Frankie G Morris wrote:
Sarah Mather's semifinal song was Get Ready. And I didn't think she did it badly.

The performance wasn't bad. When she was voted off ... and had to "sing off" ... that was the funny and bad one.
Season 4 had the best "Holy Crap" eliminations. The first elimination show was epic. You had Melinda basically calling out her lack of screen time. Sarah had the best sing-out ever and Judd's elimination was just cruel. Then, of course, you had Constantine's elimination, which was just orgasmic. But, you also had the final 5 elimination where Ryan sent Scott and Anthony to the couch, and Scott thought he was safe (when Anthony clearly realized they were the bottom 2).