| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Where's that picture of Jason and David eating hot dogs. It's from a magazine, it's funny. The Idols went to a baseball game I guess and Cookie was
wearing his Royals jersey and there's pictures of him chilling Jason and Syesha. Clearly Jason would want the man he ate a hot dog with at a baseball game
to win it all.
|
|||
Claymazement |
|||
|
Josh Gracin said, loudly and clearly after his boot in S2, that Clay should win, that he had worked the hardest and never missed a note or been in the Bottom
2, but Ruben would win, because of all the hype with the 205 shirts and what-not (not to mention that many voted for Ruben against Clay
because he was so polarizing), and it cost him his place in the tour that summer, I'm convinced. So, as much as the Clay fans appreciated his candor, I
wish he hadn't jeopardized his standing with the show by saying it.
|
|||
Claymazement |
|||
suckshardcore wrote:
|
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
Josh Gracin said, loudly and clearly after his boot in S2, that Clay should win, that he had worked the hardest and never missed a note or been in the Bottom 2, but Ruben would win, because of all the hype with the 205 shirts and what-not (not to mention that many voted for Ruben against Clay because he was so polarizing), and it cost him his place in the tour that summer, I'm convinced. So, as much as the Clay fans appreciated his candor, I wish he hadn't jeopardized his standing with the show by saying it.What an asshole. The 205 shirts didn't give Ruben his singing ability. He was talented to and of the 12 I don't know if I would say he was the best winner but based on singing and performances I wouldn't say he was undeserving of winning. Anti-Clay votes may have thrown him over the edge but he had a lot of popularity and fanbase based on his talent. Didn't he have something to do with the Military though? I don't know if they make up tours. |
|||
Claymazement |
|||
|
How does this make him as asshole? He just told it as he saw it. Yes, he was a Marine and it's possible they wouldn't give him any more time off.
|
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
I personally think it's assholish of competitors (as in people from the same season) to say one should win over another during the competition. I
especially think it's assholish to say Ruben would win because of those things rather than because of him also being talented. It's just rude imo.
It would be very rude of Jason or Syesha to say something like Cook should win but Archuleta will win because all the fangirls love him. |
|||
Claymazement |
|||
|
Perhaps so, but it could happen exactly that way. lol
But I doubt it. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
It might be the truth, I just don't think people should comment on their fellow competitors unless they did something very rude to them or something. Like
if Ruben sat on Josh one time maybe I could see it.
|
|||
Claymazement |
|||
|
Bwah! I don't think Josh would still be around to tell about it.
|
|||
Fafulous |
|||
|
The Cook home town visit vid was awesome. He looked genuinely overwhelmed by how many people came out to support him.
The bit with him and the sweet music teacher made me t.e.a.r. up a bit. So cute. |
|||
seaguy |
|||
|
The Seaguy curse is officially broken!!! WOOHOO! I'm very happy for David, and for us Cooktards of course.
|
|||
MikiBoi |
|||
|
This has turned into an orgie of Cookie avvis.
Seaguy, I <3 the doggy though, but the new one is fierce. |
|||
seaguy |
|||
|
I said I'd change if he made the top 2 and I stand by my word. Kinda fantardish and stuff, but I really don't give a shit.
|
|||
Fafulous |
|||
|
Love the new avi, Seaguy! The power of the Cook made me give in to my fantardish ways and put him as my avi, too. His powers be strong.
|
|||
lucky wench |
|||
|
Yay seaguy!! Smokin' avi!!
I thought Cook's video was almost embarrassingly better than Archie's or Syesha's. Seemed longer too, but maybe that's because they crammed so much into it. Kansas City and Blue Springs went all out. Nicely done! I need me a new avi... |
|||
seaguy |
|||
|
|
|||
MikiBoi |
|||
seaguy wrote: I kinda like this one more, LOL. |
|||
Claymazement |
|||
lucky wench wrote: noooo, I love your avi! Miki, I like that one better, too. Adorable! |
|||
seaguy |
|||
|
Should I change it to that one?
|
|||
MultiGeminii |
|||
|
I feel like the world is upside down with seaguy wearing a different avi. But Cook LOVE so <3
|
|||