| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
pinoyako |
|||
|
MICRONESIA owns because of Cirie!
|
|||
Widdi |
|||
|
1. China
2. Micronesia 3. Exile Island 4. Marquesas 5. Australia 6. Palau 7. Cook Islands 8. Pearl Islands 9. Guatemala 10. Vanuatu 11. Africa 12. ASS 13. Borneo 14. Amazon 15. Thailand 16. Fiji |
|||
dannystultz |
|||
|
1. Pearl Islands
2. China 3. Borneo 4. Guatemala 5. Micronesia 6. Vanuatu 7. Australia 8. Marquesas 9. Africa 10. Exile Island 11. Amazon 12. ASS 13. Thailand 14. Cook Islands 15. Palau 16. Fiji |
|||
Beautiful Patsy |
|||
|
I look at each season from the perspective of how much I enjoyed it when I originally saw it.
Really Great Seasons 1 - Borneo/S1 - 10/10 2 - Australia/S2 - 10/10 3 - Marquesas/S4 - 9/10 4 - Pearl Islands/S7 - 9/10 5 - Palau/S10 - 8/10 Good Seasons 6 - Africa/S3 - 7/10 7 - Amazon/S6 - 7/10 8 - Micronesia/S16 - 7/10 9 - Vanuatu/S9 - 6/10 10 - Cook Islands/S13 - 6/10 11 - Thailand/S5 - 6/10 Meh Seasons 12 - Panama/S12 - 5/10 13 - Guatemala/S11 - 4/10 14 - China/S15 - N/A Terrible, Terrible, Terrible Seasons 15 - ASS/S8 - 1/10 16 - Fiji/S14 - 0/10 I don't think I've ever loved watching anything as much as I did the first season of Survivor, so it could never leave #1 in my opinion. I loved Australia as well. Marquesas had the first and greatest take-down of the major controlling alliance, plus it had Kathy. Pearl Islands was the last renaissance of the original greatness of Survivor's classic seasons. Palau was the most recent and only post-ASS really great season (and probably the last really great season). Africa had flaws and I didn't like how the endgame went down at all, but it had the original twist and a very unique feel compared to all the other seasons. Amazon was the first time I started thinking Survivor was losing a little of its luster. Even with that plus a bad F2 and winner, it still was very entertaining. Micronesia was amazing, especially for such a late season, but in a different way than classic seasons and I have a feeling it seems so good because so many of the recent seasons have been so bad. Vanuatu had a dark feel to it and a winner I didn't like, but it still had a lot of great moments. Cook Islands was definitely flawed and the beginning wasn't very good, but the last half of the season was great. Thailand was the most boring of the classic pre-ASS seasons, but even so it was still a good season. Panama had a lot of good components (Terry, Cirie, etc.) but didn't come together in a great way and ended with a bad F2 and winner. I actually liked Stephanie and Bobby Jon coming back for Guatemala, but they couldn't save the season from being pretty meh. I have to admit, I didn't watch most of China and might've liked it a lot better had I, but since I saw some (the early episodes) I'll still list it, and it lands low since it didn't even catch my attention enough to finish the season (a first for me). ASS should've been spectacular. I was so excited. But from the first episode to the last, it was about the most enduringly painful time I've ever had watching Survivor. I loved the cast, of course, but this season just played out in such an incredibly bad way, it ranks as a terrible, terrible season. ASS should've been last. But Fiji had one thing ASS didn't - Dreamz. And for that, Fiji is and will forever be ranked dead last. |
|||
Merely |
|||
|
PALAU
Guatemala China Micronesia Pearl Islands All-Stars Australia Fiji Vanuatu Amazon Thailand Cook Islands Africa |
|||
GnarlsInCharge |
|||
Fcuk You ywia wrote: I think it proved even with decent casting and unpredictable gameplay that it needs some tweaking so that it again becomes about the contestants and the relationships they make with one another instead of the majority of the game now being about challenges and Hidden Idol related talk. |
|||
GnarlsInCharge |
|||
|
1 .Amazon
2.Pearl Islands 3.Marquesas 4.Africa 5.All Stars 6.Pulau 7.Australia 8.Borneo 9.China ~The most uneven random season ever one episode would be extremely colourful then the next boring as dirt 10.Vanuatu 11.Micronesia 12.Panama-Exile Island 13.Fiji 14.Guatemala 15.Cook Islands 16.Thailand |
|||
ShadowBlade11 |
|||
|
1. Pearl Islands - Fairplay and Rupert aside, the pirate theme made it more epic than other seasons.
2. Australia - First I ever watched and the first season the person I was rooting for won. 3. Micronesia - Blindsided NICE - Jamie from Survivor Guatemala. 4. Fiji - Yau Man and the Edgardo departure were priceless. 5. Amazon - Like many said, the F2 was bad and I wish till this day Cesternino should have won the million dollars. Unlike Micronesia, the person who gave the necklace actually survived... AND WON! Only smart decision Jenna had is to vote Cesternino at F3. 6. Marquesas - I will always consider Vecepia the most inane winner of them all, and even more so the producers that came up with the purple rock crap. It's annoying that Cirie, 6 years later, reminisce something that shouldn't have even happened. I love ties because they make the game exciting, but come on this is ridiculous, especially for Paschal. That being said it was entertaining, Boston Rob owned and all. 7. Guatemala - It felt the most like the original survivor seasons to me and it's too bad no one came back. Brian? Come on, Brian vs. Erik confrontation would have been sweet since they are practically the same person! 8. Cook Islands - The first half was bad and I wished Cao Boi would have stayed for a longer time (Nail Saloon Ninja!). But thanks to Ozzy and Jonathan it was worthwhile. I just wish Ozzy and co. were smart enough to get rid of Yul at final 4-5. 9. China - Man Jaime and Amanda are hot!... It was fun, but felt weird from time to time. I still was to decapitate Courtney. 10. Exile Island - Everyone loves Terry. I just wish he used a different strategy other than win immunities and keep immunity to yourself and never use it on a potential alliance member. Thanks to Cirie it didn't suck as much. Bruce was cool too, I wish he sticked for more. I don't know why I like the old asian guys, but they can pull off a Mr. Miyaki and bust a cap in your ass! 11. Borneo - It would have been higher if I watched it back in the day, but it's still a good season. Richard Hatch is a legend. 12. Vanuatu - It had a woman alliance as well, but it was a lot less interesting than Micronesia. It is funny how Ami was hated back then and now she is 180 degrees different. Eliza is still a motormouth, just with a significantly smaller boobs. She doesn't need them though, she is Eliza. This is where it gets ugly for me. 13. Pulau - It was lame because I knew from the merge Tom had it in his bag. Who I do need to mention is Greg. His "plan" was to get rid of Stephanie... okay, that worked, but then he got ousted. He could have taken her, Janu, Coby, Caryn and Jenn and overthrow the final 3. Ulong was definitely more fun to watch than Koror. I wish James (not the gravedigger, the redneck) would have lasted longer. 14. All Star - It had a great start, but quickly it turned into the Romber show. Everyone wanted to take Boston Rob to final two because of him being a perfect partner to be compared to, but that's the point: HE KNEW THAT. Vecepia might have been the most inane winner in my eyes, but my god is Amber the least deserving. When Jeff Probst said "Parvati is the season's Amber" I was worried it's going to be a repeat. Parvati did win in the end like Amber, but she was actually deserving. 15. Thailand - Shii Ann made the season good. My god if she was just in a different season it would have been more fun to watch. Actually I want to give it to Clay as well as he should have won instead of Brian, but his alliance hated his guts... meh -_- 16. Africa - I just can't like it. People were boring, challenges were so-so and it just had a dull feeling. In fact the only thing I can say I liked is the switch. |
|||
JVJrule |
|||
|
1. Australia
2. Micronesia 3. Pearl Islands 4. All Stars 5. Borneo 6. Exile Island 7. Amazon 8. Palau 9. China 10. Africa 11. Vanuatu 12. Guatemala 13. Cook Islands 14. Fiji 15. Marquesas 16. Thailand |
|||
m0t0 maj1 |
|||
|
1. Marquesas - stunning location, powershift, well rounded
2. China - almost returning to basics 16 players, satisfying winner 3. Micronesia - so many blindsides, favorites 4. Palau - Tom dominating, so many firsts, I enjoyed seeing Ulong die 5. Guatemala - great characters, Danni winning 6. Pearl Islands - pirate theme, higher if the Outcast twist was not incorporated 7. Borneo 8. Cook Islands - characters (I'm Asian so, meh.) 9. Australia - early controversies and conflicts, flooding 10. Africa - first season to have watched 11. Panama - not too many players, good characters, Cirie 12. All-Stars - meh 13. Vanuatu - didn't like the winner and Twila 14. Amazon - murky environment, not so much development in Jenna's character 15. Thailand - rewatched it and was stagnant and predictable 16. Fiji - helicopter shots, have vs have-nots |
|||
bluesboi |
|||
|
1. Pearl Islands
2. Micronesia 3. Borneo 4. Cook Islands 5. China 6. Marquesas 7. Australia 8. Guatemala 9. Amazon 10. Africa 11. Fiji 12. Guatemala 13. Thailand 14. ASS 15. Palau 16. Panama |
|||
Dictatorship |
|||
|
1. Borneo
2. The Amazon 3. Pearl Islands 4. The Australian Outback 5. Africa 6. Marquesas 7. Thailand 8. Micronesia 9. China 10. Vanuatu 11. Exile Island 12. Palau 13. Guatemala 14. All-Stars 15. Cook Islands 16. Fiji |
|||