quietsurvivorfan wrote:
I found this link on another bb fan site, it is a great critique of the season with suggestions to improve the show.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/24343903/
Some of their suggestions certainly were sensible, the best of which is the end of the prior relationships, I don't think anyone would argue for keeping
that. Although to be fair, by the end of the second week this season, it was irrelevent, as both relationships had been broken up. I agree with the
'Ending Slop', 'Uncensored Feeds' and 'Fairer competitions'. That said, certain things bugged me. This person really should pay more
attention to the show before making certain criticisms IMHO.
This season, the producers not only put pre-existing couples into the house, but they also forced everyone else to pair up with their alleged "soul mates." That twist was so lame and misguided that it was dropped after week three. (The show even changed its name from "Big Brother: 'Til Death Do You Part" to "Big Brother 9.")
It was quite obvious why they did the soul matest twist, because they wanted the ability to end the show very quickly if it tanked. Which it didn't. And if they kept this 'lame twist' which IMHO was responsible for a lot of the good parts of the first month of the season, the season would have been over around mid March.
CBS has three marquee reality shows: "The Amazing Race," "Survivor" and "Big Brother." It's no surprise that the two Emmy-nominated shows are cast by the same person, while someone else casts "Big Brother."Robyn Kass and her colleagues have cast every season of "Big Brother" since its second season, and have proven to be talented at gathering psychopathic extroverts with superiority complexes and not a lot of intelligence. The exceptions to this rule - perennial fan favorites Kaysar and Janelle from season six - prove that better cast members equal better television.
Perhaps it's possible that the people Kass casts are perfectly agreeable until they get locked up in the soundstage that serves as "Big Brother's" house. Or maybe she's just directed to get crazy people. Either way, after nine seasons, it's time to try something new.
Completely wrong on this one, they had a terrific cast this season, with only one of the people who were still around after the first 4-5 episodes (Sharon) who was a bust. A smart cast doesn't necessarily make a great cast.
And these 'great' casters at Survivor are the same people who completely destroyed an entire year of the show (seasons 13 & 14) with their horrific casting, and the same people who cast Kathy, Chet, Mary, Natalie and Alexis this season, all of which have been casting disasters.
At this point in time, I gotta say BB's casters are FAR ahead of Survivor's casters.
For all of its alleged changes and twists, the show remains frustratingly similar. Unlike "Survivor" - a show that really doesn't deserve being compared to its sibling - "Big Brother" doesn't innovate. The same challenges are recycled, the music never changes, the open credits are the same and Chen's hosting is beyond robotic in its repetition.
Having watched another season of BB while this season was going on through YouTube, I can say that this is wrong as well. BB can get better with innovativeness in the HOH comps (but then, you gotta remember that these things have to be very short since they're live), but the music has changed, and the opening credits have changed as well (after S5). Survivor has used the same opening music for 16 seasons (slightly remixed each time), and the only true change in style they've made to the opening credits has actually been quite detrimental (removing booted players). And this person's nuts if he thinks they don't recycle challenges on Survivor.
Ryan, the 27-year-old college student from Columbus, Ohio, was accused of being a racist, but his indefensible view and the general bad behavior on "Big Brother 9" didn't make the show any more interesting.
That was Jen being a cunt, lying about him. Ryan never said anything racist or offensive in the house that I can remember (feed watchers correct me if I'm wrong).















