1. Jason - good arrangement AND good vocals
2. Syesha - Good vocals, great song choice, best "traditional" version of a Mariah
3. D. Cook - great arrangement (perhaps best of AI), horrific vocals

5. Carly & Kristy - mediocrity at it's finest

6. Brooke- Brooke called the front desk and checked out. It was rushed and manic.
7. Porkchop - traditional arrangement and glory noted the last half of the song. blah.

B: Carly, Brooke, Syesha - Syesha out
H: Porkchop, Kristy, Carly - bland blonde or satan's spawn
G: Carly, Brooke, Syesher - Syesha gone