Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
loveski		#2861	[-]
Posts: 1737 (06/07/09 12:46 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Does anyone think the black guy makes it off the island alive? It seems like they're actively fighting the stereotype.
JoshCflyring		#2862	[-]
Posts: 681 (06/07/09 12:51 PM) "Jay Leno is funny" Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I can't wait until Henry is the killer and come back in the boards for laughing at everyone who disagrees after every evidence they have given.
Nods		#2863	[-]
Posts: 4691 (06/07/09 12:59 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	loveski wrote: Does anyone think the black guy makes it off the island alive? It seems like they're actively fighting the stereotype. I'd give him a 50% chance, if Henry isn't the killer I would say he's the one friend that survives. Based on the odd's here's how I see it going down makes it to the end Abby - 100-1 -lives Sheriff - 5-1 - lives Henry - 2-1 - lives Could go ether way Madison - Even Shea - Even Danny - Even atleast one will survive Jimmy - 2-3 Trish - 2-3 Cal - 3-4 Chloe - 3-4 Likely dead or just in the background Maggie - 1-10 Nikki - 1-10 Already dead Shane - 1-100 Mrs. Wellington - 1-100 Sully - 1-100 and ofcourse Beth - 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 - 1 - Beth has to live
pjadedd		#2864	[-]
Posts: 9555 (06/07/09 1:21 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	JoshCflyring wrote: I can't wait until Henry is the killer and come back in the boards for laughing at everyone who disagrees after every evidence they have given. Wow, you and like the 30 other people who have said it was Henry. Who are you, Perry Mason? You should totally have your own detective show.
Survivor Boy		#2865	[-]
Posts: 6617 (06/07/09 1:57 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	This thread is so overwhelming But yeah, the killer is Henry... duh
Regardless		#2866	[-]
Posts: 138 (06/07/09 2:18 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	pjadedd wrote: JoshCflyring wrote: I can't wait until Henry is the killer and come back in the boards for laughing at everyone who disagrees after every evidence they have given. Wow, you and like the 30 other people who have said it was Henry. Who are you, Perry Mason? You should totally have your own detective show. What Harper's Island needs is Perry Mason. Just imagine! Perry Mason would have figured out that Henry was the murderer and would have had him on the witness stand singing like a bird by now.
cindidindi76		#2867	[-]
Posts: 18352 (06/07/09 2:24 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	pjadedd wrote: JoshCflyring wrote: I can't wait until Henry is the killer and come back in the boards for laughing at everyone who disagrees after every evidence they have given. Wow, you and like the 30 other people who have said it was Henry. Who are you, Perry Mason? You should totally have your own detective show.
Redhead6		#2868	[-]
Posts: 63 (06/07/09 2:43 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	My theory on why Henry is covered in blood at the end of the ep: It's not JD's, it's Sheriff's, who was left alone and injured in the truck while Abby and Jimmy went off with guns. Henry found Abby's father's body while Abby found his brother's. Maybe? Also, I want to weigh in on two debates and try to unify them a bit. One is the producer who said 1/3 of the audience would say they knew it all along, 1/3 would be surprised, and 1/3 would be like "who?" The other is the 25 suspects, 1 killer quote. While that is the tagline, the exact quote from the producer's blog is that there is one killer "AMONG THEM" (the 25 suspects). I think that leaves room for an accomplice who's not part of the 25. When you think about that in tandem with the quote about the audience reaction, maybe it's not all about the same person. For example (and no, i don't actually believe this to be true), let's say it's Maggie and the gardener who is actually her and John Wakefield's lovechild. 1/3 of the audience might suspect her by then, 1/3 might be surprised, and 1/3 might be too preoccupied with the random WTF gardener reveal to even pay attention to Maggie. Spoiler [+] Also, I don't know where I read this many, many weeks ago or if it was even serious, but I could swear I read something about someone dying by sitting down in a comfy chair that had a knife or something rigged to it. If that was true and if the press was given 9 episodes, that would have to happen in "Seep."
Lori595		#2869	[-]
Posts: 694 (06/07/09 2:56 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	No way is that blood on Henry JD's. That would just be waaay to obvious to have Henry as the killer. Unless Henry thought JD was the killer and killed him. How many episodes of this are left? Wasn't it supposed to be done by July 2? My mind is going to go to mush figuring this all out. I think I'll just watch in unfold.
Phuz1		#2870	[-]
Posts: 3921 (06/07/09 3:22 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Redhead6 wrote: Spoiler [+] Also, I don't know where I read this many, many weeks ago or if it was even serious, but I could swear I read something about someone dying by sitting down in a comfy chair that had a knife or something rigged to it. If that was true and if the press was given 9 episodes, that would have to happen in "Seep." Spoiler [+] That would make sense, as the blood would then seep into the fabric of the chair. And this is just hotness.
cabanachat		#2871	[-]
Posts: 3073 (06/07/09 3:31 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Phuz1 wrote: And this is just hotness. Amen. He can seep into moi any time he wants.
Survivor Boy		#2872	[-]
Posts: 6618 (06/07/09 3:34 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If 1/3 of the audience would be like "who?" then I guess it can't be Henry can it? Unless they assume 1/3 of the audience are blind and retarded.
iismepeter		#2873	[-]
Posts: 3088 (06/07/09 3:37 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Maybe it was The Sheriff who actually killed those 7 people, and Wakefield is actually trying to get back at him?
pjadedd		#2874	[-]
Posts: 9556 (06/07/09 3:37 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	cindidindi76 wrote: pjadedd wrote: JoshCflyring wrote: I can't wait until Henry is the killer and come back in the boards for laughing at everyone who disagrees after every evidence they have given. Wow, you and like the 30 other people who have said it was Henry. Who are you, Perry Mason? You should totally have your own detective show. Hey, this thread needs as many "Clue" quotes as possible.
cabanachat		#2875	[-]
Posts: 3074 (06/07/09 3:39 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Survivor Boy wrote: Unless they assume 1/3 of the audience are blind and retarded. Not much of a stretch since the writers and editors clearly are ...
pjadedd		#2876	[-]
Posts: 9558 (06/07/09 3:41 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	cabanachat wrote: Survivor Boy wrote: Unless they assume 1/3 of the audience are blind and retarded. Not much of a stretch since the writers and editors clearly are ... Not to mention at least 1/3 of the people posting in this thread.
bumlets1		#2877	[-]
Posts: 1280 (06/07/09 3:42 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Another reason I think it could still be Maggie even though it would have been hard for her to string Richard up- They found him because of the rope leading from the shore. She could have tied him up, and then hoisted him by tying that rope to the truck that was at the Candlewick that they used to jump start the generator. (That wasn't Jimmy's truck was it?)
Drew B		#2878	[-]
Posts: 5634 (06/07/09 3:48 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	For those of you still convinced it was Henry, how could he have killed the guard at the sheriff's station? Wasn't he with the others looking for Madison? Also, it appears that Henry left the Candlewick moments after Sully/Beth/Cal/Chloe and made it to the marina moments after them. How would he have had time to go deep inland to Harkin's cabin, shoot him up with arrows, and still make it to the marina without a big time lapse? I'd honestly like to keep him as a suspect, but these killings (especially the guard) seem to exonerate him...
Pecks Bad Boy		#2879	[-]
Posts: 9 (06/07/09 3:57 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Unless a time frame is specifically mentioned, I don't think you can rule somebody out when they show one scene then the next. JD may have been broken out of jail in the middle of the night, we have no idea exactly what time that happened. The order we watch them on TV doesn't have to be the order they happen in chronologically as far as the story goes.
Drew B		#2880	[-]
Posts: 5636 (06/07/09 4:06 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I always assume that the chronological order is fixed, but there may be big gaps between scenes we see. Because we saw Henry on the Madison search both before and after the guard was shot, that fixes that the escape happened while Henry was still searching. The Harkin one is more questionable, as Henry had left the Candlewick before the Harkin shooting and arrived at the marina after. For the actual time of the killing, he was unaccounted for. My only question is why the group of Sully/Beth/Cal/Chloe didn't arrive at the marina way, way before Henry if he took a long detour to kill Harkin...

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

Quick Reply