| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
spnintendo |
|||
|
PIownage. 100% agreed about that. <3
|
|||
A Dying Clown |
|||
My only complaint with PI is a very superficial one, from a hot girls standpoint I'd probably rank it 16th out of 16 seasons. No women there I found particularly attractive. :PSame with me (and TAR2. Easily the best season, but no real female eye-candy). Guatemala has the hottest female cast ever, tho, by a long margin. |
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
spnintendo wrote: Zoe got a penis, Cat got a pussy.
|
|||
Edinboro |
|||
|
Eew at the top 3.
|
|||
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 3394 (05/02/08 10:12 AM) Registered user |
A Dying Clown wrote: Disagree on both counts. I understand how important the downfall of the Rotu 4 is to you guys, but it really put a bad taste in my mouth.I think vecepia is a very worthy winner,shes underestimated, but the boot order was unappealing to me. Also, Boston Rob and Sean, who were great characters had no chance at winning to begin with, and that bothers me. Second, Panama had a decent final 2. Danielle was a goat EVERYONE wanted to take to the end, so she would of been there no matter what. Aras is a good winner. We can debate about who would win in an Aras/Cirie f2 situation, but you have to give the guy credit that he did infact have a plan to beat Cirie(that fact that he thought he would lose to her notwithstanding. He didn't PLAN to lose to her, he just thought hypothetically it could happen).And he was interesting,in a fruitcake kind of way |
||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
92. James Clement (Survivor: China - 7th Place & Survivor: Micronesia - 7th Place) At the start of China, I liked James, because he was a lovable and a hard worker. He was a dominator in pretty much every challenge his tribe competed in, and he was basically the main reason that Zhan Hu couldn't win anything, because none of them could compare to him. But then by episode 3, James started rubbing me the wrong way. He was buddies with Jean-Robert, and he started saying some mean things about Leslie while she'd been kidnapped. He acted somewhat chauvanist, because he was one of those plyers that seemed to think strength was everything, and if you weren't strong, you were useless. James proved to be little more than a challenge hog, because he basically had no idea how to think strategically, and even Todd had to personally explain to him how to use the immunity idol properly, going into the final, pre-merge tribal council. After the merge, James was sitting pretty because Fei Long had a majority alliance, and he had two immunity idols in his possession. Of course, because he wasn't the brightest bulb in the box, he never even thought to play one of them, and he was the first person to ever get voted out while holding onto an immunity idol. The main reason why I rank him as high as I did was because he hardly seemed bitter when he was voted out, like a lot of the stronger players are. He was pretty humble about it, actually, and he was nice in his final jury question. So basically James was just a good guy at the beginning, and good guy at the end, and those somewhat made up for his bad middle. In Micronesia, James hadn't really changed much. He had his little relationship with Parvati and his alliance with Amanda and Ozzy, but other than that, he was pretty much the same, chauvanistic guy. He only really gets a boost in his overall ranking because of the fact that, this season, he wasn't shoved down our throats. He wasn't the heroic challenge God that could never lose. He was just a regular contestant that gave funny confessionals and ate bats. Still, he's an idiot with all his talk of "not eating the apple" (aka, making strategic moves). If only he could've been voted out instead of being medevaced, that would've been awesome. |
|||
Quiddity |
|||
Second, Panama had a decent final 2. Danielle was a goat EVERYONE wanted to take to the end, so she would of been there no matter what. Aras is a good winner. We can debate about who would win in an Aras/Cirie f2 situation, but you have to give the guy credit that he did infact have a plan to beat Cirie(that fact that he thought he would lose to her notwithstanding. He didn't PLAN to lose to her, he just thought hypothetically it could happen).And he was interesting,in a fruitcake kind of way X. Panama's F2 wasn't as bad as others think in my mind. I would have vomitted if Terry, a guy who got by solely because he was stronger than everyone else (winning him many challenges tilted in his favor) won the game despite being one of the stupidist strategic players ever. I was rooting for Danielle all season so can't say I was dissappointed in the F2, other than the final outcome of course. The one thing I gotta clarify though is that Danielle didn't become a goat until Courtney and Shane were voted out. EVERYONE did not want to take her to F2 at F6 and F5. And if you'll remember, Aras and Cirie tried to vote her out at F4, so you can hardly say hey wanted to take her to F2 then, it was just Terry. |
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
212. Alexis Jones (Survivor: Micronesia - 6th Place) Going into this write-up, I knew that there was no way I could rank Alexis more than ten spots away from Becky & Jenn. She was the same exact type of player. No personality, basically just young, eye-candy that rides coattails as long as she can. And that's another thing. Compared to Jenn and Becky, Alexis wasn't even that hot. She looked like a stoner homeless person, aka, a female Jason Castro. She winds up ranking below both Becky AND Jenn mainly because when she wasn't completely ignored, she was basically bitchy and unpleasant, yet she has this dellusional view of herself. When she was voted off, she said that Amanda and Parvati betrayed her. Parvati SAID she couldn't vote for Amanda, and she voted for Amanda herself! Alexis sucked so bad and it would've been a crying shame if she made it to the end and won. |
|||
YemaGrl1988 |
|||
|
^ Hahaha. Remember she got a 'key' confessional in edgic and went INV ever since and people still thought she would win? Ha. Alexis was not needed. In
fact James had more airtime than she did in the last episode!
I don't see the hype in Danni honestly (but most don't see the hype in Vee so I guess I can't argue too much) Oh and the fact that Rupert is in the middle where most winners usually are bugs me. |
|||
Dan Down Under |
|||
|
SeaHag hatred!
|
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
|
I'm hoping a higher rank for Catalie but I know that Kitty hates Catalie.
|
|||
Level 5 |
|||
|
But at least hatred makes you feel something towards the person. Alexis is in a pretty close race with Mary Who for the most pointless casting mistake of the
season.
|
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
|
We cannot say that Mary Who's casting is pointless since we only see her for 2 episodes. What if she lasted for 20 or 36 days, maybe she can be an
interesting player too. She can show off her boobs to Ozzy or Mikey B and let Kathy play with her nipples, ya know?
|
|||
Zesty66 |
|||
|
Actually from watching the insider clips and Mary's day after video, she seemed like she could have been a good player. Very smart and strategic.
|
|||
Mister Plum |
|||
|
I agree based on her post show interviews too.
|
|||
solesurvivor01 |
|||
|
As Catalie even said in one of her preshow interviews that she was an introvert, I would easily label her as the biggest casting mistake this season. Anyways,
Kitty, do you have any plans to rank anything else? I would lurve to see more.
|
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
Sooooo disappointed with Alexis' edit this season.
|
|||
Bobby Jon goes apeshit |
|||
|
Alexis was a HUGE disappointment indeed.
|
|||
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
I think my next rankings will be the top 32 best moments in Battlebots.
|
|||
hippo2002 |
|||
Bobby Jon goes apeshit wrote:
|
|||