Winnahs
1. Cookie
.
.
2. Tie 'tween Kelly and Carrie
3. Ruben
4. No Particular order three way tie between Fantasia, Taylor, and Jordan

Runnahs up (going on whose vocals impressed me the greatest number of times during their particular seasons...)
1. Clay
2. Bo
3. De-Chile
4. Diana
5. MacPhee
6. Guarini