Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
CSCin3D		#2001	[-]
Posts: 11982 (05/19/09 12:22 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	JT's "win" is a special case. There has never been a season where people were ACTIVELY TRYING to make someone else win. Call the Thailand or Borneo casts stupid, but they all wanted to win and were playing for themselves. The Tocantins cast was loaded up with millionaires and people who just wanted to look good for the cameras, so they didn't care about winning. JT probably went around telling some sob story about his father dying or whatever to get sympathy.
Mikester		#2002	[-]
Posts: 2360 (05/19/09 12:22 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	JT is a good winner, but what makes someone "the best" is all a matter of opinion. The fact that he never got voted and won unanimously is impressive, yeah, but I still think it's part of the bias that comes with the f2. Sierra & Debbie even said they were impressed with how much Stephen was running the game, and I think Stephen definitely had more influence on how he & JT voted than JT did. Still, JT gets more credit because people liked him more and he was a big strong alpha male. CsCin3D wrote: JT's "win" is a special case. There has never been a season where people were ACTIVELY TRYING to make someone else win. Call the Thailand or Borneo casts stupid, but they all wanted to win and were playing for themselves. The Tocantins cast was loaded up with millionaires and people who just wanted to look good for the cameras, so they didn't care about winning. JT probably went around telling some sob story about his father dying or whatever to get sympathy. So true.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#2003	[-]
Posts: 7993 (05/19/09 12:33 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	At best, JT can be considered a mid tier player. I agree with ADC that his charm contributed towards people activly wanting him to win, which says a lot about his social game for one thing. Second, he was a good challenge winner. My criteria for winners would put him around Danni Boatwrights level, square in the middle.
Kitty Pryde1		#2004	[-]
Posts: 9598 (05/19/09 12:38 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Except Danni is the second-best winner, not middle tier.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#2005	[-]
Posts: 7994 (05/19/09 12:54 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Only if you believe Social Game>Strategic Game>Physical Game. Danni played very well pre merge, and then was stuck at the mercy of Rafe. He easily could have booted her at the final 4 and still win the jury vote. I compared her to JT because they both charmed the cast enough to get the win, but there is nothing to show that they do well under adversity.
Kitty Pryde1		#2006	[-]
Posts: 9599 (05/19/09 12:55 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Uh, how about overcoming tremendous odds to make the finals and win? JT, Danni and Chris are the top three winners of all time because of the odds they overcome.
Joaqenix		#2007	[-]
Posts: 4121 (05/19/09 1:36 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	But Danni was also a boring wench, which can't be ignored. I literally couldn't tell you one interesting thing about Danni or that Danni did.
Kitty Pryde1		#2008	[-]
Posts: 9601 (05/19/09 1:43 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Joaqenix wrote: But Danni was also a boring wench, which can't be ignored. I literally couldn't tell you one interesting thing about Danni or that Danni did. This is a ranking of winners based on gameplay, not based on entertainment. Parvati doesn't make the top five either way.
Mikester		#2009	[-]
Posts: 2363 (05/19/09 1:56 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Parvati is in my top 5 <3 Parvati > Danni JT > Danni
A Dying Clown		#2010	[-]
Posts: 9680 (05/19/09 2:03 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I literally couldn't tell you one interesting thing about Danni or that Danni did. She was plucky heroine who defeated the foul dragon Steph, even after all her allies had been slain <3 I think she's one of the better winners both strategically and likeability-wise, but her luck with the Final 6 immunity was definitely crucial - if she'd survived without it, she'd definitely be one of the Top 3 best.
JackSparrowBauer		#2011	[-]
Posts: 1128 (05/19/09 2:52 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Dr Will Hatch two point oh wrote: Only if you believe Social Game>Strategic Game>Physical Game. Danni played very well pre merge, and then was stuck at the mercy of Rafe. He easily could have booted her at the final 4 and still win the jury vote. I compared her to JT because they both charmed the cast enough to get the win, but there is nothing to show that they do well under adversity. did you miss the part where she voted out Blake because his stories were annoying? Props to Danni for the odds she overcame, but lots of her game was flying under the radar, when Steph stuck her neck out and took risks the entire time, plus she was a returning player who had a HUGE target on her back, so her game is more impressive to me. Danni is a decent winner, but definitely not top-tier. She got Stephowned just like the rest of the Guatemala cast.
Joaqenix		#2012	[-]
Posts: 4122 (05/19/09 2:53 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kitty Pryde1 wrote: Joaqenix wrote: But Danni was also a boring wench, which can't be ignored. I literally couldn't tell you one interesting thing about Danni or that Danni did. This is a ranking of winners based on gameplay, not based on entertainment. Parvati doesn't make the top five either way. Is she #6? <3
Kitty Pryde1		#2013	[-]
Posts: 9604 (05/19/09 2:54 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Joaqenix wrote: Kitty Pryde1 wrote: Joaqenix wrote: But Danni was also a boring wench, which can't be ignored. I literally couldn't tell you one interesting thing about Danni or that Danni did. This is a ranking of winners based on gameplay, not based on entertainment. Parvati doesn't make the top five either way. Is she #6? <3 Entertainment...possibly. Gameplay...no chance in hell.
JackSparrowBauer		#2014	[-]
Posts: 1129 (05/19/09 2:57 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Parvati is a g.oddess and she played an awesome game <3.
srvivrfreakevelrich		#2015	[-]
Posts: 1236 (05/19/09 3:05 PM) Admin Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	JackSparrowBauer wrote: Parvati is a g.oddess and she played an awesome game <3. I second that motion I still dont agree with the fact the JT is the #1 winner. He didnt even think of what couldve been a game changer, the Tyson boot. But I would put him in the top 5 for strategy alone.
A Dying Clown		#2016	[-]
Posts: 9682 (05/19/09 3:27 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	did you miss the part where she voted out Blake because his stories were annoying? Nakum still had the numbers and it got rid of merge threat who Danni wasn't particular close to Steph booting Judd would be enough to make her one of the worst endgame players ever. Then she booted Lydia and became easily the worst end-game player ever.
Joaqenix		#2017	[-]
Posts: 4124 (05/19/09 3:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kitty Pryde1 wrote: Joaqenix wrote: Kitty Pryde1 wrote: Joaqenix wrote: But Danni was also a boring wench, which can't be ignored. I literally couldn't tell you one interesting thing about Danni or that Danni did. This is a ranking of winners based on gameplay, not based on entertainment. Parvati doesn't make the top five either way. Is she #6? <3 Entertainment...possibly. Gameplay...no chance in hell. I hope one day you get over your Parvealousy Kitty! ^_^
RunawayJuror		#2018	[-]
Posts: 193 (05/19/09 4:51 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CSCin3D wrote: JT's "win" is a special case. There has never been a season where people were ACTIVELY TRYING to make someone else win. Call the Thailand or Borneo casts stupid, but they all wanted to win and were playing for themselves. The Tocantins cast was loaded up with millionaires and people who just wanted to look good for the cameras, so they didn't care about winning. JT probably went around telling some sob story about his father dying or whatever to get sympathy. According to an Erinn interview, J.T. told everyone he was going to use the money for college funds for his nieces, nephews, and siblings and then if there was any money left over he might buy a truck. J.T. was definitely a deserving winner but I agree his competition was not up to par with some of the other seasons.
Katy Carney		#2019	[-]
Posts: 6120 (05/19/09 5:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	JT was handed victory and he never really played the game at all. He's not even that big of an immunity threat. He's an average guy with a southern accent and the latter is why he won.
Us Kids Know		#2020	[-]
Posts: 10562 (05/19/09 5:53 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Your season writeup = spot on, though I honestly might place the season at the very bottom. Ew @ JT #1, I would only put him above Yul and maybe a few others (Vee/Danni/Aras), blech. But you know me.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Kitty's Rankings (S18 Players, Merged Tribe, Winner, Season Ranked!)

Quick Reply