The "What If" Game

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
seltzer3		#421	[-]
Posts: 953 (12/23/08 10:46 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	So apparently Courtney (China) and Candice (Cook Islands) were the original picks for Fans verses Favorites, but declined (Thus having Parvati and Amanda replacing them). What if Courtney and Candice were playing instead of Parvati and Amanda? Another question, does anyone know who were the other 10 survivors that were casted out for the favorites? I know Michelle Yi was one of them, but who were the other nine? What would happen if they had a regular All Stars game? Assuming the other 10 were on another tribe. What would have happened if Richard Hatch didn't win the F7 immunity? Would he have been voted out as the editing suggested?
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#422	[-]
Posts: 6949 (12/27/08 9:59 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Terry Shane Ian(probably) Judd(very likely) I also remember hearing Andrew might have been cast Courtney Marit is a good possibility Twila Katie? And perhaps even a pre ASS woman As for your other question: I believe that everything would have gone as planned. Gervase was too much of a threat for Kelly, and in her mind, I bet she believed Rich would be a much easier beat than Gervase or Colleen. Rich also deserves a lot of credit for his great social skills. As much as he was edited to be disliked, he had the support of Colleen until her heart gave out and thought it was more fair to give the money to the less endowed. He reeled Sean in admirably, and he played subtle mind games with Sue and Kelly such as convincing Kelly that he was a goat when he really wasn't.
garyw		#423	[-]
Posts: 83 (12/28/08 3:30 PM) I don't take hints Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The cast was apparently: Survivor: Vanuatu - Ami (6th place), Julie (5th place), Eliza (4th place). Survivor: Palau - Coby (9th place), Jenn (4th place), Ian (3rd place), Katie (2nd place). Survivor: Guatemala - Gary (7th place), Judd (6th place), Lydia (4th place). Survivor: Exile Island - Shane (5th place), Cirie (4th place), Terry (3rd place). Survivor: Cook Islands - Jonathan (7th place), Parvati (6th place), Ozzy (2nd place). Survivor: Fiji - Michelle (10th place), Yau-Man (4th place). Survivor: China - James (7th place), Courtney (placement still unknown). I guess when Jeff split up with Julie she was cut, Courtney declined she probably realised she couldn't lose anymore weight. I have no idea why they decided on bringing in fans maybe most of their wish list declined.
kenc333		#424	[-]
Posts: 6135 (12/28/08 3:43 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Source? And Candice confirmed that she was invited, and it's been widely speculated that Parvati was her replacement.
garyw		#425	[-]
Posts: 86 (12/28/08 3:46 PM) I don't take hints Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	http://uk.tv.ign.com/articles/838/838915p1.html At this stage filming had already began so maybe they had already replaced Candice at this point.
XtremeInnovator420		#426	[-]
Posts: 1341 (12/28/08 6:14 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Hm, didn't know Katie, Lydia, or Gary were supposedly in the cast, though I think Gary would've been cool. It's pretty much assumed Amanda was only there because first Courtney and then PG declined right? And well, I think the reasoning behind Jenn being cut is probably kinda obvious, albeit kind of sad since the cancer thing's not her fault by any means.
Kitty Pryde1		#427	[-]
Posts: 7856 (12/28/08 6:28 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	They really should've cast SOMEONE from Guatemala. There were at least 4 guys from that season that would've been better than Fairplay.
XtremeInnovator420		#428	[-]
Posts: 1343 (12/28/08 6:36 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Better than Fairplay pre-Bonaduce.....I dunno...and this is from someone who loved Guatemala, but better than Fairplay post-Bonaduce with the broken teeth and the whole needing constant painkillers to stop from being in constant pain? Yeah...probably.
garyw		#429	[-]
Posts: 88 (12/28/08 6:39 PM) I don't take hints Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think Courtney declined not sure about PG both of them should have been there. I never understood why Fairplay was there in the first place.
XtremeInnovator420		#430	[-]
Posts: 1344 (12/28/08 6:47 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Rumour has it that Burnett wanted to do Fans vs Favs from the get go, but CBS wanted ASS2 with the cast that's been mentioned above. Eventually CBS supposedly said the only way that they'd agree to let Burnett do FvF was if Fairplay was one of the Favs.
uvawe		#431	[-]
Posts: 171 (12/28/08 7:41 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	kenc333 wrote: Source? And Candice confirmed that she was invited, and it's been widely speculated that Parvati was her replacement. When/where did Candice confirm this? I thought it was spec..
1TxT1		#432	[-]
Posts: 218 (12/28/08 7:51 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	garyw wrote: The cast was apparently: Survivor: Vanuatu - Ami (6th place), Julie (5th place), Eliza (4th place). Survivor: Palau - Coby (9th place), Jenn (4th place), Ian (3rd place), Katie (2nd place). Survivor: Guatemala - Gary (7th place), Judd (6th place), Lydia (4th place). Survivor: Exile Island - Shane (5th place), Cirie (4th place), Terry (3rd place). Survivor: Cook Islands - Jonathan (7th place), Parvati (6th place), Ozzy (2nd place). Survivor: Fiji - Michelle (10th place), Yau-Man (4th place). Survivor: China - James (7th place), Courtney (placement still unknown). I guess when Jeff split up with Julie she was cut, Courtney declined she probably realised she couldn't lose anymore weight. I have no idea why they decided on bringing in fans maybe most of their wish list declined. I actually think that rumor might've started with a poster here! Zesty posted his own cast list on some website and some people thought it was the real thing and that's where the rumor got started. I think that was his cast list above but I can't remember. I did read somewhere that Terry and Yul were dropped late. Coby was dropped early enough for him to come here and start giving us info about the rumors he'd heard about
kenc333		#433	[-]
Posts: 6147 (12/28/08 8:25 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	uvawe wrote: kenc333 wrote: Source? And Candice confirmed that she was invited, and it's been widely speculated that Parvati was her replacement. When/where did Candice confirm this? I thought it was spec.. It might've been a myspace post... but she said that she could go to med school or play Survivor again, and she'd already done Survivor once, while she couldn't not go to med school, so she chose to decline the offer. And I'm pretty sure Peih-Gee posted here saying she was never offered a spot, but Courtney was. Even though they knew Peih-Gee went down as a fighter, I don't think Burnett knew how popular she'd become.
muskger99		#434	[-]
Posts: 12 (12/28/08 11:29 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I always thought at the Australia F8, Kucha should have voted for Colby (but pretend to Ogakor that they are voting Jerri) - if Ogakor was sticking together, they'd have nothing to lose, but if Ogakor split - they'd gain a lot. Tribal Council #9 Elisabeth, Rodger, Nick - vote Colby Colby, Tina, Keith - vote Jerri Jerri, Amber - vote Elisabeth 3-3-2 tie, in the revote, Colby is gone 4-2 with Amber joining the Kuchas Tribal Council #10 Jerri sees that Tina & Keith voted for her, the Ogakor alliance is done. Nick wins immunity in Colbys absence Jerri, Amber, Elisabeth, Rodger, Nick - vote Keith Tina, Keith - vote Jerri Keith out 5-2 Tribal Council #11 Kucha has broken Ogakor apart as much as they could have, Lis & Rodger offer to take Tina to the F4 because she is a "good person," meanwhile Nick wants Tina out as Jerri is courting for him to join her & Amber at the F5 to break up E/R. Because the IC is smashing plates, one of the Kuchas probably win. Elisabeth, Rodger, Tina - vote Jerri Jerri, Nick, Amber - vote Tina Vote ties 3-3, Jerri has 11 past votes to Tina's 0 Tribal Council #12 Nick, Amber and Tina sit around and allow Lis and Rodger to control the game. Nick is possibly smart enough to try to unite with T/A but probably only entertains the idea and doesn't pursue it. Amber probably does not win immunity and is gone 4-1. Tribal Council #13 The Kuchas probably regroup and boot Tina if she does not win immunity. If she does, Nick is gone 3-1 Tribal Council #14 Whether it was Tina or Nick gone last time, Lis or Rodger probably have the edge at Fallen Comrades and would take each other to the F2 Final TC Colby, Keith, Nick vote Rodger Tina, Jerri, Amber, Alicia vote Elisabeth Elisabeth wins 4-3
Katy Carney		#435	[-]
Posts: 3081 (12/28/08 11:50 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	uvawe wrote: kenc333 wrote: Source? And Candice confirmed that she was invited, and it's been widely speculated that Parvati was her replacement. When/where did Candice confirm this? I thought it was spec.. Candice told me on myspace that she turned it down because her med school would only be so lenient and she didn't want to push it. I'm not the source, I'm just confirming what they said. Parvati wasn't her replacement though. They were both going to be cast in a twenty person All-Stars 2 season. When they had problems getting a good cast, the people chosen were condensed and Parvati was one of the ones that they decided to keep. Hot girl quota. That's what I was told anyway.
Vyvvi		#436	[-]
Posts: 1550 (12/29/08 9:01 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I remember hearing that Christy from Amazon was asked to be in FvF but had to turn it down because she was filming her children's show.
garyw		#437	[-]
Posts: 89 (12/29/08 9:35 AM) I don't take hints Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Katy Carney wrote: uvawe wrote: kenc333 wrote: Source? And Candice confirmed that she was invited, and it's been widely speculated that Parvati was her replacement. When/where did Candice confirm this? I thought it was spec.. Candice told me on myspace that she turned it down because her med school would only be so lenient and she didn't want to push it. I'm not the source, I'm just confirming what they said. Parvati wasn't her replacement though. They were both going to be cast in a twenty person All-Stars 2 season. When they had problems getting a good cast, the people chosen were condensed and Parvati was one of the ones that they decided to keep. Hot girl quota. That's what I was told anyway. There are so many theories in this thread one poster said that it was always going to be FvF. I'm not sure how they would have problems with a good cast surely they would have been better than the fans apart from Tracy, Kathy and Catalie.
garyw		#438	[-]
Posts: 90 (12/29/08 9:38 AM) I don't take hints Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1TxT1 wrote: garyw wrote: The cast was apparently: Survivor: Vanuatu - Ami (6th place), Julie (5th place), Eliza (4th place). Survivor: Palau - Coby (9th place), Jenn (4th place), Ian (3rd place), Katie (2nd place). Survivor: Guatemala - Gary (7th place), Judd (6th place), Lydia (4th place). Survivor: Exile Island - Shane (5th place), Cirie (4th place), Terry (3rd place). Survivor: Cook Islands - Jonathan (7th place), Parvati (6th place), Ozzy (2nd place). Survivor: Fiji - Michelle (10th place), Yau-Man (4th place). Survivor: China - James (7th place), Courtney (placement still unknown). I guess when Jeff split up with Julie she was cut, Courtney declined she probably realised she couldn't lose anymore weight. I have no idea why they decided on bringing in fans maybe most of their wish list declined. I actually think that rumor might've started with a poster here! Zesty posted his own cast list on some website and some people thought it was the real thing and that's where the rumor got started. I think that was his cast list above but I can't remember. I did read somewhere that Terry and Yul were dropped late. Coby was dropped early enough for him to come here and start giving us info about the rumors he'd heard about I can understand Yul they already had two male cast members from Cook Islands who were going to bring more entertainment than him. Terry probably never got cast as they realised he wasn't liked. Coby well he shouldn't have been on the list in the first place.
Kitty Pryde1		#439	[-]
Posts: 7871 (12/29/08 11:22 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	For the record, Jenn should never have been on the list either.
CesterninoDoggieStyle		#440	[-]
Posts: 99 (12/31/08 11:54 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	i read every word of this thread

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

The "What If" Game

Quick Reply