1. Brooke "I give her mad props for being able to sing with the background singers and over her guitar something Jason Castro proved was a little hard at least."
2. Ramiele " I really liked this. She has a nice vibe when she sings nothing too great but very well done for her small body, hit great power notes"
3. Carly "I thought this was passable, it was a decent way to start the show. She had good pitch and a nice tone but it was a bit boring."
4. Kristy Lee "I think she has potential that's all I'm saying. She got better in week 2 so if week 3 gets better even still, watch out. She has a presence I like and I feel like she could act the part."
5. Alaina "not much to say... it was ok for me guys...
6. Amanda " She deserves last place but I am giving her a pity sixth, to effect the averages, just because I feel like we could lose a bland blonde beauty queen over her"
7. Asia'h "That voice crack in the middle was the equivalent of a figure skater trying the Triple Lutz then crashing into Dorothy Hamill and breaking her nose!"
8. Syesha "Another boring performance, hard to get into it but definately Top Model worthy looks
9. Alexandrea "Bad singing, and bad fashions and boring backstory."
10. Kady "Put me to sleep and killed me"

Brain - Alaina/Amanda
Heart - Carly/Syesha
Gut - Carly/Ramiele