The next day, the challenge was to take place in the middle of the sea. The same boat that abandoned them on the island came to fetch them right
at the moment that the sun came out. Jeff waited for them on a platform with a covered-up table at his side and a huge grin on his face. "Welcome",
he said, "to our first challenge."
Even though it was so cold they didn't get any sleep last night, and even though they were a bit angry at the producers for marooning them with nothing,
they couldn't help but cheer and clap their hands to show their excitement. It was, after all, an adventure of a lifetime, and they all got a chance to go
through it twice. They all truly felt lucky at the moment.
Jeff approached them. "Dreamz, how is it so far?"
"Miserable, Jeff, thank you very much!"
They laughed, even though crying would have been appropriate as well.
"Yeah, we weren't exactly easy on you guys, huh? Well, you did sign up for an all-star season, so it shouldn't surprise you that we don't give
you everything right away. You will have a chance to earn something today that will make life at camp much easier, but we'll get to that later.
Right now we have an immunity challenge to get to.
"You will be randomly divided into two teams, each with an even number of men and women. Both teams will take their place on the balance beam-" he
pointed to another, thinner, platform a few feet from him, "-and hold on to a rope. It will be a simple tug-of-war game, which requires strength, favoring
the men, and balance, favoring the women. The team that makes all the other team-members fall into the water, or lose their hold on the rope, wins, even if
only one of the winning team stays on the platform, holding the rope. If you fall into the water with the rope, you're still out. It's as simple as
that. Once we have a winning team of eight, we split this team into two new teams of four, and so on, until we're left with only one man and one woman to
battle it out. Everybody clear on the rules?"
They all nodded. Jeff then divided them by pulling their names out of two bags, so that the teams would have the same amount of males and females in them. When
he finished, on one side of the beam stood Terry, Twila, Rafe, Yau man, Cirie, Ian, Eliza and Katie, and on the other - Tom, Courtney, Jonathan, Julie, Cindy,
Ami, Dreamz and Shane.
Both teams held on to their ropes, and exchanged whispers concerning their tactics for the challenge. Both teams placed their strongest members - Terry and
Tom, respectively - in the rear, and their women at the front.
When he looked at those 16 children, excited to compete again, Jeff's strong opinions against an all-star season softened a little. He had a feeling it was
going to be a different experience than the last. When he raised his hand to signal the start of the competition, he felt a little excited himself.
"Survivors ready?" he shouted, and when they all nodded, looking fiercely into the other team's eyes - "GO!"
The rope probably didn't have a very enjoyable time when the challenge had begun. Each team hoped that if they pulled hard enough right at the start, the
other team would lose control - but because both teams gave it their all right away, the position of the rope barely changed.
"And… pull! And… pull!", Eliza ordered her team, as she was the one at the front. They had a consistent rhythm and it seemed to work - the other team
was getting nearer and nearer to the golden-marked center of the balance beam. But for some reason, the other team didn't seem concerned about that at all…
the reason for that was soon discovered, when Tom revealed his team's plan from the back of the pack: "ready? One... Two… THREE!"
At Tom's mark, the eight of them gave it all they got - they were clearly keeping their best
efforts for that moment alone. The other team didn't expect that - half of them lost their hold of the rope, and fell into the water due to the strength of
the pull. Only the four women of the team - Twila, Cirie, Eliza and Katie - still remained holding on to the rope, but even they knew they had no chance
whatsoever. And in a few seconds, despite trying their best, it was over - The other eight were too strong together, and the whole rope was eventually on their
side. Twila was the last one to hold on to it, but it was no use. Down in the water, Terry eyed Tom and splashed the water in anger. He wasn't used to be
taken out so early.
The winning team was then divided into two new teams, which consisted of Shane, Julie, Shane and Dreamz against Courtney, Jonathan, Ami and Tom. Again, the
strongest member was positioned behind, with Dreamz now taking the place of Terry.
Again, some whispers were exchanged. And again, Jeff asked them if they're ready, and then ordered them to begin the battle.
To everyone's surprise, Tom, Jonathan, Courtney and Ami didn't seem to try and win it this time - they let the other team slowly get more and more of
the rope to their side. But then -
"One", Tom said.
And the other team quickly realized that the trick used last time was to be used once more, this time on them.
"Two…"
"Hold on tight!" demanded Shane, ready to pull as hard as
he could.
"THREE!"
But Shane was completely wrong: instead of pulling the rope with all their effort, the other team simply let go of it - sending the four people that still held
tight to the rope right into the ocean. "Well", ruled Jeff, "I did state that once you're in the water, you're out. I'm sorry,
Shane, Cindy, Dreamz, Julie."
Jeff said it so matter-of-factly, that Julie looked at him in surprise from the icy water. She was the one who asked him to treat her like any other in this
game, but nothing could have prepared her for the way it felt.
It was now down to Ami and Tom competing against Jonathan and Courtney. It was easy to predict who would win this time, there was no suspense whatsoever. The
round began, and both teams pulled, but Ami and Tom simply pulled harder, and it took no time for the entire rope to reach their end, despite Courtney's
and Jonathan's best efforts.
It was down to two. Tom sized up his competition. Ami was clearly not as strong, but she did have a better chance to outlast him on the balance beam, as it was
only about three feet wide. If she succeeds in off-balancing him, that'll be it.
"Survivors ready?"
No, survivors not ready, thought Ami. How could I be ready against Tom?!
"GO!"
Ami positioned herself safely on the beam, with her knees a little bent, and pulled harder than ever. Tom, however, did something different. He sat himself on
the beam, wrapped the rope around his upper body and started advancing towards the golden line signaling the middle. Ami wasn't ready for it, but adjusted
quickly. She pulled the rope as intensely as she could to one side, trying to make Tom lose his balance. But Tom was settled so firmly on the beam he was
almost a part of it. He gave a stronger-than-usual pull and Ami, unable to keep her balance and keeping a strong hold on the rope at the same time, gave him
the opportunity to pull it all to his side. It was over, and the inevitable occurred - Tom won.
The immunity necklace, uglier than ever with a huge, dried-out sea-star in the middle, was put around Tom's neck by Jeff, who was congratulating him along
with the others. Ami gave him a hug and told him he deserved it. They were all ready to make their way back to their island when Jeff spoke.
"There is one more thing." He removed the cover from the table at his side and revealed items that made the players gasp. "Tom, you won immunity
fair and square, but you have a decision to make. Before you, are a pot for boiling water, a machete and a huge bag full of edible potatoes. You have a chance
to reward your tribemates with one of these items - if you give up your immunity."
Nobody spoke. It was hard for them, especially for Shane who wanted to shout: "The potatoes! Take the potatoes!" but nobody spoke. It had to be
Tom's decision.
Tom didn't speak at first either. He had a big chance of going home, and yet, if he keeps the immunity he deprives his tribemates from necessities
and shows his new alliance-members he doesn't trust them. If he keeps the immunity this time, he'll need it every time from now on.
"Jeff, there's really no question. Obviously I'm gonna keep it."
...





