| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
lucky wench |
Carly's Legs | ||
|
What's up with Carly's legs? I finally put it together watching the finale that she always wears pitch black hose/tights with dresses/skirts. Are her
legs as heavily tattooed as her one arm? My husband thinks she must have a giant schlong inked down one leg. That or she has hideous varicose veins or
something.
|
|||
Drew B |
|||
Screerider wrote:And wouldn't Seacrest's comment that they left too soon really was an insult to those who stayed longer, and to the voting fans of those that stayed longer. Bascally saying, "Why'd you idiots vote for Cook (or other)? He sucks compared to Carly and Michael!"
X |
|||
NiceToAnimals |
|||
|
It definitely was a strange comment by Seacrest, one that I actually agree with, but still it's surprising he'd say it. Michael should have stayed one
more week, so he didn't go THAT early, but Carly should have outlasted Brooke and Castro, IMO.
|
|||
Drew B |
|||
|
Carly never should have made the finals, IMO. Kady, Alexandrea & Alaina >>>>>>> Carly
You're correct about Castro lasting longer than he should have, though. |
|||
NiceToAnimals |
|||
Drew B wrote: Seriously?????
|
|||
Drew B |
|||
NiceToAnimals wrote:
Yes. For what it's worth, Colton, Danny & Luke are also >>>>>>>>> Carly. Shit, after that trainwreck on Wednesday, I'm tempted to say William Hung >>>>> Carly |
|||
NiceToAnimals |
|||
|
Um, OK, then...
|
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Carly has said she doesn't have any tattoos on her legs. She thinks tattoos on legs aren't a good look for women.
I think she's just self conscious and doesn't want to show off her legs because she thinks they're fat or ugly or something. |
|||
love like a bomb |
|||
|
Michael: YES
Carly: NO |
|||
8trackmind |
|||
|
Secrest actually got something right for once, as people said. They WERE both voted off too early. Having said that, the duet was awful. Michael was fine but
Carly's voice is all wrong for duets. As for Carly wearing tight hose or whatever, she does it for a good reason. I saw a photo posted on the Carly hate
thread around top 10 week and her thighs are big. Sucksters would have a field day calling her "fat" if most of them had seen it (plenty did anyway,
of course) so it's just as well she always wore pants.
|
|||
Lobsters |
|||
|
Yes, I agree they were both gone too early.
Carly probably should have left 3 or 4. And I'll firmly believe that Michael Johns should have been standing next to David Cook on finale night. To me, THEY were the best, most versatile singers in the comp. Just my opinion though. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
|
Michael may have had the talent to be a contender, but he didn't deliver at least 75% of the time. He was completely unmemorable and seemed bored
throughout the semis. Then, in the finals, he alternated between really good and really bad performances. There was no consistency.
|
|||
Lobsters |
|||
|
Well, I never thought his performances were that bad. He should have definitely outlasted Kristy, and probably Jason and Brooke as well at the VERY least.
All three of them had some really klunker performances and while Michael didn't always do his best, he didn't have a TERRIBLE performance. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
|
AI doesn't always work as a direct comparison, though. Michael set up huge expectations with his audition and his "Bohemian Rhapsody" in
Hollywood. After that, he continually disappointed. Kristy Lee sucked pretty consistently, then started getting better. I'm not surprised that she would
inspire fans to vote more than Michael did.
Brooke built up a lot of good will in the semis and the first week of the finals. It wasn't until top 11 that she started sucking. By then, she had garnered a strong fan base. I'm not surprised that fans would vote for her more than for Michael. Jason, I don't understand at all. Michael clearly should have outlasted him... |
|||
VBeauregarde |
|||
|
Michael and Brooke suck
|
|||