Survivorbench I'm thinking exactly along the same lines as you are, it may be real. Bob wouldn't tell Corraine the stuff in the preview because Corraine saw the idol at the feast and the only thing Bob can say is that Marcus showed me a fake one which he will not say. The whole temptation thing is bullshit and Corraine ain't that stupid and would not fall for it.


If Marcus really did somehow manage to keep the idol that's one of the smartest moves in the game... yea it didn't get him anywhere but still it was extremely smart.

The only drawback for this whole idea of the Bob actually having the idol is that how could Marcus be so clever to take the idol and throw the bottle in seconds without no one noticing, everyone was looking in that direction and it would be obvious if Marcus took it.