| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 oh ehm gee |
|||
|
Posts: 2495 (03/31/09 6:08 PM) |
craig wrote: The lack of Analeigh on that list is troubling (especially considering how they managed to include stank ass Clark). Oh, and Corinne = Sugar = shitty people kthx |
||
|
craig |
|||
|
Posts: 15368 (04/02/09 5:42 PM) Registered User |
HOTTEST SURIVOR GIRL - TOP 15 POLL
http://survivorsucks.yuku.com/topic/45900? Thought I'd copy the final results of the run-off between the Top 15 in Wyldawg's poll, as I'm going to be doing something similar for the top people in the gameplay polls.
Here are #15-6. The first number is their average on the 1-5 scale. Than I've converted it to the percentage equivalent on the
regular 1-10 scale (2=70%, 3=80%, etc).
15. S1- Colleen Haskell = 1.72 = 67.2 Who'd have believed this a few years ago? Colleen dead last in hotness by 5.6, the biggest gap in the poll. I guess she benefitted initially from being able to beat up on JLew and Kelly W, rather than people comparing her to real competition. 14. S2- Jerri Manthey = 2.28 = 72.8 Classic hot bitch holding steady at #14, as in the original poll. 13. S2- Elisabeth Filarski = 2.46 = 74.6 Down from #8. The early season bloodbath continues. 12. S17- Kelly Czarnecki = 2.47 = 74.7 Kelly won the epic blonde battle by a hair, after running neck and neck with Liz all the way. I guess her original high placing wasn't just a fluke of people wanting not-Sugar to win Gabon. 11. S12- Misty Giles = 2.62 = 76.2 Misty is still #11 (well technically she was tied for 10th before). Might have deserved higher if she'd stayed longer, rather than becoming the most sadly unsuccessful flirt in Survivor history, Some flirts have been targetd by jealous girls, but to be spurned by the boys for Dan?
10. S13- Candice Woodcock = 2.69 = 76.9
Candice has dropped a bit. I don't think anybody really thought she was one of the 4th hottest of all time. It's just that she's popular with both Parvati and Penner fans, and is smart with girl-next-door appeal. Not to mention Billy falling in love at first sight. Probably suffered a bit from people who thought she was too high voting her down. 9. S9- Ami Cusack = 2.74 = 77.4 Queen Ami remains at #9. She does consistently well in polls, whether popularity, hottness, or gameplay. 8. S11- Danni Boatwright = 2.76 = 77.6 Big jump from #15 for the Guatemala winner. She has more detractors than Ami or Dolly (20 votes of 2 or lower compared to their 17 and 15), but also a few more 4 votes to make up for it. 7. S9- Dolly Neely = 2.81 = 78.1 Again, I don't think anyone thought Dolly deserved #3. But this placing sodifies her title as Sucks choice for hottest premerge boot ever. I guess her ass wiggling in that ep.1 IC is alive in Sucks memory. Beyond that, she doesn't have a wide enough portfolio of pics to fairly rate her imo. 6. S15- Amanda Kimmel = 3.16 = 81.6 The Amanda Kimmel has dropped one place in this poll, But notice that huge gap between the Top 6 and everyone else. 12 people gave Amanda 10s, while none of the previous girls got more than 6 perfect scores.
Now for the Top 5. Only 2 girls made it this high in both polls.
5. S10- Jenn Lyon = 3.41 = 84.1 Her consistently strong showing in Sucks hotness polls somewhat surprises me. She has a pretty face, but was so UTR in Palau. If I was naming the hottest 4th placers I'd list Elizabeth and Eliza, and probably Natalie and Darrah before her. 
4. S2- Amber Brkich = 3.59 = 85.9 The Brunette Ownage of the Top 4 begins with Amber, up where you'd expect her. Defintely cute in Outback, and even prettier in ASS, even if she doesn't have the flirty charisma of the ladies ahead or her. 
3. S13- Parvati Shallow = 3.60 = 86 For a while it looked like Parv would be 5th, then she made a run to claim the bronze in a photo finish. With 18 people voting her 5, she has more perfect scores than anyone but Julie, but also a few more detractors. Maybe not as physically perfect as some of the top girls, but so what, there is more to hotness than that.  
2. S6- Jenna Morasca = 3.85 = 88.5 Winning is definitely hot, since Jenna is our 3rd winner in the top 4. This classic Survivor would be my pick for #1, but I think some were hoping one of the newer hotties would win. 
1. S9- Julie Berry = 3.98 = 89.8 Probst's ex has done it again. She had 21 votes of 5, the most of anyone. So it doesn't look like she snuck through because others have more haters. Gotta admit, she has a great figure. 
Finally, here are the combined results ranking for Wyldawg's poll and my poll.
Probably the fairest measure of Sucks opinion. 1. S9 Julie Berry - 8.98, 7.81 = 8.40 2. S6 Jenna Morasca - 8.85, 7.66 = 8.26 3. S13 Parvati Shallow - 8.60, 7.22 = 7.91 4. S10 Jenn Lyon - 8.41, 7.36 = 7.89 5. S2 Amber Brkich - 8.59, 7.14 = 7.87 6. S15 Amanda Kimmel - 8.16, 7.38 = 7.77 7. S9 Dolly Neely - 7.81, 7.58 = 7.70 8. S13 Candice Woodcock - 7.69, 7.44 = 7.57 9. S9 Ami Cusack - 7.74, 7.15 = 7.45 10. S12 Misty Giles - 7.62, 7.14 = 7.38 11. S11 Danni Boatwright - 7.76, 6.93 = 7.35 12. S2 Elisabeth Filarski - 7.46, 7.19 = 7.33 13. S17 Kelly Czarnecki - 7.47, 6.97 = 7.22 14. S2 Jerri Manthey - 7.28, 6.96 = 7.12 15. S1 Colleen Haskell - 6.72, 7.11 = 6.92 My poll provided clearer and more accurate differentiation between the top 15. (A ranking is not accurate when someone like Dolly is #3 and everyone agrees "WTF she's too high, how did that happen?") When ranking 132 or 265 people at once, many people give top scores to the best 10-15%, so a few who try to sabotage the hotties they hate have undue influence. |
||
|
Katy Carney |
|||
|
Posts: 5299 (04/02/09 5:57 PM) |
I recently rewatched Vanuatu and came out of it with a much greater appreciation of Julie as a player and a contestant, but I just do not think she's all
that gorgeous. She is very very pretty tho, obviously. But she was twenty three million times the slut in Vanuatu that people claim Parvati was in either
season.
|
||
|
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Posts: 432 (04/02/09 7:22 PM) |
Julie <3 hottest of them all <3
hotness rankings... 1. Julie 2. Parvati 3. Steph |
||
