1.Jason (He'd have been considered great on any night. One of the most memorable performances of the season, in a GOOD way.)
2.Kristy (I can't believe I just said that.)
3.Syesha (What does that say about the rest?)
4.Brooke (Boring)
5.Archuleta (Boring and annoying)
6.Carly (Strident)
7.Michael (Strained)
8.Cook (What a hot mess!)

Brain: Syesha - Copying Fantasia will kill her
Heart: Archuleta - this boy's win will be an injustice
Gut: Carly - Dialidol is looking pretty scary