The "What If" Game

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
I LUV TIJUANA	The "What If" Game	Lead	[-]
Posts: 15673 (05/15/04 12:42 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Every 3 days I will propse a scenario and we will talk through what could have happened if that scenario ended up differently. SCENARIO #1- What if Paschal, Neleh, Vecepia, Sean and Kathy never aligned to take out the Rotu 4. What I think Would happen... Sean would have been voted out and become the first jury member. Vecepia would have voted with Rotu. Unless Vecepia won Immunity, she would have been next. Followed by Kathy, Paschal and Neleh, in any order. Down to Tammy, John, Robert and Zoe. Tammy and John were close. Robert and Tammy were close. Zoe and Tammy became enemies. Zoe voted out. Final Immunity Challenge- Tammy would win. She takes John to the finals, stands a better chance winning against him. JURY VOTE- Sean- TAMMY Vecepia- TAMMY Kathy- TAMMY Paschal- ? Neleh- JOHN? Zoe- JOHN Robert- TAMMY Tammy wins Survivor Marquesas! What do you guys think?
MadNei	ok	#1	[-]
Posts: 5 (05/15/04 12:53 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	are their any fan fics on the net that deal with "what if" survivors and where can they be found. seen one kucha won the first immuity challege but it was never completed beyond episode 1
unknown115	how about this	#2	[-]
Posts: 609 (05/15/04 1:00 PM) I need a life Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	season 4 starts off, and rotu loses 1st immunity. They boot John, because he's trying to backstab everyone. Muraamu loses next and boots patricia, too bossy. Next is Tammy, too threatening. Sarah's out, useless. Peter is fucking weird so they boot him. Zoe is a threat so she's out next. final 10 gabe, kathy, neleh, paschal, robert gina, hunter, rob, sean, vecepia next is gabe, then robert, kathy, paschal, and neleh. sean is pissing everyone off, so he gets the boot. Rob joins Vee and boots Hunter next, and then Gina wins and boots Vee, going against Rob final 2. Robert- Gina Kathy- Gina Paschal- Gina Neleh- Gina Sean- Gina Hunter- Gina Vecepia- Gina Gina wins 7-0 over Rob
I LUV TIJUANA	Re: how about this	#3	[-]
Posts: 15673 (05/15/04 1:07 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Start from after Rob Mariano was voted off!!!!
Gnarl24	Re: how about this	#4	[-]
Posts: 3055 (05/15/04 1:14 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I highly doubt Sean would vote Gina over Rob. And others might not see Gina as that great of a palyer compared to Rob. Having the 2 in a fianal 2 wouldn't be a clean sweap for either side.
I LUV TIJUANA	Re: how about this	#5	[-]
Posts: 15673 (05/15/04 1:53 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	please dont post other shit in here. i said ill change the scenario every 3 days. say what you think would happen if Neleh,Pappy,Kathy,Vee and Sean did not align to take out the Rotu 4. Do like what I did. I will tally the winners. It will be fun. ~ILT/Dan
wake me b4 TC	Re: how about this	#6	[-]
Posts: 536 (05/15/04 2:38 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	OK, Ive got a little time hereChapera -Rob M. -Rob C. -Tom -Sue -Alicia -Elizabeth Mogo Mog -Lex -Richard -Colby -Kathy -Shii Ahn -Jenna M. Sabogo -Rupert -Rudy -Ethan -Colleen -Tina -Jerri ep 1-Sabogo looses IC. Jerri tries to take out the winners alone, but Coleen is a much different player than Jenna, and JERRI has no allies, and is the firstboot. ep 2-Saboga looses again. RUDY still gets hurt and is the second boot. ep 3-JENNA still goes home and is the 3rd eliminated ep 4-ROB C still 4th boot ep 5-same old same old with HATCH as the 5th boot ep 6-no effect on SUES decision to quit and the 6th elimination ep 7-Tina and Ethan join Mogo, Coleen and Rupert join CHapera. Mogo still looses. Heres were things could get interesting, insecure Lex still wants to be the Alpha male, but knows that Ethan and Tina wont go with him on it. Ethan, Tina, and Colby would join forces, and Lex would team up with them. SHI ANNE is the odd man out, and is booted 7th. ep 8-swap, Lis would be the one to switch tribes. Since LIS is married, and Boston Robs charm never works on her, he doesnt try to save her, and she is booted 8th. ep 9-merge. Ethan, Colby, Tina, Lex, Kathy/Boston Rob, Tom, Alicia, Coleen, Rupert. Rob and Kathy still win IC. Tom jumps ship to reform the Boron Boys Club. Since Boston Rob wins IC, RUPERT is the 9th boot. ep 10-would Rob win the IC or would Colby be good enough competition to beat im? Lets say that Colby beats him, and BOSTON ROB is the 10th boot. ep 11-ALICIA is booted. ep 12-there is noise of taking out the boys club, but it is all editing. COLEEN is boot 12, as she Deja Vud as the final member of a pagonging ep 13-Ethan wins IC, ending Colbys run. Colby and Tina try to get Kathy on their side, but in the end, she stays loyal, and COLBY is number 13 ep 14-TINA is the 14th boot. ep 15-final 4-Lex, Ethan, Tom, Kathy. Ethan wins IC and KATHY is booted. endurance IC. Tom first down. Lex outlasts Ethan. Lex is faced with booting Ethan, who he thinks he can beat because hes a former winner, or Tom who he thinks can beat him. He does the honerable thing, and boots ETHAN. Final 2-Lex and Tom Rupert-doesnt take things lightly, such as Tom jumping ship. LEX ALicia-same thing, LEX Coleen-more understanding, and votes TOM who was with her longer. Colby-LEX Tina-TOM Kathy-LEX Ethan-hardto tell, but it doesnt matter, because LEX clinched already. OVERVIEW boot 1-Jerri boot 2-Rudy boot 3-Jenna boot 4-Rob C boot 5-Rich boot 6-Sue boot 7-She Anne boot 8-Lis boot 9-Rupert boot 10-Boston Rob boot 11-Alicia boot 12-Coleen boot 13-COlby boot 14-Tina boot 15-Kathy boot 16-Ethan runner up-Big Tom WINNER-LEX!
I LUV TIJUANA	Re: how about this	#7	[-]
Posts: 15673 (05/15/04 2:46 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	MAKE ANOTHER THREAD IF YOU WANT TO DO SHIT LIKE THAT!!!!!!!! Right now this thread is for- WHAT IF NELEH, PASCHAL, KATHY, VECEPIA AND SEAN DID NOT COME TOGETHER TO TAKE OUT THE ROTU 4. How dumb are you people!
Gnarl24	Re: how about this	#8	[-]
Posts: 3055 (05/15/04 4:33 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Rota-John, Gabe, Paschal, Robert, Kathy, Neleh, Tammy, Zoe Maraamu-Patricia, Gina, Sarah, Vecepia, Sean, Hunter, Rob, Peter Maraamu looses 1st challenge- Peter goes Maraamu looses 2nd challenge-Patricia goes Rotu looses 3rd challenge- Papschal goes Switch Maraamu-Kathy, Gina, Neleh, Sarah, Sean Rotu-Vecepia, Rob, Hunter, Gabe, Robert, John, Tammy, Zoe Maraamu looses 4th challenge-Sarah goes Rotu looses 5th challenge-Gabe goes Maraamu looses 6th challenge-Sean goes Merge-Kathy, Gina, Neleh, Rob, Vecepia, Hunter, Robert, John, Tammy, Zoe 7th boot-Rob goes 8th boot (1st jury)-John 9th boot (2nd jury)-Tammy 10th boot (3rd jury)-Robert 11th boot (4th jury)-Vecepia 12th boot (5th jury)-Hunter 13th boot (6th jury)-Gina 14th boot (7th jury)-Neleh Final 2 Zoe and Kathy John votes Kathy Tammy votes Kathy Robert votes Kathy Vecepia votes Kathy Hunter votes Zoe Gina votes Zoe Neleh votes Kathy
spnintendo	Re: how about this	#9	[-]
Posts: 7896 (05/15/04 5:16 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	i love wake me up's theory... but sigh...whatever. IF Sean and Vee never alligned... epi: 8 Sean booted: juror #1 epi 9: tammy wins IC VEE is too smart to get pagonged (although it'd be the shortest pagonging in history, even shorter than mogo's) she will then team up with kathy, pascal, neleh and the invisible zoe who likes to suck up to ppl...and boot rotu's leader. John booted. tammy wins IC ...again alliance holds...pagong... Robert goes. no way tammy can pull 3 in a row.... she goes. then, things get interesting. since kat., pappy and sweatpea have been together since the beginning, they stick together, leaving zoe and vee allyless. NO WAY VEE CAN GET OUTTA THIS! but wait! she wins immunity remember? zoe booted. and the final 4 happens EXACTLY AS IT DID. the only difference in my crappy theory is that zoe takes sean's place and gets booted later. the only reason (i think) pappy didnt wanna align with vee was because he disliked sean (at the time). but with 4 women (pappy always seems to get stuck with women), he was ok with it. final vote: sean: vee tammy: vee robert: vee john: vee zoe: neleh kathy: neleh pappy: sweatpea Rotu-3 is still pissed at neleh, and vee wins. yay.
I LUV TIJUANA	Re: how about this	#10	[-]
Posts: 15673 (05/15/04 5:55 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Do it like spninetendo did everyone, start with the 8th boot!!! Winners Vecepia- 1 Tammy- 1
mole	The 'What If' Game	#11	[-]
Posts: 411 (05/15/04 8:27 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Well, there's not much to say for this one, you've already taken the most likely scenario! So I'll vote the same way as you. One vote for Tammy to win, though I think the Rotu 3 might be convinced to Kucha New Maraamu instead, and boot Zoe early. This probably won't come back to haunt them in the final 4.
I LUV TIJUANA	Re: The 'What If' Game	#12	[-]
Posts: 15673 (05/15/04 8:46 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Winners Vecepia- 1 Tammy- 2
Jaborwok	Re: The 'What If' Game	#13	[-]
Posts: 1630 (05/15/04 8:58 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Whoa.....ILT, I hope that this type of thread isn't what we can expect as we languish and awaite the beginning of S9....cause "what if" is so subjective and non-linnear.
CSCin3D	Re: The 'What If' Game	#14	[-]
Posts: 13651 (05/15/04 9:05 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SURVIVOR: MARQUESAS Episode 8: Sean is unanimously pagonged by even Vecepia. BOOT: SEAN Episode 9: Vecepia unanimously pagonged. BOOT: VECEPIA Episode 10: Kathy tries to bring Zoe into the Kathy-Paschal-Neleh alliance because of the torn relationship with Tammy, but Zoe remains loyal to the Rotu 4. Kathy is voted out 4-3. BOOT: KATHY Episode 11: Neleh is pagonged 2-4. BOOT:NELEH Episode 12: Paschal pagonged. BOOT:PASCHAL Episode 13a: Zoe wins the Fallen Comrades challenge, she got to know the contestants the most. Zoe is immune. The other three scramble at TC. John offers to vote out Tammy to Zoe. Robert won't budge, but when the purple rock is proposed, he agrees with John. Tammy booted. BOOT-TAMMY Episode 13b: Zoe wins the Hands on Idol challenge, she has the most endurance. Votes out Robert because she is convinced she can beat John in the F2. BOOT: ROBERT Final Tribal Council: Final Two: Zoe and John Jury Votes Sean: Votes Zoe out of bitterness. Vecepia: Also votes Zoe, because she can't stand John's arrogance. Kathy: Votes John, she will respect the better gameplay, had not too good experiences with Zoe in the past. Neleh: Votes Zoe, she expressed she thought Zoe was an awesome lady in post show interviews. Paschal: Votes Zoe for same reasons as Neleh. Tammy:Votes John, but gives very hateful speech. Robert: Votes John out of bitterness. Total: 3 votes John, 4 votes Zoe. Winner of Survivor: Marquesas... Zoe Zanidakis
I LUV TIJUANA	Re: The 'What If' Game	#15	[-]
Posts: 15673 (05/15/04 9:12 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Winners Tammy- 2 Vecepia- 1 Zoe- 1
CSCin3D	Re: The 'What If' Game	#16	[-]
Posts: 13651 (05/15/04 9:22 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	More scenarios please! more scenarios!
Gnarl24	Re: The 'What If' Game	#17	[-]
Posts: 3055 (05/15/04 10:21 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Don't forget my Kathy speculation one
I LUV TIJUANA	Re: The 'What If' Game	#18	[-]
Posts: 15673 (05/15/04 11:20 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	You did it wrong tho. Anyways, 3 days is too long to wait. You can still comment on that one. It looks like Tammy is the winner. What if... Brandon remained with Samburu when they planned to vote of Lex, instead of switching sides. My thoughts... Lex voted out 5-4. Samburu has complete power, Ethan (threat) out 5-3. Kim J out 5-2. Tom out 5-1. It's down to Kelly, Kim, Brandon, Teresa and Frank. Scenario #1- Kelly/Kim/Brandon align Frank goes Teresa goes Kelly wins endurance Kelly/Brandon finals Kelly wins 5-2 (Tom, Ethan, Teresa, Frank, Kim J) Scenario #2- Kelly is outcast Kelly goes tiebreaker, brandon turns on kim, Kim P goes Franks wins IC, takes Teresa Teresa wins (7-0) Scenario #3- Kelly/Kim align Brandon goes Kelly goes Kim goes teresa wins (7-0) So I think Kelly G or Teresa would have won.
spnintendo	Re: The 'What If' Game	#19	[-]
Posts: 7896 (05/16/04 8:58 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	OR maybe, if brandon was actually smart enough... boot 8: lex goes. 5-4 (kelly "defects") hmm....lets say ethan wins immunity next. boot 9: tom goes (if only it happened this way...someone BETTER might have made ASS) 5-3 NOW, things get a lil complicated. let's say ethan wins IC again. teresa has shown that she is a strategic player (she 'controls' frank) and decides to betray the "kids" with mamaKim and Ethan. so teresa-frank-ethan-kimJ align to boot...annoyance. boot 9: brandon 4-3 somebody OTHER than kimP wins IC. pagong? boot 10: kim P. 4-2 BUT kelly is even SMARTER THAN teresa. she somehow convinces her old boran tribemates to break up T-bird and Frank. somebody wins IC. boot 11: frank 3-2 now for the lovely f-4 challenge that the producers screw up. lets say mamaKim wins it cuz kelly forgot she was the one without any piercings ( ). boot 12: teresa 3-1 ...gong! ahhh...endurance challenge. wouldn't be right without the term "pulling a KimJ" coming to being...so MamaKim pulls a KimJ. boot 13: she's dumb enough to boot kelly so final 2 is ETHAN and KIM.J (sound familiar?) now the only difference is that kelly is less pissed. and let's say ethan didn't piss off brandon. lex: ethan tom: ethan brandon: ethan kim p: kim J frank: ethan teresa: ethan kelly: kim J Ethan wins 5-2. ergh...
WylDawg	Re: The 'What If' Game	#20	[-]
Posts: 21511 (05/16/04 9:34 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	[quote]Winner of Survivor: Marquesas... Zoe Zanidakis[/quote] Okay, that just sounds very wrong and weird!

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

The "What If" Game

The "What If" Game

Quick Reply