S-18 Edgic (editing and logic) - Tocantins - Survivor Speculation - Spoiler Related - Survivor Sucks - Message Board

0 Kudo

S-18 Edgic (editing and logic) - Tocantins

Started By	Comment
JaMalle		#3661	[-]
Posts: 4403 (04/23/09 7:24 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think it's pretty easy to see that Sierra is really annoying in real life, but that was definitely a positive episode! The scene with Coach alone is enough for a solid P. Inspirational music was REALLY cheesy btw. I liked Erinn's edit this episode. She seemed in control of the situation. "Guilty as charged." for the big flip this episode. However, I honestly don't think she'll get much substantial attention. she's not one of the "warriors", so the weight of Tyson's boot will fall on JT and Stephen's shoulders instead instead of her's. We'll see next Thursday.
I LUV TIJUANA		#3662	[-]
Posts: 12619 (04/23/09 7:24 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BlakeB717 wrote: Errr, Erinn had an awful episode. She narrated an entire reward and got a scene about throwing up like a kid who got too excited, messed up, and doesn't know why. Maybe it reflects how she may play the game? Anyways, it was complex enough to probably secure her into the endgame but she is definitely not winning the game. Of course she was going to get an episode like this after a season-long build up of her being responsible for a blindside of Tyson and/or Coach. ELIMINATED! :) I'm going to rewatch again, but I think I'm sticking with JT. You're ridiculous. Where does it say anywhere that narration is not good for a winner? From what I remember, some narration on rewards and connection to the culture is usually a good thing. It worked for Bob, with the gorilla habitat thing. And the throwing up is just a bit of comedy. There's no intent in the editing department. If she won they wouldn't take it out. She's human, as are all the other winners. The best part of the episode was her was the post-Immunity Challenge and pre-Tribal Council confessional about needing to make moves to win the game, and she can't do it by letting people make decisions for her. There's her connection to winning. And if thinking Erinn had a bad episode wasn't bad enough, you are still going with JT for the winner pick. He's the biggest distraction ever. Stephen: CP3 (the one who made the plan to slash Tyson) Actually, Erinn brought it up first. They all were involved in the action of voting him out though.
Mega64		#3663	[-]
Posts: 10091 (04/23/09 7:25 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	There's holes in all their winner's edits, which should be a good thing since we don't want another blatant Earl winner. You know, as long as the winner is JT, Stephen, or Erinn.
BlakeB717		#3664	[-]
Posts: 1496 (04/23/09 7:25 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Going to a reward and not having a single phrase about it is good for the winner? Sitting down to eat when you have a challenge to compete and don't say nothing about that in your defense is good for the winner? For a character who has been P for a lot of the season, and his snarky comments about Sierra and betrayl of Tyson, any comments he made at the reward probably would have made him P which the editors will want to avoid at this point. Also, JT didn't get any emphasis sitting there eating--it was all Coach pretty much. Tyson commented on Coach, Stephen got a "Thank Lord!" but JT got nothing about feasting. That is good for him, in my books. I called Parvati over Cirie, and I'm calling JT over Stephen. Watch the recap next episode, you'll see! JT will get credit.
ncassaro		#3665	[-]
Posts: 1015 (04/23/09 7:25 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Yup, Taj definitely gets this season's Crystal Cox edit. I predicted a few pages back that Taj would fall off the face of the planet after the merge.
McPhever224		#3666	[-]
Posts: 228 (04/23/09 7:26 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	colleenlover wrote: I thought Sierra was so heavily manipalted CPP because it was all themes and scope and longevity. even with that disney snow white music. man, oh man -she's one bad player though. Sierra is one of the worst players ever, but I <3 her anyway...haha
I LUV TIJUANA		#3667	[-]
Posts: 12620 (04/23/09 7:27 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	On the topic of Sierra Erinn, she may be in the F2. What if JT did betray Stephen for her... and she won? Surprise! Probably not, though. Fixed. Seriously, if there's a surprise winner, it's Erinn. Not Sierra.
FallenTorch.fantasygamescen...		#3668	[-]
Posts: 89 (04/23/09 7:28 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	McPhever224 wrote: colleenlover wrote: I thought Sierra was so heavily manipalted CPP because it was all themes and scope and longevity. even with that disney snow white music. man, oh man -she's one bad player though. Sierra is one of the worst players ever, but I <3 her anyway...haha At least she didn't give up, but still way to luck out. She's still doomed, and the look on her confused face was almost as good as Tyson/Coach's
BlakeB717		#3669	[-]
Posts: 1497 (04/23/09 7:28 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	You're ridiculous. Where does it say anywhere that narration is not good for a winner? From what I remember, some narration on rewards and connection to the culture is usually a good thing. It worked for Bob, with the gorilla habitat thing. And the throwing up is just a bit of comedy. There's no intent in the editing department. If she won they wouldn't take it out. She's human, as are all the other winners. The best part of the episode was her was the post-Immunity Challenge and pre-Tribal Council confessional about needing to make moves to win the game, and she can't do it by letting people make decisions for her. There's her connection to winning. Worst.response.ever! "Only human" "Scene meaning nothing" "Like Bob" Bob's scene was P. Debbie got that. Does she win? Only human? The editors work around that! Every scene is shown for a reason. They didn't just go out look funny let's show Erinn puking! Way too much emphasis on that scene to be unimportant.
McPhever224		#3670	[-]
Posts: 229 (04/23/09 7:28 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Also interesting that they show Erinn early on picking her nose, and now throwing up...
Katy Carney		#3671	[-]
Posts: 5674 (04/23/09 7:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Come on y'all. Erinn was CP. She talked about Tyson and her decision to switch and it's direct impact on the game, she talked about Sierra being right about everything secretly, etc. She was CP. Not MOR. Giving her the rating she deserves doesn't necessarily endorse winner status.
BlakeB717		#3672	[-]
Posts: 1498 (04/23/09 7:30 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'm giving Erinn CP probably, but her confessional was quick so I'll have to figure out whether she narrated the process of the move or not. I think she was CP, but it was an eliminating-CP. :)
Jacare15		#3673	[-]
Posts: 1865 (04/23/09 7:30 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I LUV TIJUANA wrote: BlakeB717 wrote: Errr, Erinn had an awful episode. She narrated an entire reward and got a scene about throwing up like a kid who got too excited, messed up, and doesn't know why. Maybe it reflects how she may play the game? Anyways, it was complex enough to probably secure her into the endgame but she is definitely not winning the game. Of course she was going to get an episode like this after a season-long build up of her being responsible for a blindside of Tyson and/or Coach. ELIMINATED! :) I'm going to rewatch again, but I think I'm sticking with JT. You're ridiculous. Where does it say anywhere that narration is not good for a winner? From what I remember, some narration on rewards and connection to the culture is usually a good thing. It worked for Bob, with the gorilla habitat thing. And the throwing up is just a bit of comedy. There's no intent in the editing department. If she won they wouldn't take it out. She's human, as are all the other winners. The best part of the episode was her was the post-Immunity Challenge and pre-Tribal Council confessional about needing to make moves to win the game, and she can't do it by letting people make decisions for her. There's her connection to winning. And if thinking Erinn had a bad episode wasn't bad enough, you are still going with JT for the winner pick. He's the biggest distraction ever. Stephen: CP3 (the one who made the plan to slash Tyson) Actually, Erinn brought it up first. They all were involved in the action of voting him out though. Based on a woman's typical UTR-esque edit, this episode reminded me of a mix between Danni/Parvati, honestly. Right now, I don't think Erinn can win, but I see it more as Stephen right now. But, Erinn's episode was good, I think. It depends really on the beginning of next episode for sure...
cindidindi76		#3674	[-]
Posts: 17220 (04/23/09 7:31 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Sitting down to eat when you have a challenge to compete and don't say nothing about that in your defense is good for the winner? It's not bad for the winner when it isn't edited to be a horrible, terrible, rotten thing. Look at how differently it was handled in Guatemala and EI compared to China and this season. IMO, if the winner was one of the IC participants, they would have made it look much worse to be one of the eaters.
BlakeB717		#3675	[-]
Posts: 1499 (04/23/09 7:32 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	cindidindi76 wrote: Sitting down to eat when you have a challenge to compete and don't say nothing about that in your defense is good for the winner? It's not bad for the winner when it isn't edited to be a horrible, terrible, rotten thing. Look at how differently it was handled in Guatemala and EI compared to China and this season. IMO, if the winner was one of the IC participants, they would have made it look much worse to be one of the eaters. X
Brazil Luvs Ami		#3676	[-]
Posts: 292 (04/23/09 7:33 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BlakeB717 wrote: Going to a reward and not having a single phrase about it is good for the winner? Sitting down to eat when you have a challenge to compete and don't say nothing about that in your defense is good for the winner? For a character who has been P for a lot of the season, and his snarky comments about Sierra and betrayl of Tyson, any comments he made at the reward probably would have made him P which the editors will want to avoid at this point. Also, JT didn't get any emphasis sitting there eating--it was all Coach pretty much. Tyson commented on Coach, Stephen got a "Thank Lord!" but JT got nothing about feasting. That is good for him, in my books. I called Parvati over Cirie, and I'm calling JT over Stephen. Watch the recap next episode, you'll see! JT will get credit. I see your point Blake, but I think it would be good for him if he had a line like Todd had in China about sitting down in a challenge in order to eat.... he had nothing bout that and nothing about the reward... was him even there... It was the Debbie's and Erinn's reward... For me this episode was great for Erinn and, maybe, Stephen.. Ratings: Coach - OTTM Debbie - OTTP Erinn - CP(M) JT - MOR/CP - I will have to rewatch Sierra - CPP Stephen - MOR Taj - INV Tyson - OTTN
Seacrest22		#3677	[-]
Posts: 192 (04/23/09 7:34 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	And if thinking Erinn had a bad episode wasn't bad enough, you are still going with JT for the winner pick. He's the biggest distraction ever. You probably thought Tom was a distraction too. Just because he's a guy and is getting a lot of screentime doesn't automatically make him a "distraction".
ncassaro		#3678	[-]
Posts: 1017 (04/23/09 7:36 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Honestly, I don't like how personal this is getting, but Erinn deserves her props for this episode.
panurge46		#3679	[-]
Posts: 1331 (04/23/09 7:38 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	But...But Coach got the helicopter shots!!! He must win! Seriously, I think that JT being ignored on the reward (he only said he liked the banjo-type instruments) and then not getting to explain why he sat out the challenge just reduced his chances of winning. Yes, his interventions were manipulated, only to show him as the one guilty of abandoning the warrior alliance. The warrior alliance included Debbie and Stephen but the warriors were Tyson, JT and Coach's ego.
LKMOSCAR		#3680	[-]
Posts: 6269 (04/23/09 7:39 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	As with regards to last week's notice by Warrior, please don't add a number, like CPPP5, until the visibility chart comes up. Thanks!

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

S-18 Edgic (editing and logic) - Tocantins

Quick Reply