fave, Yao-man, and creating an insanely predicable F3 sweep. |
||
|
fanofcoils |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 3177 (06/09/07 1:38 PM) I need a life |
Borneo - Kelly W. Very annoying with the "I don't like alliances" thing
Australia - Elisabeth. Wasn't entertaining. Wasn't that big of a sweetheart. And was a bit of a jerk. Africa - Lex. Self entitled. Marquesas - Sean/Kathy. Sean was entertaining early on but after that became boring and a caricature of himself. Kathy stopped being rootable late game for whatever reason. Thailand - Ted. He was really annoying except when he talked to Shii Ann. His only nice moment in the game. Amazon - Deena. She screwed up Rob C's plans. Pearl Islands - Andrew. He was an ass. All-Stars - Lex. He was an ass the whole game. Vanuatu - Sarge. He needed to calm down. Palau - Caryn. Ruined Stephenie's chances at F7. Guatamala - Stephenie (version 2.0). She was really boring, a complete opposite of how she was on Palau. Exile Island - Cirie (shocking!). I couldn't think of anyone who ruined this season and I think Cirie is All-Stars worthy, but Cirie really had a negative attitude at times (brushing off Shane during the pecking order RC and being rude to Terry at night after that TC, though you could say Terry was also being rude to her). Cirie should always be colorful cause she is a colorful charisma! Cook Islands - Ozzy. He was doing well and then at the end became REALLY REALLY boring. Fiji - Rocky. Focused on a lot early on the season and mostly wasn't entertaining. |
||
|
ptcruisn56 |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 5223 (06/09/07 1:54 PM) Registered user |
For me personally during initial viewing...
S1 - None S2 - Colby's challenge dominance S3 - Kim J S4 - Vee S5 - Clay S6 - Matthew S7 - None S8 - Romber S9 - None S10 - Everyone after Coby got out S11 - None, maybe Lydia S12 - Danielle S13 - Becky S14 - Dreamz More so is that I felt a lot of these people held back what could have been really great moments |
||
|
cuauhtemocace2 |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 1908 (06/09/07 2:05 PM) I need a life |
1 - Sean
2 - Keith 3 - Twatwaffle 4 - General 5 - Clay 6 - Rob 7 - JFP/Poopert/Andrew 8 - JennaL/Twatwaffle 9 - Chris/Scout 10 - Caryn 11 - Judd/Rafe 12 - Aras 13 - Yul 14 - Dreamz |
||
|
cardswin5 |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 2161 (06/09/07 2:27 PM) Registered user |
1. Sean
2. No one 3. Lex 4. Tammy 5. Jan 6. Dave 7. Lill 8. Everyone 9. Scout 10. Ian 11. Stephenie 12. Terry 13. Everyone 14. Dreamz |
||
|
fsmdud |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 1935 (06/09/07 2:44 PM) Registered user |
1. Basically only Sean K. for being a fuckin retard. But it was the first season and we wouldve probably been excited even if some shits like Ramona/BB/Sonja made it to F3.
2. Keith was a waste of space, as were Amber and Nick. Varner, shut the fuck up. 3. Lex and Brandon and Kim J all blew major weenis. 4. I think only Gabe and Zoe. But even Gabes boot due to his apathy toward the game was somewhat interesting. As has been said before, no one really ruined this season. 5. Ghandia. Fat bitch and her accusations were not entertainment yet got so much airtime. Also to Ken/Penny/Shitann/Jake/Aaron for booting Robb. He was in no way a threat for the endgame. 6. Rob C. Stupid douchebag hogged all the camera time (twice as many confessionals as the next highest I think) with his pre-rehearsed lines that werent even funny. Christy for fucking up and whining. Deena for going on a power trip and thereby depriving herself of becoming the best female winner ever. Dave for being a boring pile of useless shit. 7. Fagplay and Poopert for making the whole story and season all about them. Fuckers, rot in hell for ruining Survivor for good. None of the other 14 committed anything remotely as bad. 8. Romber. Rupert and JennaL for being stupid. Lex for being stupid. Sue for flipping out. 9. Lisa for opening her fuckin mouth and losing Ami's trust. Lisa would have shaken things up at the merge and wouldve possibly sided with the boys. 10. All of them sucked, but I think all members of the F5 take the prize here. 11. Steph. Rafe for being a pussybitch. Lydia for sticking around as long as she did and not doing anything useful. 12. Terry/Dan/Austin/Nick STUPID FUCKIN SHITHEADS. FOUR GUYS ALLIANCE HOW FUCKIN RETARDED ARE YOU. You know you suck when you make us love a fruity yoga dude, a stoner chick, a coked-up spaz, a horse of course, and a fat useless bitch. 13. Yul and Becky. Suckage. Rebecca/Jenny/Brad/JP/Ceci for agreeing to be on the show. 14. DREAMZ. That wasnt strategy. That was called just plain being fuckin retarded. Runner up: Attention whore Rocky. |
||
|
finishthemoff |
That's it... | ||
|
Posts: 15489 (06/09/07 8:03 PM) Registered user |
Quote: The "old guy" actually want to recruit Amber, but Elizabeth is too hell bent on being another Colleen. True story. My list.... 1) Gretchen - even in different countries, alliance is thought of. 2) Michael - for falling in the fire 3) Brandon - for not making his intent clear 4) Sean - race card left a bad taste in my mouth 5) Ken - the most overrated player in this season. He basically sucks and didn't play hard. He took out three strong players and cost his tribe the entire game. 6) Christy - She didn't even watch the show! 7) Andrew - an eptiome of bully/braggort 8) Lex - his sense of entitlement ruins the entire show. I'm glad that someone like Shi Ann, Alicia, Amber, and even Big Tom (Lex betrayed him in their season) 9) Lisa - so glad she left. A MILF that is more like MIDLF. 10) Kim- Her choice of picking James and not Jonathon singlehandedly destroy Ulong. 11) Rafe- for not having any personality and essentially became Rob C without charm or "charisma". 12) Tennis Ace- just basically for reading the spoiler and want to rub that in our face witih incessant Danielle's love. At least CSC have the balls for having favorite in the beginning and not relying on spoiler. In the end, he wants to earn (and somewhat succeed) certain Sucksters' sympathy. 13) Ozzy- I'm a fan of Ozzy, but he single-handedly ruin the season by bringing Sundra-Becky-Yul to Final Four. 14) Cassandra-Dreamz- It didn't make any sense that Earl wasn't in their tribe and all of the sudden, decide that it was a good idea to align with him when there are other better goats like Stacey out there. Combined, they made "Crash" out of that season. |
||
|
Pulau Tiga |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 5726 (06/09/07 8:12 PM) Registered user |
Borneo - Sean (though out of all of these, I definitely still like him more than most)
Australia - Nick Africa - Kim P. (Kim J's the runner-up) Marquesas - Vecepia Thailand - Ghandia Amazon - Jenna Pearl Islands - Lill (just because she booted Fairplay) ASS - Amber (JLew's the runner-up) Vanuatu - Leann Palau - Katie (potentially Caryn) Guatemala - Stephenie Exile Island - Aras Cook Islands - The Editors (or Ozzy, but at least he made for a suspenseful final vote) Fiji - Earl |
||
|
JaMalle |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 4769 (06/09/07 8:55 PM) Registered User |
Ooo I like this listing thread!
S2- Amber for not preventing the non-Tina/Keith/Colby Pagong... S3- Brandon for F*ing up that Kelly vote. S4- Ummm Kathy's right boob, because it fell out and cost her a million. S5- Jan because she did absolutely nothing and didn't know how to play the game. S6- Jenna, because she was a stupid mean and ugly bitch who won. S7- Darrah actually pissed me off with her bad gameplay, but I'd say Tijuana, because she prevented the first unanimous vote AND she directed the first boot, Nicole. : { S8- Lamber Woah she has two spots! lol S9- Scout being useless in as many ways as possible. She was immature, pathetic, and generally unlikeable to me. S10- Caryn for ruining Katie's game our of spite and serving it on a silver platter to Tom. S11- It was perfect, but I guess I'd say Rafe, because he turned into an ugly hypocritical arrogant pmpus asswipe by the end of the season, and it was ugly. S12- Terry winning all those damn ICs, caused the survival of both Aras and Terry... Why couldn't one of Courtney/Danielle/Cirie win?!! S13- Johnathan ruined Raro and in addition, Candice. Cool story, but Johnathan sucked. S14- Dreamz for NOT giving Yau-Man the idol. |
||
|
SurvivorNinja |
Re: Who Ruined Each Season? | ||
|
Posts: 3122 (06/09/07 9:11 PM) Registered user |
Borneo - Kelly and Sean for not flipping to Pagong at F7.
Australia - Michael for falling in the fire. Africa - Jessie for getting sick so early. Marquesas - Neleh and Paschal for not letting Neleh go at F4. Thailand - Helen (and Ted, Jan, Clay) for trusting Brian. Amazon - Butch..for lasting so long. Pearl Islands - Michelle for being a pig at the Gross Food Milkshake competition. All Stars - Sue for Qutting. Vanuatu - Dolly for getting voted out so early. Pulau - Burnett for eliminating Wanda and Jonathan the way they were. Guatemala - Gary and his stupid NFL lie (Good person/character...terrible storyline). Panama - Danielle for making F2. Cook Islands - Nathan because I just didn't care for him at all. Fiji - Yau-Man's HII for eliminating Stacy. |
||
- Survivor Sucks
- Lions, Tigers, Survivors - Oh My!
- Survivor Spoilers
- MESS Hall Tribal Council
- MESS Hall Archive
- Survivor Speculation
- Survivor 20+
- The Amazing Race
- Big Brother
- Big Brother - PAST SEASONS
- The Apprentice
- American Idol
- American Idol PAST SEASONS
- The Mole
- Lost
- Other Shows That Suck
- Off Topic
- Clubs That Suck. No, Really.
- The Dump
- Monster Island
- Purgatory
- FAQ
- In Memory, 9/11/01
