They eliminated the wrong David on top 12 night. Eliminating Archuleta instead would have been in line with the 2 previous season's top 12 nights (Melissa and Brandon forgot lyrics also) and it would have also saved us from all the predictable, interchangably mediocre performances Archuleta gave us afterwards. David Hernandez had a lot of potential and Papa Was A Rolling Stone was better than anything Archuleta ever did.