Bye Jason Yeager! Bye Luke Menard!
0 Kudo
- Survivor Sucks
- Lions, Tigers, Survivors - Oh My!
- Survivor Spoilers
- MESS Hall Tribal Council
- MESS Hall Archive
- Survivor Speculation
- Survivor 20+
- The Amazing Race
- Big Brother
- Big Brother - PAST SEASONS
- The Apprentice
- American Idol
- American Idol PAST SEASONS
- The Mole
- Lost
- Other Shows That Suck
- Off Topic
- Clubs That Suck. No, Really.
- The Dump
- Monster Island
- Purgatory
- FAQ
- In Memory, 9/11/01
AI7 TOP20 GUYS: Rate 1-10 and Brain/Heart/Gut
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 Merely |
|||
|
Posts: 3012 (02/27/08 1:02 AM) Registered User |
|
||
|
RealityChopper |
|||
|
Posts: 1966 (02/27/08 1:03 AM) Registered User |
1. David H. 2. Chikezie 3. David C. 4. Luke 4. Michael 6. Robbie 7. Jason C. 8. Jason Y. 9. Danny 10. David A.  Send his ass home. HATE.
B: Jason Y./Danny H: Danny/Archuleta
G: Jason Y./Danny |
||
|
UrbanCenter |
|||
|
Posts: 9711 (02/27/08 1:07 AM) Registered User |
1. David Archuleta- excellent
2. Rocker David Cook- excellent 3. Chikeze- very good 4-10. "The Rest"- atrociously bad, differentiating them is pointless, the others were equally godawful Who goes? The two people I've already forgotten. What were their names again??? |
||
|
Its A Flavin |
|||
|
Posts: 18 (02/27/08 1:13 AM) |
1) Archuleta (amazing vocal, complex and controlled. nice interpretation of the song. the whole thing was well played. his lower register is an issue though)
2) Hernandez (I was so shocked by this vocal. It just seemed to come out of nowhere. He was having fun and it was contagious. Easily the first contestant that
I've felt could put on a real concert.) 3) Cook (found him off putting up until now but he really delivered, strong vocal, great stage presence, and the
hair is slowly becoming less painful to look at, if he'd cut it off he might even be kind of cute) 4) Chikezie (I find him really annoying in interview
segments but this was a pretty great performance. he was really aiming to entertain and the vocal was pretty good) 5) Noriega (solid vocal. boring arrangement.
he has the personality to do something more fun later on down the road) 6) Castro (bad song choice, rough vocal. he wouldn't be this high this week if the
competition weren't so weak) 7) Robbie (ugh. he's filler. but he does an okay karaoke rock song) 8) Luke (yes he's pretty, but something about him
as a performer makes me feel un!comfortable!) 9) Jason Y (mediocre vocal, I might hate him less if he got rid of that ridiculous streak) 10) Michael (vocal
alternated between lazy and grating as hell)
|
||
|
dannystultz |
|||
|
Posts: 11508 (02/27/08 2:14 AM) Registered user |
1. David Archuleta
2. David Hernandez: 3. David Cook 4. Chikeze 5. Michael Johns 6. Danny Noriega 7. Jason Castro 8. Robbie Carrico 9. Jason Yeager 10. Luke Menard |
||
|
Houster |
|||
|
Posts: 359 (02/27/08 2:21 AM) Registered User |
1. David Cook: Paul Rodgers was cheering, Simon was insane
2. David Hernandez: Not David Ruffin, Eddie Kendricks, etc., but who is? Just to be able to cut down a 6 minute great song to 2 minutes rates him high. Very good vocal 3. Jason Castro: Cheeseball song, but I thought he was better than the Stooges said he was. A little like Marty Casey doing Britney Spears on "Rockstar" 4. Chikieze: Comeback player of the year 5. Long Johns: Slow, tortured, but handicapped by a lack of a Stevie Nicks 6. Luke Menard: Someone tell Simon: "Freddie Mercury". Nice try, but Luke doesn't have the chops. His Patrick Dempsey-like looks will get him to next week 7. Vinny Barfuleta: I'm sorry, but it was the John Davidson version of "Imagine." I HATE his schmaltzy style, he ruined the song, and he's like a 17 year-old male Melinda Doolittle. And when will he admit that he won $100,000 on Star Search? 8. Danny Boy: Meh, and when he started singing it, I laughed 9. Robbie Carrico: You CANNOT baritone Lou Gramm; only slightly better than the guys on Season 2 of "Beauty And The Geek" 10. Jason Yeager: Viva Las Vegas! Slot machine lounge. Buh-Bye B: Jason Yeager, Luke Menard H: Long Johns, Vinny Barfuleta G: Jason Yeager, Robbie Carrico
Last Edited By: Houster
02/27/08 2:40 AM.
Edited 2 times.
|
||
|
James Barber |
|||
|
Posts: 10816 (02/27/08 3:13 AM) Registered User |
1. David Hernandez -- took a big risk and vocal hiccups aside, it paid off. Much improved in confidence and performance.
2. David Archuleta -- I don't have my hate trained on him yet, so he doesn't bother me. Good singer, seems to know his range. I'll give him a pass on changing the controversial parts of "Imagine" because that could have been the producers. I would ask that he please not sacrifice the emotion of a song for vocal acrobatics, as he unfortunately did tonight. 3. Jason Castro -- weak voice, but this performance was much more entertaining on rewatch; the judges were right about the guitar. 4. Jason Yaeger -- entertaining trainwreck performance; good vocal; nice butt. Too Lawrence Welk, but still better than the judges gave him credit for. 5. Chikeze -- decent performance, and even though Elliott is my favorite ever on AI, I don't think there was anything wrong with Chikeze giving his own spin. His arrogance is still off-putting, even when hidden under attempts at humor. 6. Danny Noriega -- got attention last week for his freak show moments and bickering with Simon; apparently frightened enough by the experience to take the safest road possible and focus attention on his very limited vocal ability. Bad idea. 7. David Cook -- completely average in every way except ego. I do have to congratulate him on the "me smart, me knows big words" video segment, as it replaced Ace's "I wear beanies" segment for most self-conscious, narcissistic video package ever. 8. Luke Menard -- dumb song choice, bad voice. 9. Michael Johns -- if you're going to shout out of tune, why would you pick a song from one of the best selling albums of all time? Forget Lindsey Buckingham, he's a worse singer than Lindsey Lohan. 10. Robbie -- bound and determined to show us K-Fed is not Britney's least talented ex. Let's turn a classic Foreigner song into a plodding, confused bog. Wretched. He's also defensive as hell. Go away. I think Danny and Jason Yaeger or Robbie will be leaving. |
||
|
Lovejonze |
|||
|
Posts: 4961 (02/27/08 6:29 AM) Registered User |
1. David Archuleta-the only one to completely hold my attention and didn't hit any bad notes
|
||
|
Hillary Wallbanger |
|||
|
Posts: 195 (02/27/08 6:46 AM) |
1. David Archuleta
2. David Hernandez: 3. David Cook big gap the ones below was total crap and not necessarily in that order 4. Chikeze 5. Michael Johns 6. Danny Noriega 7. Jason Castro 8. Robbie Carrico 9. Jason Yeager 10. Luke Menard |
||
|
mrsbennett |
|||
|
Posts: 866 (02/27/08 7:27 AM) |
1. David Hernandez 2. David Cook 3. Chikieze 4. David A. 5. Michael Johns 6. Robbie 7. Jason C 8. Danny N. 9. Luke 10. Jason Y BHG: Luke and Jason |
||
|
Apprentice Talker |
|||
|
Posts: 3027 (02/27/08 7:29 AM) WRP Official Spokesperson |
1. David H
2. David A 3. Robbie 4. Chikezie - very good performance, judges finally loved him 5. Michael 6. Jason C 7. Danny 8. David C 9. Luke - has many pitch problems 10. Jason Y - hated by all judges B: David H/David A H: Robbie/Chikezie G: Michael/Jason C |
||
|
SurvivorLDog93 |
|||
|
Posts: 19259 (02/27/08 7:35 AM) Admin/Play-By-Play Guru
|
I'm sorry, but it was the John Davidson version of "Imagine." I HATE his schmaltzy style, he ruined the song, and he's like a 17 year-old male Melinda Doolittle. And when will he admit that he won $100,000 on Star Search? Sad, but true! 
|
||
|
8trackmind |
|||
|
Posts: 41 (02/27/08 9:22 AM) I demand attention! |
I'll just pick my best and worst. I thought it was a very good night overall. The two best people last week were the worst this week. 1. David Hernandez-
Best of the night. He belongs in the top twelve. 9. Fidel's Grandson- Terrible Andy Gibb song (actually, ALL Andy Gibb songs are); flat voice, mediocre
performance overall. 10. Michael Johns- Harsh and unpleasant vocals. Vastly worse than anything he did before. It's still early, but seeing this reminded
me of Tamyra's first performance on top 4 night when she was voted off and Katherine McPhee's deservedly bottom two screech on top 10 night two years
ago. I'm sure he'll survive, but he's thrown away his frontrunner status. I think Jason Yeager and Luke Menard both did pretty well, but are
probably gone tomorrow. They weren't heard before last week, weren't good last week and the judges just don't like them. Two good singers have
offstage problems: David Cook (egomania) and Danny (incredibly gay speaking voice that even tweens who think he's cute will pick up on).
|
||
 NiceToAnimals |
|||
|
Posts: 8947 (02/27/08 10:13 AM) Registered User |
1. David Archuleta
2. Chikezie 3. David Hernandez 4. David Cook 5. Jason Castro 6. Robbie Carrico 7. Danny Noriega 8. Michael Johns 9. Luke Menard 10. Jason Yeager Brain: Luke and Jason Y. Heart: Luke and Jason Y. Gut: Jason Y. and Robbie |
||
|
LedbetterYellow |
|||
|
Posts: 12 (02/27/08 10:33 AM) Registered User |
1. David H. - overly theatrical. but one of the best vocalists.
2. David A. - like Pauler said, I could hang him from my rearview mirror. 3. Johns - mostly due to the pants bulge. 4. Castro - reminds me of Jack Johnson. 5. David C. - give the kid a break. he's emo for goodness sakes. ;) 6. Noriega - ISH! 7 - 9. - Jaccuzi, Luke, and Jeagermeister - meh. 10. Robbie - There's nothing I hate more than creed/nickelback/daughtry FAKE-ASS ROCKERS. I didn't get to vote due to idiot boyfriend issues, so I'm not going to put in an opinion on who's going home. |
||
|
BarbH918 |
Going Home | ||
|
Posts: 998 (02/27/08 1:00 PM) Registered user |
As long as 1) Jason Yeager - god I hate really smiley people and 2) Luke Menard - Good looking clean cut men can't sing Freddie Mercury - go home it
doesn't matter how the others ranked.
|
||
|
Brad Lascelle |
|||
|
Posts: 593 (02/27/08 1:39 PM) Registered user |
1. David Hernandez
2. David Archuleta (the winner? already? I guess this isn't such a talented group after all...) 3. Chikezie Eze 4. David Cook 5. Robbie Carrico 6. Michael Johns (too old for Idol) 7. Luke Menard (too old for Idol) 8. Jason Castro 9. Jason Yeager (too old for Idol, fake, should be in dental commercials, dead man walking) 10. Danny Noriega (make the hurting stop) BRAIN - Luke Menard / Jason Yeager HEART - Danny Noriega / Jason Yeager GUT - Luke Menard / Jason Yeager TOP 6 PREDICTION - Danny, David A., David C., David H., Jason C., Michael (too many damn Davids) = Brad Lascelle |
||
|
Heliox |
GOING HOME | ||
|
Posts: 424 (02/27/08 1:42 PM) |
 
Luke Menard ............................................................and Jason Yeager |
||
- Survivor Sucks
- Lions, Tigers, Survivors - Oh My!
- Survivor Spoilers
- MESS Hall Tribal Council
- MESS Hall Archive
- Survivor Speculation
- Survivor 20+
- The Amazing Race
- Big Brother
- Big Brother - PAST SEASONS
- The Apprentice
- American Idol
- American Idol PAST SEASONS
- The Mole
- Lost
- Other Shows That Suck
- Off Topic
- Clubs That Suck. No, Really.
- The Dump
- Monster Island
- Purgatory
- FAQ
- In Memory, 9/11/01
