| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
jasmine rose |
|||
|
She's boring.
|
|||
Merely |
|||
|
Uh-oh, Brooke's in trouble next week: Mariah Carey week AND she sings during the first half of the show. Double threat.
|
|||
Frankie G Morris |
|||
Pretty Good SHC. :) Much better than Bubbly. Heck, probably in about five years ... I won't mind hearing Bubbly again. :) ETA ... Will, Bernadine knows how to take care of business. Yo.
Last Edited By: Frankie G Morris
04/11/08 7:59 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
If Broooke sings like first or second on Mariah Carey week she's probably toast unless she really manages to change up a song well enough to suit her.
Doing one straight up I think we all know she can't hit the notes.
|
|||
Merely |
|||
|
She needs to strip down Hero and play it with just the guitar.
|
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Fuck that, the potato needs to sing "Hero" and redeem herself.
Brooke can sing "Always Be My Baby." |
|||
Merely |
|||
|
They'll probably give it to Archuleta. *barf*
:-D |
|||
Merely |
|||
|
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Yeah ever since I heard there was going to be a Mariah week I was like "yep, Archie's dad will make sure he does Hero."
|
|||
ilovety |
|||
suckshardcore wrote:
I will love Brooke even more if she sings Always Be My Baby. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
It seems like a Brookeish song.
|
|||
8trackmind |
Next week's bottom 3 | ||
|
Brooke/KKKristy/Jason. Practically ordained. Syesha and Carly can definitely do Mariah, the 2 Davids are still invulnerable. The only question is which one of
the three will get the boot. Booting Jason right after Michael would leave only 2 guys, which is insane even for THIS season. If KKKristy survives bottom 3
again she'll tie Nikki's all time record. So it probably WILL be KKKristy. Hopefully Brooke won't cry herself to death while she's in the
bottom 3. All joking aside, a lot of us are beginning to genuinely think that Brooke may be the most unstable, insecure person ever to make the top 12.
It's scary.
|
|||
Wuming Shi |
|||
|
Don't underestimate Kristy's singing prowess, as this week showed.
I sorta regained my love for Brooke after the latest show, except she was making psychotic faces at the end of the show again, when Johns was hugging the judges. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Brooke's reaction to the bottom 2 would probably be even worse than Ashley Leitao's reaction to it. This girl on Canadian Idol 3 named Ashley was in
the bottom 2 on like Top 9 night or whatever and she was supposed to be a front runner so I guess she was upset by this. Anyway she was like hyperventilating
and I think everyone thought she was going to collapse on stage, especially after she got eliminated and had to sing. I never thought I'd see a worse
reaction than that but I think Brooke could deliver.
Oh good the video is on YouTube: I liked her so at the time it wasn't that funny and I felt bad but looking back it's pretty funny. I'm rewatching it and she's flipping out even before she gets put in the bottom 3. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Shit, they cut out most of her hyperventilating and flipping out.
|
|||
Hillary Wallbanger |
|||
|
I wish someone would shove "something" in her mouth every week to stop all the contortions. I use to like her
|
|||
Merely |
|||
|
Meh, I don't think her weekly banter with the judges are so cringe-inducing anymore. Everyone's doing it now.
|
|||
SurvivorFanGP |
|||
|
Screamesha's fit with Randy was worse than anything Brooke's said to the judges. I understand she was trying to figure out why Randy thought she
wasn't emotionally connected to the song, but she was a total bitch in the process.
I don't think you can peg anyone to do bad on any given week. Brooke and Jason can easily do a simple, stripped down version of a Mariah song and get praise for it. It's one thing to IMITATE Mariah with the runs and sound like shit, but they'll draw good reviews if they change it up, which is their only option, considering their limited range. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Syesha is an arrogant twat and you can tell in her bitch fit to Randy.
I don't think Brooke talks back because she's arrogant at all. She just comes off as annoying, pathetic and desperate doing it. |
|||
ilovety |
|||
suckshardcore wrote:
Dreamlover could work for her too. |
|||