The "What If" Game

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
finishthemoff	Re: ASS after Exile Island	#381	[-]
Posts: 15489 (02/27/06 9:04 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Susan didn't seems motherly and loving though. How can she get along with Colleen?
DEVILRAYS	Re: ASS after Exile Island	#382	[-]
Posts: 744 (03/02/06 11:37 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	OK, back to the Marquesas for this one. I had this one written out before, at least halfway...then my computer decided to fuck up and I lost it. Anywho, we all know who the number one driving force was behind the overthrow of the Rotu Four. No Sean, no call to Johnnie Cochran, no last-ditch effort to stay, and no overthrow of the almighty Rotu forces. But wait - Rob was earmarked for the boot right after the merge. So somehow he doesn't go. Read on. Episode 7: After Kathy and Rob get together for the merge, Soliantu is born - and the game is afoot. Sadly, we know Boston Rob was a mere pawn for the overthrow of the Rotu 4; his immunity loss was the underdogs' gain, as Sean's credibility was far greater than his. But think about this - Rob could have saved himself at the challenge by not screwing around. If he outlasts John, he and Kathy are the last two in the challenge, and for purposes of the challenge, Boston Rob gets immunity, and damn does he need it. So it's off to Plan B for the Rotu 4, and they have the numbers to do it. Simply put, it's what drives this What If? So long Sean. 6 votes Sean: John, Neleh, Paschal, Robert, Tammy, Zoe 3 votes John: Rob, Sean, Vecepia 1 vote Zoe: Kathy Episode 8: Time to cut some coconuts. And yes, the Rotu 4 makes it pretty clear who is running the show, as Rob's out first, then Vee, then Kathy. Tammy still wins immunity, but here's the difference - Rob's credibility isn't on the up-and-up, he makes a big deal about it of course, but Vecepia decides she's better off ignoring him. Not only is there no overthrow of the Rotu 4 at this point; there's no one left who can really stand another minute of Rob. 8 votes Rob: John, Kathy, Neleh, Paschal, Robert, Tammy, Vecepia, Zoe 1 vote John: Rob Episode 9: Time for the big blowout fight between Tammy and Zoe. OK, so we know they never liked each other. We also know that Tammy's the only one who can manage those stilts worth a damn. The big blowout here - Zoe wants no part of the alliance. Fine and dandy; the Rotu 4 figures they can afford to kick out someone who's a potential bad apple. Zoe turns against the alliance; the alliance turns against Zoe. 7 votes Zoe: John, Kathy, Neleh, Paschal, Robert, Tammy, Vecepia 1 vote Robert: Zoe Episode 10: So we still have our timeline's final four here, but don't kid yourselves; Neleh and Paschal are in with the Rotu 4...err, 3. Time to build a fire, I guess...time for Kathy to be a hero? Do the producers want to save her? Well, what does it matter; Robert won it in our timeline, and he can have it here. Fortunately for Kathy, she's an old Rotu and is therefore not a target. Vecepia tries to get Kathy, Neleh, and Paschal to turn against the Rotus...but if it didn't do any good two rounds ago, all you can say for Vecepia is that it didn't hurt to try. 6 votes Vecepia: John, Kathy, Neleh, Paschal, Robert, Tammy 1 vote Tammy: Vecepia Episode 11: Well, it's too late to turn against the Rotus, and Kathy knows she's next. She's working every angle she has, even if it means turning against Paschal and Neleh. I'll chalk this one up to Neleh, since she did well in our timeline. Meanwhile, Kathy wants to break up the Paschal-Neleh connection, and frankly, the gang is going for it. With Neleh as an immunity threat, they decide they have to cut her off, and out goes Paschal. No purple rocks were harmed in the making of this episode. 4 votes Paschal: John, Kathy, Robert, Tammy 2 votes Kathy: Neleh, Paschal Episode 12: It's story time, boys and girls. And today, we're going to kill...Neleh. Well, we're going to try to; remember that Kathy won it in our timeline, and so she shall here. As for Neleh...well, she's a dead duck. She's so upset she might consider saying the word "fudge" out loud. The kicked out Pappy, and now she's probably next. Should have paid better attention at story time. Oh well; no F4 for Neleh this time. She gets her initial wish - she joins the jury. 4 votes Neleh: John, Kathy, Robert, Tammy 1 vote John: Neleh Episode 13, part 1: OK, so how to sub-divide the alliance. This especially gets interesting when Kathy wins immunity, simply because she hordes all her information. Robert's a threat, and so is Tammy, so it's time to break out the rocks. 2 votes Robert: Kathy, Tammy 2 votes Tammy: John, Robert When faced with the possibility of going home, however, John doesn't hesitate - he switches his vote to Robert. Episode 13, part 2: OK, immunity time again. Already. I guess John fancies himself as Richard Hatch, and he's banking on being taken to the finals. Tammy wins immunity, and she doesn't want to go against Kathy, so John's ploy works. 1 vote Kathy: Tammy The Final Two: Tammy vs. John Rob: Oh boy did he hate John. It wasn't so much homophobia or anything; he just didn't like John. I can't imagine him voting for John. So it goes to Tammy. Zoe: Maybe not exactly a Sue Hawk prototype, but certainly isn't going to vote for Tammy. She would prefer a better alternative, but she'll vote for John. Vecepia: Again, she may not agree with John's lifestyle, but it comes down to gameplay first. There's no obvious pick here, so I pick her as respecting Tammy's gameplay more. Paschal: None too happy with either of them, but he grew closer to John, so he votes John. Neleh: She and Paschal vote together, so while she's displeased, so she votes John. Robert: A bitter little asshole this guy is. John turned against Robert. Robert isn't going to give John a million dollars. He votes for Tammy. Kathy: Why didn't Tammy take her? Why? Well, if Tammy and Kathy had a deal, and Tammy didn't honor it, it smacks of Vee turning against Kathy and letting Neleh win immunity. Simply put, she votes John. John Carroll's mom goes to a nice retirement home in this scenario...and maybe this isn't such a great season, since another Richard Hatch wannabe wins it. Maybe it affects Thailand; I don't know.
TheLurkerSpeaks	Re: ASS after Exile Island	#383	[-]
Posts: 1503 (03/03/06 10:30 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Robert and Tammy were close. The tie at F4 (if there was one) would be between John and whoever Kathy decided to vote for. And it is unlikely that Robert or Tammy would switch votes so we may well still have seen the purple rock. More likely is that Kathy goes along with booting John. If Tammy wins immunity at F3, she definitely would boot Kathy, but there would be no deal in place to break. Kathy would know she has to win to get to F2 and wouldn't be bitter (though you can bet John would be). Votes: Rob - Tammy Zoe - Robert Vecepia - Tammy Paschal - Robert Neleh - Robert John - ? Kathy - Tammy So who apologizes to John at Final TC and gets his vote? I lean slightly toward Tammy.
colleenlover	Re: ASS after Exile Island	#384	[-]
Posts: 9333 (03/03/06 10:47 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	*Quote:* Episode 9: Time for the big blowout fight between Tammy and Zoe. OK, so we know they never liked each other. We also know that Tammy's the only one who can manage those stilts worth a damn. The big blowout here - Zoe wants no part of the alliance. Fine and dandy; the Rotu 4 figures they can afford to kick out someone who's a potential bad apple. Zoe turns against the alliance; the alliance turns against Zoe. 7 votes Zoe: John, Kathy, Neleh, Paschal, Robert, Tammy, Vecepia 1 vote Robert: Zoe Huh? this only happened because the Rotu 4 were split up in the episode before that - Zoe feelings about Tammy came out because they were both in self preservation mode. What would happen in final eight -if Rob and Sean were both gone -is A) Vecepia worming in further with the Rotu 4 B) Johnny deciding on whether Vecepia or Kathy should leave. C) Kathy being reassured by Neleh and Paschal that Vee will go next. D) Kathy working on Zoe heavily with their old friendship and trying to pull in Pap, Neleh, Zoe and outsider Vee into a counter alliance. THE KEY FACTOR in this episode would be Zoe's conscience.
TheLurkerSpeaks	Re: ASS after Exile Island	#385	[-]
Posts: 1503 (03/03/06 11:25 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Continuing the story line of S1 contestants doing Exile Island, after Episode 4 we were left with: La Mina: Greg, Richard, Sean, Gervase, Kelly, Colleen, Ramona Casaya: Joel, Dirk, Rudy, Jenna, Susan La Mina sits out Colleen and Ramona in the fish toss. Greg collects the fish while Sean is the slicer. For Casaya, Dirk collects while Joel cuts. Joel proves a better slicer than Sean, allowing Casaya to take a lead. Then Gervase and Sean fumble a few tosses to fall further behind. Even some late stumbles by Jenna for Casaya end up not mattering as Casaya takes it. Sue's the one who comes up with the idea of exiling one of the girls who sat out. She favors exiling Ramona, but Joel and Jenna lobby for Colleen who they see as more likely to contribute. Greg told Colleen he has the idol so she doesn't bother looking and concentrates on surviving. In the IC, Gervase and Kelly sit out for La Mina. Richard, Sean, and Colleen head out in the boat while Greg and Ramona wait to do the puzzle. For Casaya, Susan, Rudy, and Dirk go out in the boat while Jenna and Joel stay to do the puzzle. Richard and Sean power a faster boat initially, and Richard easily collects the first piece. Rudy and Susan collect their first piece shortly thereafter. La Mina is still ahead after collecting the second piece as well. But by this point, Richard, who is doing all the diving work by himself, and Colleen, already weakened by her Exile Island stay, are slowing, and the Casaya boat is moving faster. Rudy and Susan working together are collecting the pieces efficiently. By the time La Mina has all their pieces, the Casaya boat is already heading back. Dirk is powering that boat, and they start pulling away from the La Mina one, eventually giving Jenna and Joel a nice head start on the puzzle. They are still working on it when Richard deposits the La Mina pieces for Greg and Ramona. Greg looks to make fast work, but just as he sees how it fits together, Casaya is announced as the winner. La Mina hasn't gone to TC since the unanimous dumping of B. B., and the dynamics are untested. Richard gets along well with Gervase, who has allied himself with Ramona. Greg and Richard acknowledge each other as the strength of the tribe, and there is respect if not fondness between them. Greg has bonded with Colleen of course. Sean and Kelly are the outsiders, and by this time, they don't care for each other either. Richard and Greg each want to maneuver to outposition the other. Greg really wants Ramona gone, but Richard sees himself, Gervase, and Ramona as the base of his future alliance. He needs a fourth to take control of the voting, and he finds that fourth in Sean. Rather than taking on Greg directly, Richard decides to eliminate the other swing vote Kelly, who he doesn't believe he can trust. Ramona isn't particularly happy with this since she had started bonding with Kelly, but as the alternative appears to be herself, she goes along. Kelly leaves 4 - 2 - 1 with Kelly voting for Sean. Leaves: La Mina: Greg, Richard, Sean, Gervase, Colleen, Ramona Casaya: Joel, Dirk, Rudy, Jenna, Susan
TheLurkerSpeaks	Re: ASS after Exile Island	#386	[-]
Posts: 1503 (03/10/06 4:08 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Continuing into Episode 6: At the combined RC/IC, we have La Mina with an extra person, and Colleen sits out. Greg and Ramona get puzzle duty while Sean, Richard and Gervase will collect the pieces. For Casaya, Rudy and Jenna will do the puzzle while Joel, Dirk, and Susan get the pieces. Joel and Sean run pretty even, almost colliding on the way back, but Joel gives Casaya a small lead. Dirk though is faster than Richard, and by the time he hands off to Susan, Casaya has opened things up. Gervase quickly rushes over to the pieces, but he's not nearly as tough as Susan on the knots. Susan drops off the third puzzle piece, and Joel quickly retrieves the fourth shortly after Gervase returns with La Mina's third. Jenna and Rudy prove a poor match for solving the puzzle. Hyper Jenna is too impatient with steady Rudy, and they end up stepping on each other's efforts. When Sean returns with La Mina's final piece, they have made no progress. In contrast, Ramona is willing to follow Greg's lead, and it quickly pays off. Seeing La Mina pulling ahead, Jenna panics, and the contest is quickly a foregone conclusion. La Mina is given the choice of protecting a Casayan from TC. Rudy looks like the outsider so he is the one chosen. The six La Minans go enjoy the reward. Susan wants to stick with the plan and vote off Dirk, the real outsider. But Joel balks at removing more of their strength when they don't know when a merge might be. He tries to get Jenna to turn on Susan, but persuasion is not his strong suit. The persuasion attempt turns into a fight as a frustrated Joel starts venting. When Jenna later complains to Susan, it is suddenly Joel who is on the block. Joel has no problem getting Dirk to vote for Susan, who he's been voting for already, but now it looks like an inevitable tie. And so it is, and the firestarter tiebreaker is unveiled. In a close one, Susan gets hers lit first, and Joel goes home. Leaves: La Mina: Greg, Colleen, Richard, Gervase, Ramona, Sean Casaya: Susan, Jenna, Dirk, Rudy
x0xcindychickx0x	What if Barramundi and Balboa were two tribes (of nine)	#387	[-]
Posts: 1817 (03/11/06 11:09 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Barramundi Tribe: Alicia, Jerri, Nick, Amber, Rodger, Elisabeth, Keith, Colby, Tina. Balboa Tribe: Ryno, Rupert, Tijuana, Christa, Burton, Darrah, Jon, Sandra, Lillian Episode #1 Balboa Immuned Keith-Alicia, Nick, Elisabeth, Rodger, Jerri, Amber Jerri-Tina, Colby, Keith Boot: Keith Episode #2 Balboa Immuned Jerri-Tina, Colby, Alicia, Nick, Elisabeth, Rodger Nick-Amber, Jerri Boot: Jerri Episode #3 Barramundi Immuned Burton- Tijuana, Darrah, Sandra, Rupert, Christa, Ryno Jon-Lillian Christa-Burton, Jon Boot: Burton Episode #4 Balboa Immuned Nick- Amber, Colby, Tina, Rodger, Elisabeth, Alicia Amber-Nick Boot: Nick Episode #5 Barramundi Immuned Jon-Lillian Sandra Christa Rupert Tijuana ChristaJon Ryno Darrah Boot: Jon Episode #6 Balboa Rewarded Both tribes to TC Christa-Tijuana Lillian Ryno Darrah Darrah-Christa Rupert RynoSandra Rodger left due to health issues Boot: Christa Rodger [due to illness] Episode #7 Tribes Merge Trioke Tribe Alicia Immune Lillian- Alicia, Elisabeth, Amber Tina Colby Tijuana Sandra Rupert Amber- Lillian Darrah Boot: Lillian Episode #8 Colby Immune Sandra-Alicia Elisabeth Amber Tina Colby Tijuana Tina- Darrah Rupert Boot: Sandra Jury:Sandra Episode #9 Colby Immune Darrah-Alicia Elisabeth Amber Rupert Tina Colby Tijuana Rupert Darrah Elisabeth Tijuana Boot: Darrah Jury:Sandra, Darrah Episode #10 Tijuana Immune Tina- Tijuana Rupert Elisabeth Amber Rupert- Alicia Colby Tina Boot: Tina Jury: Sandra, Darrah, Tina Episode #11 Rupert Immune Amber- Elisabeth Rupert Tijuana Elisabeth- Alicia Colby Amber Boot: Alicia [Due to purple rock] Jury: Sandra, Darrah, Tina, Alicia Episode #12 Rupert Immune Amber- Tijuana Elisabeth Rupert Tijuana- Colby Amber Boot: Amber Jury: Sandra, Darrah, Tina, Alicia, Amber Episode #13 Tijuana Immune Rupert-Tijuana Elisabeth Colby Elisabeth- Rupert Boot: Rupert Jury: Sandra, Darrah, Tina, Alicia, Amber, Rupert Episode #14 Tijuana Immune Elisabeth-Tijuana Boot: Elisabeth Jury: Sandra Darrah Tina Alicia Amber Rupert Elisabeth Sandra- Tijuana [original tribe] Darrah- Tijuana [Good Friends] Tina- Colby [original tribe] Alicia- Tijuana [feuds with Colby] Amber- Colby [not to fond of Tijuana] Rupert- Colby [mad at Tijuana] Elisabeth- Colby [thinks Tijuana can't be trusted] Colby wins Survivor Australian Islands
RobVanStratus	Re: New All Stars tribe pick	#388	[-]
Posts: 9629 (03/18/06 12:46 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Survivor Borneo - Gretchen/Susan switched Episode 1 Immunity - Pagong - Sonja still falls at the challenge and costs Tagi the win. Tribal Council #1 - With Sue off at Pagong, Gretchen is more likely to vote for Rudy, based on her vote at the merger and her reactions to him. This allows the women's alliance to pull together, without Gretchen really realizing it. Gretchen/Kelly/Sonja/Stacey - Rudy Dirk/Rudy/Sean - Sonja Richard - Stacey 16th - Rudy Boesch (4-3-1) Episode 2 Immunity - Tagi - Stacey/Sonja, whoever is picked for the faceoff, totally stomps Gervase still. Tribal Council #2 - To me, Sue would be very abrasive towards Gervase for losing the challenge, and she'd be vocal about voting him, off and vice versa. But BB would also be begging to leave, especially without his work horse Gretchen. This would cause major confusion in the votes. BB/Gervase/Greg/Joel - Susan Colleen/Jenna/Ramona - BB Susan - Gervase 15th - Susan Hawk (4-3-1) Episode 3 Immunity - Pagong - Sonja is in the tree, and Stacey ends up slowing down the tribe. Tribal Council #3 - Stacey tries to target one of the men, and this angers Kelly, who wants a strong tribe. Gretchen, who wants to vote based on who deserves to be around, ends up splitting from the women. Stacey's own stupidity costs her the game. Dirk/Gretchen/Kelly/Richard/Sean - Stacey Sonja/Stacey - Richard 14th - Stacey Stillman (5-2) Episode 4 Immunity - Tagi - Gervase again slows down his tribe with his move to walk in the woods, allowing Tagi to take the challenge. Tribal Council #4 - BB again begs to go home but Ramona, while still slightly sick, is recovering and still a target. The votes are split between the two. Colleen/Gervase/Jenna/Joel/Ramona - BB BB/Greg - Ramona 13th - BB Anderson (5-2) Episode 5 Immunity - Pagong - Again, Kelly gets beat by the guy who can't even swim, lol Tribal Council #5 - Sonja's time is clearly up, but Gretchen isn't revealing who she is voting for at TC, leaving Kelly/Sonja guessing. Dirk/Richard/Sean - Sonja Kelly/Sonja - Dirk Gretchen - Sean 12th - Sonja Christopher (3-2-1) Episode 6 Immunity - Tagi - Tagi clearly outmatches Pagong in the races, regardless of who participates. Tribal Council #6 - Joel/Gervase again are on the block, due to their women are cows comments. Ramona moves to save Gervase, as he did for her last time, while Greg moves to spare Joel. With no Gretchen around to shoot down Joel and alliances, he sticks around. Colleen/Greg/Jenna/Joel - Gervase Gervase/Ramona - Joel [/b]11th - Gervase Peterson (4-2)[/b] Episode 7 Immunity - Joel - It's a close race, but I think Joel would be the strongest guy left. Greg/Sean are viewed as major threats in challenges thanks to finishing in the top 3. Tribal Council #7 - With Gretchen not in favor of alliances and Sean pulling his ABC strategy, Tagi is falling apart. Richard tries to make a play to be saved, but is unable to make any moves, and he is screwed. Joel manages to pull Pagong together, with no Gretchen in Pagong to oppose him. Colleen/Greg/Jenna/Joel/Ramona - Richard Dirk/Sean - Colleen Kelly/Richard - Greg Gretchen - Jenna 10th - Richard Hatch (5-2-2-1) Episode 8 Immunity - I can't remember who was close to Gervase, but I'll say Dirk pulls off an IC win to save his ass. Tribal Council #8 - Pagong really gets annoyed with Sean and they are glad to be able to get rid of him. Colleen/Greg/Jenna/Joel/Kelly/Ramona - Sean Dirk/Sean - Joel Gretchen - Jenna 9th - Sean Keniff (6-2-1) Episode 9 Immunity - Rudy just got the luck of the draw before, so I'll just guess Gretchen pulls off a shocking win, dooming Dirk. Tribal Council #9 - Dirk is clearly the target and it saddens Pagong that they are down to all great people, even though they want to win. Colleen/Greg/Jenna/Joel/Ramona - Dirk Dirk/Gretchen/Kelly - Jenna 8th - Dirk Been (5-3) Episode 10 Immunity - Gretchen - She is the best in the outdoors, making sure that she would be safe yet again. Tribal Council #10 - As Colleen/Jenna/Ramona realizes that Kelly is going home, they are heartbroken. They want to keep her around and Joel has become too bossy to them. They decide to pick off Joel and spare both Tagi women. Colleen/Jenna/Kelly/Ramona - Joel Greg/Joel - Kelly Gretchen - Jenna 7th - Joel Klug (4-2-1) Episode 11 Immunity - Kelly - She won it last time, its fairly obvious she'd stick around. Tribal Council #11 - With Gretchen and Greg as the boot choices, the 4 young women are very confused on who should go home. Gretchen's outdoor skills and motherly attitude has been a great help to them, while Greg has been entertaining, but its far more of a threat. Greg tries to pull over Kelly to vote off Jenna, but its no help. Colleen/Jenna/Kelly/Ramona - Greg Greg/Gretchen - Jenna 6th - Greg Buis (4-2) Episode 12 Immunity - Kelly - Duh. Tribal Council #12 - Kelly knows Gretchen has been voting Jenna and tries to swing Colleen to vote off Jenna. Ramona/Jenna have become a tight pair, being close friends throughout the game. Colleen feels torn, as she likes all the women left and doesn't want to vote off Jenna or Gretchen. Colleen chooses to vote with Kelly/Gretchen in the end, as Jenna has gotten too annoying. Colleen/Gretchen/Kelly - Jenna Jenna/Ramona - Gretchen 5th - Jenna Lewis (3-2) Episode 13 Immunity - Gretchen - Both Kelly and Gretchen have gotten to know the people well, but Gretchen barely beats Kelly. Tribal Council #13 - The vote is very tight. Again, the women have all enjoyed one anothers company and hate that they need to vote someone off. Gretchen/Kelly - Ramona Colleen - Kelly Ramona - Colleen 4th - Ramona Gray (2-1-1) Immunity - Kelly - Kelly beats out both the women in the challenge easily Tribal Council #14 - Kelly clearly has more of a bond to Gretchen and saves her. Kelly - COLLEEN 3rd - Colleen Haskell (1-0) Final Two - Gretchen Cordy vs Kelly Wiglesworth Jury Votes Sean - Gretchen. Doesn't want to lose to a hippie like river raft guide. Dirk - Kelly. They got along well early in the game and she is a great person. Joel - Gretchen. Definitely more of a survivalist. Greg - Gretchen. He does NOT want to lose to some hippie like river raft guide. Jenna - Kelly. Gretchen continued to vote against her and she really doesn't think she belongs there. Ramona - Kelly. A young woman who was able to be an underdog and make it far. Colleen - Gretchen. A motherly figure to her and she really admires her. Gretchen Cordy wins 4-3 over Kelly Wiglesworth! That would really change the face of the game. True survivalists would go farther in the game and Tina probably wouldn't have ever won over Colby.
cantthinkofaname	Re: New All Stars tribe pick	#389	[-]
Posts: 1671 (03/18/06 4:31 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Hey x0xcindychickx0x, what happened to Ryno?
Jafet	Re: New All Stars tribe pick	#390	[-]
Posts: 112 (03/18/06 2:03 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If it would've been Skinny Ryan I'd have a perfect reason :P
I Chenbot	Re: New All Stars tribe pick	#391	[-]
Posts: 60 (03/19/06 4:36 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Outback What Ifs What if Colby and Tina would have voted against Keith rather than Mitchell. Episodes 1-4: Debb, Kel, Maralyn, Keith booted Episode 5 With weak Mitchell rather than strong Keith in attendance at the immunity maze challenge. Easy win for Kucha. Back at camp, Mitchell Amber & Jerri seem to want to stick together. A last minute effort by Colby & Tina to swing Mitchell to vote off Jerri fails and Tina is voted out 3-2. Tina (3 votes): Amber, Jerri, Mitchell Jerri (2 votes): Colby, Tina Episode 6 Nothing changes here, Kucha wins the reward. Michael still falls into the fire and needs to be evacuated from the game. Michael: Evacuated Episode 7 The tribes merge into the Barramundi Tribe which consists of: Amber, Colby, Mitchell, Jerri, Alicia, Jeff, Kimmi, Nick, Rodger, Elisabeth. Colby feels the most vulnerable going into the perch immunity challenge, so he hangs on and wins immunity. The Kucha 6 take this opportunity to get rid of the second biggest threat and they boot Jerri 6-4, despite efforts from Ogakor to sway Kimmi. Jerri (6 votes): Alicia, Elisabeth, Jeff, Kimmi, Nick, Rodger Jeff (4 votes): Amber, Colby, Jerri, Mitchell Episode 8 Amber wins the boomerang throwing contest and takes Mitchell with her. Amber gets the most boxes and wins the immunity challenge as well. With the biggest threat Colby open for elimination, Kucha takes advantage and boots him 6-3. Colby (6 votes): Alicia, Elisabeth, Jeff, Kimmi, Nick, Rodger Kimmi (3 votes): Amber, Colby, Mitchell Jury: Colby. Episode 9 The duo of Alicia/Jeff win the reward challenge and go to the Great Barrier Reef. Amber and Mitchell take this opportunity to try and sway Elisabeth, Rodger, and Kimmi to voting one of the two out. Nick still wins the balance immunity challenge. Ogakor's plan doesn't work as the Pagonging continues and Amber is voted out 6-2. Amber (6 votes): Alicia, Elisabeth, Jeff, Kimmi, Nick, Rodger Alicia (2 votes): Amber, Mitchell Jury: Colby, Amber. Episode 10 Mitchell gives it his all and comes close but Alicia merely beats him in the fire building immunity challenge. Despite more efforts to get Elisabeth/Rodger/Kimmi against the other three. It fails and the last member of the Ogakor Tribe is voted out 6-1. Mitchell (6 votes): Alicia, Elisabeth, Jeff, Kimmi, Nick, Rodger Jeff (1 vote): Mitchell Jury: Colby, Amber, Mitchell. Episode 11 Alicia continues her winning streak as she wins both the reward and the immunity challenge. Alicia & Jeff both want Kimmi gone, but Rodger & Elisabeth know they will be outnumbered if they get rid of her. So they approach Kimmi and at tribal council we have our first tie. Jeff (3 votes): Elisabeth, Kimmi, Rodger Kimmi (3 votes): Alicia, Jeff, Nick When a re-vote fails to break the tie, Jeff is voted out due to the many previous votes he has stacked against him. Jury: Colby, Amber, Mitchell, Jeff. Episode 12 To the surprise of everyone, Kimmi ends up winning the immunity challenge. Alicia/Nick work on bringing Kimmi to their side. But ultimately, Kimmi's hatred for Alicia works against her and Alicia is voted out 3-2. Alicia (3 votes): Elisabeth, Kimmi, Rodger Elisabeth (2 votes): Alicia, Nick Jury: Colby, Amber, Mitchell, Jeff, Alicia. Episode 13 At the immunity challenge, Elisabeth pulls off a win. Nick is sent packing in a 3-1 vote. Nick (3 votes): Elisabeth, Kimmi, Rodger Kimmi (1 vote): Nick Jury: Colby, Amber, Mitchell, Jeff, Alicia, Nick. Episode 14 - Season Finale Elisabeth wins the final immunity challenge and to nobody's surprise she boots Kimmi. Kimmi (1 vote): Elisabeth Jury: Colby, Amber, Mitchell, Jeff, Alicia, Nick, Kimmi. Final 2: Elisabeth vs Rodger Colby (votes Elisabeth): He ultimately got to know her more, and Rodger pleaded a better case that Elisabeth should win rather than himself. Amber (votes Elisabeth): Loved them both, but voted for Elisabeth because of Rodger's plea that she needed the money more. Mitchell (votes Elisabeth): Respected her game play, and the whole thing with Rodger thinking she needed the money more. Jeff (votes Rodger): Respected his game play. Alicia (votes Rodger): Was closer to him, and thought it was kind of him to be willing to give up the money for Elisabeth. Thinks he deserves it more. Nick (votes Rodger): Doesn't think Elisabeth should win the game just because Rodger thinks she deserves it more. Kimmi (votes Elisabeth): Got really close with her, and even though she felt hurt that Elisabeth had voted her off. She votes for her because she felt Elisabeth played a better game. Elisabeth Filarski wins Survivor Outback 4-3!!
x0xcindychickx0x	Re: Morphed	#392	[-]
Posts: 1817 (03/19/06 1:45 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	What if Soliantu and Xhakum were 2 tribes of nine? Episode 1 Xhakum Immuned John- Kathy Neleh Paschal Vecepia Sean Vecepia- John Zoe Tammy Paschal- Robert Boot: John 5-3-1 Episode 2 Xhakum Immuned Paschal- Robert Zoe Tammy Zoe Kathy Paschal Neleh Tammy Vecepia Sean [It was a mistake on Vecepia and Sean's part due to purple rock] Boot: Pachal 3-3-2 Episode 3 Soliantu Immuned Bobby Jon Steph Cindy Judd Jamie Lydia Rafe Danni Gary Steph Bobby Jon Boot: Bobby Jon 7-1 Episode 4 Soliantu immuned Steph Danni Gary Lydia Cindy Jamie Danni Judd Rafe Steph Boot: Steph 5-3 Episode 5 Soliantu Immuned Danni Cindy Jamie Judd Lydia Cindy Gary Danni Rafe Boot: Danni 4-3 Episode 6 No Immunity Soliantu Tammy Vecepia Sean Kathy Neleh Sean Zoe Robert Tammy Boot 1: Tammy 4-3 Xhakum Gary Cindy Judd Jamie Lydia Cindy Gary Rafe Boot 2: Gary 4-2 Episode 7 Soliantu Immuned Rafe Cindy Lydia Jamie Judd Judd Rafe Boot: Rafe 4-1 Episode 8 Xhakum Immuned Robert Vecepia Kathy Sean Sean Neleh Zoe Zoe Robert Boot: Robert 3-2-1 Episode 9 Merge Solxhatukum Tribe Cindy Immuned Judd Vecepia Sean Kathy Neleh Zoe Kathy Cindy Lydia Judd Jamie Boot: Judd 5-4 Jury: Judd Episode 10 Kathy Immuned Jamie Vecepia Sean Kathy Neleh Sean Cindy Lydia Jamie Lydia Zoe Boot: Jamie 4-3-1 Jury: Judd, Jamie Episode 11 Sean Immuned Lydia Vecepia Sean Kathy Neleh Neleh Cindy Lydia Zoe Boot: Lydia 4-3 Jury: Judd, Jamie, Lydia Episode 12 Cindy Immuned Zoe Cindy Vecepia Sean Kathy Neleh Sean Zoe Boot: Zoe 5-1 Jury: Judd, Jamie, Lydia, Zoe Episode 13 Cindy Immuned Sean Kathy Neleh Neleh Vecepia Sean Kathy Cindy Boot: Neleh in tie-breaker 2-2-1 Jury: Judd, Jamie, Lydia, Zoe, Neleh Episode 14 Vecepia Immuned Sean Kathy Cindy Kathy Vecepia Sean Boot: Sean Purple Rock 2-2 Jury: Judd Jamie Lydia Zoe Neleh Sean Episode 15 Cindy Immuned Kathy Cindy Boot: Kathy 1-0 Jury: Judd Jamie Lydia Zoe Neleh Sean Kathy Judd- Cindy Jamie- Cindy Lydia- Cindy Zoe- ~Vecepia is the survivor~ Neleh- Vecepia Sean- Vecepia Kathy- Vecepia! VECEPIA WINNER OF MARQUMALA
Pulau Tiga	Re: Morphed	#393	[-]
Posts: 5771 (03/19/06 7:50 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Er, x0xcindychickx0x, I'm pretty sure that was a fanfic without any information or story, not a "What If?" *Quote:* John- Kathy Neleh Paschal Vecepia Sean Why do they boot one of their strongest men first? And why do Neleh, Paschal, and Kathy target someone that works relativey hard and is an all-around asset over the lazier Sean if they weren't worrying about challenges? *Quote:* It was a mistake on Vecepia and Sean's part due to purple rock Why are Vecepia and Sean completely oblivious to how the vote is going down when they were clearly on the inside of the previous vote? *Quote:* Bobby Jon- Steph Cindy Judd Jamie Lydia Rafe Danni Gary Again, why are they booting their strength? And why are Bobby Jon and Stephenie turning on each other when they are each the other's ticket to the win? *Quote:* Danni- Cindy Jamie Judd Lydia Cindy- Gary Danni Rafe This just doesn't make any sense, nor does the rest of it.
FairThinker	saving "what if"	#394	[-]
Posts: 47 (11/08/06 7:00 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Bumping this fine thread so that it can be enjoyed a while longer
Dr Will Hatch two point oh	Re: saving "what if"	#395	[-]
Posts: 10096 (04/13/07 7:25 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	What if Cirie booted Aras at f5? danielle would have teamed up with her, win the tiebreaker over inshane, danielle wins f3 ic, boots terry, Cirie wins. thats why Aras is an underrated. He smoothed talked her into making mistakes
RobVanStratus	Re: saving "what if"	#396	[-]
Posts: 9629 (04/13/07 7:40 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Well that would have required a change in the votes from more than just Cirie. Originally it broke down with Aras/Cirie/Danielle voting Shane, Shane voting Danielle, and Terry voting Aras. If Cirie tells Shane that Aras betrayed him, perhaps that changes his vote and then Aras is out 3-2. Then Terry wins the F4 IC and likely gives the Idol to Shane, the most crazy person and easy beat for the F4. Then Cirie has no choice but to vote for Danielle with the guys because otherwise they might Idol her out of the game. Then it's a tossup between Cirie, Shane, and Terry for the last IC. Shane might win simply because he was the smallest person at the time and if that occurs, he would take Terry, whom he perceives the easier beat for the win and plus he just saved his butt with the idol. So Cirie wouldn't have won in that situation, if what I think would happen would have happened.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh	Re: saving "what if"	#397	[-]
Posts: 10096 (04/13/07 7:43 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	You have a point if you were dealing with anyone but Terry. Hes strategically inept, and would never give up the hii
RobVanStratus	Re: saving "what if"	#398	[-]
Posts: 9629 (04/14/07 8:59 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Yeah. The only way Terry was giving that idol up at the F4 was if he had won the IC, then he could give it to his F2 partner without worry.
Quiddity	Re: saving "what if"	#399	[-]
Posts: 6880 (04/14/07 9:34 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Man, I still wish to this day that Terry gave his idol to Danielle at F4. Then Danielle turns around and tells Aras & Cirie, they vote out Terry, and Cirie isn't unfairly booted at F4 because of that lame Hidden Immunity Idol. Terry is such a strategic retard, I'm amazed he didn't do that infact :P
XtremeInnovator420	Re: saving "what if"	#400	[-]
Posts: 2661 (04/14/07 1:23 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Speaking of Terry, would it be safe to say that a "Pagonging" would still happen to La Mina if Terry had given the HII to Nick at the merge episode, causing Shane to go home?

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

The "What If" Game

Quick Reply