Will we ever have another American Idol as good as Carrie Underwood?

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
fannypackwearer		#141	[-]
Posts: 509 (04/25/08 5:18 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	latingrl2005 wrote: SurvivorFanGP wrote: ILovegreeneyes wrote: 4pack1 wrote: Besides being a stupid argument to begin with, really what has Carrie done that Kelly hasn't? vomited herself skinny? dated a football player who likes the ladies a lil too much? dated a guy many believe is gay? thanked Idol for every fart that has escaped her ass since winning? maintain her weight unlike fatass Kelly? that's the short list You missed one. Fixed. Carrie on Idol Carrie now.... If your head wasn't sooooooooo far up Carrie ASS.......you would know she's lost close to 30-40 pounds since Idol. That pic is from 2006 idiot...here's a recent one....she's looking very fit. I'll even admit that she was looking very thin in that 2006 pic but she's put a few back on since then. that was after she did 150 shows...Here's a couple recent ones....
latingrl2005		#142	[-]
Posts: 2185 (04/25/08 5:26 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Fat Piggy Bitch wrote: ILovegreeneyes wrote: 4pack1 wrote: Besides being a stupid argument to begin with, really what has Carrie done that Kelly hasn't? vomited herself skinny? dated a football player who likes the ladies a lil too much? dated a guy many believe is gay? thanked Idol for every fart that has escaped her ass since winning? that's the short list 1. Being in shape means your are bulimic? Okaaaaay bitch. Hate to see what you look like. 2. Both of the men she dated are fucking gorgeous. Can you blame her? Besides she broke up with both of them. Who has Kelly dated recently? Oh, thats right, NO ONE! She is a repressed dyke living her life in the closet instead of accepting herself for who she is. 3. Recognizing the platform and the people who gave her success instead of acting like she was too good for it. I can't believe her. What a fucking bitch! I will leave it up for you to decide which one is at a healthy weight. Tony Romo preferred Jessica and Chase is gay........great dating record!!!!!! this is Kelly 2 weeks ago...... and I think I'm in better shape than Carrie.......
ILovegreeneyes		#143	[-]
Posts: 4612 (04/25/08 5:32 PM) I need a life Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Fat Piggy Bitch wrote: 1. Being in shape means your are bulimic? Okaaaaay bitch. Hate to see what you look like. I'm fat by sucks standards since I'm a size 7... Carrie lost a dramatic amount of weight..anyone with eyes can see it.. denial won't make it less true 2. Both of the men she dated are fucking gorgeous. Can you blame her? Besides she broke up with both of them. Who has Kelly dated recently? Oh, thats right, NO ONE! She is a repressed dyke living her life in the closet instead of accepting herself for who she is. So because Kelly doesn't doesn't flaunt her relationships for public view she's a dyke? ummm okay...you must be Perez Hilton in your other life..... I prefer celebrities who keep their private life private... she also doesn't date men who are also in the celebrity lifestyle. 3. Recognizing the platform and the people who gave her success instead of acting like she was too good for it. I can't believe her. What a fucking bitch! Kelly's never dismissed or discredited Idol...that is bullshit rhetoric spewed by people who haven't a fucking clue how Kelly feels or what she's said because they clearly don't follow Kelly's interviews. Kelly speaks highly of Idol every time she is asked... she didn't appear on Idol during Breakaway because she was on tour for two years straight... before that she appeared on Season 2 and 3 and Kelly thanked Idol when she won her very first award...in the Summer of 03... she shouldn't have to lick their asses for the rest of her career IMO.. find even ONE article or interview of Kelly saying something negative about Idol and I'll shut the fuck up about it... I will leave it up for you to decide which one is at a healthy weight. again you only prove that Kelly isn't overweight you fucking moron... and Carrie looks pretty damn hot in that picture...that was right before she went all Karen Carpenter
fannypackwearer		#144	[-]
Posts: 510 (04/25/08 5:36 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Why are you posting pics of yourself? Wait, they are prob pics you found and you weigh about 500 LBS right?! Both Carrie and Kelly look great. They have different body shapes as does everyone else. Carrie is very toned and fit and does not look bulimic.
4pack1		#145	[-]
Posts: 109 (04/25/08 5:39 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Their is absolutely nothing wrong with how Kelly looks now. Their was a point during her Breakaway run that I think she actually got too skinny. But now she looks fine and like a normal girl (except for the ass, but thats a good thing) and I think she is perfectly fine with that. But Carrie seems to be more into looking perfect and glamourus all the time. Their is nothing wrong with that, but I could see how could draw people off.
ILovegreeneyes		#146	[-]
Posts: 4613 (04/25/08 5:40 PM) I need a life Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Carrie has definitely improved her weight in recent months...she looked pretty scary there for a while but she seems to have come back to reality. I do think the pressure of her new star status got to her for a while and she wasn't trying to conform a little bit and it got out of control. She looks much healthier now... Kelly went through a period last year were she was a bit on the chubby side..the stress of the album drama and stuff probably got inside her head and if she's anything like a lot of people she didn't pay attention to what she was eating to well...she's in great shape now though and even at her biggest she was far from obese.
Fat Piggy Bitch		#147	[-]
Posts: 731 (04/25/08 5:47 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	latingrl2005 wrote: and I think I'm in better shape than Carrie....... Nope. You are just an attention whore. latingrl2005 wrote: Tony Romo preferred Jessica and Chase is gay........great dating record!!!!!! This is here fault how? Again, it is better than being a repressed dyke living her life in the closet instead of accepting herself for who she is. Can you say Clay Aiken?
latingrl2005		#148	[-]
Posts: 2186 (04/25/08 5:48 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	fannypackwearer wrote: Why are you posting pics of yourself? Wait, they are prob pics you found and you weigh about 500 LBS right?! Both Carrie and Kelly look great. They have different body shapes as does everyone else. Carrie is very toned and fit and does not look bulimic. She looks a lot better now, but she was deadly skinny at no point.
seaguy		#149	[-]
Posts: 10489 (04/25/08 5:49 PM) AI Forum Moderator Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Fat Piggy Bitch wrote: This is here fault how? Again, it is better than being a repressed dyke living her life in the closet instead of accepting herself for who she is. Can you say Clay Aiken? He's a repressed dyke too? I knew he was looking like Chastity Bono there for awhile, but now it makes more sense.
latingrl2005		#150	[-]
Posts: 2187 (04/25/08 5:50 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	4pack1 wrote: Their is absolutely nothing wrong with how Kelly looks now. Their was a point during her Breakaway run that I think she actually got too skinny. But now she looks fine and like a normal girl (except for the ass, but thats a good thing) and I think she is perfectly fine with that. But Carrie seems to be more into looking perfect and glamourus all the time. Their is nothing wrong with that, but I could see how could draw people off. People act like this was Kelly's normal weight, then gained 30 pounds. This is after 1 year of touring.
caviarqueen		#151	[-]
Posts: 28 (04/25/08 5:52 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Am I the only person who has Kelly albums, Carrie albums, the Daughtry album, and Clay's Christmas album (yes, I'm a sucker for sappy Christmas music!) and enjoy all of them, depending on what I'm in the mood to listen to? I never compare them because they are all very different to me and have their own strengths and weaknesses. I think that they have all had success in their genre with some of them crossing over to other genres with great success as well. Of the current bunch, I will probably buy David Cook's album because I like his style the best. My husband likes Brooke's style, and I think her album could be decent with lots of studio clean-up and intervention. But to answer the original question of this thread, I think that CD sales will continue to decline as the economy declines, making it difficult to match past idol successes. Just my opinion, though.
seaguy		#152	[-]
Posts: 10490 (04/25/08 5:53 PM) AI Forum Moderator Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	caviarqueen wrote: Am I the only person who has Kelly albums, Carrie albums, the Daughtry album, and Clay's Christmas album (yes, I'm a sucker for sappy Christmas music!) and enjoy all of them, depending on what I'm in the mood to listen to? I never compare them because they are all very different to me and have their own strengths and weaknesses. Please stop with your logical posts.
latingrl2005		#153	[-]
Posts: 2188 (04/25/08 5:55 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Fat Piggy Bitch wrote: latingrl2005 wrote: and I think I'm in better shape than Carrie....... Nope. You are just an attention whore. latingrl2005 wrote: Tony Romo preferred Jessica and Chase is gay........great dating record!!!!!! This is here fault how? Again, it is better than being a repressed dyke living her life in the closet instead of accepting herself for who she is. Can you say Clay Aiken? I like being a whore......it gets my bills paid!!! Is being a dyke a bad thing?
ILovegreeneyes		#154	[-]
Posts: 4614 (04/25/08 6:14 PM) I need a life Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	caviarqueen wrote: Am I the only person who has Kelly albums, Carrie albums, the Daughtry album, and Clay's Christmas album (yes, I'm a sucker for sappy Christmas music!) and enjoy all of them, depending on what I'm in the mood to listen to? I never compare them because they are all very different to me and have their own strengths and weaknesses. I think that they have all had success in their genre with some of them crossing over to other genres with great success as well. Of the current bunch, I will probably buy David Cook's album because I like his style the best. My husband likes Brooke's style, and I think her album could be decent with lots of studio clean-up and intervention. But to answer the original question of this thread, I think that CD sales will continue to decline as the economy declines, making it difficult to match past idol successes. Just my opinion, though. I own Kelly, Clay, Carrie, Daughtry, Jordin, Kat Pee, Elliott, and Bo and a few from Australian Idol as well. I like good music...it's really that simple. Kelly is my ultimate favorite but that doesn't mean I don't find the others to be talented and successful. and yes, CD sales will continue to decline as the music industry downward spirals and single downloads become more and more the way people buy music..one song at a time...
Drew B		#155	[-]
Posts: 2704 (04/25/08 6:15 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'm not sure how this weight discussion has anything to do with whether or not Kelly is as good an American Idol... Frankly, I consider Carrie to be a far better mannequin than Kelly. However, if we are talking about anything having to do with personality or emotion or vitality (and I believe singing falls into this category), I don't think Carrie can compare with Kelly... Kelly is a human being. Carrie is a walking Barbie doll...
MakePaulaCry		#156	[-]
Posts: 1013 (04/25/08 6:16 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kelly Dykon Clarkson has had relatively no success since (early) 2006. BREAKAWAY WAS RELEASED IN 2004! Early 2006? , then that Addicted Tour that she had in mid-2006 where she sold out FUCKING ARENAS ranging from 12-25,000 people wasn't success you fat cunt? Even Farmbot hasn't achieved that level of SOLO touring yet. Even with the massive flop of My December, Yelly was still able to sell out arenas internationally, outside of the US. And in the US, in bigger cities, Yelly was still able to pull in crowds of up to 6,000. One arena she played had around 8,000 even. Not shabby even with a flopped album. Even the 4 leaked tracks off of Yelly's new album caused a lot of stir. And the Reba tour in arenas certainly helped. Farmbot and Yelly both have great success. Farmbot is more popular in my opinion right now but that's due to her new album success where Yelly hasn't released an album for close to a year now. It might very well change again if Yelly gets a great single for her new album, which seems very promising if the leaked tracks are any indication. In terms of actual talent, I think Yelly beats out the Farmbot by a mile. I can't see Farmbot ever attempting Ave Maria successfully.
Fat Piggy Bitch		#157	[-]
Posts: 732 (04/25/08 6:17 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	ILovegreeneyes wrote: Fat Piggy Bitch wrote: 1. Being in shape means your are bulimic? Okaaaaay bitch. Hate to see what you look like. I'm fat by sucks standards since I'm a size 7... Carrie lost a dramatic amount of weight..anyone with eyes can see it.. denial won't make it less true --Whatevs bitch. Carrie was too skinny at one point but she is over it and is fine now. She even admits that she is far too concerned with her appearance. Whats worse being too concerned or not concerned at all? Oh, thats right, repressed dyke. Got it. 2. Both of the men she dated are fucking gorgeous. Can you blame her? Besides she broke up with both of them. Who has Kelly dated recently? Oh, thats right, NO ONE! She is a repressed dyke living her life in the closet instead of accepting herself for who she is. So because Kelly doesn't doesn't flaunt her relationships for public view she's a dyke? ummm okay...you must be Perez Hilton in your other life..... I prefer celebrities who keep their private life private... she also doesn't date men who are also in the celebrity lifestyle. -- OMG! How did you know? Carrie doesn't flaunt them by any means the Paparazzi just follow her because she is A list. Oh fuck, are you kidding me? Kelly isn't a dyke? Okay, Jodie Foster. 3. Recognizing the platform and the people who gave her success instead of acting like she was too good for it. I can't believe her. What a fucking bitch! Kelly's never dismissed or discredited Idol...that is bullshit rhetoric spewed by people who haven't a fucking clue how Kelly feels or what she's said because they clearly don't follow Kelly's interviews. Kelly speaks highly of Idol every time she is asked... she didn't appear on Idol during Breakaway because she was on tour for two years straight... before that she appeared on Season 2 and 3 and Kelly thanked Idol when she won her very first award...in the Summer of 03... she shouldn't have to lick their asses for the rest of her career IMO.. find even ONE article or interview of Kelly saying something negative about Idol and I'll shut the fuck up about it... --- Sorry, about the source. Read it bitch. Oh, it has nothing to do about her going back to idol. It's about her thinking she is somehow above it. She would be no where without them and she needs to realize this. Last Edited By: Fat Piggy Bitch 04/25/08 6:19 PM. Edited 1 times.
caviarqueen		#158	[-]
Posts: 29 (04/25/08 6:20 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	seaguy wrote: caviarqueen wrote: Am I the only person who has Kelly albums, Carrie albums, the Daughtry album, and Clay's Christmas album (yes, I'm a sucker for sappy Christmas music!) and enjoy all of them, depending on what I'm in the mood to listen to? I never compare them because they are all very different to me and have their own strengths and weaknesses. Please stop with your logical posts. Sorry for the logic! The wine has not kicked in yet.
seaguy		#159	[-]
Posts: 10491 (04/25/08 6:22 PM) AI Forum Moderator Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	It's ok. Once that starts you'll be posting like a total illogical fantard in no time!
Fat Piggy Bitch		#160	[-]
Posts: 733 (04/25/08 6:23 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	latingrl2005 wrote: Fat Piggy Bitch wrote: latingrl2005 wrote: and I think I'm in better shape than Carrie....... Nope. You are just an attention whore. latingrl2005 wrote: Tony Romo preferred Jessica and Chase is gay........great dating record!!!!!! This is here fault how? Again, it is better than being a repressed dyke living her life in the closet instead of accepting herself for who she is. Can you say Clay Aiken? I like being a whore......it gets my bills paid!!! Is being a dyke a bad thing? Jesus, you are an idiot. No way you are fucking legit. Did I say being a lesbian was a bad thing? No. I said she needs to accept who she is.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Will we ever have another American Idol as good as Carrie Underwood?

Quick Reply