All Seasons Popularity Poll -- DONE :) ty all, discuss results away

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
DarrahColleenJerri		#781	[-]
Posts: 527 (07/29/08 1:07 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Amy meh? WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA????
YemaGrl1988		#782	[-]
Posts: 1311 (07/29/08 10:18 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Just because Amy didn't make the merge doesn't mean that she is a meh or nobody character. (Infact some would say she was a better character than Parvati...ha)
9RedWing19		#783	[-]
Posts: 2202 (07/29/08 12:28 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: Some we all know are polarizing like Jenna M, Rob M, and Parvati, Per some PMs between CR and myself, I'm uploading the votes into an Excel file, in order to do the counts more easily. As of now (July29th), I have the first 4 seasons complete. You need a minimum % for love and hate votes to do a meaningful polarizing count, because otherwise the most polarizing contestants are going to be the most loved ones (eg Colleen will be one of the most loved and most polarizing). I'm thinking of using a minimum 10% rule (which, after 4 seasons, would make Elizabeth F the most polarizing contestant at 71% (12% hate)). Surprisingly, RobM (S4 version) has a below average polarizing score. Also surprising, at least to me, is that after 4 seasons the least polarizing contestant is a tie between Sonja and Joel (the latter being the surprise).
doc		#784	[-]
Posts: 203 (07/29/08 1:42 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	How could anyone hate Coleen?
9RedWing19		#785	[-]
Posts: 2203 (07/29/08 2:54 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	doc wrote: How could anyone hate Coleen? 7 out of 76 voters did - scroll throught the first 4 or so pages to see who the "guilty" ones are.
doc		#786	[-]
Posts: 205 (07/29/08 8:23 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	That's like hating puppy dogs.
cantthinkofaname		#787	[-]
Posts: 1187 (07/29/08 9:27 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	exactly, puppies are loved by many, but not liked by a few.
DarrahColleenJerri		#788	[-]
Posts: 528 (07/30/08 12:43 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SHAME ON YOU: noon waiting 4 flaming wood mtj1282 SuperAgent Ari Gold Demonic Dan Barry The Killer Croc, and DA Harvey Dent Shame, shame, shame on you!
chapera rocks		#789	[-]
Posts: 9541 (07/30/08 12:45 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SuperAgent Ari Gold and Demonic Dan Barry weren't counted jsyk, since they are ghosties. Though since their ghostie owner didn't vote that week, I might have counted the first person to vote. I don't remember the other votes I didn't count, but there were 4 or 5 that round I think. Also want to thank RedWing for taking the time to do the extra stuff. I would have, but I just don't have the time, so I really appreciate him stepping up to the plate.
9RedWing19		#790	[-]
Posts: 2204 (07/30/08 7:45 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	DarrahColleenJerri wrote: SHAME ON YOU: noon waiting 4 flaming wood mtj1282 SuperAgent Ari Gold Demonic Dan Barry The Killer Croc, and DA Harvey Dent Shame, shame, shame on you! You missed Vyvvi FWIW, Richard received less "hate" votes than Colleen
craig		#791	[-]
Posts: 13571 (07/30/08 8:52 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	That reiforces my suspicon that many of the 0-2 votes for notable players aren't sincere. They are people saying: "X is overrated, so I'm gonna use my vote to balance it out." Maybe the results would be more acurate is we threw out a certain percent of the lowest and highest votes for each player.
9RedWing19		#792	[-]
Posts: 2205 (07/30/08 9:54 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: That reiforces my suspicon that many of the 0-2 votes for notable players aren't sincere. They are people saying: "X is overrated, so I'm gonna use my vote to balance it out." Maybe the results would be more acurate is we threw out a certain percent of the lowest and highest votes for each player. Let's see how it plays out - IMO, bias is very much in the eye of the beholder. I've finished tallying through Amazon, and JennaM may be on the top 10 polarizing list (at this point she is tied with Heidi and Joanna in her season, but has a lower score than Gina-S4 (!!), Tina, Jerri, or Elizabeth ). Of these contestants, Joanna is the only one with more negative than positive votes, and Heidi is the most balanced between positive and negative.
chapera rocks		#793	[-]
Posts: 9571 (08/02/08 8:15 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Results from 2004. Will finish updates later. 001. Colleen Haskell - 85.435% 002. Rudy Boesch - 72.174% 003. Elisabeth Filarski - 70.504% 004. Gretchen Cordy - 70.000% 005. Kathy Vavrick O'Brien - 68.625% 006. Kelly Wigglesworth - 68.37% 007. Ethan Zohn - 68.292% 008. Rudy Boesch - 68.036% 009. Colby Donaldson - 67.647% 010. Rodger Bingham - 67.395% 011. Richard Hatch - 66.762% 012. Teresa Cooper - 66.744% 013. Ethan Zohn - 64.477% 014. Jenna Morasca - 63.714% 015. Greg Buis - 63.700% 016. Gina Crews - 63.500% 017. Kelly Goldsmith - 63.430% 018. Jenna Morasca - 63.347% 019. Sandra Diaz-Twine - 62.508% 020. Rob Cesternino - 61.957% 021. Rob Cesternino - 61.570% 022. Tina Wesson - 60.588% 023. Tanya Vance - 60.000% 024. Shii Ann Huang - 59.929% 025. Richard Hatch - 59.565% 026. Gervase Peterson - 59.239% 027. Shii Ann Huang - 58.593% 028. Michael Skupin - 58.390% 029. Maralyn Hershey - 57.983% 030. Deena Bennett - 57.934% 031. Lea Masters - 57.419% 032. Sonja Christopher - 57.253% 033. Ami Cusack - 57.097% 033. Eliza Orlins - 57.097% 035. Ken Stafford - 56.963% 036. Kim Powers - 56.400% 037. Rory Freeman - 56.290% 038. Chad Crittenden - 55.700% 039. Julie Berry - 55.323% 040. Joel Klug - 54.783% 041. Jake Billingsley - 54.444% 042. Dave Johnson - 53.926% 043. Tijuana Bradley - 53.750% 043. Tammy Leitner - 53.750% 045. Ramona Gray - 53.152% 046. Leann Slaby - 52.634% 047. Jenna Lewis - 52.391% 048. Sean Rector - 52.063% 049. Colby Donaldson - 51.886% 050. Neleh Dennis - 51.500% 051. John Carrol - 51.250% 052. Kim Johnson - 51.163% 053. Darrah Johnson - 50.994% 054. Paschal English - 50.943% 055. Hunter Ellis - 50.813% 056. Brady Finta - 50.591% 057. Vecepia Towery - 50.563% 058. Helen Glover - 50.222% 059. Tina Wesson - 49.786% 060. Matthew Von Ertfelda - 49.628% 061. Twila Tanner - 49.462% 062. Christy Smith - 48.678% 063. Alicia Calaway - 48.655% 064. Jerri Manthey - 48.642% 065. Heidi Strobel - 48.595% 066. Ryan Opray - 48.269% 067. Rupert Boneham - 48.237% 068. Tom Buchanan - 48.198% 069. Christa Hastie - 47.981% 070. Chris Daugherty - 47.796% 071. Kel Gleason - 46.807% 072. Janet Koth - 46.777% 073. Dolly Nealy - 46.452% 074. Amber Brkich - 46.134% 075. Keith Famie - 45.798% 076. Clarence Black - 45.756% 077. Shawna Mitchell - 45.744% 078. Lindsey Richter - 45.700% 079. Jon Dalton - 45.481% 080. Jan Gentry - 45.185% 081. Andrew Savage - 45.000% 082. Rupert Boneham - 44.911% 083. Jerri Manthey - 44.874% 084. Rob Mariano - 44.87% 085. Kathy Vavrick O'Brien - 44.662% 086. Lex Van Den Berghe - 44.535% 087. Brandon Quinton - 43.663% 088. Brian Heidik - 43.111% 089. Tom Buchanan - 42.821% 090. Jeff Varner - 42.605% 091. Butch Lockley - 42.273% 092. Frank Garrison - 42.093% 093. Susan Hawk - 42.065% 094. Jessie Camacho - 41.977% 095. Rob M Mariano - 41.036% 096. Lillian Morris - 40.737% 097. Silas Gaither - 40.465% 098. Amber Brkich - 40.036% 099. Robert DeCanio - 39.913% 100. Burton Roberts - 39.744% 101. Ryan Shoulders - 39.359% 102. Trish Dunn - 39.006% 103. Erin Collins - 38.888% 104. Nicole Delma - 38.878% 105. Nick Brown - 38.644% 106. John Kenney - 38.641% 107. Zoe Zanadakis - 38.500% 108. Robb Zbacnik - 38.222% 109. Daniel Lue - 37.81% 110. Linda Spencer - 37.791% 111. Brook Geraghty - 37.634% 112. Dirk Been - 37.609% 113. Ted Rogers Jr. - 37.556% 114. Sarah Jones - 37.438% 115. Peter Harkey - 37.188% 116. Ryan Aiken - 36.818% 117. Joanna Ward - 36.665% 118. Patricia Jackson - 36.063% 119. Alex Bell - 35.744% 120. Gabriel Cade - 35.500% 121. Travis Sampson - 35.376% 122. Lisa Keiffer - 35.054% 123. Michelle Tesauro - 34.968% 124. Jenna Lewis - 34.128% 125. Scout Lee - 33.118% 126. Diane Ogden - 32.965% 127. Kimmi Kappenberg - 32.437% 128. Debb Eaton - 31.849% 129. Sean Kenniff - 31.848% 130. Roger Sexton - 31.736% 131. John Raymond - 31.704% 132. BB Andersen - 31.648% 133. John Palyok - 30.645% 134. Susan Hawk - 30.142% 135. Stephanie Dill - 29.852% 136. Carl Bilancione - 29.07% 137. Ghandia Johnson - 28.815% 138. Penny Ramsey - 28.667% 139. Mia Galeotalanza - 28.495% 140. Jeanne Hebert - 28.388% 141. Shawn Cohen - 27.917% 142. Stacey Stillman - 27.912% 143. Jed Hildebrand - 27.704% 144. Mitchell Olsen - 27.627% 145. Osten Taylor - 26.827% 146. Lex Van Den Berghe - 26.071% 147. Alicia Calaway - 25.806% 148. Clay Jordan- 24.851% Tribes 01.RATTANA-60.4% 02.Pagong-58.75% 03.BARRAMUNDI-53.5% 04.MOTO MAJI-52.6% 05.Saboga-52.333% 06.ALINTA-52.1% 07.SOLIANTU-50.4% 08.Ogakor-49.875% 09.Tagi-49.625% 10.Maraamu-49.545% 11.JACARE-49.5% 12.Boran-49.182% 13.Rotu-49.091% 14.Kucha-48.875% 15.BALBOA-48.3% 16.Lopevi-48.091% 17.Jaburu-47.727% 18.Mogo Mogo-47.642% 19.Samburu-47.091% 20.Yasur-45.812% 21.Tambaqui-43.364% 22.Drake-43.25% 23.Morgan-43% 24.CHUAY JAI-42.625% 25.Chapera-41.75% 25.Sook Jai-41.75% 27.Chuay Gahn-40.25% 28.CHABOGO MOGO-40% 29.Outcasts-38.833% Winners 1.ETHAN-64.4% 2.JENNA M-63.3% 3.SANDRA-62.5% 4.TINA-60.6% 5.RICHARD-59.6% 6.VECEPIA-50.6% 7.CHRIS-47.8% 8.BRIAN-43.1% 9.AMBER-40% Survivor Borneo 1.Colleen-85.4% 2.Rudy-72.2% 3.Gretchen-70% 4.Kelly-68.4% 5.Greg-63.7% 6.Richard-59.6% 7.Gervase-59.2% 8.Sonja-57.% 9.Joel-54.8% 10.Ramona-53.2% 11.Jenna-52.4% 12.Susan-42.1% 13.Dirk-37.6% 14.Sean-31.8% 15.BB-31.6% 16.Stacey-27.9% Survivor Australia 1.Elisabeth-70.5% 2.Colby-67.6% 3.Rodger-67.4% 4.Tina-60.6% 5.Michael-58.4% 6.Maralyn-58% 7.Alicia-48.7% 8.Kel-46.8% 9.Amber-46.1% 10.Keith-45.8% 11.Jerri-44.9% 12.Jeff-42.3% 13.Nick-38.6% 14.Kimmi-32.4% 15.Debb-31.8% 16.Mitchell-27.6% Survivor Africa 1.Teresa-66.7% 2.Ethan-64.4% 3.Kelly-63.4% 4.Kim P-56.4% 5.Kim J-51.2% 6.Tom-48.2% 7.Clarence-45.8% 8.Lindsey-45.7% 9.Lex-44.5% 10.Brandon-43.7% 11.Frank-42.1% 12.Jessie-42% 13.Silas-40.5% 14.Linda-37.8% 15.Diane-33% 16.Carl-29.1% Survivor Marquesas 1.Kathy-68.6% 2.Gina-63.5% 3.Tammy-53.8% 4.Sean-52.1% 5.Neleh-51.5% 6.John-51.3% 7.Paschal-50.9% 8.Hunter-50.8% 9.Vecepia-50.6% 10.Rob-44.9% 11.Robert-39.8% 12.Zoe-38.5% 13.Sarah-37.4% 14.Peter-37.2% 15.Patricia-36.1% 16.Gabriel-35.5% Survivor Thailand 1.Tanya-60% 2.Shii Ann-58.6% 3.Ken-57% 4.Jake-54.4% 5.Helen-50.2% 6.Jan-45.2% 7.Brian-43.1% 8.Erin-38.9% 9.Robb-38.2% 10.Ted-37.6% 11.John-31.7% 12.Stephanie-29.9% 13.Ghandia-28.8% 14.Penny-28.7% 15.Jed-27.7% 16.Clay-24.9% Survivor Amazon 1.Jenna-63.3% 2.Rob-61.6% 3.Deena-57.9% 4.Dave-53.9% 5.Matthew-49.6% 6.Christy-48.7% 7.Heidi-48.6% 8.Janet-46.8% 9.Shawna-45.7% 10.Butch-42.3% 11.Daniel-37.8% 12.Ryan-36.8% 13.Joanna-36.7% 14.Alex-35.7% 15.Roger-31.7% 16.Jeanne-28.4% Survivor Pearl Islands 1.Sandra-62.5% 2.Tijuana-53.8% 3.Darrah-51% 4.Ryan O-48.3% 5.Rupert-48.2% 6.Christa-48% 7.Jon-45.4% 8.Andrew-45% 9.Lillian-40.7% 10.Burton-39.7% 11.Ryan S-39.4% 12.Trish-39% 13.Nicole-38.9% 14.Michelle-35% 15.Shawn-27.9% 16.Osten-26.8% Survivor All Stars 1.Ethan-68.3% 2.Rudy-68% 3.Richard-66.8% 4.Jenna M-63.7% 5.Rob C-62% 6.Shii Ann-59.9% 7.Colby-51.9% 8.Tina-49.8% 9.Jerri-48.6% 10.Rupert-44.9% 11.Kathy-44.7% 12.Tom-42.8% 13.Rob M-41.4% 14.Amber-40% 15.Jenna L-34.1% 16.Susan-30.1% 17.Lex-26.1% 18.Alicia-25.8% Survivor Vanuatu 1.Lea-57.4% 2.Ami-57.1% 3.Eliza-57.1% 4.Rory-56.3% 5.Chad-55.7% 6.Julie-55.3% 7.Leann-52.6% 8.Brady-50.6% 9.Twila-49.4% 10.Chris-47.8% 11.Dolly-46.4% 12.John K-38.6% 13.Brook-37.6% 14.Travis-35.4% 15.Lisa-35.1% 16.Scout-33.1% 17.John P-30.6% 18.Mia-28.4% Last Edited By: chapera rocks 08/03/08 11:51 AM. Edited 1 times.
craig		#794	[-]
Posts: 13633 (08/03/08 2:00 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	What are the odds that Eliza and Ami would tie for Vanuatu twice in a row? The last poll got really partisan as it went along, with people voting down the rivals of their faves. Jenna vs Christy, Christy vs Darrah, Romber vs Mog Mogo, Eliza\Ami vs Twila. Hung swings for both Helen (up) and Sarge (down). Tanya the sweetheart flop has been forgetten. The older poll was less favourable for older females, but kinder to males.
9RedWing19		#795	[-]
Posts: 2206 (08/03/08 4:04 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	craig wrote: The last poll got really partisan as it went along, with people voting down the rivals of their faves. Jenna vs Christy, Christa vs Darrah, Romber vs Mog Mogo, Eliza\Ami vs Twila. As a Darrah fan, I had to test this with the more recent data. Overall, Christa had a higher score than Darrah. There were 66 voters. I looked at the difference between Darrah's score and Christa's score by voter and tallied them. The results were: -10: 1 (ie one voter gave Christa a 10, and Darrah a zero), -7:2, -6:3, -5:4, -4:4, -3:3, -2:7, -1: 13 (ie 13 voters rated Darrah one point below Christa), 0: 5, 1:5, 2:8, 3:5, 4:1, 5:2, 6:1 (that was me!!), 7:1, 8:1. If there had been the type of bias that Craig was mentioning, I would have expected to see many more highly positive or highly negative scores.
craig		#796	[-]
Posts: 13636 (08/03/08 4:28 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think Christy vs Darrah is history, and didn't effect the recent poll. That's why both are up where they should be. It was always more of a Sucks rivalry than a show rivalry, so people who weren't around here in 2003-04 won't be affected.
Dictatorship		#797	[-]
Posts: 2976 (08/03/08 4:34 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I can't remember if I voted, but I'd definitely give Darrah a 10 and Crackhead bitch a 0.
Kitty Pryde1		#798	[-]
Posts: 5159 (08/03/08 7:57 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	People actually liked that garble-mouthed invisible bitch enough to make her rival Christa?
chapera rocks		#799	[-]
Posts: 9576 (08/03/08 8:07 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	There was a lot of fighting between the two fan groups at the time. Because Christa bashed Darrah on TES seemingly for no reason (since we weren't really shown much on the show of it). I also thought it was funny Ami/Eliza tied twice.
craig		#800	[-]
Posts: 13643 (08/03/08 8:07 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Only because there was a false "Darrah wins" spoiler all season. It was like Alexis early in S16 only times 10. Edgic scored one of its greatest triumpths by picking and sticking with Sandra. Darrah's 3 IC wins fueled the Darrah love, and when Christa said all Darrah ever talked about was chocolate chip cookies and getting a boob job, it was on! (It parallels Eliza vs Amanda actually.) Last Edited By: craig 08/03/08 8:10 PM. Edited 1 times.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

All Seasons Popularity Poll -- DONE :) ty all, discuss results away

Quick Reply