It's time to rightfully crown Natalie Bolton as the winner of Micronesia.

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
survivorisdabest		#81	[-]
Posts: 2770 (04/25/09 12:43 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Natalie did not make a dumb decision by sending Jason to Exile. She gained his trust by doing so. Taking him out might not have been the right decision, but she was still in a strong majority either way. lol you just explained why she is dumb. She had to either a)stick with wanting jason out and NOT sent him to exile or b)stick with wanting to keep him and NOT blindside him. Doing half and half is moronic and just ensured that she would both not get his jury vote and continue being parvati's pawn and stay there until parvati got rid of her. I agree that Alexis was a fucking moron for sending Amanda to Exile, and I will never defend her. Erik was the same way at the final 5. Actually if you think about it Alexis was not as bad as Natalie because atleast Amanda wasnt the #1 target at the time she was sent to exile, james and erik were. Nat on the other hand sent the #1 target. it should have never been an issue when they did not rehide the idols in China. THE MICRONESIA CONTESTANTS DIDNT SEE THE SECOND HALF OF CHINA so why are you saying what happens in china is relevant to micronesia? Now, you are saying because it was rehidden in Fiji. If it was rehidden in Fiji, then why the fuck weren't they rehidden this season? That is my point!! Every season has different rules, they all dont have to have the exact same rules so stop acting like micro should not have had rehidden idols just because China and tocantins didnt! That's bullshit and never happened. Cirie said in post show interviews that she knew about the idol, not at the final 5 Um no please watch the final 5 episode again in the first scene when they get back from tribal. Cirie has a confessional where she says "Amanda had me right at the point where i was ready to force a tie". Thats a fact and you just dont remember the episode Cirie was much more of Parvati's pawn than Natalie was. She freaking said that she wouldn't have voted with Natalie to force a tie if they knew it was a final two. She was playing for Amanda and Parvati. With that said, Cirie probably would have forced the tie if there was no idol in play lol MASSIVE CONTRADICTION right here. You admit that Cirie was 100% with Parvmanda yet suddenly say she wouldnt have worked with them?? You cant say that a player of Cirie's caliber wouldnt force a tie. The fact is that a player of Cirie's caliber WOULD take a risk and force a tie against the fans in order to avoid entering a final 5 where she would be the first gone. Cirie is not a moron like the fans were. why does that only mean a fan is leaving? It doesnt, but it doesnt mean a favourite leaving either. Natalie is ridiculously awesome and entertaining but you need to realise she did several dumb things and got completely outplayed by the favourites. You can make a "_____ only lost because ____" argument for any survivor (and most of them would probably be more valid than your one for natalie IMO) but facts are facts and Nat made dumb moves and was not robbed at all.
Thailandsurvivor		#82	[-]
Posts: 6366 (04/25/09 12:49 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Since you're not listening to any of my points, I'm only responding to this. survivorisdabest wrote: Cirie was much more of Parvati's pawn than Natalie was. She freaking said that she wouldn't have voted with Natalie to force a tie if they knew it was a final two. She was playing for Amanda and Parvati. With that said, Cirie probably would have forced the tie if there was no idol in play lol MASSIVE CONTRADICTION right here. You admit that Cirie was 100% with Parvmanda yet suddenly say she wouldnt have worked with them?? You cant say that a player of Cirie's caliber wouldnt force a tie. The fact is that a player of Cirie's caliber WOULD take a risk and force a tie against the fans in order to avoid entering a final 5 where she would be the first gone. Cirie is not a moron like the fans were. Please learn to read. I said Cirie proved in post show interviews that she was following them, so she most likely (that's what probably means) will vote for Alexis. That doesn't mean the fans were majorly outplayed because there was a better chance at a favorite leaving at the final 6 with Erik winning immunity. But with all the talk about Cirie being the best player to never win, I like to think she isn't a moron who would risk her game on a purple rock when she wasn't even protecting her final two ally.
survivorisdabest		#83	[-]
Posts: 2771 (04/25/09 1:16 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	lol oops i read "probably would have forced the tie" as "probably wouldnt have forced the tie" my bad So how come now you are saying you think she wouldnt NOT have forced a tie when right before you said she would have forced the tie? wtf that is actually a contradiction and lol @ me apparently not listening to your points. i listened to them all and responded to them you said nat didnt make a dumb decision by sending jason to exile and i listened and explained why she did. how is that not listening? Same with the others. Im guessing you just dont have any comebacks to them because you cant defend natalie's bad gameplay anymore
Thailandsurvivor		#84	[-]
Posts: 6367 (04/25/09 1:21 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	You're saying it was dumb for Natalie to send Jason to Exile which doesn't make any sense. It put her in a position where she could have easily worked with him if she wanted to because he fully trusted her, but she didn't want to work with him since she'd be still be in a good position by sticking with the girl power group. Your argument is that Jason found the idol, but you seem to forget that he left anyways, so how did it make a difference? I can understand the argument that she would have been better off aligning with Jason, but there was no cons to sending Jason to exile since she managed to stop him from playing the idol. ETA- As far as Cirie voting at the final 6, yes, I do think she would have stuck with Parvmanda by voting for Alexis originally. Do I think she would have voted the same way in the revote? No. The best player to never win would not risk their game on pure luck...unless she's not as good of a player as people make her out to be. Last Edited By: Thailandsurvivor 04/25/09 1:24 AM. Edited 1 times.
hagiz1		#85	[-]
Posts: 502 (04/25/09 1:30 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	jeez, TS you know even your writing is dumb. You're saying Natalie is not dumb for sending Jason to Exile because she wanted to work with him? And then you're saying she didn't want to? You know your sentence just canceled one another? If she didn't want to work with Jason, why bother? Dude, just admit it that you're too stupid to make a good comeback to anyone here.
Thailandsurvivor		#86	[-]
Posts: 6368 (04/25/09 1:35 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Learn to read people. No, Natalie was not dumb for keeping her options open. I'm too stupid to make a good comeback? Nice one. You're not worth my time.
survivorisdabest		#87	[-]
Posts: 2772 (04/25/09 3:16 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Learn to read people. No, Natalie was not dumb for keeping her options open. pfft you really think Natalie sent jason to KEEP HER OPTIONS OPEN?? I'm sorry but that is laughable, she even admitted to only doing it because noone volounteered. Your argument is that Jason found the idol, but you seem to forget that he left anyways, so how did it make a difference? Yes it made a difference. It completely lost her his jury vote for no reason. Also if it was a player with a brain (eg. Jonathan or actually ANYONE except jason and erik) then they would have played the idol and she would have ruined the BWB's entire plan. The best player to never win would not risk their game on pure luck The best player to never win would not WILLINGLY ENTER A FINAL 5 WHERE SHE IS THE FIRST ONE GONE.
survivorisdabest		#88	[-]
Posts: 2773 (04/25/09 3:18 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I will give Natalie credit that she is amazing at manipulating, but that is only when she is spoonfed plans from the favourites and told exactly what to do. That is her only plus in gameplay, other than that she makes stupid decisions and seems to not even plan 2 days ahead.
hagiz1		#89	[-]
Posts: 503 (04/25/09 3:33 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Thailandsurvivor wrote: Learn to read people. No, Natalie was not dumb for keeping her options open. I'm too stupid to make a good comeback? Nice one. You're not worth my time. yeah only dumb people who can't give a good come back who said things like above. lol. And the fact that you didn't even defend the way you contradict yourself in one sentence just reassure us in sucks that you probably have IQ below 50. If I'm not worth your time, stop yapping and writing. thank anyway for the compliment. I know I can kick your ass real good sometimes. Last Edited By: hagiz1 04/25/09 3:38 AM. Edited 1 times.
RobVanStratus		#90	[-]
Posts: 8115 (04/25/09 3:54 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Talking about Cirie forcing a tie at the F4 is stupid, considering if she did it she'd probably have lost the game still, just in a different manner. If she forces the tie with Natalie and wins, Parvati leaves, which was her F2 goat. She had her stomped in the votes and knew it. Then Manhanda probably wins the final IC and votes Cirie off for revenge, taking Natalie to the F2. Cirie planned on a F3 with the sluts and it only failed because James got an infected finger and they switched to a F2 so they didn't waste challenges they had made. Cirie's only failure in the endgame was her inability to hold that board up with the little ball on it, which like I already said about the F3/F2 situation, shouldn't have mattered anyways.
trickmind		#91	[-]
Posts: 1123 (04/25/09 4:10 AM) Dragonslayer Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Shut up about Natalie she's not on this season.
survivorisdabest		#92	[-]
Posts: 2776 (04/25/09 4:57 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Cirie said that if she had known that it was a F2 then she still would have stuck with parvmanda at the final 5 and gone to F3 with them. Sorry but the "Cirie only lost cause of F2!!!!111" argument doesn't work Parvmanda are the true winners of micronesia! Nobody was robbed of anything. PARVMANDA OWNAGE!!
Thailandsurvivor		#93	[-]
Posts: 6370 (04/25/09 9:37 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	survivorisdabest wrote: Learn to read people. No, Natalie was not dumb for keeping her options open. pfft you really think Natalie sent jason to KEEP HER OPTIONS OPEN?? I'm sorry but that is laughable, she even admitted to only doing it because noone volounteered. She admitted to despising Jason. She also admitted that she gained his trust and could do whatever the hell she wanted. Your argument is that Jason found the idol, but you seem to forget that he left anyways, so how did it make a difference? Yes it made a difference. It completely lost her his jury vote for no reason. Also if it was a player with a brain (eg. Jonathan or actually ANYONE except jason and erik) then they would have played the idol and she would have ruined the BWB's entire plan. How did it completely lose his jury vote? She voted for James when Jason left, he had no clue that she spearheaded his exit. The best player to never win would not risk their game on pure luck The best player to never win would not WILLINGLY ENTER A FINAL 5 WHERE SHE IS THE FIRST ONE GONE. You're right. Maybe leaving at the final 6 is better. People bash the shit out of Paschal for not switching his vote to Neleh when that puts him in a position where he would have had to win an IC to make the finals. Guess what, it would be the exit same situation. Having to win an IC or manipulate some people is better than being out of the game entirely. yeah only dumb people who can't give a good come back who said things like above. lol. And the fact that you didn't even defend the way you contradict yourself in one sentence just reassure us in sucks that you probably have IQ below 50. If I'm not worth your time, stop yapping and writing. thank anyway for the compliment. I know I can kick your ass real good sometimes. You are sure owning my ass. I must be so dumb and stupid. I mean you said it yourself. Oh, and I see you had some fun with sj in your other thread. Keep it up. Talking about Cirie forcing a tie at the F4 is stupid, considering if she did it she'd probably have lost the game still, just in a different manner. If she forces the tie with Natalie and wins, Parvati leaves, which was her F2 goat. She had her stomped in the votes and knew it. Then Manhanda probably wins the final IC and votes Cirie off for revenge, taking Natalie to the F2. She had Parvati stomped, you're right. She would have lost to Amanda if it was a final three, but she beats her straight up in the same fashion Parv did. Yeah, she lost to Natalie, but Amanda wasn't known for taking revenge. Hell, she was Parv's lap dog AFTER Parvati blindsided Ozzy. Cirie planned on a F3 with the sluts and it only failed because James got an infected finger and they switched to a F2 so they didn't waste challenges they had made. Cirie's only failure in the endgame was her inability to hold that board up with the little ball on it, which like I already said about the F3/F2 situation, shouldn't have mattered anyways. Don't make me go find Jeff's blog where he says it was planned pre season. Cirie said that if she had known that it was a F2 then she still would have stuck with parvmanda at the final 5 and gone to F3 with them. Sorry but the "Cirie only lost cause of F2!!!!111" argument doesn't work Agreed. Parvmanda are the true winners of micronesia! Nobody was robbed of anything. Seeing how Natalie was a nobody for 10 episodes, I can somewhat also agree with this.
survivorisdabest		#94	[-]
Posts: 2780 (04/25/09 10:03 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	She admitted to despising Jason. She also admitted that she gained his trust and could do whatever the hell she wanted. ......? I'm not sure how this relates or responds to what i said at all so i dont even know what to say. Natalie didn't send jason to keep her options open she did it cos noone volounteered. How did it completely lose his jury vote? She voted for James when Jason left, he had no clue that she spearheaded his exit There is no way she would be able to convince him that she somehow didnt know about his boot. Someone on the jury would have told him or otherwise her opponent in the final 2 would not just sit there and let her get his vote, they would tell him the truth. Also she talked about how amazing all their blindsides were at tribal council (namely the F4 one) so she basically let jason know "hey i screwed you" Maybe leaving at the final 6 is better. People bash the shit out of Paschal for not switching his vote to Neleh when that puts him in a position where he would have had to win an IC to make the finals. Guess what, it would be the exit same situation. Having to win an IC or manipulate some people is better than being out of the game entirely. That's not the same because Paschal would only need to win ONE challenge while Cirie is a whale who cant compete in any challenges and would need to win 3. If you are going to say that Cirie wouldn't force a tie due to the risk of being out then you could say that for ANY of the girls in the final 6 because they would all be going to the exact same risk by forcing a tie. By your reasoning then Natalie could switch her vote to alexis so that she would not risk being kicked out by the rock and instead be in a ridiculously bad position. This is a weird and IMO an invalid point because everyone theoretically would have an equal incentive to switch their vote. All 5 of them would be equally dumb (or smart) to go to the risk of getting the purple rock. The only difference is that Cirie is the only one who would be completely screwed if they switched their vote to avoid a tie so she is the one with the most reason to force the tie.
survivorisdabest		#95	[-]
Posts: 2781 (04/25/09 10:09 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Just cause Amanda went with Parv's choice in the F6 tribal it doesn't mean amanda was her lapdog. Amanda dragged Parv to the F2 from the final 6. If it weren't for Amanda playing so well at F6 the favourites wouldn't even have majority and Amanda completely set up the erik boot with her manipulation of him before the RC. Amanda then won the last ICs and took Parv to the end. Given the fact that both Amanda and Parv thought they were going to a final 3 in which Amanda would destroy Parv it was in Amanda's best interests to just keep Parv around as a goat. It didnt matter that much whether Alexis or Nat went to Amanda, she wanted them both gone and was going to benefit greatly from either of them leaving. And letting Parv keep Natalie around didn't matter at all because Parv voted Natalie out two rounds later anyway.
CSCin3D		#96	[-]
Posts: 11823 (04/25/09 10:49 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	another thing: Nat/Alexis/Erik shouldn't have even voted for Amanda the night Alexis went b/c they should have known there was a possibility she had the idol.
chapera rocks		#97	[-]
Posts: 10799 (04/25/09 10:53 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Please learn to read. I said Cirie proved in post show interviews that she was following them, so she most likely (that's what probably means) will vote for Alexis. That doesn't mean the fans were majorly outplayed because there was a better chance at a favorite leaving at the final 6 with Erik winning immunity. But with all the talk about Cirie being the best player to never win, I like to think she isn't a moron who would risk her game on a purple rock when she wasn't even protecting her final two ally. Cirie talked with Natalie. Didn't get good vibes and backed off. Smart. Now I wonder why it would have taken a final 2 for Cirie to talk to Natalie in the first place. She should have been talking to her anyway once she knew Parvati wasn't going to keep her.
kenc333		#98	[-]
Posts: 8688 (04/25/09 11:27 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CSCin3D wrote: another thing: Nat/Alexis/Erik shouldn't have even voted for Amanda the night Alexis went b/c they should have known there was a possibility she had the idol. And that's because once again, the fans were outplayed by the favourites when Amanda emptied her bag after the IC.
Katy Carney		#99	[-]
Posts: 5709 (04/25/09 11:42 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Every single time the fans sent someone to exile that person found the idol, and every single time they voted for them at the next tc
Thailandsurvivor		#100	[-]
Posts: 6375 (04/25/09 5:26 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	survivorisdabest wrote: Amanda dragged Parv to the F2 from the final 6. Just because she would have won does NOT mean she dragged anyone, anywhere. She would have won due to spiteful jurors. ETA- chapera rocks wrote: Please learn to read. I said Cirie proved in post show interviews that she was following them, so she most likely (that's what probably means) will vote for Alexis. That doesn't mean the fans were majorly outplayed because there was a better chance at a favorite leaving at the final 6 with Erik winning immunity. But with all the talk about Cirie being the best player to never win, I like to think she isn't a moron who would risk her game on a purple rock when she wasn't even protecting her final two ally. Cirie talked with Natalie. Didn't get good vibes and backed off. Smart. Now I wonder why it would have taken a final 2 for Cirie to talk to Natalie in the first place. She should have been talking to her anyway once she knew Parvati wasn't going to keep her. Uh, how does that make any sense for Cirie? If Cirie offered her something, Natalie had no other options. That's ridiculous. Last Edited By: Thailandsurvivor 04/25/09 5:28 PM. Edited 1 times.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

It's time to rightfully crown Natalie Bolton as the winner of Micronesia.

Quick Reply