LostInTheDelta wrote:
12. David Hernandez
11. Chikezie Eze
10. Syesha Mercado
09. Amanda Overmyer
08. Kristy Lee Cook
07. Ramielle Malubay
06. Michael Johns
05. Carly Smithson
04. Brooke White
03. David Cook
02. Jason Castro
01. David Archuleto

I'm pretty impressed with this one. They had David A. over David C., but the order (minus Syesha) is really close to what actually happened.