Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
tmaxx		#3261	[-]
Posts: 136 (06/13/09 1:28 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	How about Shea as Wakefield's daughter? Shea's daughter seems odd, Madison, so maybe she is Wakefield's granddaughter.
cindidindi76		#3262	[-]
Posts: 18482 (06/13/09 1:29 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	enjoyresponsbly wrote: Does anyone else think the Tower card that Madison was so fascinated with has anything to do with the show's iconic lighthouse that we have yet to see in a real scene? See how there are two people falling from the top? I think the final scene will be Abby's savior grappling with the killer at the top until the two fall to their deaths. I wouldn't be surprised if there's a thunderstorm involved (we're in Washington, remember?) The Tower (XVI) is the sixteenth trump. A tower in the card has just been hit by lightning and is aflame. It is a symbol of sudden and unexpected shock - an event that is disruptive to one's life such as a bankruptcy, divorce or terrible calamity. The top of the tower is crumbling and falling to the ground beneath - symbolizing a fall of some kind. In some decks, two figures fall from the top of the tower whereas in others in others, the people themselves are on the ground in flames looking up. The card can symbolize troubled times or indeed a troubled individual with psychological problems - a nervous breakdown perhaps? or maybe it's all symbolic. Seems it could be a suitable place for a very dramatic and cheese filled final battle of sorts.
MCrre4331		#3263	[-]
Posts: 87 (06/13/09 2:03 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] We are presuming that Beth probably got killed when Danny and Sully were running from the kitchen or she just wondered off. If it's the former, what was the reason they ran off again? Was that the Henry-Shane fight? If so, that sort of makes it impossible that Henry could have done it. I know we talked about how Maggie couldn't fit in the ventilation thing but it seems like Henry couldn't either. I'm thinking there must be a back way that only the killers know that he could just stuff Beth in. Shea is definitely going to die soon. Her story arc is up. Richard and Katherine are both dead and Madison is now back. She has no more purpose. I give her one or two episodes more max. I think at the end of this, it is probably one of the people that were on the island 7 years ago. I don't think it's just one of the random people from the wedding party. My gut still says it's Henry, but this episode sort of gave me doubts because he was with people basically the entire episode, and when he wasn't, nothing really happened. I'm not sure what the justification of it being Maggie could be, but she certainly has the opportunity (besides Nikki who is painfully irrelevant). It's probably Henry unfortunately, but I'm still holding out hope that it's Maggie and that there won't be a lot of holes in the opportunity side of this whenever this is all said and done.
Annoying Tool Fanboy		#3264	[-]
Posts: 2124 (06/13/09 2:04 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] When Abby was crawling around in that shaft thing, someone grabbed her and tried to drag her back. Who could have done it? Henry/Jimmy were looking for her together so it would be kind of hard for one of them to go harass Abby while the other one doesn't notice anything. Same goes for Sully/Danny. Shea and Trish were driving around, Shane was drinking with Katherine, and Cal/Chloe were no where near that place. I guess that leaves Maggie and Nikki like always. I hate to admit it, but that combined with Madisons reaction to Maggie, and Maggie is beginning to look more and more likely. I can only hope that she's an accomplice and not the main killer if she indeed is involved.
catwoman6226		#3265	[-]
Posts: 117 (06/13/09 2:33 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] sorry, just testing
tmaxx		#3266	[-]
Posts: 137 (06/13/09 2:37 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Shea was alone or walking alone before Trish found her. Was Shea in the room when Henry and the group were arguing with Shane?
JoshCflyring		#3267	[-]
Posts: 735 (06/13/09 2:58 PM) "Jay Leno is funny" Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Nikki, Jimmi and Abby are definitely going to survive the island, I know that for a fact. I think Danny and Shane will be killed off next.
BloedroodRoze		#3268	[-]
Posts: 220 (06/13/09 3:16 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] Katherine's death scene had pretty good cinematography. Loved the blood seeping through and down the white covers. I also noticed Madison's refusal to face Maggie, which I thought was totally suspicious. I don't believe that the Sheriff put her down there at all. I'm guessing Maggie (or the killer) put Madison down there, and told her to tell Abby that the Sheriff did it or s/he would kill Shea or something. Anyway, I definitely think Maggie's in on the plan as an accomplice, and Henry will end up being the killer. I hope we get to see Henry go suddenly psycho if he is the killer <3 P.S. Chloe, pls don't die. Please. And Trish, while we're saving hot girls.
finger poppin fun		#3269	[-]
Posts: 330 (06/13/09 3:30 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	tullfan2 wrote: Here are the URL to watch two parts of episode 9 without downloading: http://www.zshare.net/video/612955910f0fffaa/ http://www.zshare.net/video/61295849ad9619a5/ Thanks, but it keeps freezing. Anyone have another link to watch online w/o downloading?
AmightyRo		#3270	[-]
Posts: 930 (06/13/09 3:53 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BloedroodRoze wrote: Spoiler [+] Katherine's death scene had pretty good cinematography. Loved the blood seeping through and down the white covers. I also noticed Madison's refusal to face Maggie, which I thought was totally suspicious. I don't believe that the Sheriff put her down there at all. I'm guessing Maggie (or the killer) put Madison down there, and told her to tell Abby that the Sheriff did it or s/he would kill Shea or something. Anyway, I definitely think Maggie's in on the plan as an accomplice, and Henry will end up being the killer. I hope we get to see Henry go suddenly psycho if he is the killer <3 P.S. Chloe, pls don't die. Please. And Trish, while we're saving hot girls. Spoiler [+] I actually do think Sheriff hid Madison, but for a justified reason--not that he was the killer. Maybe he was just trying to keep her safely hidden? And maybe he thought by keeping everyone on the island, the killer wouldn't escape. And yeah, Maggie was totally suspicious this episode <3
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#3271	[-]
Posts: 3066 (06/13/09 4:00 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] I think Madison hiding from Maggie proved that Maggie isn't the killer. Whoever the killer is and whoever hid Madison and had Madison lie is somebody Madison feels comfortable with. I think that Trish or Shea is defo the killers now. With Abby being grabbed in the tunnel the only people that weren't alone were Trish, Shea, Maggie, Nikki, and the Sherieff. The Sherieff cant' walk let alone attack his own daughter. Maggie is a fat fuck and would get stuck since it looked like Abby had a hard time going through. Nikki is too invisible. Trish and Shea could have snuck in the tunnel and back out into the woods at any time. With Shea beign really concerned about Madison I think it all points to Trish. The card speculation might be Henry throwing himself and Trish off the "tower" to save Abby/Jimmy. While Shea and Madison watch on from the ground.
BloedroodRoze		#3272	[-]
Posts: 221 (06/13/09 4:25 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] Could both Henry and Trish be the murderers? I have absolutely no proof for/against it, but just a thought. It'd be a pretty epic wedding I agree with Madison not being comfortable with Maggie, so Maggie might not have put her there. But I also have this nagging feeling abut the scene. Something about it screamed "HORROR MOVIE CLICHE" where the killer is "subtly" hinted at. Eh, I'm probably wrong anyway. For some reason, I thought Trish was pretty suspicious this episode too. Especially the scene when Abby found out she might be Wakefield's child. What I really want to know is how the murders tie in. We know that Abby is probably the center of the reasons for the murders, and that the Wakefield having a child with Abby's mom is related too (although we don't know for sure that Abby is indeed Wakefield's child yet). What is the point of killing all these people? If the killer wanted to JUST kill Abby (assuming that's his goal), he could have done so without all the other murders. And is Abby really Wakefield's child? I'm guessing we're supposed to assume that Abby's mom got pregnant with Wakefield's child, and she ran away? So that's why he killed her, out of rage of her running away with his child? But that'd be way too obvious. I'm expecting the opposite of what the show wants us to assume, so Abby probably is NOT Wakefield's child. Maybe Henry is? Btw, did Trish every live on Harper's Island? Last question: Is Wakefield really dead? Yes, we saw a skeleton in the grace... but that could have been anybody's. The Sheriff could have let Wakefield live for whatever reason, and buried another body in there instead. P.S. It's absolutely ridiculous that I'm so invested in such a show. But I lurve Haper's Island <3
cindidindi76		#3273	[-]
Posts: 18491 (06/13/09 4:43 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AmightyRo wrote: BloedroodRoze wrote: Spoiler [+] Katherine's death scene had pretty good cinematography. Loved the blood seeping through and down the white covers. I also noticed Madison's refusal to face Maggie, which I thought was totally suspicious. I don't believe that the Sheriff put her down there at all. I'm guessing Maggie (or the killer) put Madison down there, and told her to tell Abby that the Sheriff did it or s/he would kill Shea or something. Anyway, I definitely think Maggie's in on the plan as an accomplice, and Henry will end up being the killer. I hope we get to see Henry go suddenly psycho if he is the killer <3 P.S. Chloe, pls don't die. Please. And Trish, while we're saving hot girls. Spoiler [+] I actually do think Sheriff hid Madison, but for a justified reason--not that he was the killer. Maybe he was just trying to keep her safely hidden? And maybe he thought by keeping everyone on the island, the killer wouldn't escape. And yeah, Maggie was totally suspicious this episode <3 [spoiler] Having not seen the episode and just reading about it, ITA about the sheriff. He hid Madison and had her call Abby. Why Abby? Because he doesn't know anyone else's phone number. But he only did it to try to keep everyone there, not because he had plans to murder Madison. [/spoiler[
Coachocd		#3274	[-]
Posts: 7681 (06/13/09 4:57 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Annoying Tool Fanboy wrote: Spoiler [+] Spoiler [+] I'm thinking that the person who grabbed Abby is the person we saw screaming in the early previews -- whoever that character is. (The role may have been recast). Killing Beth was a lure to trap Abby. (Isn't the killer going about this the hard way? If he is really after Abby, why not just kill Abby? Why all these other deaths? I don't believe Maggie is the killer because of how Ben was killed and the skinniness necessary to climb around in those shafts). However, I am leaning towards her being the killer's accomplice. She is the Candlewick Inn. Even if the Inn is hers, she doesn't seem particularly worried about being killed herself and often walks off on her own. Even if I owned an Inn, I would try and make sure that while there was a killer on the loose, I would never be alone with fewer than 2 people. I wouldn't go walking around a giant hotel by myself. (Also, we only have her word that all of the doors are locked.) If she's not the killer or his accomplice, she certainly isn't all that scared of being killed herself. She's also the kind of person that could lure Beth away from the crowd and Katherine into the booby chair.)
The Annoying Hater		#3275	[-]
Posts: 1629 (06/13/09 4:58 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Annoying Tool Fanboy wrote: Spoiler [+] When Abby was crawling around in that shaft thing, someone grabbed her and tried to drag her back. Who could have done it? Henry/Jimmy were looking for her together so it would be kind of hard for one of them to go harass Abby while the other one doesn't notice anything. Same goes for Sully/Danny. Shea and Trish were driving around, Shane was drinking with Katherine, and Cal/Chloe were no where near that place. I guess that leaves Maggie and Nikki like always. I hate to admit it, but that combined with Madisons reaction to Maggie, and Maggie is beginning to look more and more likely. I can only hope that she's an accomplice and not the main killer if she indeed is involved. Spoiler [+] Actually, we really don't know where Cal/Chloe were during this. They went to have sex, BUT we have no idea how long they were asleep. Who's to say Chloe didn't fall asleep and Cal slipped off while her and the sheriff where napping.
tmaxx		#3276	[-]
Posts: 138 (06/13/09 5:24 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: Spoiler [+] Trish and Shea could have snuck in the tunnel and back out into the woods at any time. With Shea beign really concerned about Madison I think it all points to Trish. If someone else kidnapped Madison to prevent the killer from leaving the island, then Shea would be concerned about her missing daughter or she's just pretending to be concerned.
BloedroodRoze		#3277	[-]
Posts: 222 (06/13/09 5:35 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Please dear God let Booth be dead. I can't take any more "OMG BOOTH IS WAKEFIELD" theories anymore on IMDB. If Booth is indeed somehow alive, LAMEST twist ever.
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#3278	[-]
Posts: 3070 (06/13/09 5:48 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BloedroodRoze wrote: Please dear God let Booth be dead. I can't take any more "OMG BOOTH IS WAKEFIELD" theories anymore on IMDB. If Booth is indeed somehow alive, LAMEST twist ever. Lamest twist ever would be they were all killed before by Wakefield and are just reliving everything over and over again. Each "character" becomes a new one every time they wake up.
cindidindi76		#3279	[-]
Posts: 18495 (06/13/09 5:59 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	How the hell could Booth be Wakefield? That doesn't even make any sense.
Coachocd		#3280	[-]
Posts: 7682 (06/13/09 6:01 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BloedroodRoze wrote: Please dear God let Booth be dead. I can't take any more "OMG BOOTH IS WAKEFIELD" theories anymore on IMDB. If Booth is indeed somehow alive, LAMEST twist ever. Well, this was the fundamental twist of "And Then There Were None", that this is sort of a remake of, where the serial killer faked his own death. So, I don't rule it out. Though Henry doing the killing with Maggie's assistance makes a great deal of sense. Spoiler [+] Yuck. The killer really has something about about chopping people in half. She looks like she was planted. My thinking is that she was out of it due to drinking or being drugged and was placed in the booby trapped chair. She could have been there a while. Perhaps the wound kept her from bleeding (a.k.a. "seeping") out until she was moved.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

Quick Reply