Rank the Winners

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
JaMalle	Re: Rank the Winners	#81	[-]
Posts: 4862 (05/03/06 6:37 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	*Quote:* Oh yeah, definitely the worst jury performance in the show's history No way she was the worst. Sandra passes her by far. She never mentioned her as an outcast. Maybe she didn't need to, but she failed to use all the ammo she had against Lil. Brian also ROYALLY screwed up, and I would have been quite happy if all the work he did failed because he didn't know how to suck up. Only reason he WON the jury was because of one thing: Clay not answering Helen's question. Brian's performance sucked. Neleh also had a bad jury performance (worse than Danni's). I thought Neleh had it all sewn up against V. Guess bad jury perfromance can really kill you.
SurvivorFanGP	Re: Rank the Winners	#82	[-]
Posts: 11980 (05/03/06 7:02 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Vee had it in the bag against Neleh, it was pretty obvious..the Rotu 4 were obviously going to vote based on their bitterness of Neleh/Pascal betraying them. Vee was never a part of the original Rotu in the 1st place, so they didn't blame her for saving her ass and not getting voted off at 8th, after Sean. I don't remember why Zoe voted for Neleh, but 3 bitter Rotu + Sean, the obvious vote, = Vecepia crushing Neleh in front of the Jury.
chapera rocks	Re: Rank the Winners	#83	[-]
Posts: 12364 (05/03/06 9:29 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The Vee-Neleh vote was actually up in the air. Apparently Robert was very up in the air and he was the deciding vote. Also, there was a possibility of Neleh getting John's vote had she appologized - although she shouldn't have because he's a big baby.
beatles20147	Re: Rank the Winners	#84	[-]
Posts: 12613 (05/04/06 4:19 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	^ Well if it's the difference of $900,000, then she should have apologized.
chapera rocks	Re: Rank the Winners	#85	[-]
Posts: 12364 (05/04/06 4:22 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	True, but what I mean is that John is a big baby for even wanting an apology. I should have said "Although she shouldn't have had to appologize..." He didn't even outright say it - and he's somewhat of a hypocrite. He wanted Vee to say "I pwned you all, and did what I had to do to win the game" yet wanted Neleh to say "I'm so sorry John [for pwning you all and doing what I had to do to win the game]!! One of the reasons I hate John.
JaMalle	Re: Rank the Winners	#86	[-]
Posts: 4862 (05/04/06 4:34 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	*Quote:* He didn't even outright say it - and he's somewhat of a hypocrite. He wanted Vee to say "I pwned you all, and did what I had to do to win the game" yet wanted Neleh to say "I'm so sorry John [for pwning you all and doing what I had to do to win the game]!! X Though, I must admit that I thought Neleh was a lil prissy bitch. Should have had the votes though.
philipsach1	Re: Rank the Winners	#87	[-]
Posts: 4 (05/04/06 4:35 PM) I don't get most of the jokes Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	This is a tough one to list, since you have to look at the competition for each winner, since no cast was alike. But for me, in terms of game play: 1. Tina 2. Tom 3. Richard 4. Brian 5. Jenna 6. Danni 7. Sandra 8. Amber 9. Vecepia 10. Ethan 11. Chris
FatalPosporos	Re: Rank the Winners	#88	[-]
Posts: 748 (05/05/06 1:47 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Rich 2. Tina 3. Brian 4. Jenna 5. Danni 6. Sandra 7. Tom 8. Vecepia 9. Chris 10. Ethan 11. Amber
TayBerry	Re: Rank the Winners	#89	[-]
Posts: 2 (05/06/06 8:12 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	11. Amber...why the heck was she even on this season??? 10. Vecepia 9. Chris 8. Ethan 7. Tom 6. Danni 5.Jenna 4. Sandra 3. Rich 2. Tina 1. Brian- did not like him but he had everyone eating out of the palm of his hand.
GretchenIsMyGod	Re: Rank the Winners	#90	[-]
Posts: 3182 (05/07/06 5:47 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	i'm surprised nobody has compiled everyone's rankings and given a general ranking based on every winner's average ranking
dannystultz	Re: Rank the Winners	#91	[-]
Posts: 12475 (05/07/06 5:55 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Dawnie's back. Highwind is going wet himself.
JaMalle	Re: Rank the Winners	#92	[-]
Posts: 4862 (05/08/06 8:58 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	*Quote:* i'm surprised nobody has compiled everyone's rankings and given a general ranking based on every winner's average ranking You go through the 5 pages. lol Eh, maybe I'll do it. Or maybe I'll just be lazy and not.
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor	Re: Rank the Winners	#93	[-]
Posts: 6459 (05/08/06 9:18 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	It's not worth the effort if Lord and Master isn't first in the rankings. Plus, this thread isn't really specific on whether we're listing by how they played or how we liked them.
JaMalle	Re: Rank the Winners	#94	[-]
Posts: 4862 (05/08/06 9:46 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Because I have no life, and I love math, I did the averages. I didn't include votes including likability or Rupert. 1. Rich 2.77 2. Tina 3.27 3. Brian 3.54 4. Tom 4.90 5. Sandra 6.09 6. Danni 6.13 7. Jenna 6.41 8. Vecepia 7.05 9. Ethan 7.95 10. Amber 8.27 11. Chris 9.45 Danni/Sandra are almost interchangable. Lamber and Chris sucked. lol
KFlame220	Re: My Ranking	#95	[-]
Posts: 333 (05/08/06 10:48 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'll go by my wht I have read, personal preference, and remembered. I forget what some did to win. 1. Brian - Just plain cool, great player 2. Rich- the original, and started the method of playing the game 3. Amber- She played well, riding Rob and helping make decisions 4. Chris- outlasted the women, could say that he pagonged the 5. Tom- a powerhouse 6. Ethan- I am not sure where to put him, dont really remember Africa, but I dont think he pissed anyone off 7. Vecepia- helped overthrow the Rotu 4 8. Jenna- convinced the jury, even though Rob helped her win 9. Danni- Came back from the chopping block, aligned with the right people 10. Tina- I am not sure what she did to win 11. Sandra- UTR, did not do anything note worthy, and not one of my favorites
Osten Carty	Re: My Ranking	#96	[-]
Posts: 3990 (05/08/06 11:30 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Hatch - Prince Maciavelli couldn't have created a more murderous coup. 2. Lord and Master Heidik - So masterful and controlling, he nearly ruined the show (but that didn't happen until Boston Rob copied Heidik's method). Carried his entire tribe from start to finish. 3. Tom - Had Koror working like clockwork. It was simply set up for him to win. 4. Jenna - Underrated, but still had a large amount of power for much of the game. She came across as spoiled, but she put up good numbers in the clutch and played suprisingly smart. 5. Danni Boatwright - Another strong player who had an unfair edit. She was always in power in Nakum and had some sort of mind control over Gary and Brandon and Bobby Jon. Her navigation of Xhakum post merge was also impressive. 6. Ethan - It was Lex's game to win, and he lost 2 votes to freakin' Kim Johnson 7. Tina - Thanks to Tagi, sticking with your tribe was in style, but much of her game is credited to the Colbster. 8. Sandra - Fairly safe smart under the radar victory. 9. Vecepia - On paper, she looks fine, as the one who did the subtle things they couldn't show on TV, but in the end she feels empty. 10. Fat Fuck Chris - Retarded strategy in the beginning. Incredibly lucky that everyone thought he was just a big fat girl. Why oh why couldn't him and Royry have switched places. 11. Boston Amber - Why they put her on all-stars, one will never know. Outback had lots of young girls in allstars, the bitchy one, the tough one and Amber, the dumb one. She did what she knows best and follow. Mariano did what he knows best and fuck girls. And the rest is survivor history.
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor	Re: My Ranking	#97	[-]
Posts: 6459 (05/09/06 4:15 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think the user average is pretty on target...........The Big Five (Richard/Tina/Brian/Sandra/Tom) should all be in the Top 5, with Sandra unquestionably being the weakest of the bunch. I agree with Danni being in sixth place.....her only real mistake was the booting of Blake. Had they kept him and had the numbers at merge, she probably would have finagled her way to the end and won anyway. Jenna fits in with Danni as the other middle of the line player. No huge fuck ups like the people below her on the list (she pretty much would've won anyway if Rob hadn't done a power move at F7).......helped a great deal by a female favoring final challenge (not that there haven't been male favoring challenges in the past, such as Thailand and Vanuatu)....... Vecepia in eighth makes perfect sense......voting for Neleh at F4 was a big fuck up (should've voted for Kathy.....then Paschal would've collapsed in the final challenge, and she would've only needed to outlast lil' Neleh.....purple rock saved her ass). Still, her mistake isn't as bad as Chris saving Julie/Twila and voting out Julie at F5 (which made it so he had to win the F4 immunity) or Ethan going along with Lex's shenanigans (voting out Clarence/Kelly). And Amber should be last instead of Chris. Because All Stars just didn't count.
TheLurkerSpeaks	Re: My Ranking	#98	[-]
Posts: 1503 (05/09/06 7:47 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1 Tina 2 Rich 3 Tom 4 Brian 5 Danni 6 Vecepia 7 Sandra 8 Jenna 9 Chris 10 Ethan 11 Amber
veeisforvictory	Re: My Ranking	#99	[-]
Posts: 1707 (05/09/06 11:57 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	*Quote:* Vecepia in eighth makes perfect sense......voting for Neleh at F4 was a big fuck up (should've voted for Kathy.....then Paschal would've collapsed in the final challenge, and she would've only needed to outlast lil' Neleh.....purple rock saved her ass). Are you kidding me? voting for Kathy at F4 would have been the biggest strategic blunder ever...although Vee was strong I think Neleh could have beaten her in the last challenge and taken Paschal...Vee just had a tough choice of voting off a strong player like Neleh who could and did beat her at the last challenge and Paschal who was a jury favorite but easily beatable in any challenge... one more thing who thinks that by Vee having Kathy to try to vote off Neleh in F4 that it made it easier for Neleh to vote off Kathy despite being with her since the beginning...its just amazing how crucial that F4 IC was to how the game turned out...
gunkulator	Re: My Ranking	#100	[-]
Posts: 52 (05/09/06 1:05 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Rich - He not only invented most of the strategy that the other's copied, he implemented it superbly. Purposely letting go in F3 challenge is still the most original move I've ever seen on Survivor. 2. Brian - the Lord and Master and Heir Apparent to Rich. What Rich invented, Brian perfected. A sociopath's sociopath. 3. Jenna - Charmed her tribemates into voting for her despite possessing a soul of pure evil. How she got Christy to vote for her is the greatest mystery in all of Survivor. 4. Tom - Steamrolled his way to the end and then used his Jedi Mind Powers to make Ian take a dive. gap Here and below the winners are signficantly less worthy, getting to the end via UTR, coattails and/or luck. 5. Tina - Rode Colby's coattails to the end while UTRing like crazy. She made a power move against Maddog early, though. 6. Danni - Played hard but got lucky that the rest of her tribe was picked off before her. It could have easily been her. 7. Ethan - After teaming with Lex and getting rid of Silas, he was a strategic zero. 8. Sandra - UTR to the max. Can anyone remember anything she said or did? 9. Vecepia - Probably the luckiest winner ever. The Rotu 4 would have reigned supreme if not for the introduction of the "chop the ropes of your tribemates" challenge which tipped their hands. Future alliances now expect these challenges and act accordingly. 10. Chris - What a dumbass. Twila had to tell him how to strategize. Twila! 11. Amber - The ultimate coattail rider and UTRer. She didn't team with Rob so much as Rob annointed her to be his mafia wife.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Rank the Winners

Quick Reply