| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 iToons |
|||
|
Posts: 70 (04/23/09 12:37 AM) |
Michelle sucks, Keesha sucks, so does April, Libra, and Renny.
I hope there is never an AS2, the first one sucked enough to leave me not wanting to see another one. |
||
|
Redmond |
|||
|
Posts: 235 (04/23/09 8:14 AM) |
SSerenaSS wrote:Big Brother is not a team game, Fans v Faves does not make sense. If Dick and Daniele were back in together I don't think they'd stand a chance of making it to the end game, not together anyway. Chilltown did but Chilltown had Dr Will. Dick and Daniele strategy wise were useless and had no self-awareness...They were best buds with fucking Amber those first three or so weeks for Christ's sake! They were good in challenges, especially Daniele, so they could make it fairly far on that basis, but I don't think they'd make it to the end game together. Like I've said before, you've got to remember there is potentially three more seasons before the next All-Stars, they could be plenty of better players introduced in those seasons that could run rings around Dick and Daniele. Dan from BB10 would run rings around them, although he'll have a pretty big target on his back because he is the best overall player since Dr Will. |
||
|
Emcee Batley |
|||
|
Posts: 425 (04/23/09 12:36 PM) |
Why bring back Michelle when you can have Seahag? If any female other than Keesha were to get picked from BB10 it would be Libra.
|
||
|
pushingjate |
|||
|
Posts: 2792 (04/23/09 2:22 PM) |
danisucksit wrote:  Sheila fan or not, the bitch was horrible at the game. She'd be a F3 goat for the second time in a row. I really wouldn't want to
watch that. and X to Dick/James.
|
||
|
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
|
Posts: 2418 (04/23/09 5:13 PM) |
If it is Fans vs. Favs then they would probably pick the Fan Favorites from each season.
Favs - 7 Big Brother 7 - Kaysar/Will & Janelle Big Brother 8 - Dick? (was voted by America between him and Daniele) Big Brother 9 - Alex (voted back in by America) and James (won America's Favorite on Jury) Big Brother 10 - Keesha (America's Favorite on Jury) & Angie (people seem to like her for some reason) |
||
|
pushingjate |
|||
|
Posts: 2795 (04/23/09 6:18 PM) |
AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: Oh fuck you. Dan was the most popular from BB10. Don't get it twisted. |
||
|
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
|
Posts: 2424 (04/23/09 7:45 PM) |
pushingjate wrote: They wouldn't cast 5 guys and 2 girls as favs. Which other female from Big Brother 7 til now can be considered a fan favorite besides Keesha, Angie, and Janelle. I also don't think Dan would play again. |
||
|
Emcee Batley |
|||
|
Posts: 433 (04/23/09 10:33 PM) |
If it was ever Fans vs. Faves they would do: Dick, James, Dan and Daniele, Sheila, and Keesha. If they were to ever pick a seventh my guess would probably be
either Eric, Adam, or Renny....
But they would never do half and half, there are too many great All-Stars, even just for the first three Post-AS seasons. The first AS was a success (minus the final two.) I mean on no other AS program could you get Will, Boogie, Janelle, and Danielle to make the final six (along with the great and entertaining Chicken George). The only true moot point was Erika. What a bore/season ruiner. |
||
|
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
|
Posts: 2446 (04/23/09 11:49 PM) |
Emcee Batley wrote: I don't think they would pick Adam after the retard comments and Eric wasn't especially well liked by America. Renny might come back but that would be 3 people from season 10. I can see Janelle coming back for real. |
||
|
Redmond |
|||
|
Posts: 238 (04/24/09 12:50 PM) |
Fans vs Faves just doesn't make sense, they wouldn't do it, Big Brother is not a team game and as Emcee Batley said, there are too many great All-Star
candidates to waste half of the cast on 'fans'.
I don't want to see Janelle again or Kaysar or anyone that was in the first All-Stars, as much as I love Will, that includes him too. I wouldn't mind them bringing back some pre-All-Star housemates that didn't get to compete in the first AS, perhaps Nicole, Amy, Roddy and Jun. The only housemates I think are a lock for a second AS are Dick and Dan. Most likely's would include Jen, Daniele, Eric, Crazy James, Natalie. Possiblies would include Jessica, Sheila, Renny, Keesha, Memphis, Adam, Chelsia. |
||
|
pushingjate |
|||
|
Posts: 2810 (04/24/09 12:58 PM) |
AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: While Eric wasn't well liked by America, I think he auto gets in so he can play the game for himself this time. |
||
|
SSerenaSS |
|||
|
Posts: 252 (04/24/09 6:22 PM) |
Redmond wrote: Who said it had to be a team game? I said Fans and Faves not FANS vs. FAVES although it might turn out to be like that anyway. I was just saying that concept because there is no way in hell that they'd do another All-Stars again. The first All-Stars was a big headache for the producers and to get some of their big names came with so many prices and attachments. (Like Will not doing it unless Boogie was in and Danielle saying that she will only participate if she got in 100% regardless of votes). The simplest way to get around this is get 7 faves and 7 big fans of the show and have them go at it. |
||
|
SSerenaSS |
|||
|
Posts: 253 (04/24/09 6:28 PM) |
Redmond wrote: There will never, ever, ever, ever be another All-Stars. All-Stars was a failure on so many levels and the ratings were not high at all and it costs alot more money this time around. And at there being too many great All Star contestants. And your list is pathetic. Jessicunt? Sheila? Memphis? Chelisa?
What the hell did they do. Even Adam, Renny and whiny Daniele weren't all that interesting besides having occasionally good DR's (not to me though).
The only reason they did All-Stars to begin with because it followed the popularity of Season 6. Survivor did fans and faves, and it worked after the failure
that was the original All-Stars. I'm pretty positive that they'd do this concept over a full out All-Stars EVER again.
|
||
|
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
|
Posts: 2465 (04/24/09 7:56 PM) |
pushingjate wrote:Why call it Fans vs. Favorites then? I think Eric was ranked the lowest for his season. Even Carol was above him. |
||
|
Emcee Batley |
|||
|
Posts: 451 (04/24/09 9:07 PM) |
SSerenaSS wrote:Please bet your life on it, Grodner has already stated before on House Calls that an AS2 is way more than likely, infact she said she'd love the idea of New Stars vs. Old Stars. |
||
|
Spanky Hot Dog |
|||
|
Posts: 2775 (04/24/09 9:07 PM) |
No third-timers please. Even though I liked a lot of the people from All Stars.
|
||
|
Emcee Batley |
|||
|
Posts: 452 (04/24/09 9:09 PM) |
I wouldn't mind one or two people from Pre-AS like Marvin or Jun or or Will Mega or Roddy. But they pretty much nailed everyone deserving the first time
for the Top 20.
|
||
|
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
|
Posts: 2469 (04/24/09 9:41 PM) |
Big Brother woucl be 2 people from each season (minus the first Big Brother) to return. No 3rd timers
Big Brother 2 - Hardy & Monica Big Brother 3 - Amy & Lori (I dont' see Jason wanting to return) Big Brother 4 - Jun & Nathan Big Brother 5 - Holly & Will Big Brother 6 - Rachel & Sarah?? Big Brother 7 - N/A Big Brother 8 - Daniele & Dick Big Brother 9 - Crazy James & Alex Big Brother 10 - Keesha & Memphis |
||
|
CAPSattack |
|||
|
Posts: 1881 (04/24/09 10:43 PM) |
ew fuck rachel/memphis/nathan/crazy james
replace them with ivette/libra/jee/alex |
||
|
Emcee Batley |
|||
|
Posts: 459 (04/24/09 11:26 PM) |
If you did another All-Stars today I'd think the best Top 20 would be:
Big Brother 1: Will Mega Big Brother 2: Nicole, Monica Big Brother 3: Amy, Jason Big Brother 4: Jun, Jack Big Brother 5: Cowboy, Marvin Big Brother 6: Rachel Big Brother 8: Dick, Daniele, Jen, Eric Big Brother 9: Adam, Sheila, James Big Brother 10: Dan, Renny, Libra |
||
