Louie77's Ranking of Every Winner Ever!!!! (200-1 are up)

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
Kitty Pryde1		#641	[-]
Posts: 5314 (08/10/08 3:53 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	What are the top fifteen shows? BB8, BB9, AR10, AR12, AI5, ???
WylDawg		#642	[-]
Posts: 15961 (08/10/08 8:18 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I have always felt that he has invented the way the game is played and if it wasn't for him, what we know as Survivor now might be completely different and it would reward the people who are best at surviving. Ironically, that would mean people like Rupert and Matt winning thier respective seasons. I'm sure you'd hate that. But yes, thank God the show doesn't work that way.
finishthemoff		#643	[-]
Posts: 9390 (08/10/08 9:42 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	People WILL still make alliance. It is a common sense.
craig		#644	[-]
Posts: 13682 (08/10/08 9:55 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	What separates Earl from guys like Aras or Pirate Ben? Earl's tribe lost a ton of challenges like Ulong at the beginning Earl was never was especially the mastermind, Erika was taken out against his wishes ep.2 Then he gets LUCKY in the switch, and ever more lucky that the dumbasses in the other tribe alienated the 2 blacks but didn't boot them. It's a no-bnrainer for Cassie to allign with Earl, and her relationship with Dreamz is the key to getting him to betray the Horsemen. And it's Stacy brilliant idea to target Edgardo. Ay F6, Earl tells YM don't worry, your're safe, and he isn't playing Yao. But Yao figures out he is being targeted and uses the idol. After that Dreamz and Casssien can't win, so they play for a black person to win. Earl is lucky that YM was color-blind but Dreamz wasn't. Bottom line - Earl won 0 challenegs and didn't make any great strategic moves.
PanamanianDevil		#645	[-]
Posts: 545 (08/10/08 10:34 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: What separates Earl from guys like Aras or Pirate Ben? Earl's tribe lost a ton of challenges like Ulong at the beginning Earl was never was especially the mastermind, Erika was taken out against his wishes ep.2 Then he gets LUCKY in the switch, and ever more lucky that the dumbasses in the other tribe alienated the 2 blacks but didn't boot them. It's a no-bnrainer for Cassie to allign with Earl, and her relationship with Dreamz is the key to getting him to betray the Horsemen. And it's Stacy brilliant idea to target Edgardo. Ay F6, Earl tells YM don't worry, your're safe, and he isn't playing Yao. But Yao figures out he is being targeted and uses the idol. After that Dreamz and Casssien can't win, so they play for a black person to win. Earl is lucky that YM was color-blind but Dreamz wasn't. Bottom line - Earl won 0 challenegs and didn't make any great strategic moves. I think he's survived the most tribal councils of any of the winners. That says a lot about his strategic ability
Mister Plum		#646	[-]
Posts: 3153 (08/10/08 10:46 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: What separates Earl from guys like Aras or Pirate Ben? Earl's tribe lost a ton of challenges like Ulong at the beginning Earl was never was especially the mastermind, Erika was taken out against his wishes ep.2 Then he gets LUCKY in the switch, and ever more lucky that the dumbasses in the other tribe alienated the 2 blacks but didn't boot them. It's a no-bnrainer for Cassie to allign with Earl, and her relationship with Dreamz is the key to getting him to betray the Horsemen. And it's Stacy brilliant idea to target Edgardo. Ay F6, Earl tells YM don't worry, your're safe, and he isn't playing Yao. But Yao figures out he is being targeted and uses the idol. After that Dreamz and Casssien can't win, so they play for a black person to win. Earl is lucky that YM was color-blind but Dreamz wasn't. Bottom line - Earl won 0 challenegs and didn't make any great strategic moves. You made a good point but I think trusting Yauman is already a great strategic move.
finishthemoff		#647	[-]
Posts: 9403 (08/10/08 10:59 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	PanamanianDevil wrote: craig wrote: What separates Earl from guys like Aras or Pirate Ben? Earl's tribe lost a ton of challenges like Ulong at the beginning Earl was never was especially the mastermind, Erika was taken out against his wishes ep.2 Then he gets LUCKY in the switch, and ever more lucky that the dumbasses in the other tribe alienated the 2 blacks but didn't boot them. It's a no-bnrainer for Cassie to allign with Earl, and her relationship with Dreamz is the key to getting him to betray the Horsemen. And it's Stacy brilliant idea to target Edgardo. Ay F6, Earl tells YM don't worry, your're safe, and he isn't playing Yao. But Yao figures out he is being targeted and uses the idol. After that Dreamz and Casssien can't win, so they play for a black person to win. Earl is lucky that YM was color-blind but Dreamz wasn't. Bottom line - Earl won 0 challenegs and didn't make any great strategic moves. I think he's survived the most tribal councils of any of the winners. That says a lot about his strategic ability Bullshit. Vee did.
finishthemoff		#648	[-]
Posts: 9404 (08/10/08 11:00 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: What separates Earl from guys like Aras or Pirate Ben? Earl's tribe lost a ton of challenges like Ulong at the beginning Earl was never was especially the mastermind, Erika was taken out against his wishes ep.2 Then he gets LUCKY in the switch, and ever more lucky that the dumbasses in the other tribe alienated the 2 blacks but didn't boot them. It's a no-bnrainer for Cassie to allign with Earl, and her relationship with Dreamz is the key to getting him to betray the Horsemen. And it's Stacy brilliant idea to target Edgardo. Ay F6, Earl tells YM don't worry, your're safe, and he isn't playing Yao. But Yao figures out he is being targeted and uses the idol. After that Dreamz and Casssien can't win, so they play for a black person to win. Earl is lucky that YM was color-blind but Dreamz wasn't. Bottom line - Earl won 0 challenegs and didn't make any great strategic moves. Pretty much true, but you need to mentions that the fact that Yau-Man actually alienated Sylvia and possible Asian castaways. I'm just SHOCKED how Latin castaways self-destruct even worse than CI. Shocked! I never think Earl is a horrible winner, but he WOULD HAVE NOT WON IF IT IS FINAL TWO! He is a girly man!
Dyke Cruser		#649	[-]
Posts: 1546 (08/10/08 11:06 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	finishthemoff wrote: I never think Earl is a horrible winner, but he WOULD HAVE NOT WON IF IT IS FINAL TWO! He is a girly man! Spoiler [+] It wasn't a final 2 anyway so it doesn't matter. Earl has a million bucks and you dont have anything.
finishthemoff		#650	[-]
Posts: 9407 (08/10/08 11:19 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The bottom line is... that only strengthen the case that Earl was carry to final four. He doesn't really do much to advance his game... and as much as I think Yul is grossly overrated... Yul did more with the plan even though I still believes that dumbass twists saved Yul more than anything else. The lameass switch also saved Earl. So you add NOTHING to the table. Nothing.
Mister Plum		#651	[-]
Posts: 3155 (08/10/08 11:23 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	That's the game. There will be twists and it's either beneficial to you or not. One of the twists Earl had to face is the Have Nots twist, is he lucky? We can Yes because he can use it in his Final Speech but it's still disadvantageous for him for obvious reasons. For Yul, the Mutiny twist is also not advantageous for him because it screwed his tribe but because of their will to win, they succeed. I hate the Aitu 4 though.
finishthemoff		#652	[-]
Posts: 9410 (08/10/08 11:25 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The mutiny twist actually favors Yul as they allowed a dominating swimmer to go in twice while Rotu could never figure out how to keep their best players (rebecca last wayyy too long when there are stronger JP and Brad to be kept around) for a long-term. I can only speculate what happens if Ozzy mutiny and not Jonathan and Candice. Last Edited By: finishthemoff 08/10/08 11:28 PM. Edited 1 times.
Mister Plum		#653	[-]
Posts: 3156 (08/10/08 11:30 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	finishthemoff wrote: The mutiny twist actually favors Yul as they allowed a dominating swimmer to go in twice while Rotu could never figure out how to keep their best players (rebecca last wayyy too long when there are stronger JP and Brad to be kept around) for a long-term. I can only speculate what happens if Ozzy mutiny and not Jonathan and Candice.
oh ehm gee		#654	[-]
Posts: 1235 (08/11/08 7:32 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	A F2 in Fiji would've been amazing.
CatLurvesDorothy		#655	[-]
Posts: 739 (08/11/08 7:46 AM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	oh ehm gee wrote: A F2 in Fiji would've been amazing. Cassandra defeating Dreamz? What a lovely finale that would've been.
oh ehm gee		#656	[-]
Posts: 1236 (08/11/08 8:22 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CatLurvesDorothy wrote: oh ehm gee wrote: A F2 in Fiji would've been amazing. Cassandra defeating Dreamz? What a lovely finale that would've been. Even with Earl there the jury was bitter. How would they act without an obvious choice?
CatLurvesDorothy		#657	[-]
Posts: 740 (08/11/08 8:42 AM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	oh ehm gee wrote: CatLurvesDorothy wrote: oh ehm gee wrote: A F2 in Fiji would've been amazing. Cassandra defeating Dreamz? What a lovely finale that would've been. Even with Earl there the jury was bitter. How would they act without an obvious choice? Definitely in an interesting way, although I see Cassandra winning due to more of the bitterness being against Dreamz.
WylDawg		#658	[-]
Posts: 15962 (08/11/08 8:54 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: What separates Earl from guys like Aras or Pirate Ben? Earl's tribe lost a ton of challenges like Ulong at the beginning Earl was never was especially the mastermind, Erika was taken out against his wishes ep.2 Then he gets LUCKY in the switch, and ever more lucky that the dumbasses in the other tribe alienated the 2 blacks but didn't boot them. It's a no-bnrainer for Cassie to allign with Earl, and her relationship with Dreamz is the key to getting him to betray the Horsemen. And it's Stacy brilliant idea to target Edgardo. Ay F6, Earl tells YM don't worry, your're safe, and he isn't playing Yao. But Yao figures out he is being targeted and uses the idol. After that Dreamz and Casssien can't win, so they play for a black person to win. Earl is lucky that YM was color-blind but Dreamz wasn't. Bottom line - Earl won 0 challenegs and didn't make any great strategic moves. Just like Morasca was strung along by Heidi and Deena and then lost all her power at F7 at the hands of a computer nerd and had to rely on Heidi trying to convince the deaf girl that she shat on and then when that didn't work, she had to rely on immunity. But we never see you bringing that up.
ZombieLinda		#659	[-]
Posts: 4736 (08/11/08 9:28 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If the producers didn't rig it and clue Yau-Man in about being voted off in the f6, we would have had the glorious most unlikable f3 ever of Cassandra, Stacy, and Dreamz. <33333
Mister Plum		#660	[-]
Posts: 3164 (08/11/08 9:33 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I disheart riggedness. I hope there's no riggedness on Survivor.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Louie77's Ranking of Every Winner Ever!!!! (200-1 are up)

Quick Reply