| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 Demonic Tutor |
|||
|
Posts: 266 (09/27/08 9:07 PM) |
CirieFieldsofDreams wrote: Yeah right. This is just going to be a popularity contest |
||
|
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Posts: 5656 (09/27/08 9:12 PM) |
I'll agree that China Amanda deserves a spot, but Micronesia Amanda played as Ozzy's bitch, then as Parvati's bitch, and only got three votes
because of the same kind of bitter jurors that let fucking AMBER win All-Stars.
|
||
|
1TxT1 |
|||
|
Posts: 188 (09/27/08 9:21 PM) |
Micronesia Amanda is still better than China Amanda
|
||
|
solesurvivor01 |
|||
|
Posts: 2430 (09/27/08 9:25 PM) Registered user |
S1:These would be my picks for the top 40. Additions in bold, subtractions crossed out (I crossed out Amanda and Cirie their second times because they were counted the first) |
||
|
kenc333 |
|||
|
Posts: 3567 (09/27/08 9:30 PM) |
As great as Eliza is as a narrator and to cause drama, I wouldn't consider her one of the greatest Survivor players. As admitted by her, she's good at
mental challenges, but her social game is relatively weak. She's just a Sucks favourite and provides entertaining moments.
|
||
|
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
|||
|
Posts: 6046 (09/27/08 9:35 PM) Registered User |
I have hereby decided to add exactly 11 names and makes this an 80 to 40 exercise. I had not listed anyone from Pagong because they didn't actually form
acknowledged alliances which pretty much are the bulk of this game. I didn't include Cassandra & Rodger mostly
because of hesitation and not seeing them have too many campaigners. I didn't want to include Lil because she had been voted out once already. Kelly
Goldsmith got a bad wrap thanks to Lex but could've played her hand better and solved the fiasco the right way. To me, in the episode, Kelly just kind of
laid down and died when she should've been putting a lot of names into Lex's head and steering him away from her. She also could've brought up the
numbers game. Jake was the leader of his tribe and oddly managed to be the last left standing. He nearly made my initial draft. Darrah was another player that
made some key game moves and nearly made it, but I thought she would be outright laughed at thanks to her invisibility on the series. No way am I listing Jenn
or Gregg. No way. The Parvati/Candice/Nate/Adam alliance pissed me off so much in Cook Islands because they couldn't even understand just why Jonathan
flipped. Pathetic. My respect for Parvati later grew when I learned that she hadn't been a Survivor fan and had applied for The Amazing Race, therefore, it
makes things understandable as to why she didn't comprehend some of the more intricate game attributes.
My proposed 11: Colleen (still pretty ridiculous) Rodger Kelly G Jake Lil Darrah Rupert (PI) Gary (Guat.) Parvati (CI) Candice Cassandra Currently, the 69 I listed at first give us a six female gap. Females had six more listed from S1-12, then saw the lead entirely eradicated in S13-S14, then it went six to 1 (Todd vs. Courtney/Amanda(x2)/Peih-Gee/Natalie/Parvati/Cirie) in the last couple seasons. Interesting that even more will be added via this process, but I really can't think of enough males that should go on there. |
||
|
Nogales |
|||
|
Posts: 77 (09/27/08 9:44 PM) |
This is already biased
 . Colleen and Kelly G.?
|
||
|
CatLurvesDorothy |
|||
|
Posts: 1054 (09/27/08 9:48 PM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! |
I agree with the additions.
Hopefully Cassandra actually manages to make the list. |
||
|
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 5106 (09/27/08 9:56 PM) Registered user |
SurvivorFanGP wrote: Why, she didn't win did she? Oh, and I actually think that Rudy is a solid UTR player, so he should be included |
||
|
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
|
Posts: 1958 (09/27/08 9:57 PM) Registered user |
Yay at people finally seeing the Cassandra awesome-ness.
|
||
|
solesurvivor01 |
|||
|
Posts: 2431 (09/27/08 10:01 PM) Registered user |
kenc333 wrote:I thought you hated Eliza 
But anyways, my logic for putting her up there was the fact that in Vanuatu, she seemed to be on the chopping block nearly every week, but she saved herself every time until the final four. Good social game or not, that definitely says something. And I think we'd all agree she was a huge asset in many challenges (I don't know where the idea that she was a challenge liability ever came from). ETA: We also know that in Micronesia, had any of the following NOT happened, then she likely gets a lot further: Danny Bonaduce attacks JFP Jonathan gets medevaced Chet Pussies out Kathy Quits And let's face it, the chances of all these happening was really unlikely, and it really shows how unlucky she was.
Last Edited By: solesurvivor01
09/27/08 10:04 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
kenc333 |
|||
|
Posts: 3569 (09/27/08 10:06 PM) |
I do hate Eliza =P
In my books, she's an awful player, but I'm trying to keep my argument as unbiased as possible. She's popular around Sucks because she's snarky and posts here, but she's not popular with me. |
||
|
CatLurvesDorothy |
|||
|
Posts: 1055 (09/27/08 10:09 PM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! |
Actually, Eliza from Micronesia does have a good case...
|
||
|
Quiddity |
|||
|
Posts: 3664 (09/27/08 10:10 PM) Registered User |
I didn't include Cassandra & Rodger mostly because of hesitation and not seeing them have too many campaigners. Cassandra easily wins the game if it wasn't for a F3 twist that she had no possible way of knowing about leaving Earl in the game. I can understand not wanting to rank her that high, but to not even give her the chance to be considered among the top 40 is quite absurd if you ask me. BTW, add in my support for letting Leann be in the running. Its been rumored that she was the true leader of the lesbo alliance, not Ami. She certainly set herself up for the F3 better than Ami did before it all blew up. If Ami and Julie, who made the same big mistake that Leann made is in the running, I say Leann should be too. |
||
|
solesurvivor01 |
|||
|
Posts: 2433 (09/27/08 10:13 PM) Registered user |
kenc333 wrote:Fair enough :) She's definitely far from the top of this list, but she makes the cut IMHO. |
||
|
solesurvivor01 |
|||
|
Posts: 2434 (09/27/08 10:18 PM) Registered user |
Quiddity wrote:I actually had Leann there, originally, but the main reason I took her down was she was the one who caused the estrogen alliance to blow up. It was her, not Ami, who told Scout that she was no longer part of the core four. It was Leann who decided to boot Eliza, without realizing that Eliza could turn on her. I think everyone here knows that I may be biased a bit (see avatar), but IMHO Leann blew it all up. As for controlling the lesbo alliance, it's quite possible she had a much bigger role than shown. In fact, it would surprise me if she didn't. The way I see it, Ami was controlling the alliance, but Leann had a very strong influence on Ami. |
||
|
LKMOSCAR |
|||
|
Posts: 4572 (09/27/08 10:23 PM) Registered user |
Dr Will Hatch two point oh wrote:Hell yeah she did! |
||
|
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 5109 (09/27/08 10:28 PM) Registered user |
OOO, post a link, I missed alternate reality Survivor
|
||
|
Micronesia Princess |
|||
|
Posts: 747 (09/27/08 11:21 PM) |
solesurvivor01 wrote:Leann does not deserve to be there for sure. Cassandra does |
||
|
kishuu |
|||
|
Posts: 282 (09/28/08 12:36 AM) |
Christy was by far the worst player in Amazon amongst the Jury+F2, removal pls.
I say no to PI Rupert. He didn't do much, if you put him in, I have to say you have to put Trish in. She's the one who knew a possibility of Rupert flipping. So by putting PI Rupert in, you're effectively allowing most of the PI cast to be included based on the fact they were better as players than him. Also, Colleen is a pretty ridiculous choice for the list. it's obvious that she'll rank high because of popularity. Kelly G is undoubtedly, a good choice. She won't rank high imo, bottom few would be good for her. She knew that she had to flip. Lex outright told her 'Like hey, you're gone cause I think you voted for me' so she did what she had to do, which was flip. She wasn't close to Frank or Brandon, so she went to Kim P and Teresa. They rallied up old Samburu but Brandon screwed up. Ultimately, it was pretty much out of her hands because Brandon wanted to be Lex's bitch. |
||
