I haven't done finale ratings yet. I will post them ASAP.
Still not able to concentrate long. Averaging 3 hours of sleep per day for days is taxing. Hopefully not much longer, or I'll just make up for it while driving or something.
Wallduck said, "Edgic is prejudiced in favor of CPs. When you have to go looking for the best available CP, as we did with Ken, it may be a sign that the winner is not CP. "
Hmmm. A complex character can easily slide into most of the guidelines early, so one could say it is less prejudiced than predisposed to consider said character. It's like deciding who to pick first in a pickem basketball game and choosing the tallest player. It's always harder to see the 6 foot point guard who can dunk than the 7'3" center. When would Kenny and/or Matty and/or Marcus have looked like a worse choice than Bob throughout the season? Examing how to give that a clear answer would be something to shoot for. Instead of trying to call Bob a total anomaly, then like Danni before him, we should figure out what he did that does fit and examine that.
Separate subject, I actually would like to see two things occur, only one of which might. I'd like to see a separate forum for Edgic. I understand it won't really happen, been asked ad nauseum. But if the admins really would want Edgic to not engulf spec so much, that's one way to do it. And second, I actually wouldn't mind seeing a separate thread based on theme. It alone doesn't really work in Edgic, I feel deep down.
And before anyone gets upset, check out the end of the Vanuatu thread and the beginning of Palau. KQ asked me to watch "storylines", a nice way of saying "themes", and I tried. I made up tons of ideas for Palau. But I used pure Edgic to see Tom, despite him pushing some boundaries, because it became clear much more quickly. Themes help write a weekly column about the show, but I don't think I could use them to tie a season together, with any degree of certainty, until it was over.
But I suck, so there.
Might seem a strange callout, given some others' dislike of him, but to RVS, I saw you in the last week actually giving analysis of the editing to make points. It went awry with Sugar, as I went awry, so not putting you down, but wasn't it fun to actually analyze the show's edit? You didn't worry about putting down your own ideas for discussion. That's all that's done here, really. Maybe I'm Neville Chamberlain, but why not actually try it. You have an affinity to do so. Drop the condescension of any idea opposed to yours and you'll even look prettier than Oo. (That was in fun, Oo, in case...) I mean it. I ask anyone, why not just play.
Michael













hen in the Course of human events it
becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another and to assume among the powers of the earth, the
separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they
should declare the causes which impel them to the separation.

