1. David Archuleta-the only one to completely hold my attention and didn't hit any bad notes
2. Chickie - I dug it
3. Hernandez - by defaul, I was bored. The song is too repetitive
4. David Cook
5. Danny Noriega
6. Jason Castro - I like that he picked a bubble gum song and tried to folk it up, but it was boring
7. Robbie - I never realized how dirty that song was before. Why would AI pick a song about a potential hookup with an underage groupie?
8. Michael Johns - hardly a note was in tune
9. Luke Menard - almost a comic performance, but damn his face is pretty
10. Yaegermiester - Hated it