He'd need to actually play the game and show he is playing to win. Kim P would have squashed him in the vote. Remember, Tom liked to help them bathe, he would have voted Kim P.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
RobVanStratus |
Re: The "What If" Game | ||
|
I think its highly unlikely that Frank would win Africa.
He'd need to actually play the game and show he is playing to win. Kim P would have squashed him in the vote. Remember, Tom liked to help them bathe, he would have voted Kim P. |
|||
AfricaLover333 |
Re: The "What If" Game | ||
|
Im gonna try to do the same idea as Rootin4Rudy without twists.
Survivor Marquesas: IC # 1:Rotu Wins TC Boot:Peter RC # 1:Rotu Wins IC # 2:Rotu Wins TC Boot:Patricia RC # 2:Rotu Wins IC # 3:Rotu Wins TC Boot:Hunter Now no switch but we dont know the reward so to Immunity. IC # 4:Hard to tell but since more Maraamus sat out this challenge like in the show most likely Rotu would have won it. TC # 4:The alliance would probably still continue and vote off Gina 4-1 over Sarah. RC # 3:Hard to tell but most likely Rotu wins again because Gina isnt there and the old Rotu did have the winners of this challenge on it. IC # 5:I think that Rotu yet again would win basically because they had more things to use as signals. TC # 5:A tie which leads to Sarah being voted off.(2 votes Vee) RC # 4:I think that at this time Maraamu would have had it more together with only 3 people so they probably would have won this challenge. IC # 6:Again Maraamu would win just like shown in this episode. TC # 6:This would probably cause a tie because Kathy,Neleh,Paschal and Gabriel would have banned together to oust the Rotu 4.Leaving a tie between Gabe and John where probably John leaves. MERGER IC # 7:Most likely Kathy would win this challenge again. TC # 7:I think the Rotus would stick together to oust Rob M 8-2 over Gabriel. RC # 5:Kathy wins again and enjoys her underwater trip. IC # 8:Seeming how Rotu is together Tammy would probably end up winning again. TC # 8:I dont really think Tammy/Robert/Zoe are dumb enough to let the NEW Rotu 4 get the power so they approach Vee and Sean for an alliance and at TC they boot Gabriel 5-4 over Sean. RC # 6:Sean and Paschal would probably win this just like the show. IC # 9:Tammy wins again because she won this challenge giving her the advantage. TC # 9:The alliance would most likely stick together again and end up voting off Kathy 5-3 over Zoe. RC # 7:Well since Paschal won this challenge in the real marquesas Id say he wins this one and takes Neleh. IC # 10:Robert wins because of his fire skills. TC # 10:Well most likely Neleh would leave because she has more strength in her for the future so she leaves 5-2 over Tammy. RC # 8:Since Kathy son isnt there Itd probably end up with Robert's sister winning. IC # 11:Vecepia wins just like the real show. TC # 11:The alliance would take out there last victim Paschal 5-1 over Sean. RC # 9:Sean would win the car because of his strength but Tammy comes close. IC # 12:Well in the real one Kathy wins but in this one I think it would come out with Vecepia winning Immunity. TC # 12:I think that the Rotus would ban together and take out Sean 3-2 over Tammy. This all seems like the Real Marquesas but with Robert,Tammy and Zoe as the new Neleh,Paschal,Kathy. IC # 13:Well since Vecepia won this challenge it might be the same but we have to think about how well the others would know.But since Vee was with everyone shed probably win. TC # 13:I think Zoe would actually feel confident and not try something with Vee and Zoe ends up leaving 3-1 over Tammy. IC # 14:Tammy would have alot of endurance but so would Vecepia knowing shed need this.Robert would probably end up going first.Vee wouldnt probably take it much longer and shed lose giving Tammy the win. TC # 14:Tammy sticks to her alliance with Robert and Vecepia goes. Final Jury Voting: Gabriel-Tammy,He bonded with her more out there then with Robert and felt Robert rode Tammys coattails. Kathy-Robert,She is bitter with how Tammy played th egame and feels Robert had a different strategy approach. Neleh-Robert,Again feeling bitter about being picked off but wanted revenge on Tammy so voted Robert. Paschal-Tammy,He being the person who spent more time out there then hes alliance saw how Tammy really was and how she played the game. Sean-Tammy,He felt Tammy wasnt a prissy girl and felt she lead herself to the win when Robert just slide into the F2. Zoe-Robert,Zoe didnt like Tammy and didnt want her to win. Vecepia-Tammy,Vecepia is not a bitter person and votes for who trully deserves to win. Tammy Leitner Wins Survivor Marquesas 4-3! |
|||
Jet Jaga |
Re: The "What If" Game | ||
|
Outcasts in All Stars...
After Jerri's boot, the tribes enter challenge beach and are shocked when the first four people voted out, Tina, Rudy, Rob C and Richard show up to compete to re-enter the game. The outcasts win, sending both tribes to TC. Chapera, sadly, votes out Amber (3 votes Amber, 1 vote Shii) while MM ousts Alicia (4 votes Alicia, 1 vote Jenna). The outcasts vote Rudy and Richard back into the game... Tina - Rudy/Richard Rudy - Rob C/Richard Rob C - Rudy/Richard Richard - Rudy/Rob C Merge Tribe: Rudy, Richard, Rob M, Tom, Jenna, Rupert, Lex, Kathy, Shii Ann Rob M and Kathy win immunity. Richard starts to stir the pot almost immediately by making his intentions known that he and Rudy will be voting Lex at TC and if anyone wishes to join them they can. Lex goes on a furious rampage, much to Richard's delight, and does himself in in the process. (7 votes Lex, 2 votes Rupert). Ep 10: Kathy sulks and becomes anti-social after Lex's cruel boot. Wily Richard manages to win the reward/immunity challenge and she has nowhere to turn, with even a teary eyed Shii Ann bidding her farewell. (7 votes Kathy, 1 vote Rudy). Ep 11: Rob M knows he on the outs, his girl is gone and his allies are abandoning him, but he wins immunity and begs old Chapera to stay loyal and keep Richard from winning, bamboozling him once again (4 votes Richard, 3 votes Tom). Ep 12: Rob M's brother wins reward and Tom wins immunity. Shii Ann is voted out. (5 votes Shii Ann, 1 vote Rob M). Ep 13: Rob M wins a car, giving it to Jenna. Tom questions Rob's loyalty as a result, approaching Rupert about voting out Rob. However, Rob wins immunity and Tom's game is done. (4 votes Tom, 1 vote Rudy). Final Four: Jenna, Rob M, Rudy, Rupert Kind of the reverse of All Stars, Rupert wins the first IC and Rob M is voted out. (3 votes Rob M, 1 vote Rudy). In a hard fought final challenge, Jenna pulls of a win and poor Rudy must again settle for third place. (1 vote Rudy). Final Two: Jenna and Rupert Lex: Jenna (preference) Kathy: Rupert (dislikes Jenna) Richard: Jenna (gameplay) Shii Ann: Jenna (it's just a game...) Tom: Rupert (dislikes Jenna) Rob M: Jenna (gameplay) Rudy: Rupert (loyalty) Jenna Lewis wins, beating Rupert. This would be much worse than the actual outcome, especially if Rupert won a million also by America's votes. |
|||
CSCin3D |
Re: The "What If" Game | ||
|
The winners of my scenarios so far are Zoe and Brandon. Don't know how that happened LOL.
What if in S1, MB hadn't told the people to vote not vote out Rudy? Episode 3: Immunity: Pagong Boot: Rudy Sean, Dirk, Kelly and Stacey all vote out Rudy as they wanted to before MB told them to vote for Stacey. Episode 4: Immunity: Tagi Boot: Ramona Episode 5: Immunity: Pagong Boot: Susan Susan is the outcast of the group and is voted out. Episode 6: Immunity: Tagi Boot: Joel Episode 7: Immunity: Greg Boot: Gretchen Richard organizes them all to vote for Gretchen Episode 8: Immunity: Gervase Boot: Richard Kelly with no alliance-ish commitments, gravitates towards Coleen and Jenna, they and Stacey all decide to vote off Richard. Gervase and Greg also vote for Richard to go along with them. Episode 9: Immunity: Anybody but Sean Boot: Sean It's between Sean and Dirk, Kelly likes Dirk so Sean goes. Episode 10: Immunity: Greg Boot: Stacey Stacey starts getting really bitchy, eerybody's sick of her and she is voted off. Episode 11: Immunity: Kelly Boot: Dirk The outsider is Dirk, they vote off Dirk. Episode 12: Immunity: Kelly Boot: Greg Kelly organizes the rest of the gals to vote off the immunity threat, Greg. Episode 13a: Immunity: Kelly Boot: Jenna Colleen and Gervase are annoyed by her and don't want her to win. Episode 13b: Immunity: Kelly Boot: Colleen Even though Gervase is about to become a father, she thinks people won't vote for Gervase because of his laziness, and between her and Colleen, most people would vote for Colleen. Final Tribal Council: Jury Votes Richard: Kelly. thought she played a good game. Sean: Gervase, it's really a toss up but I can't see him voting for Kelly. Stacey: Kelly, another toss up. Wants a girl to win? Doesn't like Gervase? Dirk: Kelly, they were friends. Greg: Gervase, his buddy. Jenna: Gervase, wants a pagong to win. Colleen: Gervase, is pissed at Kelly. Gervase wins 4-3. Winner of Survivor: Gervase (Not that I want him to win). Instead of Pagonged the phrase is now Tagied. |
|||
Danishdog99 |
Re: The "What If" Game | ||
|
What if they merged late?
Survivor 1: (if each tribe voted once) TC7: Gervase 3 Gervase - 2 Jenna TC8: Sean 4 Sean - 1 Susan Rattana: Colleen, Jenna, Greg, Gretchen, Kelly, Richard, Rudy, Susan IC9: Greg TC9: Gretchen 4 Gretchen - 1 Rudy - 1 Susan - 1 Richard - 1 Jenna IC10: Greg TC10: Jenna 6 Jenna - 1 Richard Kelly can't vote for Sean because he's not here, and she would have voted for Greg but he's immune. IC11: Kelly TC11: Greg 4 Greg - 2 Susan IC12: Kelly TC12: Colleen 4 Colleen - 1 Richard IC13: Kelly TC13: Susan 2 Richard - 2 Susan...1 Rich - 1 Sue...Past votes: Susan IC14: Kelly TC14: Rudy TC15: So because Kelly couldn't vote for Sean when she normally would have, she isn't seen as seperated from the alliance. Therefore, her friendship with Susan doesn't falter as much, and Kelly doesn't vote out Sue. Sean - Richard Gretchen - Kelly Jenna - Kelly Greg - Richard Colleen - Kelly Susan - Kelly Rudy - Richard Kelly wins 4-3 against Richard! |
|||
Unregistered(d) |
Re: The 'What If' Game | ||
|
What if in the F5 Kathy aligned with Sean/Vecepia instead of Paschal/Neleh? Neleh gets voted off. F4, Paschal gets voted off. F3, Vecepia wins IC and takes Sean. That'd be a close one... |
|||
RobVanStratus |
Re: The 'What If' Game | ||
|
Kathy would have won the Final IC.
No Neleh to tell her to watch her shirt and her boobies. Kathy hung in for the F10 Immunity when she needed it, she would have done the same in the F3 Immunity if she needed it. If Kathy goes with Sean/Vee, she wins. |
|||
kochman |
Re: The "What If" Game | ||
|
This particular scenario is something i've been thinking about for a while now. While it's something Clarence probably wouldn't have done, I knew it would only work using him or replacing him with an imaginary player in his place. I don't quite remember all the reward and immunity challenges so try to bear with my if something doesn't fit when I name a winner who probably wouldn't have won a particular challenge. Ok, here goes.
What if Clarence Black betrayed Boran Clarence knows he's in big trouble. He's never really been forgiven for stealing the beans and nobody wants to make deals with him and Tom keeps throwing him votes at Tribal Council, which tells him that he'll be voted out for sure the next time they go to Tribal Council. He feels there's no way out. Until Boran get treemail telling them to send 3 of their members on a quest. Thinking he could possibly save himself, he volunteers to go. Tom, who doesn't trust Clarence, also volunteers to keep an eye on him, and Kelly agrees to be the third. They meet Jeff Probst at the meeting point and are shocked to find out that they are now members of Samburu. Clarence doesn't quite know how to react until he gets to the next immunity challenge. Clarence flubs the challenge deliberately to the point that Samburu loses. Nobody really minds because they can just vote out Lindsey and Boran can lose next time to get rid of Silas. The Samburu 3 still try to go for Tom, thinking he wouldn't be smart enough to win a trivia tie-breaker and the Boran 3 go for Lindsey knowing she would lose a tie-breaker. Until Clarence makes his move, that is. At a shocking Tribal Council, Tom is voted out 4-2. Tom gets really pissed at Clarence and threatens to shoot him again and Jeff has to drag Tom away from him. After Tom's torch is snuffed he gives Clarence a glare similar to the one he gave Rob in All-Stars. Back at camp, Kelly screams and curses at Clarence on how he's sold out Boran. Clarence simply tells her she's next, which scares Kelly into silence. Clarence then makes a deal with the Samburu 3, telling them that Frank and Teresa have sold out Silas and that to protect him they need to throw the next immunity challenge. At the reward challenge, Boran is shocked to find that Tom is gone and Lex gets angry with Clarence and threatens to cut his throat. Back at camp Lex and Ethan fume that their alliance is busted and bring in Kim J. to replace Tom, telling her they have to lose the next immunity challenge. The immunity challenge is pretty pathetic to watch as both tribes are trying to lose on purpose and Jeff Probst looks visibly annoyed at the whole thing. However, Boran mistakenly puts Silas in the challenge and he ends up winning single-handily winning it for Boran. At TC that night Kelly is voted off 4-1 all while telling Clarence that Lex will make him pay for his betrayal. The next day the Samburu tribe plans for the merge and Clarence tells them that along with Silas, theyll also need either Frank, Teresa or both to give them overall majority of the merged tribe. They agree to let Clarence talk to Frank and Teresa knowing they dont trust the remaining Samburus anymore, while the Samburus fill Silas in on their plans. The next immunity challenge is indeed the first individual immunity challenge of the game, which involves holding your arm up to keep the bucket from falling on you. The final 2 in the challenge are Clarence and Teresa, as before. Clarence makes a deal with Teresa telling her that he will drop the bucket if she promises him she wont write his name down at TC. While Teresa thinks about it, Frank makes the promise to Clarence so Teresa will win. Teresa also agrees to make the promise and Clarence drops his arm. Back at the Boran camp the merged tribe decides to still name their new tribe MotoMaji, while Lex angrily tells Clarence openly that he is a snake and that he is being voted off tonight. Frank and Teresa refuse to vote for Clarence because of the promise they made to him, so Lex decides to get Brandon to vote for Clarence and he agrees. Seeing the two of them together, Clarence and the other Samburus corner Brandon and tell him that if Lex doesnt leave tonight he will be the one leaving at the next TC and Brandon, angry but also very frightened agrees to vote off Lex. Clarence goes to Frank and Teresa and tells them about Lexs temper and reminds them of the earlier threats he made to Clarence, and that theyll likely by voted off by him shortly after Clarence leaves. At TC that night Frank and Teresa, deciding they dont want a vindictive Lex on the jury, choose to rejoin with the Samburus to vote off Lex 7-3. Lex leaves giving nasty looks to all the Samburus. The new alliance continues to vote together again at the next TC (After cornering Brandon again making sure he votes with them), votes off Ethan next 7-2, making him Juror #1. Clarence then tells Silas, Lindsey, Kim P. and Brandon that Frank and Teresa have outlived their usefulness and can be taken out now, which puts a huge smile on Brandons face. Clarence then tells Kim J. shell be safe if she votes out Frank tonight. And sure enough at the next TC, Frank is blindsided 6-2 with the 2 votes going to Kim J., making him Juror #2. Teresa knows shes in trouble and tries to make any deal possible to stay in the game. It doesnt work and she ends up leaving at the next TC 6-1, becoming Juror #3. Feeling cocky, Silas tells the other Samburus that they dont need Clarence anymore and plan to vote him off at the next TC, until he wins the IC, that is. Knowing Silas tried to set him up, Clarence get Kim J. to vote for Silas and convinces the other Samburus to get rid of Silas, reminding them that hes a challenge threat too. In another blindside, Silas is voted off 5-1 his vote going to Kim J. and making him Juror #4. Clarence wins the next IC and Kim J. is finally voted off 4-1, her vote going to Brandon and making her Juror #5. While gathering firewood, Clarence and Brandon make a final 2 pact, knowing that neither one of them can beat either one of the ladies. The fallen comrades challenge ends up being mostly about Borans and Clarence wins IC. There ends up being a 2-2 tie between Brandon and Lindsey and she loses having more votes than Brandon making her Juror #6. At the final IC, Clarence manages to outlast Kim P. and he votes her out at TC that night, making her Juror #7. The Final 2 are Clarence and Brandon. The Jury Vote Goes ETHAN: CLARENCE        He betrayed Boran, but cant stand Brandon winning. FRANK: CLARENCE        Doesnt like Brandon at all. TERESA: CLARENCE        Doesnt like Brandon and respected Clarences gameplay. SILAS: BRANDON                Pissed at Clarence for beating him. Wants Brandon to win. KIM J.: CLARENCE                Same reasons as Ethan. LINDSEY: CLARENCE        Pissed at Brandon for selling her out. KIM P.: BRANDON                Was Brandons friend during the game. Clarence Black wins Survivor Africa 5-2 I know there may be a few things wrong with this scenario, but I had to get it out of my head. I hope you enjoy it. |
|||
spnintendo |
Re: The "What If" Game | ||
|
Uhhh...i'll do a short one.
WHAT IF JENNA WAS DUMB ENOUGH TO RISK THE PURPLE ROCK?? GASP*Rob miraculously pulls the purple one and gets sent home. Then, at the F3 challenge, Jenna does the leg stunt again, and let's say (for argument's sake) Amber is so drunk/tired/sleepy/distracted/sad that she falls off too. And RUPERT wins the F3 IC!!!! So Rupert, being loyal to Jenna, takes her to the final 2 and totally slaughters her in 7-0 vote. Wow, survivor fans get what they want....finally. Oh wait nevermind. But, really, this is the only way Rupert could have actually WON SURVIVOR. Au revior Blackbeard... |
|||
Simdog11 |
What if... | ||
|
OK I'm giving this atry:
What if Mark Burnett had waited a little while longer to film ASS?? .......Jenna M's mom would have since passed on, Vecepia wouldn't decline to due her newborn, Jonny Fairplay's popularity would've been established leading to a spot for him, and Sandra would've had recovery time to do another show. Vee replaces Alicia. Jon replaces Tom....I know he'd probably really replace the Robfather but I think Rob M. is a much more interesting cahracter. Sandra replaces Jenna L. Mogo Mogo: Rich, Lex, Colby, Kathy, Shii Ann, Jenna M Chapera: Susan, Vecepia, Jon, Rob C, Rob M, Amber Saboga: Tina, Jerri, Sandra, Rupert, Rudy, Ethan E1: Saboga loses. Rupert, Sandra, Rudy, and Jerri vote off Tina. E2: Saboga loses. Liability Rudy still goes. E3: Mogo Mogo loses. Jenna M, Kathy, Shii Ann, Colby, and Lex take out Rich. E4: Chapera loses. Rob M, Amber, Susan, Vee, and Jon collectively boot Rob C. E5: Saboga dissolves. Ethan and Jerri go to Mogo Mogo. Rupert and Sandra go to Chapera. Mogo Mogo loses. Jerri can't save herself against Kathy/Jenna M/and Shii Ann (you know how girls can be). E6: Chapera loses. Susan doesn't quit because Rich is already gone. Rupert, Sandra integrate well and help Rob M and his harem to boot Jonny Fairplay. E7:Mogo Mogo loses. Ethan is initial target but he is shielded by jenna M. Colby's pushiness causes him to get the boot. E8: Mogo Mogo loses. Despite Jenna M's efforts, Ethan has no more lifelines. E9: Tribes reshuffle. New Mogo Mogo is Rob M, Sandra, Rupert, Susan, and Vecepia. New Chapera is Lex, Kathy, Shii Ann, Jenna M, and Amber. Chapera loses and this time, Jenna M speaks up and convinces them to NOT keep Amber. E10: Merge. Rob M. and Susan win immunity. (Sue could kick Kathy's ass any day). Seeing herself as a 5th wheel, Sandra jumps ship and cuts a deal with former Mogo women. Kathy is all too pleased to vote off Vecepia. E11: Rob M wins immunity. Lots of deal breaking as Rupert questions Sandra's loyalty to him, Mogos question her loyalty to them. Lex begins to wonder about his spot in everything, brought to his attention by Rob M and Susan. Ultimately, Sandra has outplayed herself. E12: Knowing she needs it, Susan wins immunity. Rob M is an easy target for the 4 original Mogo Mogos. E13: Rupert (or Shii Ann) wins immunity. Although she tries to get a former MogoMogo to swing and join her and Rupert, Susan is out of options. E14: Lex wins immunity. By this point, tensions have boiled over between everyone. Kathy, Shii Ann, and Jenna M are tight though, and although Lex was open to other options, Rupert gets the boot. E15: Jenna M wins the immunity, just like in Amazon. She, Kathy, and Shii Ann take out Lex. Next, Shii Ann, having proved her endurance, wins the final immunity. She votes off the only former winner left, Jenna M. Final jury vote: Vecepia: Shii Ann Sandra: Kathy Rob M: Kathy Susan: Shii Ann Rupert: Shii Ann Lex: Shii Ann Jenna M: Kathy SHII ANN WINS ALL STAR SURVIVOR |
|||
Cuauhtemoc Cosby |
Re: What if... | ||
Quote: I hope your definition of a "little longer" is at least 2-3 years, because the baby at nine months old still requires as huge amount of care as a baby maybe five months old. |
|||
colleenlover |
Re: What if... | ||
|
Image of Vecepia burping her baby and checking it. "Okay, looks good enough to me -nine months, no more drama. On to All stars, baby!"
|
|||
Simdog11 |
Re: What if... | ||
|
Exactly! I figure once Vecepia popped the thing out of her and filmed her TLC special, she'd be good to go.
|
|||
Unregistered(d) |
Re: The "What If" Game | ||
|
I see two situations... S4 F9 Boot: Sean F8 Boot: Kathy (Rotu 4 is scared of her) F7 Boot: Vee (continuing with their order) F6 Boot: Neleh F5 Boot: Paschal F4: Ok, John and Tammy align against Zoe and Rob. Rob goes with John/Tammy and gets rid of Zoe. Tammy wins F3 IC and gets rid of Rob. She wins. Other situation, involving Neleh going on a Darrah IC run... S4 F9 Boot: Sean F8 Boot: Kathy (Rotu 4 is scared of her) F7 Boot: Vee (continuing with their order) F6 Boot: Neleh wins IC and Paschal gets the boot F5 Boot: Neleh wins IC again and Zoe gets the boot F4: Neleh wins AGAIN and aligns with Rob against John and Tammy. John goes home. Tammy wins F3 IC and takes Neleh, who wins. |
|||
AfricaLover333 |
Re: The "What If" Game | ||
|
Just like in Colleens Final words saying might have won had she started on Tagi.Heres what I think.(Sonja goes to Pagong and Colleen to Tagi)
IC # 1-It would go to Tagi because Sonja would have weaken them. TC # 1-Hard to say B.B. is pissing everyone off which would lead to them voting him off. B.B.-Jenna,Sonja,Ramona,Gervase,Joel,Gretchen Sonja-B.B.,Greg IC # 2-It would probably be a tie and end up Stacey VS Gervase and Tagi would win again. TC # 2-At this point it would probably be smart to vote off the weakest link and I think there would be a unison. Sonja-Ramona,Jenna,Gervase,Joel,Gretchen,Greg Ramona-Sonja IC # 3-At this IC I think Pagong would come back and end up winning like they did. TC # 3-I think now that the weakest(Sonja) isnt on this team theyd probably vote off Rudy who is the next weakest. Rudy-Stacey,Colleen,Kelly,Sean,Dirk Stacey-Richard,Susan,Rudy IC # 4-I think that it would come down to Tagi winning Immunity on this one. TC # 4-With going back to TC I think Joels speech about keeping the team together is still in there by this time I think they would try to boot the weakest and it would be Ramona again. Ramona-Jenna,Gretchen,Joel,Greg Jenna-Ramona,Gervase IC # 5-I think that Pagong would end up winning like they did in this IC. TC # 5-I think now the younger group would have formed an alliance and they would probably go for Susan because Rich provides alot for them. Susan-Stacey,Kelly,Colleen,Sean,Dirk Stacey-Susan,Richard IC # 6-Well in this one I think with Stacey and Colleen being on Tagi it would weaken them during the Immunity challenge.So I think Pagong would win. TC # 6-Tagi would now have to cut off the person outside of the alliance. Richard-Stacey,Kelly,Sean,Dirk,Colleen Stacey-Richard IC # 7-I think that Greg would win this just like the real show. TC # 7-The alliance stays in tact while Pagong minus Gretchen tries to stick together. Gretchen-Stacey,Kelly,Sean,Dirk,Colleen Stacey- Joel,Greg,Gervase,Jenna Gervase-Gretchen IC # 8-I think it would end up with Gervase winning because with weaker people in the merger and him winning it before would end up being him. TC # 8-It would be Greg who would probably end up going again for being a threat. Greg-Stacey,Kelly,Sean,Dirk,Colleen,Jenna Jenna-Gervase,Greg,Joel IC # 9-It would end up being Sean winning Immunity since he got 2nd in the real show so he would have the necklace. TC # 9-I think that the old Pagongs would try to form a bond and I think Kelly would start to try to get out of the alliance. But the threat would still go. Joel-Stacey,Sean,Dirk,Colleen Sean-Gervase,Joel,Jenna Dirk-Kelly IC # 10-I think this wouldnt end up being Gervase because of his poor performance in this IC,I dont think Jenna,Stacey or Colleen would work well I think Dirkw ould win Immunity. TC # 10-I think now that Kelly is bonding with the other tribe she tries to get rid of Sean who she doesnt like.But it ends up being Jenna who isnt liked by them and is on Seans alphabetical strategy. Jenna-Sean,Colleen,Stacey,Dirk Sean-Gervase,Jenna,Kelly IC # 11-I think that Kelly would win this IC because Stacey probably wouldnt do long because she knows shes safe and same with Dirk. TC # 11-With Kelly Immune Gervase gets Pagonged off. Gervase-Sean,Colleen,Dirk,Stacey Sean-Gervase,Kelly IC # 12-I think that during this IC it would obviously be Kelly because Stacey and Colleen wouldnt do well.Dirk and Sean would come close. TC # 12-The alliance has to break someone and I think it would end up being Sean because the girls know Kelly would vote him. Sean-Kelly,Stacey,Colleen Stacey-Sean,Dirk IC # 13-Now that Dirk is on the line I think he would do well in the IC but Kelly learned too much and she wins. TC # 13-I think that now that this has happen Kelly would align with Dirk at the vote to vote Stacey off.(Just like Sue) Stacey-Kelly,Dirk Dirk-Stacey,Colleen Stacey goes in tIe Breaker IC # 14-I think Colleen would have known she needed Immunity but Kelly again comes up and wins. TC # 14-I think Kelly would vote off Dirk because she has a chance to get his Jury vote. Dirk-Kelly Final Jury Votes: Greg-COLLEEN-(He likes her better and wouldnt vote Kelly) Joel-KELLY-(Felt like Jenna,that she was a close friend) Jenna-KELLY-(Felt Kelly was on her side and was a friend) Gervase-KELLY-(Bitter and wants Kelly to stuff it to the others) Sean-COLLEEN-(Was closer and a closer alliance partner) Stacey-COLLEEN-(She is bitter like Sue and votes Kellys opponent. Dirk-KELLY-(I think that since the game has progressed Dirk would never vote Kelly off or vote for Kelly to lose because he likes her alot inside and out of the game. Kelly would win Survivor Borneo 4-3!(If Colleen was on Tagi) |
|||
PleasantMama |
S1 | ||
|
What if in S1, MB hadn't allegedly told people to vote out Stacey? And what if Stacey had given up on trusting Sue and formed her own strategy by having Kelly help her to court the idiotic, gulliable duo of Dirk and Sean (Remember Dirk had a crush on Kelly and I'm sure Stacey could've kept her eye roll reflex in check long enough to ensnare Sean as well)?
Episode 3: Immunity: Pagong Boot: Rudy The newly formed "Generation X" alliance takes out Rudy. Episode 4: Immunity: Tagi Boot: Ramona Episode 5: Immunity: Pagong Boot: Susan Susan is less useful and more socially inept than Rich. Episode 6: Immunity: Tagi Boot: Joel Episodes 7 through 10: Richard worms his way into the alliance, when Stacey realizes she may need his vote. He continues to prove invaluable to the tribe. With Stacey around, Kelly isn't so lonely and doesn't defect as clearly. Besides, Stacey finds Jenna annoying. Gretchen, Greg, Gervase and then Jenna are eliminated in that order. Episode 11: Immunity: Colleen Boot: Sean Colleen wins the balance challenge since Kelly has no reason to feel threatened and so her will to win immunity is non-existant - She gives minimal effort in challenges. Richard is sharp and sees that he's heading into the finals with two firm groups of two. He suggests to the girls that they toss the more athletic guys, and since Tweedle Dum and Tweedle Dee have never stopped being annoying, they readily agree. Episode 12: Boot: Kelly Richard offers his allegiance to Colleen, who accepts due to lack of better choices, and then approaches Dirk, blaming the women for the removal of Sean and offering Dirk an endgame deal, saying he may be able to get Colleen to switch her vote. When Kelly fails to win immunity, she is blindsided at tribal council, since she is considered to be far more athletic than Stacey (Remember athleticism mattered all the way through in S1 - they had no idea what kind of challenges were coming up). Episode 13a: Immunity: Colleen - the questions are probably all Pagong Boot: Stacey Nothing interesting here. Stacey fails to win immunity, everyone hates her, and Rich has deals with both Colleen and Dirk. Episode 13b: Immunity: Dirk Boot: Colleen Colleen just doesn't have it in her to win another endurance challenge. Richard steps out, as in reality, knowing that either one will take him to the end. The sweet and unbeatable Colleen takes the final fall. Final Tribal Council! Jury Votes: Greg: Richard. Recognizes that he WAS the game. Gervase: Richard. Never bonded with the freaky Dirk. Stacey's tirade on Rich affects his vote somewhat. Jenna: Richard. Feels bad for him after Stacey's speech. Never really liked Dirk and recognizes Rich as the better survivalist and player. Sean: Dirk, his buddy. Kelly: Dirk. Bitter. Following Stacey's lead. Stacey: Dirk. Bitter. Expect a doozy of a hypocritical speech. Colleen: Richard. He never betrayed her, she likes and respects him more. Richard wins 4-3. The more things change, the more they stay the same. |
|||
AfricaLover333 |
Re: S1 | ||
|
What if Thailand was Men VS Women?
IC # 1-I think the men would win this because Ghandia did fuck up on this challenge. TC # 1-I dont think Ghandia would go with her closeness to Tanya.I think it would wind up with Jan leaving because she is the eldest.But Ghandia and Tanya rack up some votes. Jan-Ghandia,Tanya,Helen,Penny Ghandia-Jan,Shii ann,Stephanie Tanya-Erin IC # 2-I think that the women would pull together well on this one and win it. TC # 2-With the men at TC I think that theyd boot the weakest link who is Clay.But I think that Jake would get a vote. Clay-Jake,Brian,Ted,John,Robb,Jed,Ken Jake-Clay IC # 3-I think the women would win again because of Shii anns smartness and the womens bonding. TC # 3-The men would probably be fed up with John who is bossy and I think that some would get annoyed with Jeds laziness. John-Brian,Ted,Robb,Jed,Ken Jed-John,Jake IC # 4-I think that in this one the men would win even though I did say the women were smart in this IC in Thailand more men did the challenge and got it right. TC # 4-I think the women would need to boot Tanya because shed be more sick.But Helen would get some votes on annoyance. Tanya-Helen,Penny,Shii ann,Stephanie,Erin Helen-Tanya,Ghandia Twist # 1:I dont think anyone would switch how the things are going. IC # 5-I think the men would pull through and win this one. TC # 5-I think people would get annoyed with Stephanies isolation and laziness. Stephanie-Ghandia,Helen,Penny,Shii ann,Erin Ghandia-Stephanie IC # 6-The women would win for there mental strength. TC # 6-I think that the men would be tired of Jed by now and get him off with some people voting Jake on weakness. Jed-Jake,Ted,Brian,Ken Jake-Jed,Robb Twist # 2:They dont merge but stay on the beach. IC # 7-I think the women would pull through and win with more of them having small bodies to go through and there ingenuity skills. TC # 7-I think that Robb would now be on the chopping block and end up leaving. Robb-Jake,Brian,Ted,Ken Jake-Robb IC # 8-I think that the men would pull through with Jake,Brian and Ken on there tribe and the women go to TC. TC # 8-I think now that Ghandia would already have a deal with Shii ann and Helen is kinda with them.While Penny and Erin would have a deal but I think it would wind up being Erin directed by Helen. Erin-Shii ann,Ghandia,Helen Ghandia-Erin,Penny ~Merge~ IC # 9-It would wind up being Ken winning because he got 2nd in the actual one. TC # 9-I think that with Penny feeling on the outside of her team shell probably team up with Jake and Ken and form a Final 3 type deal.I think Brian would go because he doesnt need the money. Brian-Ghandia,Shii ann,Helen,Jake,Ken,Penny Ghandia-Brian,Ted IC # 10-I think that since its elimination that with Ted being on the outside of the alliance he goes out first then Ghandia,Shii ann,Helen follow giving them some kinda heads up.Then Jake,Ken go and Penny wins IC. TC # 10-Now that Ted,Ghandia,Helen and Shii ann see a heads up about them going to be picked off they align and decide to boot Ken off for being a threat. Ken-Ted,Ghandia,Helen,Shii ann Ted-Ken,Jake,Penny IC # 11-I think that during this IC Ted would win with his brother like the show. TC # 11-I think Ghandia would be fed up with Helen and try to get Shii ann to join in to vote her off.While Helen is on to boot Ted. Helen-Ghandia,Shii ann,Ted,Penny,Jake Ted-Helen IC # 12-I think that Penny would win because shed be the most atheltic in this IC and end up winning. TC # 12-I think Shii ann would get in trouble with Penny and Jake but they all decide to keep there alliances and boot Ted. Ted-Shii ann,Jake,Penny,Ghandia Shii ann-Ted IC # 13-With the battle for IC I think it would end up being Jake with Immunity because he would have the most skill. TC # 13-I think that it wouldnt be a tie because Shii ann would want to sell out Ghandia and so would Ghandia to Shii ann to make the Final 3.I think theyd vote Shii off. Shii ann-Ghandia,Penny,Jake Ghandia-Shii ann IC # 14-I think it would come to endurance and Penny would win it. TC # 14-Penny would stick with Jake and boot Ghandia. Ghandia-Penny Final Jury Voting: Erin-PENNY-Erin had a stronger bond and alliance with her. Brian-JAKE-Had a stronger bond and knew more of. Ken-JAKE-He did like Penny but felt He knew Jake longer and better. Helen-JAKE-She feels betrayed by Penny and feels she betrayed there tribe. Ted-PENNY-Felt Jake was a backstabber and liked Penny alittle better. Shii ann-JAKE-Didnt like Penny and bonded with Jake alot. Ghandia-JAKE-Penny was a backstabber,liar and a cheater and she felt Jake didnt need to do that to win. Jake Wins Survivor Thailand 5-2!! |
|||
kochman |
What if the outcasts got a twist of their own? | ||
|
I've got another what if for you. Here goes.
WHAT IF THE OUTCASTS GOT A TWIST OF THEIR OWN? Pearl Islands pretty much happens as it did up to the Drake and Morgan TC's where Shawn was still voted out and Osten still quit. The Outcast TC is where things really change. Jeff wonders aloud that Drake and Morgan must have really been shocked to see them come back and then wonders if they're ready to handle a shock of their own. At that moment Shawn walks out wearing an Outcast buff. Jeff explains that Shawn will also be included in their vote to be let back in the game, and goes on to say that no one from Morgan will be included because Osten quit, which prompts Lill and Ryan S. to nod their heads in frustration. Everyone gives their speech on why they should stay as they did normally. When Shawn speaks last, he tells them all that Drake was really upset at having to go to TC that night and that they all resented the Outcasts. The speech basically told them that they'll be voted out at the first opportunity. Shawn goes on to say that unless the Outcasts are strong enough to win IC's, that both Outcasts will be back out of the game in 9 days. He then recommends that they vote Burton and himself back in the game because they have the best chance to stay in and that they would have to try and make it to the end together, since they would both automatically lose if either of them went up against anybody else at the end. Lill and Ryan S. Vote for Burton and each other, not scared by Shawn's speech at all, but the others realize that Shawn is right and don't feel confident enough winning IC on their own and vote Burton and Shawn back in the game. Burton and Shawn reaffirm their alliance to the end as the remaining Outcasts leave for the last time. At the random buff draw, Shawn goes back to Drake and Burton goes to Morgan. The Drakes are completely shocked to see Shawn back, especially Jon. Rupert speaks to Shawn the next morning, explaining why he was voted out and Shawn forgives him, but deep down he knows Rupert screwed him in their deal and has no real loyalty to Drake whatsoever. Shawn doesn't consider himself an Outcast. He considers what happened to him a mistake that was corrected. At Morgan, despites Savage's plea not to trust the Outcasts, Burton ends up being the new leader of Morgan since he's bringing in fish and actually working around camp. Burton still wins the first individual IC, but gives the immunity sword to Savage instead of Rupert. Burton insists to the Morgans that they need to vote off Rupert right away, but Morgan still thinks they need him and refuse, wanting to vote off Jon instead. Burton and Shawn reluctantly agree and Shawn really relishes getting back at Jon. At TC that night, Drake is shocked as Jon is voted out 6-4. At the next IC, the Drake's are picked off one by one, eventually giving the IC to Ryno. The Morgans still refuse to vote off Rupert and everyone agrees to vote off Christa next as she's starting to annoy the Morgans. At TC that night, Christa is voted out 6-3, making her Juror #1. Burton still wins the IC dart game, causing Sandra to blow her stack and curse him out in front of the tribe. Since Morgan STILL refuses to vote Rupert out, they settle on Sandra. At TC that night, Sandra is voted out 6-2, making her Juror #2. The next morning, Burton makes it clear to the rest of the Morgans that Rupert absolutely has to go at the next TC, and they FINALLY agree, but since they like him so much they let him win the family visit, showing a lot of footage of Rupert making out with his wife. Burton still falsely wins the word scramble IC, and has it stripped from him, which leads Darrah to still win the IC. At TC that night, Rupert is voted out 6-1, making him Juror #3. Burton and Shawn then make a final 4 pact with Darrah and Ryno. They both agree thinking how sweet it would be to go up against an Outcast at the end. They both lie to Savage and Tijuana, letting them think that they're voting off Shawn next. Darrah still wins the flare gun IC. At TC that night, Andrew and Tijuana are shocked to find out that Andrew is voted out 4-2, making him Juror #4. Ryno, Burton, and Tijuana win the water course RC, sending them to the resort for the night. They all lie to Tijuana and tell her that Shawn is going for sure that night and Tijuana buys it. Darrah still wins the tube IC. At TC that night, Tijuana is voted out 4-1, making her Juror #5. At the next TC, the Jury still wins the quiz IC, making sure nobody has immunity. Scared of the purple rock, Ryno reluctantly decides to vote for Darrah. She's voted out 3-1, making her Juror #6. During the final IC, Shawn falls off his raft early on, making it a real tense battle between Burton and Ryno, which Burton eventually wins. At TC that night, Ryno is voted out by Burton, making him Juror #7. The Final 2 are Burton Roberts and Shawn Cohen. There is a lot of anger directed at the final 2 by the jury at the final TC. Shawn maintains that he doesn't consider himself an Outcast and that he screwed Drake because Drake screwed him first. Burton talks about his work ethic and physical prowess as reasons why he should win. Final Jury Votes: CHRISTA:SHAWN She buys Shawn's argument and doesn't like Burton. SANDRA:BURTON Thought Shawn was too lazy and thought Burton was a better player. RUPERT:SHAWN Was shamed by his betrayal and really didn't like Burton. ANDREW:SHAWN Bought Shawn's argument and didn't like Burton taking over Morgan. TIJUANA:SHAWN Bought Shawn's argument. DARRAH:SHAWN Bought Shawn's argument. RYNO:SHAWN Bought Shawn's argument . SHAWN COHEN WINS SURVIVOR: PEARL ISLANDS 6-1. |
|||
spnintendo |
Re: What if the outcasts got a twist of their own? | ||
|
What IF Rich's name came before Jenna's? (S1)
...sorrie if this has already been mentioned. Epi 9: Rich goes 4-3-1 Epi 10: The Pagongs latch onto Kelly. Rudy goes...um cuz he's next on the alpha-block. 5-2. Epi 11: Sue alpha-next. 5-1. Epi 12: Pagongs plus Kelly get rid of cuckoo doctor. 4-1. Bye Sean. Epi 13: Final 4!! Kelly wins immunity. Gervase is sacrificed for calling women cows awhile back. Then Kelly wins final immunity, brings Jenna cuz she bonded with her more. Bye bye my sweetheart, Colleen. Final 2: Jenna vs Kelly Greg: Jenna (for starting on the same tribe) Rich: Kelly (for "outsmarting" him) Rudy: Kelly (picked the name her could remember) Sue: Jenna (hopes Kelly dies of thrist) Sean: Jenna (would rather lose to a 22 year old single mom...then to just a 22 year old) Gervase: Kelly (um...is slightly-er smarter than a cow) Colleen: Jenna (makes up her mind last minute) Kelly loses AGAIN 3-4! Whoopee. |
|||
RobVanStratus |
Re: What if the outcasts got a twist of their own? | ||
|
Remember how it came down to Jenna L and Amber as to who was going to get the green buff and stay with the ex-Chaperas?
What if Jenna L got the red buff and Amber got the green buff? Episode 9 - Rob has no feeling of a need to have Lex save Jenna. Chapera loses Immunity. Lex knows Jerri still will be loyal, and Jenna was just as annoying as Jerri. TC 9 Lex/Kathy/Shii Ann/Jerri - Jenna Jenna - Jerri Episode 10 - We merge again. No Kathy/Lex/Rob blowup because there was no deal. Tom jumps over as planned, and brings along Rupert, hoping MM will spare Rupert. With Rob being the pick for the first jury boot, Lex will give more of an effort to win Immunity, and Lex/Kathy take home Immunity. TC 10 Lex/Tom/Rupert/Kathy/Jerri/Shii Ann - Rob Rob/Alicia/Amber - Jerri Episode 11 - Can't remember how they chose teams, so Lex replaces Rob and Jerri replaces Jenna, Lex/Shii Ann/Amber/Alicia vs Jerri/Kathy/Tom/Rupert. Lex/Shii Ann/Amber/Alicia still win reward. Amber wins Immunity because she has no Rob to throw the IC for. TC 11 Lex/Tom/Rupert/Kathy/Jerri/ShiiAnn/Amber - Alicia Alicia - Jerri Episode 12 - Now Amber is in the same position as Shii Ann was before. Shii Ann and Amber have a showdown for Immunity, but Shii Ann still wins. TC 12 Lex/Tom/Rupert/Kathy/Jerri/ShiiAnn - Amber Amber - Jerri Episode 13 - Now we are down to the Final 6. Tom won Immunity in the show, but who knows who could have won it? Rupert didnt win it, neither did Shii Ann. Tom still wins Immunity. Lex and his women go against Tom's wishes to keep Rupert. TC 13 Lex/Kathy/Shii Ann/Jerri - Rupert Rupert/Tom - Jerri Episode 14 - Hmm, who would win reward now? Tom definitely lost. I would pick Lex or Kathy to win, and to take the other on the reward. Shii Ann wins the word puzzle Immunity easily. Tom is vulnerable, and Lex gives him the same crap, "Its business this time" TC 14 Lex/Kathy/Jerri/ShiiAnn - Tom Tom - Lex Episode 15 - Final Four of Jerri, Kathy, Lex, and Shii Ann. Immunity would go to Shii Ann, she, much like Amber, would have an easier time navigating the maze. Lex makes a bold move and wants to eliminate Kathy from the game, because she is too likeable. Shii Ann finds out and tells her biggest ally Kathy, of the plan. They pull Jerri aside and tell her the F3 could be hers if she eliminates Lex. TC 15 Kathy/Shii Ann/Jerri - Lex Lex - Kathy Lex gets blindsided and taken out of the game. Now we go to the Final 3 Challenge. I think Jerri would fall out first, but not just give up easily. Then Shii Ann and Kathy have a showdown. Shii Ann wins the final Immunity and has a tough decision. Does she take Kathy and possibly lose the game for being loyal, or take Jerri and sweep the votes probably? Shii Ann in the end decides to keep her alliance true. TC 16 Shii Ann - Jerri Final Two - Shii Ann vs Kathy Jury Rob - Kathy. They are friends and she deserves it. Alicia - Shii Ann. She came in and pulled off 4 Immunities as the weakest and smallest one there. Plus there wasnt enough time for the SA/Alicia fight to break out to not get her vote. Amber - Shii Ann. She played a great game. Rupert - Shii Ann. They both came out here alone and she played great. Tom - Shii Ann. He likes her, and knows she is a smart player. Lex - Shii Ann. Kathy betrayed him, so he felt like she didn't deserve to win anymore. (Even though he did backstab her first, this is how I think he'd act) Jerri - Kathy. Shii Ann annoyed her more. So Shii Ann would have won 5-2 over Kathy if Jenna had drawn that red buff. Damn. |
|||