Yeah, I loved Starr and think she brought much needed education and the unintentional (and sometimes intentional) humor. Her, Meredith and Lisa are in a leg of their own. I'd add Barabara in there too though.

The smartest thing Lis has ever done is declare herself the lone Republican in a panel of Dems. She doesn't seem to have an original thought in her head cause she's so hellbent on defending anything conservative, Sean Hannity and Fox News. Maybe if she actually thought for herself and came to her own conclusions I'd agree but until that point she belongs in the same tier as Whoopi, Sherri, Rosie, Joy (mostly) who are so one-sided in how they see things they come off as nothing more than charictures of themselves.

With that being said, she makes the best arts and crafts out of any panelists...sorry Ro <3