| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Paris Hilton |
|||
|
Jon Peter Lewis for #1!
|
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
|
Vonzell should be on Top 10 or else..
|
|||
Apprentice Talker |
|||
|
Jasmine Trias should in the top 50 list... Please...
|
|||
SurvivorFanGP |
|||
Apprentice Talker wrote: Yes, Claude! Jasmalien was the best thing about season 3 <3 |
|||
Will |
|||
|
Kimberley Locke.
|
|||
Jessfrogger88 |
|||
|
Sorry Will, my bad.... Can I call her Kim?
I would edit but yuku sucks.� Here is something to make up for it. |
|||
Jessfrogger88 |
|||
|
#36. Ramielle Mulubay Sorry Rammy,� I still love ya, but after disappointment after disappointment I couldn't have you ranked as high as 21.� I still think you have a pretty good voice, but I just think you need a lot more time to practice and get experience and I believe she got a bit lost in her performances.... Cept her top 24 performance and top 12 performance which I thought were terrific and spot on.� Rammy was a hip chick with a cool style and she liked to cry.� She really won me over because when I was sad someone got voted off so was she!� I could identify with that!� I still think she is super cool and probably one of the most down to earth idols every... For that and a great voice.� Rammy gets downgraded from 21-36, but hey 36 is still respectable. Unfortunately the douchebags on youtube decided to disable embedding on all her good performances� Sidenote ..for the list the longer you last can help or hurt you... you have more time to make an impression and also more time to change a first impression.
Last Edited By: Jessfrogger88
04/15/08 9:41 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
|
David Cook's ranking's too low. |
|||
Jessfrogger88 |
|||
|
I know after tonight's voice box thing i wish i would have ranked him a little higher. That performance would have been enough to put him just ahead of
the person at #35.
Last Edited By: Jessfrogger88
03/18/08 10:57 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Jessfrogger88 |
|||
|
#35. Heather Cox Yes I'm serious... She had a really good audition.� She was amazing...... in her audition.................. She was possibly the hottest idol ever to grace the stage.... hot...� but i seriously was rooting for her to do well.� I thought her first peformance was decent her second sucked..........but she was hot!� At least consider the rack. |
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
|
She's pretty but she's hilarious on picking songs.
|
|||
Jessfrogger88 |
|||
|
#34. Anthony Fedorov I think Anthony was a really rare find for Idol.� He was a teenage white boy with a great traditional singing voice.� I seriously think in a few years he could be like another Josh Groban.� Granted he was a bit cheesy, but idol is very cheesy.� I thought most of his performances were good.... a few terrible.. "Climb Every Mountain". � However, but for being a Russian orphan who had his vocal chords stolen my gypsies, occasionally sounding like Balki from perfect strangers, and for being the first soul to melt Carrie the ice queens heart and get in her pants he gets #35... That's Nice! |
|||
SurvivorFanGP |
|||
|
Anthony was so underrated. And Heather is arguably the most forgettable AI contestant ever.
|
|||
Apprentice Talker |
|||
However, but for being a Russian orphan who had his vocal chords stolen my gypsies, occasionally sounding like Balki from perfect strangers, and for being the first soul to melt Carrie the ice queens heart and get in her pants he gets #35... That's Nice!Fedorov is Ukrainian not Russian, he had a tracheotomy when he was a child. I saw his audition in Cleveland three years ago and I watched it on TV that he may speak again. |
|||
Jessfrogger88 |
|||
|
#33. Ayla Brown Ayla, Ayla, Ayla.� What can I say about Ayla?� I will say this.� Ayla was a pretty neat find.� She was a basketball playing tom boy with a pretty good voice.� She wasn't the most attractive and some thought she was a cold-hearted bitch.� I never thought that though.� I think she was just an over-achiever and looked at everything in her life as a challenge she wanted to overcome.� I think she had a lot of great potential but I don't think her semi-final performances were what she needed to make it.� Apparently the AI gods wanted her in the top 12 and BAD, because after she got das boot they went on a tirade against Sweet Melissa for no reason.� Many fantards joined the mob... singling her out as the one who got Ayla cut!� That pissed me off, but I can't take that on Ayla Brown.. So this lesbo comes in at #33.� |
|||
SurvivorFanGP |
|||
|
Ayla's "Reflection" and "I Want You To Need Me" are great. She wouldn't have won, but I was in the boat that wanted her to make it
over Melissa. She's one of the most underrated contestants ever. <3
Bitch probably had a field day when Melissa got booted the following week. |
|||
Jessfrogger88 |
|||
|
yeah kinda sucks that her only performance on Youtube is her most mediocre.. I for the record didn't think it was that bad, but just nowhere as good as
the others.
|
|||
Jessfrogger88 |
|||
|
#32. Jennifer Feuntes Jfu was robbed! Robbed I tell you!... They put her in the most talented group ever on idol behind Klo and gave her horrible critiques.� Then they embarrassed and confused her into thinking she actually had made the top 12.... LOLS.� (best reaction ever) � Because of this terrible treatment she has put a curse on idol and all who sing her signature song.� Can you imagine the performances that would have followed.� It would have been shear magic and America would have been dancing ever Tuesday.� Where else could a happy singing and dancing soul like Jennifer end up but in the greatest show on earth.� For brining joy to young and old Jfu gets #32...... .....DANCE!....... |
|||
Jessfrogger88 |
|||
|
#31. Vonzell Solomon Vonzell, Baby V, or ... Carol whatever was pretty great.� She was season 4's highest placing diva and she defo filled that niche well.� She was a bit different though, a bit more polished, a little less attitude and she was skinny as a pole.� She rocked it out though.� She had pretty good vocals but not perfect. What she lacked in vocals she made up for in performance and personality.� She would be higher on the list, but there was always something a little bit off for me about baby V.� I liked her a lot, but for some reason I couldn't get behind her as much as others, however she definitely ears her spot at 31. |
|||
SurvivorFanGP |
|||
|
<3 Baby V!
She and Carrie were my favo's that season. Best.comeback.ever. She was first so middle of the pack, but her string of awesome performances really made people start to realize her. <3 |
|||