| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 Cuauhtemock Cosby |
Re: Re: | ||
|
Posts: 854 (05/06/07 7:59 PM) I need a life |
Quote: Hahahaha, love it, love it, love it!!! I h.eart Leann! She was great. |
||
|
craig |
Re: Re: | ||
|
Posts: 16646 (05/06/07 11:36 PM) Registered User |
Leann called the shots on all the bad decisions - bringing Julie into the F4 alliance but not Eliza, telling Scout she wasn't in F4, keeping Chris over Eliza.
Ami made plenty of decsions, and I doubt Chris is fully aware of what happened on Yasur premerge. |
||
|
losemygrip |
Karma | ||
|
Posts: 160 (05/07/07 12:39 AM) Registered User |
Quote: Well, that's what Chris thinks, no doubt. I think a lot of players genuinely regret the mean things they had to do to win. Chris does not. He enjoys being mean. Like Boston Rob. Sociopaths both. And, of course, that's not REALLY the end. The karmic backlash will come sooner or later. Welcome to the land of the cockroaches, Chris. |
||
|
Cuauhtemock Cosby |
Re: Karma | ||
|
Posts: 854 (05/07/07 9:32 PM) I need a life |
Oh, I'm sorry craig, I wasn't aware that YOU were more privy to decisions that Leann made over people that were actually on the island with them.
|
||
|
Francois40 |
Re: Chris Daugherty spills some beans | ||
|
Posts: 2851 (05/08/07 3:12 PM) Registered user |
Quote: I wouldn't even say this was true: Eliza was getting three votes herself from A/L/J. Leann was getting 3 votes from S/C/T. Whomever Eliza voted for other than Leann was moot; it would be a 3-3 tie, with Eliza and Leann not voting in the revote. Then you'd have S/C/T vote Leann again, A/J vote Eliza, and Leann is STILL gone, just less dramatically, perhaps. While pulling in Eliza was wonderful finesse and made for one of the (if not THE) most exciting blindside in history, ultimately, I think the same result could have come about without her cooperation, since SHE was on the line herself. |
||
|
AnomyBC |
Re: Bleah! | ||
|
Posts: 4943 (05/08/07 7:55 PM) Registered User |
Quote: Yeah, that never made sense to me either. He should have voted out Scout, and went to the Final 3 with Twila and Eliza. In that situation, no matter what happened at the final immunity, he'd almost definitely be going to the Final 2. The only way it makes sense for him to vote out Eliza is if he didn't think he could beat her in a jury vote... And it does sound like he was worried that he might lose to her, but he also says that he thought Scout would have been "unbeatable", and if he thought that, then his decision to vote out Eliza over Scout makes even less sense. |
||
|
panurge46 |
Chris | ||
|
Posts: 1580 (05/10/07 10:54 AM) Registered user |
We always talk about the F2 goat but when you have a F3 patsy like Scout, (weak in challenges + big jury threat) you keep her. Scout, to paraphrase Rob C, could only win a "Name the Perry Como song" challenge and Twila had to see she couldn't beat her for jury votes. Chris was practically assured F2 in this setting.
Chris had to think that Eliza would see herself having a better shot at the million going against Twila since Chris would certainly get Sarge + Chad + Twila + Scout votes. Eliza was a strong challenge performer and a smart woman. Chris had to take her out. |
||
|
Kirblar |
Re: Chris | ||
|
Posts: 8567 (05/10/07 2:42 PM) Registered user |
Eliza seems to think she would have beaten Chris if he made F2 with her, and I think she's right. (She had Ami/Leann/Julie locked down, and if Chris turned on Twila/Scout they wouldn't have voted for him.) If Eliza pulled off 2 immunities, though, I'm less sure of her chances.
|
||
|
SenseiKreese |
Re: Chris | ||
|
Posts: 2886 (05/10/07 2:51 PM) Registered user |
The key there is if Eliza could get either of Twila or Scout's votes. They never seemed to respect her much in Vanuatu, and I've always had a theory that respect>like when it comes to who the jury will vote for. Even if they may have hated Chris for backstabbing them, I'm still not sure they could have forced themselves to vote for Eliza. It's an interesting scenario though. Eliza seems to think she would have won this vote, while Chris seems to think he would have won it. It's too bad we'll never know.
|
||
|
SPunKeeMonKee |
Re: Chris | ||
|
Posts: 12879 (05/10/07 3:10 PM) Registered User |
Am I the only female who actually enjoyed this season BECAUSE of Chris?
 I disliked almost all the women on Yasur, they were just unbearable to watch with all their hypocrisy. UGH.. Chris, Eliza & Royry pretty much made the season for meThanks for all the info, it was a great read :) Makes me love Chris even more Quote:Big red ecks. |
||
|
RazorrzzEdge |
Re: Chris | ||
|
Posts: 6102 (05/10/07 9:15 PM) Registered user |
Yay Spunkee. A voice of reason among people with clouded judgment.
I relished Chris's bloodthirsty attitude. It was poetic. It's exactly what those conniving bitches deserved. Hi, Eliza! But no, I'm not talking about you. I'm referring to Julie since she fucked the men at the merge, and Ami for her nonchalant attitude about ditching Lisa.
|
||
|
kmill |
Re: Chris | ||
|
Posts: 2258 (05/11/07 7:35 AM) Registered user |
This thread is a great read. I remember when I the shift occured when the season originally aired, I really wanted Eliza to take the rest of it.
|
||
|
About Breaking the Rules |
Re: Karma | ||
|
Posts: 3803 (05/12/07 2:32 PM) Registered user |
Quote:If he were, and if he had the power to get rid of one juror and replace her with someone else, he'd toss out Ami and bring in Mia. Besides, you said it yourselves, Chris believed Leann was the leader of the bowheads, while Ami was merely the front. Quote:Chris isn't going to face any karmic backlash. He's the one with the cash, and I don't think he's going to use it foolishly. And besides, why should he feel any remorse about his actions? He treated the chicks to a big ol' heapin' taste of their own medicine. You don't feel bad about making him look like a fool, well, let's see how you like it. |
||
|
hotchiemothcie |
Re: Karma | ||
|
Posts: 1000 (05/21/07 3:48 AM) Registered User |
I'm sure Chris felt real bad about what he did to the women after he saw what really happened with the chicken wings.
|
||
|
chad6 |
Re: Karma | ||
|
Posts: 3780 (05/21/07 3:52 AM) Registered user |
why does everyone keep saying Scout was a jury-threat??? She didn't seemed very liked or respected (as alot of people say) by anyone...true, she may have won against Twila (with her swearing on her son's name), but she would have lost to Chris, or Eliza....
|
||
|
SenseiKreese |
Re: Karma | ||
|
Posts: 2886 (05/21/07 8:26 AM) Registered user |
Well perhaps it's because someone from Vanuatu actually TOLD us she would have been a jury threat. But then again, Chris is no chad6, so I suppose that was little more than idle speculation.
|
||
|
craig |
Re: Karma | ||
|
Posts: 16646 (05/21/07 9:48 AM) Registered User |
Chris is pretty much alone in thinking scout a jury threat.
Sarge despised her (remember the singing scene), thought her an annoying hippy who was embarassing at challenges. Eliza and Julie didn't like her. Ami and Leann bumped her from F4 because of trust or likeability issues. They voted for her at F6, and Ami's commented about the darkness of her rainbow. Scout could beat Twila, but wouldn't do any better against Chris than Twila did. |
||
|
panurge46 |
Chris | ||
|
Posts: 1580 (05/21/07 12:55 PM) Registered user |
Quote: Really, that's all that mattered. Someone said Chris was stupid to go to the F3 with the duo of Scout and Twila. When I mentioned Scout as a jury threat, I meant Chris knew Twila would think she'd have a better chance going up against him. Taking Eliza to F3 in place of Scout would have been dumb for him. |
||
|
Angelus |
Re: Chris | ||
|
Posts: 304 (05/21/07 2:03 PM) Registered user |
Quote: I always though that was one the vilest things ever done on any Survivor and anything that happened to the women afterwards was deserved. |
||
|
chad6 |
Re: Chris | ||
|
Posts: 3780 (05/21/07 6:06 PM) Registered user |
I do agree bringing Eliza to the final three would have been a horrible idea from a physical stand point, but as far as jury0threats I think that Chris would have won over Scout, Twila, or Eliza
Chris vs. Scout Twila- Scout Eliza- Chris Julie-Chris Ami- Scout Leann- Chris (maybe Scout?) Chad- Chris Sarge- Chris Chris vs. Eliza Twila- Chris Scout- Chris Julie- Eliza Ami- Eliza Leann- Eliza Chad- Chris Srage- Chris |
||
