Anne Murray was one of the best mentors ever. She actually paid attention and helped each one.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
FionaFlanagan |
|||
|
That was one of the worst nights of any Idol show ever. I don't care who wins at all anymore they are so underwhelming. Earl and Mitch seemed to want to
go with their second songs. Theo needs to sit the fuck down behind the piano. I don't want to see him haul himself around the stage or piano top.
Drew's first song was the best of the night because he didn't mumble and scream.
Anne Murray was one of the best mentors ever. She actually paid attention and helped each one. |
|||
swim4life227 |
|||
|
Yay Earl is gone.
The Dritch finale is still possible <3 |
|||
seaguy |
|||
|
Was there a bottom 2?
Theo <3 |
|||
swim4life227 |
|||
|
No. For whatever reason they didn't do a bottom 2 last year at this point.
There was an omg shattering 3.7 million votes |
|||
louie77 |
|||
|
Earl
He deserved to be in the finale...such a fun guy. At least Mitch is still going strong. And no, no bottom 2. |
|||
swim4life227 |
|||
|
I don't why that's exciting. That probably means he loses in the final 2 like every other year. |
|||
smartguy24 |
|||
|
Oh hell...with Earl gone we might as well have a Mitch and Drew final 2 to send this show to the graveyard.
|
|||
Remington Steele |
|||
swim4life227 wrote:Why is that funny? Isn't that about the same percentage of votes for AI (excepting the finale)? |
|||
Keitspid |
|||
|
So, I was out of town and I just got back this afternoon, so I haven't watched the actual performances yet. I watched the results show, though, and
judging by the recap that I saw, I didn't miss much (although I want to watch Drew's Gravity and Theo's final song). But whatever happened on the
show last night, I am pretty happy with the results. Definitely my favourite Final 3 EVAH!
Thedritch ftw! Oh wait, they already did. <3 |
|||
MikiBoi |
|||
|
Drew's hairy chest is a lucky charm <3. |
|||
roadblocker |
|||
|
Most meh final three ever.
Theo to lose, pls. This is the first time since the first season that a Nova Scotian has made it this far. Can we finally crown our first East Coast winner? |
|||
Lobsters |
|||
|
omg I can't believe that stupi duck Mitch is still there.
|
|||
dagny1331 |
|||
|
Lobsters, were you trying to say:
A. Stupi duck B. Stupid uck C. Stupid duck or D. Stupid Fuck ? |
|||
smartguy24 |
|||
roadblocker wrote:Might as well...it'd be funny...a dude who plays the guitar every.fucking.week showing no versatility whatsoever comes out on top. Sounds like a plan! |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Worst Top 3 ever.
Billy and Ryan - thumbs up, Gayry - regional vote getting fucker Theresa, Kalan and Jacob - all kinds of amazingness Melissa - amazing, Aaron - great, Rex - mediocre and got by on fangirl votes and regional votes but everyone else was mediocre too and only Ashley was more deserving Eva - phenomenal, Craigina - the dyke could sing, even if regional votes helped, Tyler - awful, this is the only other Top 3 that rivals S6 for awfulness Brian - decent enough in comparison to options like Dwight and Matt, Carly - awesome, Bixbitch - awful |
|||
Miraclemax |
|||
X
I'm really tempted to vote for Mitch next week. But I probably won't watch anyway.
And again if a male wins he will only possess 2 of the following 3 qualities: looks male, sounds male, has hair.
|
|||
roadblocker |
|||
|
Can't believe that this season went from having the best Top 24 in a long time to a potentially salvageable Top 10 and then ended up with these three.
Theo - best chance to be the winner out of the three although I don't care about him. he can sing but in the end... who cares? Mitch - he's okay to me personally although at times I'm kind of indifferent to him too. he's also an acquired taste Drew - he Tyler Lewis'd his way to the top three. there were other semi-finalists of his kind that were better than him (like Martin and Gary) but Canada likes mediocrity so we're still stuck with Drew |
|||
Miraclemax |
|||
|
This season has turned into CI4 all over again.
Theo/Eva = Front runner, best singer Mitch/Craig = from the east coast, high voice Drew/Tyler = the guy that nobody remembers Earl/Chad = The inconsistant but unique one. When he's bad he's brutal but when he's good he's amazing. Mookie/Steffi D = Unique but not too polarizing. Really cool contestant. Amberly/Ashley = female that should've been in the top 2 and actually could've given the front runner a run for their money. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Wow, that's very bang on.
Wasn't an Ashley fan and she's very different from Amberly but yeah she was better than someone like Tyler and maybe could have beaten Eva. Canada will NEVER have an all girl Top 2 though so that wasn't going to happen. |
|||
Miraclemax |
|||
|
I always thought it should've been Ashley vs Eva in the finale. Steffi and Chad should've rounded out the top 4. CI4=CI6. We end up with a pretty good top 6 but the next 3 eliminations are terrible and we are left with a terrible top 3 (except for the winner Eva/Theo) |
|||