Yuku free message boards

Hello everyone, I'm new to edgic but it looks fun and I feel like giving it a try. Here's hoping I did this right.

EPISODE 1:
Ace - CPN4 - The negativity was reinforced by both Paloma and Charlie who talked about how Ace's leadership style was rubbing them the wrong way. CP for his confessional about his leadership ability.
Bob - OTTP3 - Got positive reinforcement from just about everyone in the tribe. I was tempted to give him CPP for this episode but it was mostly about him just being the eternal boy scout.
Charlie - MOR3 - Escaped OTT just because of the first confessional about "stupid Survivor" for Crystal picking Susie. Pretty toneless here.
Corinne - UTR2 - Talked about wanting to be the bitch but then gave positive SPV to Bob. Pretty hidden on this episode.
Jacquie - INV - Nothing here.
Kelly - INV - Nothing here either
Marcus - MOR3 - We got set up about an alliance to try to let Ace crash and burn, but this was just the set up and there was no complexity behind this. Also a little bit of negativity about going to the top of the hill first, but because his tribe still won, it was basically erased.
Paloma - UTR2 - She's annoyed at Ace and laughs about yoga. Thats pretty much all we know.
Sugar - UTR1 - There's really animals out there.

Crystal - MORP3 - Almost a CP but I feel like she just fell short here. I gave her P because she was given a confessional after the challenge to defend why an athlete had trouble with the hill.
Dan - UTR2 - Always around the action here and he talked a lot in camp but he was pretty much hidden.
GC - MORM4 - Took a break in the challenge, selfishly went up to the top of the hill first even though his tribe was struggling, but then was positively shown when he was elected as the leader at TC.
Gillian - OTTN5 - The OTT is for her "positive" attitude being shoved down our throats and Randy and Probst said it best that she just took the whole always stay positive and never give up schtick and went WAAAY too far with it. There was enough N SPV about both her challenge ability and attitude that I think it warrants an N.
Ken - OTTP4 - For Ken, this whole episode was about his feelings towards Michelle whether it be about her as a hot girl in Africa or as a possible alliance partner which is why I gave him the OTT. The P is for him being the loveable underdog.
Matty - MOR3 - He made enough of an impression for MOR, methinks.
Michelle - OTTN5 - Michelle hates her tribe besides Ken was what we saw of her.
Randy - CP5 - Though all he really did was narration, I think we got inside his head enough to warrant the CP.
Susie - UTR1 - There was something there but not much.

EPISODE 2:
Ace - INV - Nothing
Bob - UTRP1 - Even when he doesnt speak he still gets P SPV from the Onion 4.
Charlie - MOR3 - Both episodes he came dangerously close to OTT but the editors are giving him just enough confessionals not on Marcus to avoid it.
Corinne - MOR2 - I can see UTR here but since her confessional was about strategy, I went with MOR.
Jacquie - UTR2 - Part of the Onion 4 but seemingly the least important one since she didnt get a confessional about it. She did get a confessional where she said she thinks the tribe will never lose.
Kelly - INV - Who?
Marcus - CP3 - Everyone will remember the onion analogy, awesome edit for him here.
Paloma - INV - Nothing
Sugar - INV - Nothing

Crystal - MOR3 - No real tone here.
Dan - CP5 - I was having a hard time with tone here but in the end I went with neutral just because I didnt think there was strong enough evidence for P or N.
GC - CPM5 - N for being a horrible leader and not listening to the tribe, P for the positive scene at the end where Fang may have got it together, CP because we heard enough from him at the end to make him not one-note.
Gillian - MOR4 - She at least showed some semblance of strategy before she left but definitely not enough for a CP.
Ken - UTR2 - For someone to get a vote and be this hidden makes him definitely UTR in my mind.
Matty - UTR2 - Again, he's seen in the action a lot but he's always in a big group.
Randy - MOR3 - He's still in the narration mode about aspects of camp but he is giving his viewpoints on it too. This was not enough for a CP by any means though.
Susie - MOR2 - Had that scene with Gillian about who to vote for which elevated her to MOR in my mind.

Winners Picks:
1. Marcus - He's really getting a great edit for a winner that it almost seems too perfect.
2. Crystal - She was able to defend herself after failing at the challenge and got no N SPV for that. Two pretty good episodes
3. Corinne - Needs development and may be a longshot but still I can see something in her.

Not out of it yet: Dan, Matty, Randy

Probably not: Bob, Charlie, GC, Ken

Eliminated: Ace, Jacquie, Kelly, Paloma, Sugar, Susie