Corrine and I's response to her placing: KEEP HATING!
Onions (minus Randy) <3
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
JaMalle |
|||
|
|
|||
Small Town Boy |
|||
|
Can we just have a new update so we can stop the argument between Michelle and others?
Preditctions.... Joanna Amber All Stars and Sue All Stars out. |
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 wrote:To say she deserved it over Amanda, who picked up steam by the season's end, was just on the show (and is thus infinitely more memorable than that chick already), and made it to the finale is just ludicrous. Who cares if Michelle was screwed by a twist if she wasn't interesting. Aaron was screwed over, Jonathan Libby was screwed over, Willard was screwed over, etc, and none of them were interesting and none of them deserved to be back in any way shape or form. Again, who cares if her ever so interesting personality was hidden, does that mean half of the other bad edits deserve a second chance? She was not a good choice, given that there are over 20 people were better picks. And given that they needed 5, no dice. Hell even if they needed 10. Especially since they already had 3 definitely more worthy people from her season alone (Earl, Dreamz, Yau-Man -- now I'm not saying she's the 4th most deserving, but at least there's no debate that those 3 deserved it more). Now I'm not going to justify Amanda's position as an all star, since she only got cast for being Erica Shay's friend, but there is no chance in hell that Michelle was a good choice to replace her. |
|||
Pulau Tiga |
|||
Thailandsurvivor wrote: Ciny is not hot or likable, and was indeed completely boring. And she wasn't screwed over by a twist. Neither Parvati nor Amanda should have been on Micronesia, but Cindy would have been far worse of a casting choice than either of them. Anyway, I agree with Osten and Lisi being so low. They're similarly low on my rankings. I have to rewatch Gabon before I can pass judgement on Corrine, but eh, no loss with her ranking near the bottom. Lex is severly underrated, but I get why people hate him. Amanda is a random choice to have ranked so low. I don't really care about her one way or the other, but she wasn't unlikable by any means, I don't think. Hell, she was my pre-season favorite (and winner pick) for China, and it's not like she ruined Micronesia by being the inevitable obligatory bad casting choice who wins the season (that was Parv). Rocky was an amazing character and a lot of fun to watch. Yeah, the guy was a camera whore, and yeah, he was obnoxious, and yeah, he treated Anthony awfully. But you need characters like him on the show and had he lasted longer, people probably would have liked Fiji just a little bit more. He was really entertaining and I liked him, honestly. I mean, Lisi was entertaining in a perverse way as well, but because she was so painful to endure and is clearly such a detestable human being on every front, I can't even recognize her entertainment value. |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
|
|||
CSCin3D |
|||
|
Christy was a whiny kunt. She totally deserved it.
Cruelty to deaf people <3 |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Oh, and about the spoilers, I'm only doing five next update, so there's some overlap, not six people.
|
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
|
Amber, Jenna, and Dreamz next?
<3 Kitty for keeping Amber in another update. |
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
|
WTH at Matty and JoAnna. I hate Burton too.
|
|||
Small Town Boy |
|||
|
Next update tonite or tomorrow?
|
|||
pinoyako |
|||
|
What a weird choice for Matty's picture. o_o
|
|||
SFC |
|||
|
Thank God Matty was so low. Couldn't stand him and the way Jeff adored him
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
Small Town Boy wrote:It's almost 1 in the morning, and since I have work tomorrow, there might not be a new update until Friday. |
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 8021 (05/20/09 11:03 PM) Registered user |
Somewhat in Ozzys defense, it seems he is so low only due to your dislike of JAOP, which is fine in itself but you can't blame him for making a logical
decision. For someone who didn't watch the show, he had a pretty decent understanding of strategy, and had a good social game.
Also, he was a cocky jerk in Cook Islands. The little spat he made about the mutiny is evidence of that. I can understand where he's coming from because I know someone people who are like him, and comparing him to Lex is "blech" worthy. |
||
Pulau Tiga |
|||
|
Ozzy was exactly the same in Micronesia as he was in CI, and I don't get why so few people saw that the first time around. I really disliked him in both
seasons, and that's part of the reason I was so happy to see Yul beat him (although I never really understood why so many people used editing to jump on
the Ozzy bandwagon, when Yul clearly had a stereotypical winning edit and Ozzy did not).
I liked Matty, actually. Maybe I was just preparing myself for his inevitable win after Marcus was booted. But that never happened, and I still kinda like the guy. I suppose if I had payed more attention to Gabon, I would have seen all his hypocrisy and awful personality that everyone talks about. But with my very casual viewing of the season, I bought into the editing. He seemed nice. Joanna sucked. Burton was cool, and he's one of those people who made lots of mistakes but is still probably a decent player on most fronts. At least he understood the game, he just had a tendency to make the wrong moves. But for the last fucking time, there was nothing hypocritical about his final words (although they were certainly bitter, which is a negative). Sure, he wrote Lill's name down, but that's because it was his response to her betraying him. She turned on him, so he and Fairplay turned on her. I don't get how everyone tries to make his final words into some sort of monstrosity when all he was doing was complaining about being screwed over. Fairplay was fucking awesome. I mean, he's an awful human being. But as a reality TV show character, he's fantastic. He helped make PI the best season ever, and his return to Micronesia was really the most fitting way I could imagine him playing Survivor one more time. The fact that him staying would have made the season so much more awesome is just a testament to how great he was. |
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
That JFP pic is such lulz. He has personal style <3
|
|||
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
Pulau Tiga wrote:X |
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Ozzy was my least favorite ever even before Micronesia. He was horrendous in Cook Islands.
I hate Matty so much. He was just as hypocritical and self-righteous as Sugar, but Sugar at least did stuff to prove her point, while Matty just sat back and acted like a whiny little baby. He did nothing all season, but people liked him for some reason. If he won, then Gabon would probably be the worst season ever. |
|||
chapera rocks |
|||
Thailandsurvivor wrote:X I actually liked Matty. |
|||
Joaqenix |
|||
CSCin3D wrote: Yeah, Ozzy was the exact same both seasons. I liked him better on Micronesia only because his douchiness was so evident and they weren't trying to hide it <3 |
|||