it was mean... but the look on their faces was kind of funny...if you look at it like a suckster and not like a human being.... which I thought was required around here...
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
ILovegreeneyes |
|||
|
yes it was shitty...why does it seem this is the first time anyone is noticing how fucking awful they are to these contestants? my God people pay fucking
attention..... They pull some stunt like this almost every fucking year....it started with the "pick the group you think is safe" with George
Huff....designed to add drama and suspense and a lil humiliation is always good.... they did it again in Season 4 but Bo didn't fall for it... In season 5
they had an asshole who went along so it fell pretty flat.... Last year they did the whole "you're going home...oh wait no you're not" to
Jordin and this year they flipped it... "you've got the lowest votes but you know last year we didn't eliminate anyone during IGB.... too
bad...this year we are" Next year it'll be someone else and people will bitch and complain about how mean they are like they are surprised....
it was mean... but the look on their faces was kind of funny...if you look at it like a suckster and not like a human being.... which I thought was required around here... |
|||
James Barber |
|||
why does it seem this is the first time anyone is noticing how fucking awful they are to these contestants?Fans here and elsewhere have complained about this type of treatment for years. Complaining about how Michael was sent out doesn't somehow mean everyone here pretends it's never happened before. |
|||
ILovegreeneyes |
|||
kennethp21 wrote: OMG I forgot all about that!! Ryan had already sat him down and said the group he was with was safe and then out of nowhere he's like "judd, you're out" that was the MOST fucked up thing I've ever seen on this show in seven seasons... eta: the outrage is what makes it seem like people are just noticing... just seems odd to me I guess...esp for sucksters who thrive on being cruel..
Last Edited By: ILovegreeneyes
04/10/08 9:13 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
MikiBoi |
|||
|
I guess I'm in the small minority who thought it was kinda funny.
The music biz is cruel anyways, he'll get much worse kicks to the nuts after Idol is done. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
it was mean... but the look on their faces was kind of funny...if you look at it like a suckster and not like a human being.... which I thought was required around here...Sometimes I can't separate the two. Honestly though I think Michael probably took it less hard than Carly. Michael was probably like well that was rude but Carly looked pretty crushed by the whole thing. She got like this huge smile on her face when she thought Michael was staying and then she proceeded to cry a river when she found out her foreign buddy was going home. |
|||
marathon |
|||
suckshardcore wrote: The silver lining to it all was Paula's face when she heard the news.
|
|||
latingrl2005 |
|||
|
Posts: 2008 (04/10/08 9:16 PM) Registered User |
MikiBoi wrote: I'm right there with you.... |
||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Paula was probably thinking her only eye candy options left are a fattie with a comb over, a stoner and a minor.
|
|||
kennethp21 |
|||
|
i dun think it was funny, but i didnt find it offensive.
it would be unfunny if Ryan said: "last year we didnt eliminate anybody, this year we do! GOtcha! See ya latar, mate! G'day!" |
|||
CanIBreathe |
|||
|
I thought Ryan was gonna do the ole switcheroo and say that he was safe and that nobody would be eliminated this week, but there
would be a double elimination next week.
That got me a lil happy because eventhough I wasn't rooting for him to win, I felt that he was better than a few that are still left and should have lasted longer. At least top 4. Isn't the way the contestants were treated was the reason why dunkleman quit the show??? Ryan is so obsessed with fame that he would whore himself out for the right price no matter what the cost (and I read elsewhere that he literally was a loan boy for some of the most famous celebs at these secret downlow parties before the fame. But I don't know exactly how true that is). I agree that the Judd boot was way worse than Michael's boot or Jordin's fake boot. But I did It sucks, but hey, maybe he'll win an oscar someday...
Last Edited By: CanIBreathe
04/10/08 10:08 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
ILovegreeneyes |
|||
|
yes, Dunk says he didn't resign for season 2 because of the way they treated the contestants....
|
|||
swim4life227 |
|||
|
Greenie, I lost any respect I had for you after seeing that avatar. Just kidding ;)
Why are people bitching about what they did to Michael? They dick around with KLC every week. When she's bottom 2, they always say "Kristy....THIS week....you are...... SAFE" Everytime they have done it to her. Not to mention when she's not bottom 3 they always fuck with her too. Also, in top 24 they called her alone on stage after they did that to someone else who was eliminated. Anyways I am glad this overrated fucker is out. In the beginning I thought he would be for sure final 2 if not the winner. He really wasn't that hot either. Pretty much the opposite actually. |
|||
Gregoire |
|||
|
I actually wanted fattie to stay a little while longer. I wanted to see how much weight he would gain. He might actually look like Ruben by the finale and then
win.
|
|||
James Barber |
|||
I'm still not sure why people can't be annoyed with the treatment of Michael as well as some of the others. If they do this to Kristy then I'd complain. It's nothing new to Idol, or exclusive to any one person, but it still seems like a stunt, one that makes the show look like a joke every time they try to act superior. |
|||
ILovegreeneyes |
|||
|
maybe people will stop watching and the show can be canceled....<------ (that always looks wrong to me only spelled with one l
|
|||
IdolSchmydol |
|||
|
Shitty, shitty, beyond shitty way to dump the poor guy, and I wasn't a big fan either.
First they say "you're out", then they say, "but wait, maybe not....", and then, "not this year - nyah, you're still out" Not funny at all |
|||
jasmine rose |
|||
|
I'm calling Bullshit!!! Michael is way better than Krusty or Sighesha!!!! Oh well, I'll be seeing him on Leno, Ellen, etc...
|
|||
nooneynooney |
|||
|
I'm used to the Idol tricks, but the producers have been saying all week that someone would definitely be going tonight. Nigel said that it wasn't
fair last year because the person who would've gone home that week actually made it through the following week too. They got to stay, while someone else
went home before they did.
I just didn't think Michael would go this early, so I'm kinda bummed. I liked his voice, and his studio versions were always pretty good. |
|||
jasmine rose |
No | ||
ProbstFan123 wrote: No.... more like a nice cold pint of Ale!!! He won't have that stupid curfew anymore! Cheers, Michael... I love ya.
|
|||
Surge22 |
|||
|
I'll miss his cute, sweaty, greasy, pleasantly plump face. :-*(
|
|||