Questions that were never answered

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
platinumtlc		#161	[-]
Posts: 7611 (12/31/08 1:19 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Chet, did Probst read the votes like he would normally, or did he just tell you guys to revote? Meaning, did they lead you to believe that the tie and the revote was going to be aired on TV, or did you know they weren't going to show it to us? I don't know why they didn't show it to us.
chettyboy		#162	[-]
Posts: 154 (12/31/08 8:17 AM) What in the CHET!? Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	When we had the revote, Mikey and I did not vote, everyone else did. Probst read them the first time like he normally does with all of the suspense etc. Then when it was a tie, he said revote without chet and Mikey voting. Then he read them again all suspensefull etc which at that time Joel changed his vote from Jason to Mikey and we all know the rest. I was sitting next to Mikey and it was uncomfortable as I pretty much knew (or hoped I did) what the final result would be. When Jeff says "Let's Tally the votes" and walks away, he is gone for at least a half hour or longer. They never show that part, you just sit there on those dame uncomfortable fake logs and wait for the results. Thanks...good question
craig		#163	[-]
Posts: 14673 (12/31/08 8:55 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	So was the tie Chet, Kathy, Tracy, Natalie vs. Mikey, Jason, Alexis, Erik? So I guess Tracy was the key person pushing for a Mikey boot, or else Jason could have gone? The editing at the start made us assume that Natalie was Alexis's follower, but I guess she played her own game and had her own friends.
Kirblar		#164	[-]
Posts: 7295 (12/31/08 9:23 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The weird split votes were due to HII fears, weren't they?
panurge46		#165	[-]
Posts: 1183 (12/31/08 11:29 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: So was the tie Chet, Kathy, Tracy, Natalie vs. Mikey, Jason, Alexis, Erik? So I guess Tracy was the key person pushing for a Mikey boot, or else Jason could have gone? The editing at the start made us assume that Natalie was Alexis's follower, but I guess she played her own game and had her own friends. Maybe Erik first voted against Chet but it could as well have been Natalie. Erik was Joel's lapdog so I'd say he voted Mikey B. both times. I can see Natalie first following Alexis but then going with the majority on the revote. Had to keep that head down, you know.
chettyboy		#166	[-]
Posts: 155 (12/31/08 11:55 AM) What in the CHET!? Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Natalie seemed to always be the swing vote, but after the vote, Natalie would look at me and wink and I knew I was safe.
chettyboy		#167	[-]
Posts: 156 (12/31/08 12:00 PM) What in the CHET!? Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The only one who voted Jason was Joel. But then changed it when he saw that he would be the one to break the tie between Mikey and I. Let me tell you, I was relieved, but still confident that it was going to go the way it did. In the beginning, Tracy Kathy and I were always safe even though Tracy and I got votes, because key people knew that the three of us would always vote their way (which was always three votes) as long as we were not one of them. Personally I wanted Jason to go from day one and if the tribes had not switched, Joel agreed that the three of us and he would get rid of Jason the next tribal. So had we not switched, Jason's smelly ass would have been gone long before me.
panurge46		#168	[-]
Posts: 1184 (12/31/08 12:12 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If the tribes had not switched, would it have mattered? Airai was doomed with that strategy. You'd have soon been forced to join Jason in Loser Lodge.
Kirblar		#169	[-]
Posts: 7298 (12/31/08 12:25 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	panurge46 wrote: If the tribes had not switched, would it have mattered? Airai was doomed with that strategy. You'd have soon been forced to join Jason in Loser Lodge. So Chet should have allowed them to boot him for the good of the "tribe"?
Sicycat		#170	[-]
Posts: 404 (12/31/08 1:17 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	chettyboy wrote: When Jeff says "Let's Tally the votes" and walks away, he is gone for at least a half hour or longer. They never show that part, you just sit there on those dame uncomfortable fake logs and wait for the results. Are you serious?? What the hell does he do for half an hour.
kenc333		#171	[-]
Posts: 6219 (12/31/08 1:31 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Sicycat wrote: chettyboy wrote: When Jeff says "Let's Tally the votes" and walks away, he is gone for at least a half hour or longer. They never show that part, you just sit there on those dame uncomfortable fake logs and wait for the results. Are you serious?? What the hell does he do for half an hour. I think it was mentioned either in DVD commentary or Survivor Live or something, but they have to go through the votes, and then watch the Survivor's voting confessionals to determine which ones will be aired, and then order the votes accordingly, and with dramatic effect.
panurge46		#172	[-]
Posts: 1185 (12/31/08 3:22 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kirblar wrote: panurge46 wrote: If the tribes had not switched, would it have mattered? Airai was doomed with that strategy. You'd have soon been forced to join Jason in Loser Lodge. So Chet should have allowed them to boot him for the good of the "tribe"? Was Chet in charge? Joel's strategy was the one that doomed Airai. I thought you had seen the season.
Kirblar		#173	[-]
Posts: 7299 (12/31/08 3:25 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	panurge46 wrote: Kirblar wrote: panurge46 wrote: If the tribes had not switched, would it have mattered? Airai was doomed with that strategy. You'd have soon been forced to join Jason in Loser Lodge. So Chet should have allowed them to boot him for the good of the "tribe"? Was Chet in charge? Joel's strategy was the one that doomed Airai. I thought you had seen the season. "Airai" doesn't exist ;) I hate it when people talk as though someone's screwing over their tribe - it's an individual game, not a team sport.
chapera rocks		#174	[-]
Posts: 10096 (12/31/08 3:28 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	It was still a dumb move for Joel. He could keep strong people that are on his side vs. weaker people who are just trying to save themselves and have no long lasting loyalty to him ... as evident in episode 5.
Kirblar		#175	[-]
Posts: 7300 (12/31/08 3:31 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	chapera rocks wrote: It was still a dumb move for Joel. He could keep strong people that are on his side vs. weaker people who are just trying to save themselves and have no long lasting loyalty to him ... as evident in episode 5. Oh, most definitely.
Thailandsurvivor		#176	[-]
Posts: 4140 (12/31/08 3:31 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: So was the tie Chet, Kathy, Tracy, Natalie vs. Mikey, Jason, Alexis, Erik? Yeah, I just said that on the previous page. Erik and Joel both switched their votes (which is why it was 6-3 for Mikey B to leave). The editing at the start made us assume that Natalie was Alexis's follower, but I guess she played her own game and had her own friends. No shit. Did you really believe Parvati was controlling her the entire game? Oh wait, you probably did. Come on. This is also why it pisses me off that no one thinks Natalie has the game won if Amanda doesn't find the idol. Her and Alexis are sitting pretty for the rest of the game after Amanda leaves. She was not Parvati's follower, and it would have been a complete 180 on the show with Parvati following Natalie had the producers not unfairly rehid the idol.
platinumtlc		#177	[-]
Posts: 7615 (12/31/08 4:46 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Amanda's idol had to be the most easiest to find ever.
unduli clone		#178	[-]
Posts: 3788 (12/31/08 5:18 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Thailandsurvivor wrote: No shit. Did you really believe Parvati was controlling her the entire game? Oh wait, you probably did. Come on. This is also why it pisses me off that no one thinks Natalie has the game won if Amanda doesn't find the idol. Her and Alexis are sitting pretty for the rest of the game after Amanda leaves. She was not Parvati's follower, and it would have been a complete 180 on the show with Parvati following Natalie had the producers not unfairly rehid the idol. If Amanda had gone at F6, I think Parvati would've still won, reeling in the favorite votes against fans Natalie and Alexis in the F3 (as it most likely would've shaken out). Natalie did have a good game, though - if not for Amanda's idol she would've been F3 for sure: any switchup at F5 (which was unlikely) would've left Alexis on the outs, not Natalie, since she was close with Parv. Amanda's idol wasn't unfair though.. I mean, Jason found his in one visit as well, so it's not as though Amanda's was any easier.
Thailandsurvivor		#179	[-]
Posts: 4148 (12/31/08 5:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	unduli clone wrote: Thailandsurvivor wrote: No shit. Did you really believe Parvati was controlling her the entire game? Oh wait, you probably did. Come on. This is also why it pisses me off that no one thinks Natalie has the game won if Amanda doesn't find the idol. Her and Alexis are sitting pretty for the rest of the game after Amanda leaves. She was not Parvati's follower, and it would have been a complete 180 on the show with Parvati following Natalie had the producers not unfairly rehid the idol. If Amanda had gone at F6, I think Parvati would've still won, reeling in the favorite votes against fans Natalie and Alexis in the F3 (as it most likely would've shaken out). Natalie did have a good game, though - if not for Amanda's idol she would've been F3 for sure: any switchup at F5 (which was unlikely) would've left Alexis on the outs, not Natalie, since she was close with Parv. Amanda's idol wasn't unfair though.. I mean, Jason found his in one visit as well, so it's not as though Amanda's was any easier. Well, since it was a final two, it would have been Natalie and Alexis barring an immunity win from Erik at the final 4 and final 3 or Parvati at the final 3. I don't know if Natalie would have beaten Alexis, but she would have destroyed Parv in the jury questioning. Amanda staying in general after recieving the most votes is unfair to me. Just like it was unfair when Yau Man stayed in the game over Stacy. Also, in just the previous season, the idol was not rehidden when James left the game. I don't see why they had to bring it back for Micronesia especially when if Ozzy had not told people he had the idol/people didn't look through Jason's bag, no one would know it was out of the game when those two left.
kenc333		#180	[-]
Posts: 6221 (12/31/08 5:34 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	To be fair, Cirie was willing to force a tie to try to keep Amanda in the game. And Amanda has said in post show interviews that Cirie was going to vote for Alexis, but Amanda told her to vote for her instead, so that she could guarantee that there was enough votes for the idol to take effect.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Questions that were never answered

Quick Reply