| Started By | Comment | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 AidanAcello |
|||||
|
Posts: 2073 (02/12/09 4:05 PM) |
JDeanUT wrote: Wut! Pffft, that list is obvo invalid. 
|
||||
|
craig |
|||||
|
Posts: 14944 (02/12/09 5:19 PM) Registered User |
The EW list has 18 girls and 12 guys.
There are 10 females that make both the Sucks and EW Top 18 lists: Colleen, Elisabeth, Amber, Jenna, Julie, Ami, Dolly, Danni, Parvati, Amanda They snub Candice, Jenn, Misty, and 5 of our 13-18 (Kelly, Jerri, Paloma, Jessie, Tijuana) Instead they have Sarah, Erin, Heidi, Steph, Sally, Cecilia, Michelle, and Sugar. Sure hope that Sugar and Elisabeth weren't supposed to be the top 2. Someboby likes fake blonde sweethearts. The S12 choices are most odd. Sally and Austin over Misty, Danielle, and Aras? I think EW omitting Jenn in line with non-Sucks opinion. I'm amazed how well she does in Sucks hotness polls (6th in Wyldawg's and she is doing even better in my Clubs one). |
||||
|
colleenlover |
|||||
|
Posts: 8978 (02/12/09 6:12 PM) Registered User |
I think Jenn is beautiful. And will probably look the same in twenty years.
But I think in film, tv, movies you need something a little off on you to make you pop -Colleen, Sugar and yes, Parvarti all had a glow that made you watch them. |
||||
|
JackSparrowBauer |
|||||
|
Posts: 54 (02/13/09 10:14 AM) |
I'm surprised Candice made it to the top 4. She was good looking, but I didn't know that that many people considered her one of the hottest ever.
|
||||
|
WylDawg |
|||||
|
Posts: 17789 (02/13/09 2:58 PM) Registered user |
So may things that don't work about this list:
1- There's no seperate list for men and women, let alone the fact that they're not even equally represented. I think the average person would find it hard to judge both genders on their sex appeal impartially. 2- There's no ranking. Let's just throw in a couple of pretty people in there. 3- They've chosen some of the worst pictures for these people. Anyone who's never seen the show would wonder if EW is being sarcastic. 4- Sean, Erin, Austin, Sally, Andrew.......................................really?? I know beauty is extremely subjective, but I think the general, rational concensus would be that Tanya > Erin, Nick/Aras > Austin, Misty > Sally and Terry/Skupin > Andrew. And then there's Sean.  Don't most people
find Hunter, Boston Rb, John AND Gabe more attractive? I mean that's 4 people.
|
||||
 Kitty Pryde1 |
|||||
|
Posts: 8826 (02/13/09 3:20 PM) |
I dunno, Wyldawg. I'd say Andrew was EASILY the hottest guy from Pearl Islands.
|
||||
|
tomash |
|||||
|
Posts: 85 (02/13/09 3:26 PM) |
Kitty Pryde1 wrote: I'd say Osten and Ryno were both at least on par, maybe even Burton.
|
||||
|
Oowatanite |
|||||
|
Posts: 6837 (02/13/09 3:31 PM) Registered User |
They just used 30 random attractive players in that EW list. Nothing more, nothing less.
|
||||
|
tomash |
|||||
|
Posts: 87 (02/13/09 3:33 PM) |
I doubt they made 100 people fill out surveys and rate the survivors from 1-10 yeah
|
||||
|
craig |
|||||
|
Posts: 14956 (02/13/09 4:50 PM) Registered User |
I recall from Survivor Live, that Dalton always had a big crush on Sally Kneesocks.
Sucks just hates S5 Erin and S7 Andrew too much to rate them highly. With Erin, Danielle, and Mary, it's all about people's reactions to large fake boobs. I prefer real ones, but if your gonna go fake, why not go big and flaunt them? One more day of voting in my follow-up poll: I've decided to take the Top 15 females in this Survivor Hotness Poll and have a run-off. The poll is in Clubs: |
||||
|
cindidindi76 |
|||||
|
Posts: 15417 (02/14/09 2:18 PM) Registered User |
And then there's Sean. Personally, going on looks alone I find Sean more attractive than any of them. |
||||
|
Soviet |
|||||
|
Posts: 208 (02/14/09 3:56 PM) |
Kitty Pryde1 wrote: Sarcasm? |
||||
|
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||||
|
Posts: 8847 (02/14/09 4:29 PM) |
Soviet wrote: No. His competition was ugly Fairplay, dorky Ryan S., over-muscled Osten, head too small for his body Shawn, fat pirate Rupert, too-hairy Burton, and bland, un-rugged Ryno. |
||||
|
kishuu |
|||||
|
Posts: 1188 (02/14/09 10:35 PM) |
Sugar doesn't know how to use make-up well imo.
Also, hottest guy in PI is obviouly Ryno followed by Shawn. Burton's hair turned me off |
||||
|
craig |
|||||
|
Posts: 14972 (02/14/09 10:43 PM) Registered User |
I've started to post results for my Clubs rematch poll.
First, here are the "players who deserved to be in the Top 15." They're listed by number of mentions received. 7 Brooke Struck, Darrah Johnson 6 Tijuana Bradley, Brianna Varela 5 Jessie Camacho, Leann Slaby 4 Heidi Strobel, Kim Powers 3 Paloma Soto-Castillo, Jaime Dugan, Michelle Yi, Eliza Orlins 2 Cecila Mansilla, Tanya Vance, Sugar Kiper, Stacy Kimball, Jessica deBen, Corinne Kaplan Must have been a lot of people voting Brooke and Darrah down in the original poll to keep them out of top 30. |
||||
|
grodney |
|||||
|
Posts: 675 (02/26/09 8:31 AM) Registered User |
Androgynous offspring if they mated:
4F and 26M: 
12F and 24M: 
Composite Cook Islands hotness, combo of #4, #23, #44, and #86: 
|
||||
|
Buccaneer |
|||||
|
Posts: 184 (03/03/09 10:53 AM) |
Wow that's weird.
|
||||
|
craig |
|||||
|
Posts: 15349 (03/31/09 3:42 PM) Registered User |
Parvati won a 2008 Minxie Award.
http://digitalminx.com/minxie_awards/minxie_awards.htm Voted #1 in category: HOTTEST REALITY TV STAR
Take that Hills girls, DWTS babes, and Top Model wannabes! Notice also the excellent taste in making Corinne the sole nominee for Gabon. |
||||
|
SPunKeeMonKee |
|||||
|
Posts: 11903 (03/31/09 4:04 PM) Registered User |
craig wrote:Corinne was the least attractive of the supposed "hotties" from last season.. Include her rancid personality and she's hideous. |
||||
|
srvivrfreakevelrich |
|||||
|
Posts: 669 (03/31/09 4:08 PM) Admin |
wheres sugar and paloma and charlie?
|
||||
