40 Greatest Survivor Players - (#5-1 On Pg. 29!) - Clubs That Suck. No, Really. - The Rest... - Survivor Sucks - Message Board

0 Kudo

40 Greatest Survivor Players - (#5-1 On Pg. 29!)

Started By	Comment
solesurvivor01		#61	[-]
Posts: 2438 (09/28/08 12:15 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CSCin3D wrote: Natalie and Alexis were always playing for 4th and 5th. They both don't deserve to be on the list. ecks. I don't really see how we can count them for top 40 material when they were both Parvati's bitches. I hate Parvati, but I'll fully acknowledge that she was totally controlling these two morons. Also, Amanda is an absolute must for this list. She made the FTC twice, was responsible for several blindsides, never received a (valid) vote against her, etc. The fact that she was a shitty endgame player just means that she won't be at the top of this list.
LKMOSCAR		#62	[-]
Posts: 4590 (09/28/08 12:20 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	COMPLETED. Oddly enough, when reviewing Cassandra, I felt no reason to not give her a 10. I probably handed out 7 tens.
GnarlsInCharge		#63	[-]
Posts: 2334 (09/28/08 12:20 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CSCin3D wrote: Are you fucking nuts? Alexis and Natalie THREW THE GAME AWAY. They were just Parvati's bitches. Umm they were openly targetting Parvati's goat(Amanda). Other than Parvati they were the only players who had a solid path to the F2 that season. They should easily be 2 of the highest ranked players not to make the finals.
1TxT1		#64	[-]
Posts: 194 (09/28/08 12:23 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	solesurvivor01 wrote: CSCin3D wrote: Natalie and Alexis were always playing for 4th and 5th. They both don't deserve to be on the list. ecks. I don't really see how we can count them for top 40 material when they were both Parvati's bitches. I hate Parvati, but I'll fully acknowledge that she was totally controlling these two morons. Also, Amanda is an absolute must for this list. She made the FTC twice, was responsible for several blindsides, never received a (valid) vote against her, etc. The fact that she was a shitty endgame player just means that she won't be at the top of this list. There's plenty of followers like that on this list like Kim J. and Paschal. Kucha does not deserve to be on this list and anyone who was against alliances like season 1 should not be here for greatest survivor players
CSCin3D		#65	[-]
Posts: 9304 (09/28/08 12:23 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	GnarlsInCharge wrote: CSCin3D wrote: Are you fucking nuts? Alexis and Natalie THREW THE GAME AWAY. They were just Parvati's bitches. Umm they were openly targetting Parvati's goat(Amanda). Other than Parvati they were the only players who had a solid path to the F2 that season. They should easily be 2 of the highest ranked players not to make the finals. The only reason they targetted Amanda was because Erik won immunity. If he hadn't in the F6, they would have voted him out and Natalie and Alexis still would have been booted by Parv/Amanda/Cirie. They were under the delusion that Parvati and Cirie were going to take them to the F4, which simply wasn't the case. They got played like fools. If they were really playing the game, they would have used Jason's idol to take out Amanda at F8.
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor		#66	[-]
Posts: 6055 (09/28/08 12:25 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Wow. Tremendous response. We could be passing up 50 voters by the end of the night. Here's some tidbits: - 27 players can't even qualify for the list at the moment as they have 50% or more of their vote totals going to the "Not In The Top 40" category. Those that don't qualify will be listed right after the poll closes & I tally the results. Anybody that does qualify will be listed, so the list will start at 54 or whatever but I'll only continually update the Top 40 every season by adding in new players. - Only 2 players have had 2/3 of their votes go to the "10" category. They are both winners. - Only 3 winners have earned a vote in the "Not In The Top 40" category. They all only earned that one vote, no more. - 88.9% is currently the highest percentage of "Not In The Top 40" votes. It is shared by three players.
YemaGrl1988		#67	[-]
Posts: 1965 (09/28/08 12:26 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CSCin3D wrote: GnarlsInCharge wrote: CSCin3D wrote: Are you fucking nuts? Alexis and Natalie THREW THE GAME AWAY. They were just Parvati's bitches. Umm they were openly targetting Parvati's goat(Amanda). Other than Parvati they were the only players who had a solid path to the F2 that season. They should easily be 2 of the highest ranked players not to make the finals. The only reason they targetted Amanda was because Erik won immunity. If he hadn't in the F6, they would have voted him out and Natalie and Alexis still would have been booted by Parv/Amanda/Cirie. They were under the delusion that Parvati and Cirie were going to take them to the F4, which simply wasn't the case. They got played like fools. If they were really playing the game, they would have used Jason's idol to take out Amanda at F8. But they were super fans who knew the game of survivor in and out!!1!1!111!11!!!!
LuteinSa		#68	[-]
Posts: 180 (09/28/08 12:26 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CSCin3D wrote: GnarlsInCharge wrote: CSCin3D wrote: Are you fucking nuts? Alexis and Natalie THREW THE GAME AWAY. They were just Parvati's bitches. Umm they were openly targetting Parvati's goat(Amanda). Other than Parvati they were the only players who had a solid path to the F2 that season. They should easily be 2 of the highest ranked players not to make the finals. The only reason they targetted Amanda was because Erik won immunity. If he hadn't in the F6, they would have voted him out and Natalie and Alexis still would have been booted by Parv/Amanda/Cirie. They were under the delusion that Parvati and Cirie were going to take them to the F4, which simply wasn't the case. They got played like fools. If they were really playing the game, they would have used Jason's idol to take out Amanda at F8. They're still better players than like anyone from the first 2-3 seasons
Dictatorship		#69	[-]
Posts: 4172 (09/28/08 12:30 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Voted! Petition to give Heidi 10s. Come on, guys, think about the Amazon! She was the smartest player there and was fucked when Alex revealed his loyalty to her!
Thailandsurvivor		#70	[-]
Posts: 1827 (09/28/08 12:33 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Wait what? How were Natalie and Alexis Parvati's bitches? I'm sorry that you guys were blind enough to believe the editing that they would have taken out Erik if he lost immunity. They had planned to take out Amanda at the final 6 anyways. Cirie would leave at 5 and Erik at 4 for being an immunity threat. I don't know how Natalie was Parv's bitch when she set herself so that Parv AND Alexis would both be taking her to the finals. Not the other way around. ETA- Voted Last Edited By: Thailandsurvivor 09/28/08 12:38 PM. Edited 1 times.
solesurvivor01		#71	[-]
Posts: 2440 (09/28/08 12:35 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	It's almost impossible to compare Alexis/Natalie to players on the first couple of seasons because the game was so different then. There were no idols/excessive backstabbing/excessive blindsides/etc. I'm actually going to agree with CSC. Those two were gone at 4 and 5 if Erik didn't win immunity, and if they really were playing the game, then at the F8 they round up Jason and Erik to vote out Amanda and get James to vote for Parvati, and then these "superfans" would be playing more like superfans. ETA: If they really wanted to take out Amanda, then why would Alexis be stupid enough to send her to exile to find the idol, especially if she knows there's a good chance that James would be taken out due to his injury.
kenc333		#72	[-]
Posts: 3593 (09/28/08 12:40 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Dictatorship wrote: Voted! Petition to give Heidi 10s. Come on, guys, think about the Amazon! She was the smartest player there and was fucked when Alex revealed his loyalty to her! I know! She was like the mastermind behind half the plans that go on at camp... (I voted her not deserving to be in the top 40 , sorry!)
CSCin3D		#73	[-]
Posts: 9305 (09/28/08 12:41 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Thailandsurvivor wrote: Wait what? How were Natalie and Alexis Parvati's bitches? I'm sorry that you guys were blind enough to believe the editing that they would have taken out Erik if he lost immunity. They had planned to take out Amanda at the final 6 anyways. Cirie would leave at 5 and Erik at 4 for being an immunity threat. I don't know how Natalie was Parv's bitch when she set herself so that Parv AND Alexis would both be taking her to the finals. Not the other way around. Umm, it's not such a good idea to hinge the outcome of the entire game on a tie vote when you could have had it wrapped up at the previous TC. Plus, we don't know what would have happened if James had stayed in the game. Parv/Cirie/Amanda very well could have used him one more round to take out Erik. And Natalie shouldn't have been worried about an F2, since from her perspective she should have been playing expecting an F3.
Thailandsurvivor		#74	[-]
Posts: 1828 (09/28/08 12:41 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	solesurvivor01 wrote: It's almost impossible to compare Alexis/Natalie to players on the first couple of seasons because the game was so different then. There were no idols/excessive backstabbing/excessive blindsides/etc. I'm actually going to agree with CSC. Those two were gone at 4 and 5 if Erik didn't win immunity, and if they really were playing the game, then at the F8 they round up Jason and Erik to vote out Amanda and get James to vote for Parvati, and then these "superfans" would be playing more like superfans. ETA: If they really wanted to take out Amanda, then why would Alexis be stupid enough to send her to exile to find the idol, especially if she knows there's a good chance that James would be taken out due to his injury. Natalie hated Jason. And she played him hard. Alexis did make the mistake of sending her to Exile (which is not Natalie's fault at all, don't give me that shit), but you're saying that she was supposed to expect James to be taken out of the game? For real? This is an injury that James had had for over a week, and he was still playing. There's no way either of them expected him to have to leave the game.
Thailandsurvivor		#75	[-]
Posts: 1829 (09/28/08 12:44 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CSCin3D wrote: Thailandsurvivor wrote: Wait what? How were Natalie and Alexis Parvati's bitches? I'm sorry that you guys were blind enough to believe the editing that they would have taken out Erik if he lost immunity. They had planned to take out Amanda at the final 6 anyways. Cirie would leave at 5 and Erik at 4 for being an immunity threat. I don't know how Natalie was Parv's bitch when she set herself so that Parv AND Alexis would both be taking her to the finals. Not the other way around. Umm, it's not such a good idea to hinge the outcome of the entire game on a tie vote when you could have had it wrapped up at the previous TC. Plus, we don't know what would have happened if James had stayed in the game. Parv/Cirie/Amanda very well could have used him one more round to take out Erik. And Natalie shouldn't have been worried about an F2, since from her perspective she should have been playing expecting an F3. Was it a tie vote? Uh, no. They were able to get Cirie on their side because of the purple rock threat. James would not have been willing to work with Parv as he was a bitter bitch as seen in the final tc. I gave Natalie a 9, but you really can't say that she doesn't deserve to be in the top 40 just because she got the most screwed in editing in history next to maybe Becky.
CSCin3D		#76	[-]
Posts: 9306 (09/28/08 12:47 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The bottom line is Natalie had plenty of opportunities to take the game over, but constantly screwed herself over to play into Parvati's hands. You can't deny that using Jason's idol to boot Amanda at F8 and/or creating a pseudo fan alliance would have made things MUCH easier and given her a chance to win.
kenc333		#77	[-]
Posts: 3594 (09/28/08 12:48 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Thailandsurvivor wrote: I gave Natalie a 9, but you really can't say that she doesn't deserve to be in the top 40 just because she got the most screwed in editing in history next to maybe Becky. Speaking of which, Jonathan and Yul both spoke very highly of Becky's game pointing out that she was a victim of editing. Probst even admitted that Becky's game was underrated.
CSCin3D		#78	[-]
Posts: 9307 (09/28/08 12:50 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BTW: Editing was actually very generous to Natalie. They could have emphasized how stupid she was for voting out Jason, but instead made her look like an evil mastermind strategic genius, when she really was just evil and an idiot.
astroline		#79	[-]
Posts: 1425 (09/28/08 12:52 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I thought Natalie was an evil mastermind strategic genius, actually... I gave out only 4 10's in this poll, to Tom W., Parvati (FvF), Cirie (EI), and Natalie.
Thailandsurvivor		#80	[-]
Posts: 1830 (09/28/08 12:53 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	astroline wrote: I thought Natalie was an evil mastermind strategic genius, actually... I gave out only 4 10's in this poll, to Tom W., Parvati (FvF), Cirie (EI), and Natalie. I love Natalie and all, but to call her a better player than Hatch, Heidik, and Tina? Not sure if you can.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

40 Greatest Survivor Players - (#5-1 On Pg. 29!)

Quick Reply