| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 SurvivorLDog93 |
AI7 TOP12: Rate 1-12 and Brain/Heart/Gut |
Lead | |
|
Posts: 19447 (03/11/08 4:50 PM) Admin/Play-By-Play Guru
|
Thread reopens after the show airs on the east coast.
Remember when doing B/H/G that there will be a Bottom 3 this week. Oh, the drama! The suspense! |
||
|
JRobbed |
|||
|
Posts: 10076 (03/11/08 7:59 PM) Registered User |
1. Jason
2. Michael 3. Chikezie 4. Brooke 5. Syesha 6. Carly 7. Ramiele 8. David H 9. David C 10. David A 11. Kristy 12. Amanda B: Kristy/Amanda/David A H: Kristy/Amanda/David C G: Kristy/David H/Syesha My ratings terrify me - Michael and Chikezie were basically at the bottom last week |
||
|
Gregoire |
|||
|
Posts: 27378 (03/11/08 8:00 PM) Registered user |
1 David Cook 2 Brook 3 Carly 4 Chikeze 5 Saesha 6 Michael Johns 7 Amanda 8 Ramiele 9 Jason 10 Hot Gay Stripper 11 David Archie 12 Kristy Brain -- Kristy/David
A Heart -- Kristy/Amanda Gut -- David Hern / Kristy
|
||
|
meatball77 |
|||
|
Posts: 7722 (03/11/08 8:00 PM) Registered user |
Ramiele going home because she was the most forgettable
|
||
|
mrsbennett |
|||
|
Posts: 882 (03/11/08 8:00 PM) |
1. Carly 2. Jason 3. Brooke 4. Chikezie 5. David C. 6. Ramiele 7. Michael 8-12: Everyone else was horrible. B: Kristy and Chikeze B2 with Chikeze gone H: Kristy and Amanda B2 with Kristy gone G: Kristy and Syesha B2 with Syesha gone |
||
|
Us Kids Know |
|||
|
Posts: 3438 (03/11/08 8:00 PM) Registered user
|
B: Hernandez/Syesha/KKKristy
H: Archuleta/KKKristy/Hernandez G: Ramiele/Hernandez/Amanda? |
||
|
Will |
|||
|
Posts: 28191 (03/11/08 8:01 PM) Not a Registered User anymore |
1.Syesha
2.Amanda 3.Jacuzzi 4. David 5. Jasmine 2.0 6. Michael 7. Irish Bitch 8. Brooke 9. David Cook 10. Dreadlocks 11. KKKristy 12. PorkChop Brain: Castro/KKKristy/Porkchop Heart: Castro/KKKristy/Porkshop GUT: Syesha/Amanda/Jacuzzi |
||
|
Ralph Wiggum for President |
|||
|
Posts: 1383 (03/11/08 8:01 PM) |
1. Brooke
2. Jason Castro 3. Syesha (sad how good she seemed in retrospect) 4. Chikezie (God help me he's this high) 5. MJ 6. Ramiele 7. Irish Plant 8. David Cook (hate him, hated his version) 9. David H. Massive GAP 10. Amanda 11. Devil Child 12. KKKristy B: KKKristy, Amanda, David H-KKKristy gone H: David Cook/Devil Child/Amanda-Devil Child gone G: KKKristy, David H, Ramiele-DAVID H. gone |
||
|
LuckyDuck4U |
Good show! | ||
|
Posts: 355 (03/11/08 8:02 PM) |
The Best...
1. Brooke - LOVED LOVED LOVED her. She looked so professional and soulful. Outstanding. 2. Carly - Very solid performance; she could be touring now too The Good... 3. Rocker David - good performance; very solid 4. Jacuzzi - as much as I can't stand him, he was entertaining and did a good job The So So... 5. Aussiebum- decent, better than last week but sort of dull 6. Dreds - college dorm performances don't belong on American Idol 7. Ramiele - she's cute but that performance was not 8. Syesha - started out bad but got better by the end; karaoke though And the awful... 9. Kristy Lee - at least she took a risk but boy, was that bad 10. Breathy, Manboy David - SUCKED! Anyone who forgets the lyrics should go! 11. Stripper Boy - embarassingly bad; I thought he was a dancer?!?!! 12. Amanda - she's painful to watch and even worse to listen to Brain: Amanda (she'll be saved by the VFTW voters), Stripper Boy, Breathy Manboy David Heart: (a five way tie!) Rocker David, Aussiebum, Jacuzzi, Syesha, Amanda Gut: Kristy Lee, Syesha, Stripper Boy
Last Edited By: LuckyDuck4U
03/11/08 9:00 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
FingerWagginAlicia |
|||
|
Posts: 2359 (03/11/08 8:03 PM) Registered user |
1. Castro
|
||
|
GorillaCheese |
|||
|
Posts: 2 (03/11/08 8:04 PM) |
Chikezie
Jason Brooke David C. Carly Michael Ramiele Amanda David H. Syesha David A. Kristy B: David H./Syesha/Kristy H: Syesha/David A./Kristy G: Ramiele/Syesha/Kristy |
||
|
E Moch |
|||
|
Posts: 417 (03/11/08 8:04 PM) |
1. Carly - Awesome...
2. Brooke - I love her! Another great, genuine performance. 3. Cook - Dark horse, most definitely. 4. Syesha - I guess? I dunno, she just bores me. 5. Chikezie - Strong performance! 6. Ramiele - Good voice, boring performance. 7. Michael - What a completely boring performance. 8 Archuleta - Poor kid. This week, he was in way over his head. 9. Hernandez - Just felt it was definitely a poor performance by him. 10. Castro - God he fucking sucks. 11. Amanda - Her rocket schtick is sooo old. 12. Kristy - Worst performance on Idol ever. Brain: Castro, Amanda, with Kristy going home. Heart: Castro, Amanda, and Kristy...with God intervening and smiting all three of them. But, want Castro off my TV so much. Gut: Amanda, Ramiele, Kristy...with Kristy going home. |
||
|
marathon |
|||
|
Posts: 769 (03/11/08 8:05 PM) Registered user |
David H is in some trouble this week. His best hope is that the judges scared his fans.
And apparently the pimp spot wasn't enough for David A...they also scared his fans on top of that. |
||
|
JFP4Ever |
|||
|
Posts: 181 (03/11/08 8:06 PM) Registered user |
1. Brooke
2. David C 3. Jacuzzi LMAO 4. Amanda LMAO 5. Jason 6. Syesha 7. Kristy 8. Michael 9. Ramiele 10. David H 11. Frog Boy 12. Tattooed Pig B: Kristy/David H/Michael H: Tattoed Pig/Frog Boy/David H G: Kristy/David H/Ramiele |
||
|
GrenadeJumper85 |
|||
|
Posts: 3505 (03/11/08 8:06 PM) |
1. Carly
2. Chikezie 3. Brooke 4. David C. 5. Michael 6. Ramiele 7. Jason 8. David 9. Syesha 10. Amanda 11. KKKRisty 12. David A. Brain: Kristy/David H./Ramiele Boot: David H. Heart: Archie/KKKristy/Jason Boot: Archie Gut: David H./Ramiele/Syesha Boot: David H. |
||
|
LaurenTheLush |
|||
|
Posts: 662 (03/11/08 8:06 PM) |
1. Brooke White
2. Carly Smithson 3. David Cook 4. Chikeze Eze 5. Jason Castro 6. Michael Johns 7. Syesha Mercado 8. David Hernandez 9. Amanda Overmyer 10. Ramiele Malubay 11. Kristy Lee Cook 12. David Archuleta (I like him, but forgetting the words is unforgivable, even if KKKristy sucked). What deserves to happen- Amanda/Kristy/David H What I want to happen- Amanda/Ramiele/Kristy What will actually happen- Amanda/David H/Kristy |
||
|
AwesumCrush00 |
|||
|
Posts: 2263 (03/11/08 8:07 PM) Registered User |
B: Kristy, Amanda, David H.
|
||
|
The Purple Parrot |
|||
|
Posts: 4987 (03/11/08 8:08 PM) Registered user |
The whole show was horrible with Brooke being the only shining moment.
1. Brooke 2. Amanda 3. Carly 4. Jason 5. David C 6. Chikezie (Oh God, I can't believe I'm ranking him this high) 7. Ramiele 8. Syesha 9. Michael 10. Kristy 11. David A 12. David H Go home/bottom 2/bottom 3 B: Kristy/Chikezie/Michael H: Archuletta/Kristy/Chikezie G: Hernandez/Ramiele/Syesha or Kristy |
||
|
static cling |
|||
|
Posts: 2400 (03/11/08 8:08 PM) Registered User |
I miss Alex and Alaina.
1. Carly - not a fan but she's consistently good....this time, she was great 2. Brooke - she's gonna be huge 3. David C - he's gonna be huge GAP 4. Chikezie - I hate his smugness... 5. Ramiele - she doesn't have any range but it was a beautiful song 6. Jason - middling but he's always worth watching GAP 7. Michael - blah...he never does anything interesting or original 8. David A - that was rough but his vocals are still impressive 9. Syesha - yawn 10. Amanda - she does the same thing every week...and she has no charm 11. David H - cheezy and boring 12. Kristy Lee - I actually liked her version but her vocals are so flat and lifeless B: Syesha, Kristy Lee, David H - Syesha goes H: Syesha, Amanda, Chikezie - Syesha goes G: Wouldn't be shocked to see Ramiele fall from grace |
||
|
maximus34998 |
|||
|
Posts: 6 (03/11/08 8:09 PM) |
1. Brooke White
2. Chikezie 3. Carly Smithson 4. David Cook 5. Syesha Mercado 6. Amanda Overmyer 7. David Hernandez 8. Jason Castro 9. Michael Johns 10. Ramiele Malubay 11. Kristy Lee Cook 12. David Archuleta Don't Forget The Lyrics!!! (Does David remember he's on Fox?!?!?!) Brain: Kristy/David H/Ramiele Heart: David A/Kristy/Ramiele Gut: David H/Ramiele/Jason |
||
|
roachc420 |
|||
|
Posts: 281 (03/11/08 8:10 PM) Registered User |
1. Brooke - LOVE
2. David C. - this may or may not be attributed to bias 3. Chickieze - loved the arrangement 4. Amanda - ditto 5. Jason - love him GAP 6. Syesha - I can't remember it 7. Archulizard - it wasn't that bad...wasn't that good either 8. Michael - see above GAP 9. Ramiele - yawn NAP 10. Carly - WTF? 11. David H. - completely unbelievable GRAND CANYON 12. Kristy - I actually have heard (and liked! shhhhh) that version before. She just massacred the shit out of it. B: Kristy H: Carly G: David H. |
||
