| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 fffingybyach |
|||
|
Posts: 269 (06/24/08 9:29 PM) |
Well - I stick by who I liked last night - 1. Mookie 2. Paul Seeing the suck ass that was tonight, lol. The only others that I guess that I sort of liked were Theo and although Sebastian is a cutie I'll stick with the una bomber for the talent - Oliver. Damn the woman stank. There were a couple that have decent enough voices but their song choices were horrible - Tetiana last night & that chick Jessica were the only 2 I remembered at all of the women. |
||
|
roadblocker |
|||
|
Posts: 15247 (06/24/08 9:31 PM) Registered User |
Jesse - MEH. at least he admitted right off the bat that he's a pop-rocker (not that there's anything wrong with that) so that should dispel the
"faux rocker" comments.
Mark - He's taking a page from Craigina Sharpe's Book of Performing on CI and that is to sing songs only suited for girls. It'd be hilarious if he won though because he has absolutely no star power. Jessica - YAWN. I've heard this song sung several times on idol (and better) and Messica's version is nothing to write about. And the "Boomie's outstretchd hand" thing has got to stop. Boring twunt. Shaun - I felt like he was kind of emulating Chris Martin vocally. Just alright. Maybe a little bit safe. I give him props for changing the arrangement. Lindsay R. - I don't dislike her anymore BUT I don't like her (get it?). She performed a little better than I thought she would. Screechiness might be an issue if she lasts long. Omar - I guess I should give him props for not picking a generic RnB song. The song arrangement was interesting. Not sold on him yet. He might just continue the tradition of Black male singers on CI sucking. Marie-Pierre - She can sing but the song choice was safe and boring. She might be in danger. Sebastian - The first good performance of the night. He did better than his bro did last night. I felt the performance was very genuine. Theo - One of the show's better singers - I'll give him that. I hate "Apologize" but his arrangement was radically changed from the Timbaland version, I didn't really notice it until he got into the chorus. He sang it well but I couldn't get past the Craigina comparisons. Amberly - <3 <3 <3 First off, she looks absolutely stunning with her hair tied back. I also love her cute outfit. Her voice has a really pleasant, pure tone to it. Excellent song choice despite not being one of Norah's more popular tunes. She can have my babies. Me and Amberly = MEANT.TO.BE. Adam - Erm... I don't like the song choice at all. He could've showcased his vocals with a different song. It was like someone made a song request in the audience and Adam decided to tackle it. Not his best performance. He was better in Toronto rounds. Katelyn - I love Katelyn but I'm so tired of "Hallelujah" and it should be retired from the idol song catalogue. With that said, I thought the countrified spin on the song was just okay. Kudos for changing the arrangement and not sticking to the very predictable acoustic version. The Good 1. Amberly - MARRY ME MY GODDESS! 2. Sebastian 3. Theo 4. Katelyn 5. Marie-Pierre 6. Adam -gap- 7. Omar 8. Jesse 9. Shaun 10. Jessica 11. Lindsay R. 12. Mark |
||
|
MikiBoi |
|||
|
Posts: 2900 (06/24/08 9:34 PM) Registered user |
My vote totals:
|
||
|
Remington Steele |
|||
|
Posts: 1382 (06/24/08 9:42 PM) |
If the boys keep choosing the the wrong songs, Amberly can slay them all. It doesn't matter how many more of them there are.
|
||
|
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Posts: 14442 (06/24/08 9:47 PM) Registered user |
I'd be funny to see it be classic CI and the guys ahead and then a girl randomly comes out a la Eva and kills them all because all the best ones split
votes and went home. On a normal show Keith or Greg would have won that title, but this is CI and it's built for people like Eva. The front runner males
won't win this, it will be a come from behind male like Earl or Mitch, not someone like the Pigs or Mookie, or it will be a girl, namely Amberly because
all the other vaginas are toast.
|
||
|
smartguy24 |
|||
|
Posts: 2494 (06/24/08 9:49 PM) Registered User |
MikiBoi wrote: Well you've been doing better than me. I've only managed about 100 votes total for 4 contestants over two nights. Hitting redial just doesn't
have the same excitement as it did for CI4 and Eva. Although...I never started voting for her till the top 10 started...maybe I've jumped the gun.
|
||
|
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Posts: 14444 (06/24/08 9:51 PM) Registered user |
Redial can kiss my ass. I voted maybe 100 times total last night and only so my American peeps could have votes for Mitch and Earl.
I hate voting and I've never going to like doing it. My mind will be changed like the little pussy I am when the Top 10 ends up sucking and I need to fight like a muther fucker to get the one good person to win though. |
||
|
JRobbed |
|||
|
Posts: 10195 (06/24/08 10:26 PM) Registered User |
Miraclemax wrote: The only problem with voting people in is that the ones that go the first week won't get the chance to build up a fanbase like the ones who don't
get in until week three. Therefore, being the best the first week is actually kind of a handicap.
|
||
|
Queen Narnia |
|||
|
Posts: 949 (06/24/08 10:33 PM) Registered User |
Finally, able to watch tonight and the guys this season are far too overrated. Some are decent and I fully expect everyone with some semblance of talent to be
quickly out the door. This season could be a total trainwreck.
1. Amberly- Hopefully the Mennonite vote is strong. 2. Theo- Possibly more gay than Mark Day. 3. Mark- He's an enjoyable mess to watch. 4. Katelyn- I <3 her. Please stay! 5. Sebastian- My TV boyfriend has a horrific voice, but he sure looks good. 6. Adam- WTF kind of song choice was that? Overrated. 7. Marie-Pierre- Toast 8. Jessica- Toast. 9. Shaun- Bad vocals 10. Omar- Transcending my ass Sass, I hate unnecessary runs and ewwwww about the whole thing. 11. Other Girl- Screechy and probably gone. 12. Jesse- Worst rendition of Rebel Yell EVER! |
||
|
WylDawg |
|||
|
Posts: 15688 (06/24/08 10:42 PM) Registered user |
And Wyldawg, with the exception of your feelings about Mookie, get the fuck out of my head already!
It's kinda weird that I was shocked about the admitting to the gayness thing, given that 3 out of 4 guys on idol shows ARE gay or questionnable at the very least. |
||
|
MikiBoi |
|||
|
Posts: 2901 (06/24/08 10:52 PM) Registered user |
smartguy24 wrote: I'm only doing this now for the semis smartguy, if I can manage. I never voted in the semis before and not this much. Once the 10 starts, I'll probably have just 1 or 2 I like as usuall and vote for them a few. Amberly is not that great, imo. Meh, I wasn't impressed. I don't even remember what she sang. Sebastian gets a + for exposing his hairy chest. Sexi <3<3<3. |
||
|
MikiBoi |
|||
|
Posts: 2903 (06/24/08 11:03 PM) Registered user |
Signs Theo was a gae before his reveal
Theo came to Toronto's Top 200 audition this year and was blown away by the talent around him. "I remember being speechless during the Toronto week, wondering how the judges were going to find a Top 22 from all this talent. I can't blame them for picking 24 competitors, and I am so stoked to be chosen as one of them." Theo found his niche in the Top 24 by bringing a unique, self-assured performance style to the table which has always been supported by his friends and family. "When I perform anal, I am giving 100% of myself and what I stand for as an artist." A university student working towards a double major in Psychology and Classical Music, Theo's vocal training has been in opera, but his musical tastes cross all genres - from Bob Marley to Lauryn Hill, to Damien Rice and beyond. Like his musical tastes, Theo also describes his personal style as a bit of a mash-up. "If a preppy guy and a hippie got into a fight - I would be wearing the clothes that got ripped off." With a description like that, Theo's Canadian Idol style is sure to be unique. According to Theo, "You make your own way as an artist. You need to discover your own path in the industry." Ultimately, Canadian Idol was his path. "The competition has made me much more aware of who I am as an artist." |
||
|
ilovety |
|||
|
Posts: 503 (06/24/08 11:26 PM) Registered User |
1. Theo
2. Amberly - i love her 3. Sebastian 4. Adam 5. Katelyn 6. Jessica 7. Marie Pierre 8. Mark 9. Omar 10. Shaun 11. Lindsay 12. Jesse |
||
|
Heliox |
|||
|
Posts: 745 (06/25/08 12:06 AM) |
tonight..:
1. Theo--- outstanding and now my favorite in the competition 2. Lindsay R-loved her..minus the screechiness 3. Jessica-- best voice and she did the song well ...okay so this is where I say the top 3 I had tonight were on my 'I don't care if they make it list' until they outshone the early favorites 4.Amberly--but I want to hate her..mennonite eh? isn't she going to burn in hell for this? .. I can hope so, but she can sing damn it..and damn her!! 5.Sebastien- first half of song was incredible..if he could have only kept it up 6.Omar-I actually liked this version 7. Mark- surprise again for me 8. Adam-again with the rockabilly/60's crap that Oliver and Lindsay did. WTF WTF for all 3. They all deserve a swift kick in the pants for their song choices. don't care about the last 4 and hope 2 of these go... 9. Shaun 10.Katelyn 11. Jesse 12. Mary Pierre |
||
|
bucking fitch |
|||
|
Posts: 1202 (06/25/08 7:21 AM) Registered user |
Miraclemax wrote: This would be a really good idea, and works with the cumulative votes rumour. I find myself largely underwhelmed after this first week. They suck me in every year thinking this is going to be the best season EVAH! and then 90% of the people I thought were really talented end up sucking the first week. Just a couple of standouts, and a few more with the potential to be standouts. I thought Jessica would suck, she wasn't that bad. Mark has a decent voice, but his personality is way too cheesy and makes me throw up in my mouth a little bit. I don't get the Omar love, I thought he was off key alot, and I cringed through most of his song. Adam rocked, but I wasn't thrilled with the song choice. I liked Theo and Amberley as well. The rest were just, meh. |
||
|
Mai4 |
|||
|
Posts: 3018 (06/25/08 7:30 AM) Registered User |
1. Theo - ::creams:: Boy is just amazing. Loved it!!
2. Jessica - Finally get to hear my girl!! <3 Song choice was weak, but she SANG it. 3. Omar - Loved his flow and arrangement. KKKanada better vote for him. 4. Amberly - Short & Sweet! She's my Brooke White of this year. (Minus the crazy) 5. Sabastien - He looked & performed well. He just needed stronger vocals. 6. Lindsay - She was shrilly, but I still kinda liked it. 7. Adam - He's a pro and I loved it vocally, but WTF with that song choice? 8. Marie-Pierre - Hated the song choice (leave Amy songs ALONE!). Yet she sang it fairly well. 9. Shaun - I was bored throughout the entire performance. 10. Katelyn - Generic singer. She was pitchy as hell during the chorus. 11. Mark -  I officially hate him.
12. Jesse - HATE, HATE, HATE Rebel Yell!!! (He sucked too) Send Home: Jesse, Katelyn, Shaun, Marie-Pierre & Mark (  yeah right).
|
||
|
pjadedd |
|||
|
Posts: 6759 (06/25/08 8:26 AM) Registered User |
OK, Part 2:
Jesse - Another interesting song choice. First 5 seconds and I can tell this is total karaoke. And, he gets to the chorus . . . and it's really bad karaoke. This is just getting worse as it goes along. At this point, I would just stop, apologize, and walk off stage. Mark - You're not funny. Physical performer? I just ate breakfast. Thanks. Really, he's the one that chose Alone? It is cool a guy is doing it. Too low to begin. Stop pointing. Well, Carrie Underwood has nothing to worry about in terms of whether this was better than her version. And what was with the "come on" at the end? Even if I thought his performance was good, I'd hate him due to his annoying personality. I agree with Sass that there were a few good notes, but overall, no. Still better than Jesse. Jessica - I'm sure she altered SHC's emotional state (into rage). Something just rubs me the wrong way when your goal is to see people's emotional reaction. Very "you like me, you really like me" desperation. She's Katharine McPhee, just not as good. Still better than the first two, but that's not saying much so far. I'm expecting an emotional trainwreck when she gets eliminated. Shaun - I haven't liked him since the auditions. Too fucking cocky. I really hate his hair and shirt. I'm bored. This episode sucks so far. Lindsay - Look at me, I don't do covers. I'm edgy. She basically wants to be David Cook. I have very low expectations. This is edgy? Really? Owww, that hurt my ears. Man, I hate a lot of contestants this season. Omar - Some notes that sounded odd, but still really good. I like his voice. Very smooth sounding. Best so far by a mile even though the end was a little weak. Marie-Pierre - I already hate the beginning with the dancing. Very smoky voice. I really like her voice, but not the song. Sebastian - Not as much of the "I have to take a dump" vocals as his brother, but they're still there. Sounds much better than Oliver. I keep waiting for more, though. It sounds like he's holding back. Theo - I have big expectations, as he is my favorite going into the top 24. I was hoping he was doing Apologize when I saw the song list. Not as good as I was hoping, but still better than everything else tonight, which has been dismal. Nice ending. Amberly (aka Kelly Kapowski) - Yeah, she's Brooke White, hopefully with more crazy. I was a little bored, but it was pretty good vocally (except for one note that I just heard as I finished typing it was good). Adam - What the fuck is this? Way to pick a song that shows no vocal range whatsoever. Asshat. Still nowhere near the worst of the evening, though. Katelyn - They like pimping the blonds, don't they? Good to start off, then comes the chorus. Really weak vocals. Not the chorus = good. Chorus = bad. Overall, this episode was just not that good. Ranking: Theo Omar Amberly Sebastian Jessica Marie-Pierre Katelyn Adam Shaun Mark Lindsay Jesse |
||
|
pickledsquirrelnuggetss |
|||
|
Posts: 912 (06/25/08 10:13 AM) |
Omar is garbage. He is so unbelievably fake, I can't stand to listen to him sing or talk. He's running with his "i'm so passionate and
sensitive and I feel every song I sing" thing and I can't believe the judges, or at least Sass, are buying into it. On top of that he sang the song
horribly. Normally I like guys who don't sing all that great but are still obviously talented....like Sebastian. Omar can sing though, and he may have
talent, but when you sing badly trying to sing well that just doesn't work for me.
|
||
|
louie77 |
|||
|
Posts: 15214 (06/25/08 12:55 PM) Registered user |
Ok, finished watching, and i actually quite liked this group. I liked the large majority of them and it was certainly better than Monday night's bunch.
|
||
|
MikiBoi |
|||
|
Posts: 2904 (06/25/08 1:33 PM) Registered user |
Wednesday, June 25 at 7:30 pm ET/7:30 pm PT TOP 24 RESULTS SHOW Four competitors will be eliminated in tonight's episode. |
||
