| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
guatemala fanfic |
|||
|
Great Early Show preview. I'm going to guess that Dave goes very far by playing one of the most improved games. Most of the people who had a confessional
will probably go far. There's a couple who I think might go early but I'll wait to see Jeff's thoughts before I speculate too much.
|
|||
island sun |
|||
CirieFieldsofDreams wrote: A lot of people are liking Tracy. I can certainly see why, though.
|
|||
island sun |
|||
guatemala fanfic wrote: Interesting speculation. I'm sure you'll have more after Jeff's thoughts too. By the way, I think I'm going to hold on posting those until tomorrow, just to stay on my intended schedule. |
|||
unduli clone |
|||
|
1st boot = Tracy Dave, Ashley, Erika F3, Erika wins. PLEASE. |
|||
island sun |
|||
unduli clone wrote: I guess you'll have to read and find out ;) |
|||
Lurlene McDaniels |
|||
|
I'm disapointed that Melissa McNulty isn't in it!
|
|||
guatemala fanfic |
|||
I'm disapointed that Melissa McNulty isn't in it!Not to highjack your thread (sorry), but I just wanted to say something to this: I considered putting her in my cast of original contestants, and back when I was writing my Fiji fanfic, I considered including her in that story but thought it might be too awkward. |
|||
Lurlene McDaniels |
|||
|
Ah, that would have been cool! I've considered putting her in a fanfic before too but I think she'd just end up way OTT (and likely quit or be voted
out early after having some meltdown).
|
|||
island sun |
|||
|
It would kind of mess with the "second chance" idea, considering Melissa didn't really have a first chance. She was given one, I suppose,
but...like gf said, it'd be awkward.
Good to know you're a Wanda fan! I hope everybody has at least one fan. I'm sure I'll find out soon when I open up the popularity poll (tomorrow, btw). |
|||
Brazil Luvs Ami |
|||
|
island sun, I love your cast choice, but I think you should have put Amy from Guatemala, she really deserves another chance, more than Ashley!!!
|
|||
island sun |
|||
Brazil Luvs Ami wrote: I'll go into this a little more tomorrow after Probst's thoughts because a little is explained in there. Amy was definitely considered, though. |
|||
hippo2002 |
|||
|
Misty Angie Aron Tracy FTW!!!
|
|||
Syoma |
|||
|
Angie and Tracy love!
Hoping CBS will be reading this and decide to do the real thing. |
|||
island sun |
|||
Syoma wrote: Wouldn't that be something!
|
|||
VBeauregarde |
|||
|
I hope Tracy wins in both the fanfics here
|
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
|
Yay for Erica! I hope she lasts the merge this time!
|
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
|
Another post but longer:
Aaron - He did get screwed in China but wasn't all that entertaining. Angie - I like her. She is a very good female cast member. Brook - He's a fan of the show so I am sure he can work something out. Cao Boi - Yes! He has to be included in this. I don't care if he is the first boot he will still be entertaining. Erica - My favourite as of now. I liked her in Fiji and I hope you can make her a character :) James - I love this guy! Red necks for the win! Leslie - As Gf's fanfic proved she can make it to the end so I think she will this time. Misty - She is smart, so hopefully she can use that strategy and not the flirty strategy. Anthony - I am very excited to see him. I liked him in Fiji so hopefully he won't let me down. Ashley - She's tough. But Dave's there too. Brian - Well, he can either go really far or be the first one out. I hope he doesn't over think anything this time. Dave - He's a worker, but Ashley's there too. Jeff - I don't know about him. I think he is the most boring one there. Tina - Yes! I love her. She's tough and she needs to make it far this time! Tracy - Very glad she's there. Definitely the best fan. Wanda - I want to see how she plays this time. It will be interesting. Now on the seasons: Vanuatu: Brook (Definitely a good male cast, I would've liked to see Rory but you know Brook never got a chance) Palau: James, Wanda, Jeff, Angie (The only one that I don't like is Jeff but there aren't many good replacements, I would've like to see Jolanda) Guatemala: Brian (Flawless choice) Exile Island: Misty, Tina (Both good female choices for the pre-merge females of Exile Island) Cook Islands: Cao Boi (Very good choice) Fiji: Erica, Anthony (I like both of them so it's very good) China: Ashley, Dave, Leslie, Aaron (I would've liked to see Sherea but she's in GF fanfic so I understand that. Chicken would've been nice) Micronesia: Tracy (Best choice. Kathleen was a good choice but if you had to pick one it had to be Tracy) Very good choices. I can't wait to read. |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
I would've swapped Aaron for Bobdawg, just to even up the seasons a little bit. And swap Jeff with maybe Brady.
|
|||
Brazil Luvs Ami |
|||
|
I just missed Amy and Sylvia...
|
|||
island sun |
|||
|
Thanks to everyone for replying!
YemaGrl1988, I loved reading your thoughts on the cast, and intresting predictions as well. Overall, I am very satisfied with my choices. I knew there'd be a few "___ was robbed!" repsonses, but I'm happy with the decisons I made. I was a little worried about balancing the seasons more, but I think things turned out fine, even with Palau and China being higher in number. Bobby and Brady didn't really make strong impressions on me when I watched them the first time. Sylivia and Amy were contenders, but I later decided not to include either. I'll be posting Jeff's Thoughts in a few minutes, and then I'll open up the popularity poll so you can all vote for your favorites. Stay tuned... |
|||