All Seasons Popularity Poll -- DONE :) ty all, discuss results away

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
9RedWing19		#801	[-]
Posts: 2207 (08/03/08 8:43 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Dictatorship wrote: I can't remember if I voted, but I'd definitely give Darrah a 10 and Crackhead bitch a 0. You didn't vote for any of the first eight seasons.
9RedWing19		#802	[-]
Posts: 2208 (08/03/08 8:45 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kitty Pryde1 wrote: People actually liked that garble-mouthed invisible bitch enough to make her rival Christa? Yep - and in case you hadn't noticed, the amount of screen-time contestants get is determined by the editors and not by the contestants. You may wish to take that into account should you continue contributing to the Edgic thread.
Kitty Pryde1		#803	[-]
Posts: 5161 (08/03/08 8:49 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I understand that. I understand that Darrah was still incoherent during the times when they decided to give her screentime.
Dictatorship		#804	[-]
Posts: 2977 (08/03/08 9:11 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	When was Darrah incomprehensible? I hear that all the time, but I don't think anyone can honestly say that they had trouble understanding her ever. I personally love the Southern accent and find it endearing.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#805	[-]
Posts: 4214 (08/03/08 9:12 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Not that it means anything, but I'm curious as to why this board has an overwhelming preference for females over males? It can't all be sexual in nature
chapera rocks		#806	[-]
Posts: 9580 (08/04/08 1:24 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Before I fix up the rest of that post, just pointing out the differences that 4 years made... I'll finish it up when I have time, but starting it off... The number is how the person changed from then to now. So ex: Sonja in 2008 is 55.278%, and in 2004 she was 57.253%, so she went down 1.975% and would thus be -1.975. +16.976 ~ Susan Hawk +16.746 ~ Stacey Stillman +12.764 ~ Richard Hatch +10.070 ~ Sean Kenniff +7.533 ~ Greg Buis +5.280 ~ Jenna Lewis +4.871 ~ Gervase Peterson +1.630 ~ Kelly Wigglesworth +0.566 ~ Rudy Boesch -1.511 ~ BB Andersen -1.975 ~ Sonja Christopher -2.192 ~ Gretchen Cordy -3.910 ~ Dirk Been -4.202 ~ Colleen Haskell -6.714 ~ Ramona Gray -9.441 ~ Joel Klug So Half the players in Borneo stayed within 5%, and the other half didn't. Surprisingly 4/7 to take a dip were women. Joel took the biggest hit, Sue got the largest gain. Jenna also looked to take a hit 4 years ago because ASS was fresh, but I guess people were willing to give her a chance for Borneo 4 years later. Rudy's almost exactly where he as then. +22.007 ~ Kimmi Kappenberg +19.921 ~ Jerri Manthey +13.599 ~ Jeff Varner +10.097 ~ Tina Wesson +9.345 ~ Amber Brkich +6.288 ~ Nick Brown +5.031 ~ Maralyn Hershey +4.701 ~ Elisabeth Filarski +4.222 ~ Alicia Calaway +4.154 ~ Mitchell Olsen +2.672 ~ Debb Eaton +2.057 ~ Rodger Bingham -0.582 ~ Michael Skupin -1.962 ~ Keith Famie -3.537 ~ Colby Donaldson -12.012 ~ Kel Gleason For Outback ... wow, a lot of people went up. And 4 guys went down. The Kel love wore off I suppose. Maybe most people went up because they appreciate the older seasons more? But people like Alicia, Tina, and Amber, especially, went up because the backlash from ASS has worn off a bit I think. Jerri takes a huge spike, probably because the hate has worn off. Surprisingly enough Kimmi has the biggest jump in numbers, didn't expect that, but I'm okay with it because I love Kimmi (upon rewatching the season + Commentary ... I HATED her so much during the original airing). We'll see if anyone can surpass Kimmi's numbers. Last Edited By: chapera rocks 08/04/08 1:48 PM. Edited 1 times.
limnThief		#807	[-]
Posts: 46 (08/05/08 5:07 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Thanks
tropical rain		#808	[-]
Posts: 61 (08/05/08 6:15 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	thank you chapera rocks, that was very interesting. most surprised to see that kimmi made the largest jump.
craig		#809	[-]
Posts: 13655 (08/06/08 8:22 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kimmi was always my fave Kucha, the only member of that tribe I really liked, so after her boot I was glad to see them go down. The most memorable scene ep.1-5 was "I can eat a worm" and Varner being an ass to Tina. Last Edited By: craig 08/06/08 8:26 AM. Edited 1 times.
9RedWing19	CR Poll - Summary	#810	[-]
Posts: 2209 (08/08/08 7:46 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I've finished copying the poll results into Excel to make it easier to do analysis & summaries. Doing some miscellaneous statistics first: There were 136 different posters that took part. 27 rated every season. Looking at the 27 that rated each season. The "Fanboy" award for the highest average rating (at 63.4%) goes to canthinkofaname. The "If You Hate the Contestants So Much, Why do You Watch the Show" award for the lowest average rating (at 33.0%) goes to n00b waiting 4 flaming wood. Defining a "Love" vote as 8, 9, or 10, and a "Hate" vote as 0, 1, or 2, there were just under 10% more hate votes than love votes. There was one contestant who did not receive a single love vote: Daniel from S6. Every contestant received at least one hate vote. 2 contestants received only one hate vote: one is not surprising (Sandra S7); one is likely more unexpected (Deena S6). Full Love / Hate / Polarizing results will follow shortly.
9RedWing19		#811	[-]
Posts: 2210 (08/08/08 8:05 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Here are the Love / Hate / Polarizing results, where a Love vote is 8, 9, or 10, a Hate vote is 0, 1, or 2, and a Polarizing vote is a Love or a Hate vote. Starting with the top 10 Love scores (no real surprises). Season Contestant % Love S12 Cirie - 77.1% S15 Courtney - 75.0% S7 Sandra - 72.7% S15 Peih-Gee - 72.7% S1 Colleen - 72.4% S4 Kathy - 71.4% S8 Shii Ann - 69.7% S16 Eliza - 69.3% S9 Eliza - 68.3% S3 Teresa - 68.3% Next, the top 10 Hate scores. S10 Jonathan cracking the top 5, given that he was on the show for all of 15 minutes, is odd. Season Contestant % Hate S7 Osten - 72.7% S15 Denise - 71.6% S6 Daniel - 71.2% S10 Jonathan - 68.3% S6 Roger - 65.2% S16 Joel - 63.6% S14 Dreamz - 60.0% S14 Mookie - 60.0% S14 Rocky - 57.1% S16 Chet - 55.7% S4 Zoe - 55.6% For the Polarizing results, I'll start with the top 10 simply using the sum of the Love and Hate votes. Season Contestant % Polarizing S12 Cirie - 87.1% S15 Courtney - 81.8% S9 Eliza - 81.7% S1 Colleen - 81.6% S16 Eliza - 80.7% S8 Shii Ann - 78.8% S15 Peih-Gee - 78.4% S14 Yau-Man - 77.1% S7 Osten - 75.8% S15 Denise - 75.0% S3 Teresa - 74.6% The problem here is that this parallels the Love vote. So, I re-did the results but to make the list a contestant had to have a minimum of 10% Love and Hate votes. Season Contestant % Polarizing S12 Cirie - 87.1% S9 Eliza - 81.7% S16 Eliza - 80.7% S14 Yau-Man - 77.1% S16 Cirie - 73.9% S14 Lisi - 71.4% S7 Jon - 71.2% S2 Elisabeth - 71.1% S13 Candice - 67.6% S14 Michelle - 67.1% This list is better, but still includes contestants such as Cirie that are not really what I consider to be Polarizing. So I re-did the results with a 15% minimum for Love and Hate votes. This time I've provided the top 15 and ties. Season Contestant % Polarizing S14 Lisi - 71.4% S7 Jon - 71.2% S13 Candice - 67.6% S13 Jonathan - 66.2% S2 Jerri - 64.5% S6 Heidi - 63.6% S6 Jenna - 63.6% S11 Stephenie - 63.4% S12 Shane - 62.9% S15 Todd - 62.5% S8 Rob M. - 62.1% S11 Judd - 62.0% S4 Sean - 61.9% S13 Parvati - 60.6% S9 Chris - 60.0% S10 Katie - 60.0% This list I think is more meaningful (though I am surprised that 15% of the posters loved Lisi). Finally, here is the top 10 for Least Polarizing contestants. Season Contestant % Polarizing S8 Ethan - 31.8% S9 Brady - 31.7% S14 Boo - 31.4% S12 Ruth Marie - 30.0% S12 Bruce - 30.0% S13 Cecilia - 29.6% S7 Nicole - 28.8% S13 Jessica - 26.8% S7 Michelle - 25.8% S7 Trish - 19.7% If there's any more data anyone would like to see, just post the request in this thread and I'll see what I can do.
Fei Long Dragon		#812	[-]
Posts: 190 (08/09/08 3:25 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	That's neat!
tropical rain		#813	[-]
Posts: 63 (08/09/08 7:00 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Thank you 9RedWing19 for doing this. I'm surprised yet not surprised about Jonathan (S10) being so hated. We knew he "worked hard", but we also knew he couldn't form many alliences and he also got into that arguement with Angie (more of a hero) at the reunion. That would probably make him a UTRN1 with a boring personality (if that), which Sucks doesn't approve of.
iluvbbsofun		#814	[-]
Posts: 210 (08/09/08 12:24 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	It had more to do with that he was a loser than that.
Jennabridges18		#815	[-]
Posts: 65 (08/09/08 2:57 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	wow good job on getting all the stats! i voted on this a few times for my favorite seasons, and i love that the women ruled this poll! Girl power! hahaha
Dictatorship		#816	[-]
Posts: 3120 (08/09/08 3:14 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The 15% minimum list is spot on for the most polarizing contestants IMO. Great work, CR and RedWing!
chapera rocks		#817	[-]
Posts: 9586 (08/10/08 1:05 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Great compilation, RW! Good stuff!
craig		#818	[-]
Posts: 13690 (08/12/08 1:02 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	One other thing I'd like to see is a list of the players with the most hate votes who scored above certain thesholds (75%, 70, 65, 60, 55, 50, 45, 40, 35, 30%), and the players with the most love votes who scored below certain thesholds.
dragoondaniel78		#819	[-]
Posts: 1254 (08/12/08 5:04 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'm extremely APPALLED that Candice took the top spot for Cook Islands. I absolutely HATE that idiotic bitch and I reserved my judgment till I watch the episode where she got voted out. What the fuck? She betrayed her alliance/friends from Aitu who trusted her and where she was in a power-position so that she could be with her "white friends"... She's so whiny and a crybaby is a more annoying flirt than Parvati and bitched at Jonathan for not sharing the food HE caught with them 3 Raro brats who are so fucking lazy in their fucking shelter. It has been a LONG time since I got so annoyed at one stupid character. And that goodbye kiss from Adam at her final TC...? Retarded. The only thing I felt CI gained from her was her repeated sending back to Exile Island where she apparently "suffered". That was just hilarious. So people... I'm curious. Why did you guys rate her up so high? If I were to rate her now, she'll probably get a 3 or 4 solely based on her pre-mutiny appearance where she was somewhat likable. Last Edited By: dragoondaniel78 08/12/08 5:13 AM. Edited 1 times.
9RedWing19		#820	[-]
Posts: 2211 (08/12/08 8:42 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: One other thing I'd like to see is a list of the players with the most hate votes who scored above certain thesholds (75%, 70, 65, 60, 55, 50, 45, 40, 35, 30%), and the players with the most love votes who scored below certain thesholds. Craig, just to be sure that I understand what you asking for: For all contestants whose score was >75%, identify who had the greatest percentage of Hate votes. Repeat for lower thresholds. If this is what you want, understand that the same contestant could "win" at more than one threshold (ie I checked - S9 Eliza has the highest hate vote percentage at both the 75% threshold, and the 70% threshold). So, let me know if that is what you want to see, or do you want a new contestant at each threshol?. Because of the different number of votes cast in each season, doing it by Love/Hate vote percentages is better than raw vote tallies. Caveat: my results are not identical to CR's (because of some combination of my transcription errors, his transcription errors, his excluding of certain voters (I did not exclude any votes)).

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

All Seasons Popularity Poll -- DONE :) ty all, discuss results away

Quick Reply